News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by toomuchtodo on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:03PM (#28170687)
Issue them visas and a path to citizenship in developed countries.
Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by ud_0 on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:18PM (#28170895)
I think that UN countries should indeed do that, at the very least it'd send a strong signal. But they won't, because when the dust settles they'll be looking to do business with the Taliban or at least try and have some kind of diplomatic relations. They (we) have historically been completely okay with the oppression of women and minorities in other countries, and we still are.

That being said, it would just be a gesture. These women are not free to travel, or make any kind of life choices freely. And even if they were, social pressures are almost insurmountable.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by mc32 on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:23PM (#28170972)
Sadly, sometimes you have to fight your own battles and wars. Be they for independence, the right to vote, etc. (see Vietnam)

If the dissenters leave and don’t put up a fight, who is going to do the right thing?

Imagine if the resistance fighters of France or Benelux said instead, it’s fucking bad here, we gotta get out of town and let’s go to Argentina (or Angola, pick a place).

That would have left the baddies without resistance. That’s what would happen if no one were to put up a fight. Yes it’s deaths, but the future might be worth it. If Americans can go die over there to protect civil society surely locals can organize a fight.

Look at the VC of Vietnam, they could have said, shit, let’s just go to China or whatever and forget our homeland, but they didn’t. They fought tooth and nail with every breath, men women and children. I disagree with their choice of government but I admire their will for self determination and willingness to fight for what they thought was righteous.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by ud_0 on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:39PM (#28171204)
There is no meaningful dissent under this system. Resistance fighters are also not going to happen in the near future, because these need broad population support, at least regionally. I would argue that the Taliban grabbing control of the country is the people of Afghanistan fighting their own wars, as revolting as it is.

I wonder though if what has been posted in another thread here had happened: if we either hadn't have gone in at all, or retreated immediately after. Maybe the passage of time would have softened up the Taliban government structure by now and there would be meaningful change brewing from within. In that sense, fighting their own wars could have helped the country. I've seen good cases being made for the theory that the people of Afghanistan would almost certainly be better off by now. As it stands today, they are reset to the very beginning of any possible road to democracy and human rights. Then again, there is no guarantee they'll ever choose that. I sort of see the point of those who argue that "we" need to be fine with that, too.

However, this piece of news is more immediate and the suggestion made here relates to immediate relief for people in trouble. And in such cases, I can't ethically be in favor of letting anyone fight their own wars.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by maccolgan on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:30AM (#28179056)
Why is there a extremely pervasive belief in the HN crowd that there is The Right Way and every country must immediately adopt it (and if they do not, they are making a mistake)? It just seems like Afghanistanis are self-determining to support Taliban anywhere outside of Kabul.
Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by ud_0 on Saturday August 14, 2021 @05:22AM (#28179307)
> Why is there a extremely pervasive belief in the HN crowd that there is The Right Way and every country must immediately adopt it (and if they do not, they are making a mistake)?

I can't speak for the others, but for me it's because I'm a humanist and I strongly believe governments must be, as well. I'm arguing from a perspective of minimizing human suffering and (ideally) optimizing progress and development towards a future that is pleasant, prosperous, and scientifically literate.

On the more contentious side I would also argue the implementation of a state in such a society must be entirely secular, even if there is a majority religion, because the humanist goals laid out above are fundamentally incompatible with a state religion. But as I said, that particular bias is mostly my personal opinion and could be considered outdated (maybe a side effect of my age).

That is not to say there is a single ideal country I can point at and declare that they're currently fulfilling this ambition completely. But it's easy to identify a government, power structure, or ideology where the core agendas actively move society further away from it. I understand why these kinds of value judgements don't sit right with you, but I'm not arguing for the superiority of Western culture per se.

Edit: About your point of "immediately" adopting democracy, there is no moderate time span. Fundamentalist regimes with popular support, especially when they're religion-based, are usually incredibly stable because of the way consent is continually built and dissent is harshly squashed. If a country slides politically over time, it's usually not towards a secular democracy. Chances are the Taliban will rule Afghanistan for many generations.

> It just seems like Afghanistanis are self-determining to support Taliban anywhere outside of Kabul.

There is no question that the Taliban gobbling up the country is an expression of public will. I do think it's regrettable, and I strongly believe "we" should offer assistance to the few people who actually make it out. But other than that, there is really little to do but watch. It's been a long time coming.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by mc32 on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:45PM (#28171311)
To be terse, a population has to be ready to receive a system of government for it to work. It has to be organic and can take many decades to play out.

Russia is an example. After centuries Empire and communism, they were in no way ready for democracy. Democracy may still work out some day in Russia, but not now. Also not now in Afghanistan. They need to work that out themselves.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by baybal2 on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:48PM (#28171352)
The Democracy also doesn't work in USA. Americans are too immature for the Democracy, so let's hand the country to Putin.

People following your line of logic are so arrogant, and coarse.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by Thrymr on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:34PM (#28171136)
Sometimes a superpower comes in and enlists you in their war in your country, and then leaves and hangs you out to dry. This happened to the Hmong in Laos during the Vietnam war as the CIA used them in their secret war across the border. Eventually thousands of them did settle in the US [0].

[0] https://www.mprnews.org/story/2019/10/25/how-a-former-cia-wo...

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by baybal2 on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:26PM (#28171019)
US barely fought the Afghan war. The war was "Afghanised" very early on. The lion share of casualties in Afghanistan are the ANA troops.
Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by fhood on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:36PM (#28171162)
This is disingenuous. Unless I somehow completely missed something, US military support was absolutely crucial in fighting back the Taliban.
Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by mc32 on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:28PM (#28171049)
Then why does the withdrawal of US troops result in collapse?

You have to be willing to fight for what you believe in.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by onepointsixC on Friday August 13, 2021 @01:08PM (#28171620)
The US cut and ran, forced the Afghan gov to release thousands of Taliban fighters, and cut off intel and logistic support. It wasn't just a withdrawal, we tied a weight around the Afghan gov, threw them in the river and told them to swim. At least with Saigon we managed to evacuate thousands. This admin hasn't even done that.
Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by mc32 on Friday August 13, 2021 @01:13PM (#28171676)
After 20 odd-years, I don't call this a cut-and-run. This has been a simmering topic since Obama took over --but of course, once in the white house, he changed tack.
Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by alephnerd on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:41PM (#28171257)
Air Support - with the US withdrawal, there's been a decrease in that especially given the Aug 31st deadline. And India's not immediately interested in providing immediate air support as well (in order to try and make inroads with the Taliban, like all other nations in the region are)

https://theprint.in/diplomacy/afghan-govt-wants-iaf-support-...

https://theprint.in/defence/will-pull-india-into-a-vortex-wh...

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by baybal2 on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:58PM (#28171488)
> Then why does the withdrawal of US troops result in collapse?

Because US troop withdrawal is also a simultaneous porkbarrel withdrawal.

This is something very obvious I am surprised nobody talks about.

US "war funds" to the most Afghan establishment were basically loyalty bribes.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by ren_engineer on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:53PM (#28171422)
maybe not direct deaths but the Trillions of dollars that were thrown away in Afghanistan could have been spent improving and saving the lives of citizens in the United States

I'm not sure there's been a more wasteful government action in human history than the US government in the Middle East

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by s5300 on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:15PM (#28170832)
We (the US) offered interpreters who worked with our troops in the middle of the absolute shit a path to citizenship and then left them literally in the dust so that they and their families can be tortured and killed.

Maybe the Euro Countries (or even Canada?) could be nicer, but the USA (politicians making the decisions that go in affect) clearly don't give the slightest fuck and haven't for decades.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by swiley on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:23PM (#28170967)
Also legal citizenship/visas are a real crapshoot in the US due to the extreme (and by extreme I mean it sounds like hyperbole and would be hilarious if it weren't people's lives getting screwed around with) incompetence, slothfulness, and general unreliability of the USCIS.

Most people who live here have never dealt with them and have no idea just how bad it really is. I think their interview process might include an IQ test with an upper limit for acceptable candidates.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by ClumsyPilot on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:48PM (#28171354)
"legal citizenship/visas are a real crapshoot in the US"

I know several developer that immigrated to US, and then because of what they had to deal with regularly. No personal experience though

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by ClumsyPilot on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:20PM (#28170921)
This absolutely accurate

https://youtu.be/QplQL5eAxlY

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by s5300 on Friday August 13, 2021 @08:46PM (#28176681)
Huh, look at that. I was somewhat right

https://mobile.twitter.com/JustinTrudeau/status/142632472646...

(Presuming it's actually followed through with)

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by Johnyma22 on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:10PM (#28170763)
Friends & Family might be a higher priority for them.
Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by codeecan on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:44PM (#28171301)
And spread the problem further? They were given many resources to improve their country and squandered it.

We know what happens when you have mass immigration from countries with low standards of living. We saw it with Gaddafi, it destabilizes regions and introduces problems with housing supply, welfare budgets and wage suppression.

Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by Siira on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:19PM (#28170903)
This will likely exacerbate the country’s situation, though it’s a pragmatic way to help the victims.
Re:Afghan women forced from banking jobs as Taliban take con... by toomuchtodo on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:27PM (#28171039)
It drains the country of future conflict while supporting these victims. It brings the fight to developed countries on their terms and soil. You'll never win against the Taliban by fighting the war in Afghanistan, so you slowly transition through immigration policy the population base they subjugate.