News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by Uehreka on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:23AM (#28168517)
When I see someone on Facebook/Twitter link to a site like this to demonstrate that the person they’re arguing with is “doing a fallacy”, I just accuse them of Appeal To Authority. I feel like these kinds of sites are often just used to shut someone down by saying that they’re doing something wrong, without actually going through the work of following through with why the “fallacy” makes their argument weak. Also, in my experience fallacies/biases are often more indicative of a weak argument than a wrong one.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by bradrn on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:43AM (#28168727)
Well, if you really want to go this route, you can beat them at their own game and accuse them of Arguing From Fallacy. (A nice illustration: https://theupturnedmicroscope.com/comic/logical-fallacies-ar...)

That being said, I do think it’s important to avoid fallacious reasoning — it helps in making arguments clearer. As mentioned above, just because someone uses a fallacy doesn’t mean their conclusion is wrong, but it does mean that you can prove their argument wrong. (And any reply should ideally be phrased in these terms: ‘your argument has problem X’ is easier to respond to than ‘your argument has fallacy Y’.) Furthermore it means they are thinking less clearly than they perhaps should be.

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by netr0ute on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:42AM (#28169486)
The Fallacy Fallacy doesn't actually do anything because it is covered by itself and creates a loop.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by entropicdrifter on Friday August 13, 2021 @02:47PM (#28172766)
I'd say the bigger problem is that it's roughly equivalent to saying, "Just because my argument is bad doesn't mean I'm wrong."

I mean, yes, that's true, but you have yet to prove yourself correct, so why should anyone change their mind?

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by ElFitz on Friday August 13, 2021 @03:13PM (#28173199)
And that’s how you get a stack overflow.

Always remember your exit condition when doing recursion, folks!

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by eivarv on Friday August 13, 2021 @01:32PM (#28171888)
And by extension, fallacious reasoning means that you have no good reason to take what the reasoner is arguing as true (unless they can a non-fallacious argument) – right?

The fact that an argument is fallacious doesn't necessarily mean that the conclusion is wrong, but there does (logically, by necessity) exist (at least) a non-fallacious argument for a correct conclusion.

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by gauravjain13 on Friday August 13, 2021 @07:59PM (#28176360)
Yes, exactly this. It’s useful to understand biases: cognitive diversions from the truth.

Echoing OP’s sentiment: How one uses/weaponizes such knowledge depends on one’s goals: to win petty ego battles in debate or seek the truth?

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by mistermann on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:29PM (#28171068)
> just because someone uses a fallacy doesn’t mean their conclusion is wrong, but it does mean that you can prove their argument wrong.

One way this can go wrong is if the two people are thinking at different levels of abstraction or dimensionality (variables), especially when one or both participants don't understand what that means (which seems to be "most" people in the general public).

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by overboard2 on Friday August 13, 2021 @05:16PM (#28174625)
What do you mean?
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by lhorie on Friday August 13, 2021 @11:35AM (#28170246)
> accuse them of Arguing From Fallacy

But then, you're just doing an ad hominem...

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by entropicdrifter on Friday August 13, 2021 @02:49PM (#28172801)
That's not an ad hominem. You're attacking their argument, not them as a person.

An ad hominem would be like saying, "Oh yeah, well you're an alcoholic", for instance, as though that could discredit their argument even if it were true.

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by robbedpeter on Friday August 13, 2021 @01:16PM (#28171708)
I know I am, but what... am... I?
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by rtkwe on Friday August 13, 2021 @09:43AM (#28168729)
Yeah I remember seeing a lot of people deploying the fallacy list(s) as an argumentative tool to say "ha! you're argument vaguely resembles this 'fallacy' so you're instantly wrong." It's a lot less now I think, they've fallen out of style I guess, or I'm just getting in/reading less pointless arguments.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by hsn915 on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:21AM (#28169186)
I call this the "fallacy" fallacy.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by imwillofficial on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:06AM (#28168988)
The lengths people will go to, to avoid thinking, is impressive.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by ElFitz on Friday August 13, 2021 @03:12PM (#28173164)
Also, a cognitive bias isn’t necessarily a fallacy.

It’s only a prism that deforms our perspective of the world.

Fallacies are a different beast altogether.

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by teachrdan on Friday August 13, 2021 @01:18PM (#28171735)
It's a bit funny because Appeal to Authority isn't a fallacy. The actual fallacy is Appeal to Incorrect / False Authority:

"An appeal to false authority is a fallacious argument that relies on the statements of a false authority figure, who is framed as a credible authority on the topic being discussed."

https://effectiviology.com/false-authority/#:~:text=An%20app....

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by eivarv on Friday August 13, 2021 @01:41PM (#28172022)
Does it actually matter?

An argument doesn't get any more or less fallacious based on who believes in it (the authority, in this case) – that's not an argument in itself.

It might be reasonable (a useful heuristic) to lean to the side of the expert, but the fact that an expert believes something doesn't in itself make the conclusion correct.

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by teachrdan on Friday August 13, 2021 @01:54PM (#28172145)
To the contrary, if someone is a correct authority, their statements have more weight on their domain of expertise. While all of us on HN are very clever and could think of a number of exceptions, I would trust a climate scientist as a legitimate authority on climate change over a religious leader or a PR person.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by eivarv on Friday August 13, 2021 @02:50PM (#28172816)
I too would trust a climate scientist as a legitimate authority on climate change over a religious leader or a PR person – but that's not what I'm discussing.

I'm saying global warming isn't true because scientists believe it to be true (this would be a fallacious argument).

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by entropicdrifter on Friday August 13, 2021 @02:59PM (#28172960)
That would be a fallacious argument because it does not follow (non-sequitur) that the beliefs of scientists can cause shifts in reality, but nobody was arguing that.

They were arguing that it is logical to conclude that climate change is real because the overwhelming consensus among climate scientists (the actual domain experts) is that it is real.

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by eivarv on Friday August 13, 2021 @03:10PM (#28173145)
That's not an argument that deals with whether climate change is real or not – but whether it's reasonable to believe it is, based on one's own lack of understanding in combination with making (reasonable) assumptions.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by entropicdrifter on Monday August 16, 2021 @02:20AM (#28195434)
It is an argument that the consensus of the overwhelming majority of experts on any given subject with such a consensus is strong evidence for that position.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by nostromo on Friday August 13, 2021 @01:24PM (#28171814)
> The actual fallacy

... according to linguistics researcher with a website. He sounds like as much a false authority on philosophy as anyone else.

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by entropicdrifter on Friday August 13, 2021 @02:53PM (#28172857)
From the Standford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:

9. The ad verecundiam fallacy concerns appeals to authority or expertise. Fundamentally, the fallacy involves accepting as evidence for a proposition the pronouncement of someone who is taken to be an authority but is not really an authority. This can happen when non-experts parade as experts in fields in which they have no special competence—when, for example, celebrities endorse commercial products or social movements. Similarly, when there is controversy, and authorities are divided, it is an error to base one’s view on the authority of just some of them. (See also 2.4 below.)

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/fallacies/

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by tomcatfish on Friday August 13, 2021 @03:03PM (#28173024)
The point the parent was making is that citing authority isn't a bad thing to do. Citing authorities in _a different field_ often is, though.

(Citing a doctor on the common cold is not a fallacy, but citing a doctor on global economics is)

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by nostromo on Friday August 13, 2021 @03:22PM (#28173335)
And in doing so they cited a linguist about philosophy.

And it doesn’t matter anyway - thankfully we use science now and not philosophy to determine truth.

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by damagednoob on Friday August 13, 2021 @05:03PM (#28174494)
It also tends to derail the conversation and you end up arguing about fallacy definitions instead of the actual point.
[dead]
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by Peritract on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:45AM (#28169523)
I don't think 'cognitive bias' is used half as dismissively or dishonestly as 'woke' is.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by 411111111111111 on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:41AM (#28169470)
People increasingly argue with fallacies, so it shouldn't come at a surprise that the frequency in which they're pointed out increases as well.

Public discord really has taken a nosedive and I'm surprised you seem to be okay with people using fallacies to strengthen points. Their points might even be correct, but reflection gets increasingly harder the more you accept these fallacies as arguments.

I'm often speechless how pretty influencial YouTubers/streamers wholeheartedly believe something based purely on fallacies. All the young viewers which aren't able to identify them most definitely become even more susceptible to this kind of logic, worsening the situation in the future.

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by npteljes on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:24AM (#28169224)
These biases are also played out as deliberate argument tactics, and they work really well, especially on those who can't detect it. Basically each of them is also guide how to be more persuasive, if you don't care about playing dirty.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by denton-scratch on Friday August 13, 2021 @01:52PM (#28172129)
Correct.

Politicians deploy fallacious arguments all the time. Inserting fallacious arguments into speeches in such a way that they aren't obvious is part of basic political speechwriting.

The task facing a politician is to build a cohesive coalition out of a bunch of people who don't really share much. Many of them couldn't distinguish a fallacy from an obscene act. Political speech is persuasive speech, and accurate reasoning is rarely persuasive.

Re:Guide to cognitive biases by projektfu on Friday August 13, 2021 @10:41AM (#28169472)
That’s funny. I consider myself “left” but find these dismissive charges of bias deployed a lot by libertarian debaters.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by kodah on Friday August 13, 2021 @12:01PM (#28170652)
Libertarians might too, the two aren't mutually exclusive. I also don't think it's something to get defensive about. I'm left and I've certainly seen the behavior that the poster mentioned. That said, what I'd say to both of you (that I've learned as well) is that the left and the right are not monolithic groups and are highly fragmented in various ways. This can lead to the obvious misunderstanding the other side for the words and attitudes of a few and judging your own group (thinking highly or negatively) for your own perceived bedfellows rather than your actual bedfellows.
Re:Guide to cognitive biases by clairity on Friday August 13, 2021 @08:00PM (#28176373)
left-right is a false dichotomy invented to simplify politics (by literally dichotomizing it), so you’ve already lost by thinking in those terms (as has @magila in the parent comment) or any other 1-d axis like liberal-libertarian.