News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by Cyberdog on Sunday August 15, 2021 @01:57PM (#28190778)
I don't come to HN for politics, so I'll try to say this as apolitically as possible:

I'm reading in some places that after deciding to pull out, the United States decided to not fulfill promises to emigrate many Afghan civilians who helped the US or the US-backed government by serving as translators and such. These "traitors" may find life particularly difficult under a reinstated Taliban government. If this is true, it is shameful and (for better or worse) may make attempts at finding local support for future regime-building adventures much more difficult.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by eplanit on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:03PM (#28190830)
It's 20 years, 100s of billions of dollars, and many thousands of lives -- all wasted. The government that was setup (and then propped up) to replace the Taliban is gone, and replaced again by the Taliban: 0 net gain. All those rights and liberties that had been gained for women and girls have vanished literally overnight.

Everything, all efforts, sacrifices, and losses are for absolutely nothing. The depth of this historic failure is mind-boggling.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by uniacid on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:08PM (#28190867)
$2 Trillion or so, also we have to admit the failure was the US changing its role there from hunting Bin Laden and the Taliban to "Nation building" with an obviously corrupt Govt that has always been there.

It shouldn't be a surprise since you need a society that wants to actually break from the same continued cycle, unfortunately Afghanistan isn't it due to many reasons.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by dragonwriter on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:12PM (#28190913)
> we have to admit the failure was the US changing its role there from hunting Bin Laden and the Taliban to "Nation building"

The cause of the failure was when, in 2003, the US decided to focus on an entirely unnecessary war of choice (aggression, really) in Iraq (and a whole bunch of propaganda own-goals scored in that war that affected the US particularly in the Islamic world reinforced that.) Nation building was always an element of fighting the Taliban, not mission drift, since having something stable and broadly supported in place was the key to prevent a resurgence.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by throwaway894345 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:27PM (#28191082)
I don’t have a strong opinion, but “nation building” always sounds like this horrible thing and I don’t quite understand why. Charitably, bringing democracy to corrupt, oppressed countries seems eminently desirable. Maybe nation building has a bad rep because it’s immensely difficult and we always fail at it (presumably it takes many decades and we always think it will take 5 years?). Genuinely trying to understand.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:03PM (#28191454)
It's just based on a flawed premise. Democracy functions based on the public's democratic beliefs about legitimacy and power, so you can't impose it on a country the way you can install a king or set up an occupational council. No matter how well you mimic the forms and functions of a democracy, if the fundamental root of power is "the Americans said this is how we're doing it", the government's gonna fall as soon as they stop saying that.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by throwaway894345 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:45PM (#28191863)
I kind of agree, but culture is malleable and if you sustain democratic trappings for long enough the culture will adapt accordingly. I think this kind of culture change takes generations and our flaws have always been expecting the change to take place in a handful of years. Indeed, the Chinese and North Koreans have lived through the worst communism has to offer, but after a sustained period they have largely come to accept it as legitimate (although it requires a sustained investment in intense propaganda and isolationism because they are clearly stuck in a local optimum). Similarly Rome was pretty good at this sort of thing as it incorporated even backwater Britain into its empire.

If I were going to go about nation building, I would “export democratic values” some 20 years in advance of any military action by way of film, literature, etc. Cynics can think of this as propaganda, but really it’s just giving Afghans or whomever a more accurate taste of western life. When enough people had a good idea about what democracy was concretely and were ready to support it, I would then provide for military support with the expectation that the democrats would need sustained assistance for many decades.

Of course, there might be lots of reasons why this still isn’t a good idea, especially that we might be able to do more good per dollar elsewhere. But I don’t think “we tried it (poorly) for 20 years and it didn’t work out” is a good criticism—we shouldn’t expect the kind of requisite culture change to happen over a single generation.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday August 15, 2021 @04:11PM (#28192081)
I agree that it can in principle work over generations (and there's a solid argument that's precisely what happened in Germany and Japan after World War II). But this kind of explicit cultural imperialism is... frowned on, to say the least, in modern times. Can you imagine the controversy if the US had gotten up in 2002 and said "the goal of our occupation is to ensure that young Afghanis grow up American"?
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by dragonwriter on Monday August 16, 2021 @09:39AM (#28197902)
> agree that it can in principle work over generations (and there's a solid argument that's precisely what happened in Germany and Japan after World War

Germany and Japan were occupied (excluding the post-1955 nominal occupation of Germany because the Cold War prevented agreement on a formal end) for less time than Afghanistan when you add them together. To the extent something worked there but not in Afghanistan, it had nothing to do with it taking “generations”.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by SpicyLemonZest on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:01AM (#28198907)
Political factors encouraged people to consider the “occupation” phase over quickly, but parts of Japan were under direct US civil administration until 1972, and both countries to this day have an order of magnitude more troops than Afghanistan did. If a German 20 years after World War II were plotting to restore the Nazi government, “the US might just shoot us all” would have to be part of the calculation.

Germany and Japan were also quite a bit more successful at actually ending the organizations occupying troops found unacceptable.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by throwaway894345 on Monday August 16, 2021 @10:22AM (#28198453)
Germany already had democratic values and Japan had been formally westernizing for a century prior.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by athrowaway3z on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:36PM (#28191775)
https://youtu.be/sehmmzbi3UI (specificly ~2min starting from from 3:15 )
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by temp8964 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:38PM (#28191210)
OMG! corrupt corrupt corrupt ! I can't believe how many times the US supported local governments have been accused of being corrupt!

Kuomintang' China, South Korea, South Vietnam, Iraq, etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. You name it! Every single local government supported by the U.S. was and is being accused of being corrupt. You know what? They are all corrupt judged by the western standard. Corruption is the norm in the countries need U.S. support. If, for God's sake, they can build a government which is not corrupt (like a consituational republic???), what kind of society would that be? Why would they even need U.S. support in the first place?

And you know what? Corruption is not a choice of the central government. It is not like the central government can choose being corrupt or not. It is a reflection of the society it is in.

It is just shameful that because of this extremely naive accusation, the U.S. government made countless foreign police mistakes.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by dragonwriter on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:44PM (#28191271)
> Corruption is not a choice of the central government.

Often, it is.

> It is not like the central government can choose being corrupt or not.

Sure it is. It can also choose how much energy to devote to rooting out corruption at lower levels, but in many of the cases at issue it was the very top leaders that were deeply corrupt, so corruption was, in fact, a very direct choice of the central government.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by oldway on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:08PM (#28191507)
It's trying to install a puppet regime which ruled for the last 30 years and looted the country in Ethiopia which is hated by 90% of the country. The attitude for the US has changed in a country of more that 100 mil people.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by est31 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:22PM (#28191026)
The price tag sounds impressive at first but note that most of it never leaves american hands. Instead it is paid to contractors in key congressional districts.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by iav on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:36PM (#28191191)
While that might be true, that's kind of saying that if I go around breaking windows, I'm helping the economy as people are going to go out and spend money to buy new windows. Our society produces a limited amount of goods and services, and any allocation to one project means we have a little bit less for everything else. Whether the beneficiary is American or not isn't really relevant as it doesn't change the end result that everyone else has to tighten their belts to make room for the war.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by ASalazarMX on Sunday August 15, 2021 @07:10PM (#28193416)
> the US changing its role there [..] to "Nation building"

You must mean "installing puppet government". The Taliban were before, the puppet government lasted two decades, and now the Taliban are back. If it had been done with more diplomacy it might have succeded, but after the Twin Towers attack there was a push to overreact, and to profit from the sudden political capital.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by jscheel on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:26PM (#28191670)
$2 trillion that was paid for with debt. Estimates peg it at $6.5 trillion after interest.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by petre on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:13PM (#28190919)
So now the US weapons supplied to the Afghan army fell into the hands of the Taliban?
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by ruined on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:27PM (#28191085)
yes. there are photos going around of rooms full of weaponry seized, and they are already patrolling in humvees and mraps. there are even some videos of probably ANA defects piloting American helicopters for the Taliban.

https://instagram.com/p/CSj-3bgsxKQ

this is absolutely astonishing to me. im honestly surprised the us didn't conduct airstrikes on the vacated armories and hangars. they just got a leg up from antique firearms and fertilizer bombs into modern weaponry and air force.

i expect all of this to show up in Iraq, Syria, etc

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by nradov on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:50PM (#28191330)
On the positive side the Taliban won't be able to sustain those American helicopters for more than a few flights before they run out of spare parts. Iranian revolutionaries were able to continue operating American aircraft for a while by fabricating their own parts but the Taliban lack that capability.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by yumraj on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:00PM (#28191415)
I'm pretty sure Pakistan will help Taliban, after all they are the parent of Taliban.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by beerandt on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:29PM (#28191114)
We'll start bombing what we left behind as soon as the retreat/ evacuation is over. Maybe sooner.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:20PM (#28190990)
Someone already gave them a supply of Stinger missiles.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by busymom0 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:15PM (#28190943)
They are leaving behind several fully functioning military equipment which are now under Taliban's control. Basically a gift to them.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by petre on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:21PM (#28191010)
So basically the exact thing that happened with Daesh in Iraq.

I don't even know what to say. My country helped by sending support troops, some of them died there.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by dayforit on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:20PM (#28191000)
There is an one particular group of winner from all of this tho.

Why is it so hard for you and people to see?

All was there to make profit from the war for certain people? It was never about the peace and it can't be.

War profiteering is really really old proffession, isn't it? older than so many nations?

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by vehementi on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:31PM (#28191142)
Like, of course this war has been about profiting arms companies etc. all along - did people think otherwise?
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by pydry on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:32PM (#28191724)
In 2002 they did. The war had, like 90% support among the public.

I can still remember Jon Stewart saying "hey, afghanistan was good. we should have another one of those." A year or two later. That was the peacenik end of the political spectrum.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by vehementi on Sunday August 15, 2021 @08:10PM (#28193736)
It was obvious at the time (from outside the US)... I guess the propaganda was strong. I remember everyone I talked to seeing it was bullshit.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by Jabbles on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:06PM (#28190857)
This estimate suggests ~$800B

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-47391821

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by eplanit on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:07PM (#28190861)
You're right, will correct.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by kazinator on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:22PM (#28191019)
This was at least forty years in the making, starting with at least the Soviet-Afghan war. Afghanistan was used for conducting a proxy war between the Soviet Union and the USA, similarly to another Vietnam. This proxy war militarized the region and sowed the seeds for radicalism.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by jjcc on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:38PM (#28191205)
There are many reasons why the mistakes happened again and again and can not be fixed. Mainly human cognition defects that confuse beliefs driven by spiritual satisfaction with solid facts. The deep root cause can not be addressed so they will make the same mistake again.

If somebody want give some advice that can prevent the next 2-trillion dollar mistake here in HN what will happen? The advice will be down voted heavily and maybe it will been seen as a bot from repressive regime. So most of people know the ground truth but also understand this collective bias choose keep silent.

In machine learning the trainer want to select the data from different sources to avoid over fitting. In real world there's no role acting as a god to feed different types of data. The human brain train their own neural networks. The consequence is people select the data that reinforce their existing belief because of impact from million of years evolution, even ignore the facts that can not add up. (Does any body suspect something wrong with all our perception due Taliban take control of power so quickly, I ask HNers think about it for intellectual challenge, not about or beyond politics )

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by saiya-jin on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:57PM (#28191398)
I have a fine, really simple advice - don't start wars. I don't know where some US citizens take the idea that half of the world is longing to get invaded and westernized, it is simply not the case. If some politician tells you so, he/she is lying and you should seriously questions their motivation (like Bush' administration after 9/11 and its ties to companies who got many of the army orders). The idea that politicians are up there for the good of mankind if laughable at best, and dangerously naive at worst, regardless of country.

Don't start wars half around the world for made up / weak reasons with a country that is not anyhow threatening you, the amount of evil that is 'inserted' into mankind doesn't dissipate but all of us have to deal with it for generations to come. On top of all the destruction and death/murders/rape/torture/etc.

This is valid for any country, I may be bashing chinese in 10 years (and would be bashing colonizing west european states 100+ years ago), but for now its clear on whom this is aimed.

I can't imagine how all the patriotic US veterans must feel now - all the things they went through and lost friends, physical and mental health meant much less than nothing. Nothing would mean there wasn't 20 years of war and death, that would be a damn fine thing compared to current situation.

Oh and one final one, that one is also easy - don't start war in Afghanistan. Graveyard of empires they called it.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by Denvercoder9 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:03PM (#28191449)
> with a country that is not anyhow threatening you

Afghanistan did harbor Al-Qaeda, which executed an attack on US soil.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by saiya-jin on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:11PM (#28191541)
Sure and most of those folks came from Saudi Arabia. But anyway Al-Qaeda was out pretty quickly, yet US stayed with half-hearted effort to conquer and do changes.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by queuebert on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:18PM (#28190971)
Agreed. I fear the cold calculus is ... Afghanistan is strategically important for Russia, not the U.S., and making it peaceful is actually not in the best interests of the U.S. If Russia wants a path to a warm-water port, then it can deal with it.

I have no evidence of this, so just speculating on the actual motives.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:23PM (#28191038)
I don't think it makes sense to speculate about a hidden calculus here, because the US military leadership and national security establishment were uniformly opposed to withdrawing from Afghanistan. The pressure to withdraw came from the general public.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by orange_website on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:28PM (#28191098)
I don't concretely know what's happening, but I have an idea.

Why didn't the US State Department see the failure of the fledgling and corrupt democratic Afghanistan government? The US should have pulled out 10 years ago, or if it was actually interested in the strategic nature of Afghanistan, it could have arranged to purchase permanent bases independent of the Afghan government, fortify them, install missiles, occupy the Khyber Pass, block China/Russia, shore up rare earths, etc.

So why didn't we take these actions sooner if we knew the government couldn't handle it? Incompetence? Too many cooks?

My guess is that we were still interested in Afghanistan, but that this is a new shift in geopolitics. It's a chess move, and not one originated by the Trump or the Biden administration directly. My guess is that this is being done to appease Putin.

The US is softening up on its approach to Russia as a regional counter against China. This is more important than having forces on the ground in Afghanistan (which have to fly in over Pakistan anyway). And of course it's more important than building and propping up democracies. If it weren't, we'd still be there.

The story to look at now is China. This is a chess move in that story.

Just my thoughts. I could be wrong.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by wyldfire on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:33PM (#28191155)
> Why didn't the US State Department see the failure of the fledgling and corrupt democratic Afghanistan government?

They almost certainly did, but they serve the foreign policy directives of the executive-at-the-time.

> The US should have pulled out 10 years ago,

Of course, but there's nearly no upside to breaking this status quo. It's all downside. Biden will take this hit because it looks embarrassing to withdraw and leave people worse off than when we found them. I agree with you: his predecessors should have done it.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by beerandt on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:31PM (#28191132)
China's got plans for one of it's new trade routes going through there, as well.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by tlogan on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:37PM (#28191197)
> women and girls have

> vanished literally overnight.

This is not a very intellectually honest comment. What about Saudi Arabia? What about women and girls there? Why raise issue about women rights in Afghanistan but be silent about Saudi Arabia, Emirates, etc. For god sake they are going to host World Cup.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by gjsman-1000 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:43PM (#28191268)
Because even Saudi Arabia allows education for females. The Taliban does not (seriously, it’s a crime to teach women to read).
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by tlogan on Sunday August 15, 2021 @05:08PM (#28192546)
I get it: we will do all kinds of moral gymnastics to keep Saudis (and others with oil) happy.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by sofixa on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:32PM (#28191730)
> This is not a very intellectually honest comment. What about Saudi Arabia? What about women and girls there? Why raise issue about women rights in Afghanistan but be silent about Saudi Arabia, Emirates, etc. For god sake they are going to host World Cup

The Taliban don't allow women to get any sort of education or work, which is worse than the situation in SA, UAE and Qatar ( the ones who are going to host a World Cup)

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by oezi on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:18PM (#28190966)
I am most surprised that there is no fighting back at all. Are all those deserting soldiers really thinking their lifes and the lifes of their families will be spared?
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by nradov on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:55PM (#28191380)
Most of the regular soldiers and their families will be spared. The Taliban have nothing to gain now by killing them and making more enemies. They can afford to be magnanimous in victory. Reprisals will largely be targeted towards special operations troops who actually did fight against the Taliban instead of just running away, and the former translators whom we abandoned.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by gremloni on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:33PM (#28191156)
The Afghans want to live under sharia. They just want to do with money like the Saudis.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by tyre on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:19PM (#28190980)
There are a few issues at play.

The biggest one is that the Taliban overtook the country far, far faster than anticipated. The Afghan military crumbled and lost ground about as fast as the Taliban could move its army.

So while there were and are plans to evacuate those who helped the US military, the visa process—tens of thousands of which are in process and which began in the sprint—they weren’t expecting for the situation to change in a matter of days. In June, the US intelligence community was predicting they could have six months post-leaving before the Afghan government collapsed.

Instead, the past week did it.

The US won’t be able to get everyone out, but they are making a good faith effort. They are adapting by, for example, asking allied countries to temporarily take people whose visas are in progress but not fully finished.

It’s a horrible situation. Thousands if not tens of thousands will be left behind. They and their families will be in danger.

But we also have to be careful of who we let into the country And the embassy and in-country forces have other priories as well like destroying sensitive documents—which will itself save lives of people who worked with us—and extracting allied diplomats, their families, etc.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by fshbbdssbbgdd on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:28PM (#28191095)
When the US abandoned Vietnam, we ferried people out by helicopter as Saigon fell. We rescued 5500 Vietnamese civilians this way. The ambassador wouldn’t leave until marines forced him to get onto a helicopter. How many did we rescue this time? Do we have fewer helicopters than we did in 1975? Do our helicopters have an interlock that prevents them from taking off if someone without a visa is onboard?
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by nexuist on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:40PM (#28191230)
We are sending helicopters for evacuation. In fact, we are literally sending the same ones: the helicopter linked below also performed evac in Saigon.

https://www.helis.com/database/cn/8983/

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by tyre on Sunday August 15, 2021 @04:54PM (#28192449)
I’m not sure what your point is.

The Afghani military and government collapsed far faster than anyone anticipated. We knew they would fail—our estimates (that were wrong) were still a question of _when_ the state collapses, not _if_.

Did we ever have enough helicopters in the country? Sure, probably. But part of leaving the country involves taking our stuff out of the country. We left Bagram a week or two ago.

Now the situation in the ground has changed. Yes, in retrospect, with information we didn’t have then, it would be nice to have more helicopters. But even though we have more in the US military, you can’t Amazon Prime overnight ship a helicopter. We are sending more troops.

The comment about locks checking visas is snarky, but also uninteresting. We’re talking about an emergency evacuation in a failed state that’s a hotbed for terrorism. Of course we should know who we’re bringing into aircraft and prioritize people we know and who have been vetted for visas.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by reducesuffering on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:30PM (#28191712)
There is much more diligence to be done. Hell hath no fury like accidentally letting a sleeper Taliban into a Western country who commits a terrorist attack.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by luckylion on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:47PM (#28191885)
It happened in Europe quite a few times with ISIS-members. There has been no perceivable fury, so ... hell doesn't exist? Hell is a picnic?

I'm not sure, but it doesn't matter.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by publicola1990 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:23PM (#28191045)
But US asking other countries to take in these Afgans instead of taking them to US territories isn't a good look for the US.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by CydeWeys on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:29PM (#28191115)
Where do the Afghans themselves want to go? They don't all want to come to the US.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by publicola1990 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:34PM (#28191166)
Well I got the impression that US is not taking them to US territories not because they don't want to go there, rather because US isn't able to make arrangements to do so in time.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by nradov on Sunday August 15, 2021 @03:01PM (#28191427)
You cannot be serious. The Biden administration has made only a token effort to protect and evacuate translators and other vulnerable Afghanis who worked for the US occupation forces. Biden abandoned them to their fate and their blood is on his hands. He could have simply issued orders to load them on US aircraft and fly them out, but chose to do almost nothing.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by throwaway894345 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:09PM (#28190887)
Not sure why you’re being downvoted. Whether or not you agree with the US leaving (especially in the manner that we left), it seems like we should all be able to agree that the US should honor its commitments to protect translators and other partners. I don’t understand the controversy here.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by t0mas88 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:00PM (#28190803)
This discussion is also in the news today in the Netherlands with regards to our own involvement there. Some translators have been evacuated, some have not yet been picked up. And apparently there are others that weren't local translators but that did support the military there (e.g. as drivers or suppliers) and are at risk. That last group hasn't been saved yet and it's unclear whether something has been arranged.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by hef19898 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:24PM (#28191048)
Same in Germany. I wonder how one can be naive enough, read government and armed forces, to

a) say you gonna retreat by date X

b) say local helpers will get the opportunity to get to your home country

c) organise your troop withdrawal, without any thoughts on how fast the Taliban will take over

d) pull your troops, sans local support staff and their families, out. Be surprised that your locals are now stuck

e) expect that next time your army goes somewhere you'll still find reliable local help

How difficult would it have been to evacuate your supporting locals along your troops before the country is taken over by your opponent. But then the German Army is unable to tell how many soldiers the deployed there since the war started... Mark me surprised, I am way beyond being shocked by stuff like that so.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by t0mas88 on Thursday August 19, 2021 @05:21PM (#28239529)
I'm of the opinion that the German or Dutch army probably isn't as incompetent as half the population thinks compared to the US. It's just that the US has a much more "thank you for your service" culture than the "what an idiots" attitude the Germans and Dutch (and UK?) have to our armies.

Not sure how the French do with this?

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by lordnacho on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:04PM (#28190834)
This wavering with helping our friends will surely have an effect on our chances of making friends in the future.

It's quite frankly dishonourable to leave them in the lurch like is happening. I do appreciate the advance has been swift but it should not have been hard to simply put everyone on a plane and process their claims someplace less dangerous.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by christophilus on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:09PM (#28190885)
We did the same to the south Vietnamese. Disgraceful. I really feel bad for any Afghanis who aided the US.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by pwdisswordfish0 on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:11PM (#28190899)
This is a topic in Germany as well. Apparently it’s some kind of bureaucratic nightmare to apply for help. Insanely shameful.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by dragonwriter on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:15PM (#28190940)
> If this is true, it is shameful and (for better or worse) may make attempts at finding local support for future regime-building adventures much more difficult.

This is such a regularly recurrent kind of thing at the end of US interventions that the n+1st instance probably won't noticeably change the total effect from what is there from the first n instances.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by ciguy on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:08PM (#28190875)
Look up how the USA treated the Hmong after they pulled out of Vietnam. This is nothing new unfortunately, I hope the translators and workers made plans to get out on their own because it was virtually guaranteed that they would be abandoned when things got rough. As an American, I find it incredible that they got anyone at all to work with us.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by petre on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:17PM (#28190960)
Some of these people were probably desperate enough to get rid of the Taliban, that's how the US made friends. I read a piece about a couple of days ago about a woman leading a group of anti Taliban resistance fighters. Probably a propaganda piece but still.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by ciguy on Sunday August 15, 2021 @10:19PM (#28194365)
I'm sure some were but it's clearly not a majority of the population.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by uniacid on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:03PM (#28190825)
I think the problem the US did was we announced we were leaving prior to doing any of that necessary work before we even announced or started to leave.

In hindsight I'm not sure why but it felt liked it was indeed a rushed effort, obviously started by the Trump admin and now Biden's admin, either way I think everyone is tired of the situation in general since it's not a society or place anyone will ever change unless we decide to stay there for a few centuries.

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by shagie on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:10PM (#28190894)
> unless we decide to stay there for a few centuries

And The Great Game continues. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Game

https://www.loc.gov/ghe/cascade/index.html?appid=a0930b1f4e4... is also certainly looking at for the context too (nicely done presentation from the Library of Congress Geography and Map Division)

Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by Dma54rhs on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:20PM (#28190994)
The (not anymore) secret talks with Taliban started under Obama already, but looks like in the end the Taliban smelled your weakness and saw the opportunity getting into power without listening what americans want from them.
Re:Afghan President Ghani relinquishes power, Taliban form i... by gigatexal on Sunday August 15, 2021 @02:31PM (#28191139)
Yeah as an American Afghani’s that helped troops and risked their lives should be given refuge in the US. It’s the only decent thing to do.