News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by lethologica on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:04AM (#28140524)
So what are we Aussies missing out on then?
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:24AM (#28140642)
You don't because you are living in a period where everything is wonderul for Australia.

You know what they say: everybody is a genius in a bull market.

So you have sun, good food, plenty of money and little immigration.

Life is good (if you are not living in the desert naked).

Unfortunatly, there is nowhere in the world where things stay nice and easy. The run ended in europe after 1970, it ended in the US after 1990 and it will end in Autralia.

Now, when things are getting hard, having weak democratic institutions, no political awareness and corporate medling is going to hit hard.

But I wouldn't be too cocky because it's not like we didn't mess up loads of things in our own countries, even if we have strong political commitment.

Besides, if I could enjoy your life style, I would probably be way less sensitive to privacy issues.

So don't take what I said as the words of someone who has the ethical upper hand, because I certainly don't.

And Australia is damn comfy.

Also my partner will probably convince me to go back live there with her at one point, so I'll enjoy it as much as I can.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by thisone22 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:54AM (#28140875)
'So you have sun, good food, plenty of money and little immigration.'

Australia has one of the highest rates of inbound immigration in the world. Number 2 in the OECD actually, right after Luxembourg.

And I, like the overwhelming majority of Australians, consider high immigration intakes to be a good thing.

Check your sources.

[1] https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/people/population/migratio...

[2] https://data.oecd.org/migration/foreign-born-population.htm

[3] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1133441/australia-attitu...

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwawaylinux on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:52AM (#28141409)
Skilled immigration is neocolonialism. I truly can't believe how many (supposedly enlightened) people I've had try to tell me with a straight face how wonderful it is to have all these doctors/engineers/etc coming to their country, and how great it is for their economy and healthcare system etc.

Like, you don't think all the people in India or The Philippines or Chad need doctors or economic advancement?? It's just incredibly greedy and selfish. Can you imagine what a person who has just lost their child due to a preventable illness from being unable to see a doctor think when they hear some privileged person from an unimaginably wealthy country that already has an order of magnitude more doctors per capita and whose children will never see the suffering theirs routinely do -- boasting how wonderful it is that they are harvesting all the best healthcare workers from their country. Makes you shudder to think about it really.

These same people will bemoan a corporation from their country going to another one to conduct a resource extraction business (exploitation!) and yet when it comes to their own interests, they are quite happy to take and exploit a less well off country's most valuable resource which is its human capital.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by xyzzy123 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:09AM (#28141552)
Is it neocolonialism, or is it more like letting people vote with their feet? In a perfect world, we'd all be able to choose where we live.

Most of the people I talk to in Australia are more concerned about all the people that DON'T get let in.

Another lens is that countries are in the business of providing defence, governance, economic opportunity and lifestyle services. Immigrants are customers.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwawaylinux on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:12AM (#28141568)
Yes, yes it is neocolonialism. And it's easy to justify by saying "in a perfect world", but we don't live in a perfect world do we so that logic is just completely flawed. "In a perfect world we would do X" does not mean that doing X in the imperfect world we live in results in a better world.

It is neocolonialism because it is extracting the most valuable and profitable resources of less well off countries for your own benefit. Sure they can't compete with the massive incentives offered by the uber wealthy countries. Probably because those wealthy countries have been exploiting their resources including human capital in the past which keeps them poor and dependent.

But they should be thankful that their children get to sew shoes for us for a few cents a day.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by xyzzy123 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:29AM (#28141711)
Let's take doctors as a specific example.

Suppose we take the Phillipines and Malaysia, they (together) have about 6x the population of Australia. They have the capacity to train a lot of doctors - and a doctor can have a great life in either of those countries.

They can both also produce doctors more efficiently than Australia, partly due to living costs / ppp and population size, and partly due to Baumol's disease hitting education costs harder in AU.

But let's be honest, no country is talent-limited on doctor production. What's limited are training slots, and that is partly a practical concern... but also licensing restrictions - which tend to be regulated by doctors who have a strong interest in avoiding the oversupply of doctors.

What I am trying to say with all this is that there are many reasons someone might not be getting good medical care in say, the Phillipines but those reasons are not primarily due to doctors emigrating.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwawaylinux on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:34AM (#28141761)
What you write doesn't refute the problem which is that countries like this generally have worse health outcomes, healthcare systems, they have fewer skilled workers to build their economies.

Skimming their best resources off the top can't be justified by some dry economic formula (if it happens to be correct) that just by pure coincidence results in a worse outcome for that poorer country and a better outcome for the wealthier one. Colonialists had all sorts of economic arguments too.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by xyzzy123 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @12:28PM (#28144142)
You might enjoy this article from a Malaysian doctor (ok, Cambridge educated but fine) who is arguing that Malaysia is over-producing doctors: https://www.thestar.com.my/opinion/columnists/vital-signs/20...

I would agree that the Phillipines are under-supplied according to OECD ratios but again, I don't think the problem is emigration.

Personally I think your mental model of these countries is out-of-date. They are sophisticated and industrialised but do have high inequality and some governance problems. As usual, it's a distribution problem. I think you are under-estimating their capacity and they are not at all lacking in talent, education or human resources. Australia is lucky to get skilled migrants but is by no means "draining" them. I think I'd want to see a more quantitative argument before I was willing to accept that.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwawaylinux on Thursday August 12, 2021 @01:30AM (#28152339)
I'm not saying some individual's story or a particular situation in a particular country is neocolonialism. It's the entire system of siphoning resources from disadvantaged regions to wealthy ones.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by shell0x on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:17AM (#28142273)
As an expat, I go there where I get treated best. Why wouldn’t I? Do I owe my country of birth anything?
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwawaylinux on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:12AM (#28142976)
Are these rhetorical questions? I'm not quite sure how they address my comment.

There is a difference between that and the systemic concerted efforts by wealthy countries to poach and take the most valuable, skilled, educated of the human capital from poorer countries who are in positions of weakness and far less bargaining power.

I understand that the narrative is that it's about "helping the unfortunates", but really it's not. If a country wanted to help people you wouldn't "help" mainly the ones who can give them something (they are actually helping you), leaving the many more less fortunate ones in an even worse state.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by shell0x on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:11PM (#28149257)
I understand what you mean, but it’s not exclusive to wealthy countries poaching people from developing countries either right.

In Germany(already a wealthy country) doctors move to Switzerland for better pay and better working conditions too.

It’s also very expensive to move internationally. Visas can cost up to $10,000 alone, so I doubt that so many people actually leave developing countries for developed ones.

There are also tons of people who would never move countries because their family and social circle is in that particular place or they want to make their country a better place.

I also think many people move back home from overseas to their home country, bringing their improved skillset with them.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwawaylinux on Thursday August 12, 2021 @01:35AM (#28152378)
I didn't intend to imply that's the only situation where skilled migration occurs, but that is what I wrote so I should correct myself. When there is a relatively fair and level competition to compete for resources then there's less room for exploitative behavior of course. That applies not just to labor but really anywhere.

I think you're rationalizing or painting yourself a reality that you wish was true. Brain drain from disadvantaged countries on an industrial scale is a serious problem. Not for the wealthy privileged countries who benefit of course, which is why nobody says much about it and those who do get attacked.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by kwere on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:44AM (#28143446)
for a collectivist mentality you owe everithing to the community thats own you
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by JohnWhigham on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:16AM (#28143019)
People from less fortunate countries wanting to better themselves in more developed countries is somehow whitey's fault. I...wow. I never thought I would see such backwards retarded thinking on HN, but here we are.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by lethologica on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @06:35PM (#28148771)
Talk to some immigrants here in Australia and you’ll find that a lot don’t end up in the industry they were in from their home country. We have some pretty strict rules around qualifications for doctors, engineers etc and a lot of other countries educations doesn’t cut it for our standards. So most end up becoming taxi drivers or cleaners. When you speak with some of them, it’s almost tragic to have a talented individual unable to contribute to the field they’re qualified in. But no one forced them to come. No one forces them to stay. Is that still neocolonialism?
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwawaylinux on Thursday August 12, 2021 @01:29AM (#28152331)
Yes it is. I'm not saying some individual's story or an anecdote is neocolonialism. It's the entire system of siphoning resources from disadvantaged regions to wealthy ones.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by SuoDuanDao on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @03:50PM (#28146842)
If that's true, then neocolonialism is meaningless as a pejorative. I associate neocolonialism with economic hit men and predatory loans, not private citizens having the option to leave often abusive governments. By your definition, neocolonialism is simply the absence of serfdom.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwawaylinux on Thursday August 12, 2021 @01:24AM (#28152298)
> If that's true, then neocolonialism is meaningless as a pejorative. I associate neocolonialism with economic hit men and predatory loans,

Now that is meaningless. There are a whole vast range of ways to be exploitative and wealthy and powerful taking from poor and powerless.

> not private citizens having the option to leave often abusive governments.

I'm talking about the aggregate outcome for the people. The greater good. It's funny the disconnect some people have here between being so fast to denounce "individualism" greed, selfishness etc., in their own countries when they see it is a detriment to them. And yet they go completely the other way when it's a benefit to them and a detriment to people of other countries. That's the height of selfishness and hypocrisy as I see it.

> By your definition, neocolonialism is simply the absence of serfdom.

No it's not.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by SuoDuanDao on Thursday August 12, 2021 @07:50AM (#28155055)
yes, it is. Serfdom is when a peasant has no right to leave his lord's land. If neocolonialism includes recognition of the right to emigrate when another country wants to accept you as an immigrant, it's too broad a definition to be any kind of useful pejorative.

The collective outcome may be bad for the country from which people emigrate, but the individual outcome is very good for the people who emigrate. And at a higher level of organisation, the importance of retaining one's best and brightest creates incentives for all governments to behave better than they would if it was accepted the people born in a country belonged to the rulers like some kind of global slavery system.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwawaylinux on Thursday August 12, 2021 @07:07PM (#28162849)
I don't know what you want me to respond with, what you're writing is a strawman, it's not what I wrote anywhere.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by SuoDuanDao on Friday August 13, 2021 @06:57AM (#28167490)
What I'd like is for you to either narrow your category of 'Neocolonialism' in the future or explain you have a minority view about it. The term as it's used today implies the speaker is arguing against it. If your use of the term neocolonialism applies to people 'voting with their feet', then you are either rehabilitating the term or implicitly arguing for serfdom. Neither of which I think were your intent.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwawaylinux on Saturday August 14, 2021 @03:44AM (#28178872)
I have explained my view on it. Of course it's a minority view because few are willing to admit they willingly and knowingly benefit on the exploitation of those who have less than they do to begin with, but that's exactly what they do.

Trying to say it's either the industrial harvesting of the most skilled people from less advantaged countries, or it's "serfdom" is just outlandish. I don't even know where to start with that!

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:03AM (#28140947)
Australian have temporary immigration, becomming permanent is actually quite hard compared to europe where you can basically just walk in there.

Also, I consider it a chance to be able to go to school as well, it doesn't mean exams are easy.

Immigration is the same. It gives, and it takes.

Because australia is an island with a pretty good legal filter for immigrants, they get less social tensions.

Also because they have plenty of space and money, right now they can welcome immigrants way more easily.

And finally because immigration from asia is a good part of the immigration source, which also makes things easier culturally.

The situations is different in every part of the world.

Immigration is not a single variable universal phenomenom.

Today if you talk about the challenge that diversity can bring, you are labelled with pretty harshed words. But nothing is free.

Source: I've been an immigrant a lot.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by partomniscient on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:48AM (#28141379)
Based on what I've heard/read a lot of us would fail our own immigration test on Australian knowledge.

I grew up here in our system and was only vaguely aware there was even a second verse in our national anthem. The people trying to become citizens here and have only been here for a short time knew _all_ the words.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:39AM (#28142549)
I'm planning on using the c word a lot at the exam to sound more native
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by NonContro on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:19PM (#28150002)
"Do you think Australia needs more people?

Graduates: 58% yes

Non-Graduates: 24% yes"

https://www.macrobusiness.com.au/2020/10/72-of-aussies-do-no...

Not overwhelming.

Also there are some people who are happy with immigration, but only from other culturally-compatible regions, and as long as diversity (eg. max 10% from any one country) and equality (eg. max 49% males from any one country) is part of the intake.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by trissylegs on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:43AM (#28140778)
Australia's economy is pretty dependent on Coal, Aluminum and Gas. Two of these a hopefully going away soon but the Government is so In bed with mining and they throw more money at elections than every other sector put together that nothing will done about it until it collapses.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by alvah on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:38AM (#28141270)
Do you understand what you're actually wishing for when you cheer on the destruction of a large percentage of the economy? What comes after will not be so comfortable.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:46AM (#28141348)
The thing that gets me is not when people advocate for economically shooting themselves in the foot on principal, it's fine to have principals and stick to them even when it hurts you. What does infuriates me is that most of these people then apply a double standard for the other tribe and call them stupid when they advocate for sticking to their principals even when it hurts them.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jussij on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:55AM (#28141435)
I suspect the OP is wishing for Coal and Gas to go away soon in the hope it can spare the world from the upcoming catastrophe that is climate change.

What is stupid, with Europe and the USA both planning a tax on carbon, in just a few decades the OP's wish will most likely come true, yet Australia keeps wishing for a different future.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by alvah on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:15AM (#28142241)
OP's way of life has been made possible by cheap energy. Wishing it away before renewables are able to provide baseload power in an advanced economy (and the storage problem is, at best, decades away from being solved) is unwise.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jestar_jokin on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:12PM (#28151352)
South Australia has been doing pretty well with a renewables-backed grid.

There was a smear campaign in 2016 regarding a state-wide blackout, caused by severe weather affecting the distribution & transmission infrastructure. [see #1] The incumbant political party used this as an opportunity to blame the renewable generators (and state government, from the "opposite side" of politics). [see #2]

The same severe weather event would have affected any power generator.

[1] https://www.aer.gov.au/wholesale-markets/compliance-reportin... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_South_Australian_blackout...

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jussij on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:08PM (#28149225)
If Australia and the rest of the world continues to rely on coal as it's main source of baseload power then I suspect we are all doomed.

No amount of economic wealth is going to help once the environment has been damaged beyond repair.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by XorNot on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:43AM (#28142603)
Australia has the most abundant uranium reserves in the world. We have exactly 1 nuclear reactor we don't use for making power (yet is actually regionally vital for supplying medical isotopes to hospitals in SE-asia as well).

Every side of politics has acted like complete cowards on this issue, with the Liberals the worst offenders - they pay it lip service every election then do nothing while handing out cash to the coal miners.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by alvah on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:56AM (#28142774)
Agree 100%. Nuclear power will likely never happen in Australia now though, too many Karens terrified of it.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jestar_jokin on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:04PM (#28151285)
A forward-thinking government would be incentivising a diverse economy, subsidised by the windfall from the currently profitable industries.

Instead, the incumbant governments just subsidise the inumbant industries; or rather, the existing "winners". (E.g. subsidising Murdoch media, mining companies, all pulling in millions/billions in profit.)

Australia has one of the lowest rankings in terms of economic complexity [see #1]. Until the government can subsidise emerging markets, there's no reason for businesses to take risks - the low population can't support it.

Propping up existing industries will eventually be a failing strategy. When Australia's "luck" (exploitable resources) runs out, "what comes after will not be so comfortable". But there's still time to steer away from that discomfort. (Unlike the imminent ecology collapse...)

[1] https://www.aumanufacturing.com.au/astralias-low-economic-co...

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by stubish on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @06:05PM (#28148413)
More and more Australians are putting environmental issues ahead of economic, and are aware that this will make things less comfortable in the short term. Making personal sacrifices for the greater good is generally considered a positive trait in civil society. Many are hopeful that things will be better in the long term, and are hopeful an alternative source of income can be found before the inevitable collapse happens.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by kwere on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:57AM (#28143665)
that wealth enable chronism, it could be better long term for the australian people (or most resource-based countries) if it dissipated tomorrow
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by dharmach on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:17AM (#28141619)
>>Now, when things are getting hard, having weak democratic institutions, no political awareness and corporate medling is going to hit hard.

Many living in democracies will find this true for their country.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:48AM (#28141897)
Hence my last paragraphes. I'm pretty sure we are not heading in the right direction either.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by h0l0cube on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:41AM (#28140765)
> The run ended in europe after 1970, it ended in the US after 1990 and it will end in Autralia.

I wouldn't be so sure that they'll ever need to abandon their crutch of geological resources. There's nothing particularly industrious or forward-looking about Australia, precisely because they can dig up dirt and sell it at a premium.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by BiteCode_dev on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:56AM (#28140888)
The world is complex. Climate change, pollution, water shortage, demographic fluctuation, power grabbing, economical crisis, etc. So many things can happen and change the rules of the game entirely. Not to mention all what we don't know.

The book anti-fragile have a very good bit on that.

The point is everything moves, nothing stays the same, good and bad runs go hand in hand.

But imagine if a dictator of the last century had access to Facebook social graph...

You gotta be careful when it's good, to not have it too bad when it's getting bad later

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by h0l0cube on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:08AM (#28141541)
Yeah, I really think that having diverse and plentiful raw materials on mostly unused land is always going to be valuable. Off-earth mining is where disruption will eventually come from, but that's going to take a long while yet to become competitive with on-earth mining.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by charbonneau on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:16AM (#28140593)
I don't expect you to understand, but in Europe, people actually care about their rights [1]. There are weekly protests with lots of impact [2].

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28139889

[2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/10/protest-stop-c...

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by logicchains on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:39AM (#28140748)
>I don't expect you to understand, but in Europe, people actually care about their rights [1]

That's a bit condescending. In recent weeks there were tens of thousands of people marching on the streets of Sydney and Melbourne to protest covid lockdowns and defend their right to free assembly.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by shric on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:13AM (#28141039)
Do you have a source for "tens of thousands"? I think it was fewer than 10k.

Thankfully only 3,500 in Sydney out of a population of 5 million. Fortunately the vast majority of Australians aren't completely selfish and thoughtless. Nobody likes lockdowns. The government doesn't benefit from them, it's not lining some evil overlord's pockets.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by inkblotuniverse on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:28AM (#28142418)
>The government doesn't benefit from them It gains more control over people's lives and consolidates economic power into megacorporations. Shrinks the pie, but you have more direct control over it, and megacorp one will have better bribes bribes you than 1000 mom and pop stores. Seems like an okay deal to me.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jlangenauer on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:46AM (#28141859)
I believe the governments in Australia do benefit from the lockdowns. I'm from Australia, but live in Germany, so when I look back home from here, I'm shocked by how deliberately the fear of Covid has been stoked and played up in Australia. Constantly in and out of lockdowns, daily press conferences about death and case numbers, no path out and no hope.

It feels to me that Australia will be a country suffering from PTSD once it finds a way out of the pandemic and impossible dream of zero covid.

(For comparison, here in Europe, the pandemic is largely over, and our vaccination wall is looking strong enough that even what's coming over winter shouldn't be too bad.)

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by XorNot on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:47AM (#28142652)
There are not enough vaccines. Which is to say, the current Liberal government was offered a blank cheque from Pfizer to order as many as it could mid last year, instead didn't (because they're incompetent and incapable of understanding moderately sophisticated ideas), and then proceeded to engage in a runabout of graft, corruption and waste that means even when we are technically overflowing with AstraZeneca vaccines it's actually still surprisingly hard to have them (and I'll note, we also got short changed on AZ because Europe shut down exports of it for a while - though that's also on the Fed gov because again, we could've bought literally as much Pfizer as we wanted early on).

They aren't benefiting from anything: the governments are all rightly tanking in popularity, and being held up by Rupert Murdoch's multi-decadal commitment to dumbing down the narrative.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by ostenning on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:48AM (#28141378)
Australia barely protests about anything, and when a group of passionate people finally standup for something they believe in, they generally are ridiculed. Politicians squash any kind of dissent, even passing laws restricting protests. This isnt about antivax/anti-lockdown protests either, im talking about climate change, social inequality, workers rights etc.

Australia is a largely apathetic country, complacent because of their own wealth and removal from the international community.

But the situation is going to turn quite negatively for Australia, its becoming progressively worse because nobody actually believes in anything fundamental. We keep installing savvy businessmen politicians rather than people with a longterm vision for the country.

The result is exacerbating social problems. It makes you think where the countries priorities are when homelessness in Melbourne has gotten terribly worse in the past 7 years. People rather maximise their gains on the property market, borrowing exorbitant amounts of money to buy property they cant really afford, meanwhile devaluing the currency.

The result is the social fabric of a nation disintegrating.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by hestefisk on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:38AM (#28141266)
You mean the illegal protest where people turned up without masks, defying public health orders? I doubt that captures the majority of us concerned about mass surveillance.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by ghiculescu on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:55AM (#28141436)
The fact that you describe protesting as illegal kinda says it all.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by justinclift on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:31AM (#28141730)
Err... we're literally in a pandemic, where people getting together in large numbers makes things worse.

When we're not in pandemic conditions, people are quite welcome to gather and protest whatever the heck they want.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by inkblotuniverse on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:29AM (#28142435)
What a great precedent! Now we can just keep the (declaration of) pandemic going for the next 10 years, and we have license to shut down anything we like!
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by peytn on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:23AM (#28142351)
I go to a large gathering every week. It’s called the supermarket. In light of that, it seems silly to suspend civil rights.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by justinclift on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @02:06PM (#28145483)
Maybe the supermarkets here are different?

We all keep good spacing (1.5m) between each other, wear face masks, etc.

Very, very different to the protests apparently, judging by the photos in the newspapers.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jjgreen on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:07AM (#28142151)
Don't be surprised if that takes, er, a while to happen
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by XorNot on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:48AM (#28142666)
So do you people who keep telling everyone dictatorship is next whenever anything happens get tired of being wrong literally every time?
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jjgreen on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @10:56AM (#28142775)
I missed the bit where I told anyone that dictatorship was next.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by XorNot on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @06:23PM (#28148619)
Oh, so what was the implication of your comment meant to be? Why is the government not going to end the pandemic measures anytime soon?
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jjgreen on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @06:37PM (#28148797)
I said nothing about governments, just that the pandemic is not ending any time soon. It will be with our grandchidren, and theirs.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by XorNot on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:00PM (#28149103)
But why is the pandemic not ending? It seems strange that with the rollout of vaccines it would last for another 50 years.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jjgreen on Thursday August 12, 2021 @03:57AM (#28153394)
You think it can be beaten? I doubt it (and I'm not alone in thinking that). Even if vaccine coverage were 99% everywhere the world (it won't be), and it were 99% effective (it's not) there will still be a reservoir of virus in cats, deer, gerbils ... time will tell I guess, but I think it more likely that our species will accept that it's not going away by declaring it "endemic" rather than "pandemic", as with flu.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by XorNot on Thursday August 12, 2021 @12:08PM (#28158027)
A pandemic is the rapid spread international spread of a disease. Key word: rapid.

Question: why is there not a flu pandemic every year? Answer: because the flu is not a novel virus, and does not hit the population in the same way. The flu can be very severe, which is why we vaccinate against it, but within any given population there is a multitude of degrees of existing immunity from previous rounds of flu through the population.

COVID-19 is a novel virus - no human on Earth until 1.5 years ago had ever been infected with it, and it's spread follows the expectation of a novel virus: with no prior immunity, the entire population is initially infectable.

This, obviously however, is not a continuing situation: prior infection with COVID-19 confers immunity against COVID-19, as well as effective immunity against the variant mutations which have arisen. There have not been cases of reinfection within over a year. Even if COVID-19 can infect vaccinated populations, it does so with less severe outcomes, and having done so leaves behind a reservoir of now immune recipients.

In fact even if a new COVID-19 strain arose well after infection, people who had been exposed or vaccinated to earlier strains would not present the sort of completely vulnerable population which the initial COVID-19 virus represented.

COVID-19 is now going to be an endemic disease, but that hardly means people will keep catching up, but instead that in any given year a small subset of the population is likely to contract it and recover - possibly requiring medical intervention, but this is a number which can be managed and planned for.

What has made COVID-19 a problem though, is the novel nature of the virus and it's rapid spread. We are perfectly able to deal with expected loads on healthcare, but not with a surge of 10-20% of the entire population of a country within a 6-12 month window with over a month of recovery time. But against a vaccinated population that figure falls by almost 92-96%, with 60-70% of people never developing symptoms. That is a manageable number over the same time frame.

COVID-19 is not like the flu, and infectious novel diseases will always require immediate and drastic countermeasures. An ideal outcome for COVID-19 would have been containment in Wuhan: it would have lent plenty of time to develop, test, and incorporate into routine vaccine schedules innoculations against it.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by bradrn on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:44AM (#28140795)
> tens of thousands of people marching on the streets of Sydney and Melbourne to protest covid lockdowns and defend their right to free assembly

As an Aussie I must say that I see these protests rather differently. For better or worse, Australia has gotten used to having zero COVID: people here tend to see the protesters not as brave individuals defending their rights, but as idiots who recklessly endanger the lives of others by spreading disease through a largely unvaccinated populace. Many people here are of the opinion that some ‘fundamental’ rights can and should be suspended in a critical emergency.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by BLKNSLVR on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:43AM (#28140787)
Fucking perfect example. Exemplifies exactly the things that get Australians hot and bothered enough to protest - getting it totally and absolutely arse-about.

Perfect example, nicely done.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by shric on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:36AM (#28140722)
Link 2 is a 404 for me.

Hilariously, Australians protest about their rights by trying their best to extend lockdowns further [1].

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/jul/24/anti-...

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by logicchains on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:41AM (#28140760)
Why is it hilarious? The whole point of human rights is they they don't just disappear whenever there's an emergency, otherwise the next dictator who comes along will just declare an emergency and violate everyone's rights, as has happened countless times in history. It's sad not funny that people protesting their rights being violated just leads to their rights being violated even more.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by thisone22 on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:05AM (#28140971)
Ok, this is a spectrum.

How far along the spectrum does the emergency need to get to justify a lockdown?

For example

- The Black Plague which killed 30%~ of Europe. At what point would a lockdown be justified?

- Germany just invaded my northern border. Again. Am I allowed to force my residents to turn their lights off to avoid bombing?

Rights aren't universal, and no serious person argues this. There is always an emergency that's bad enough.

The question is 'what is bad enough' and this has no scientific answer. The answer is up to the government of the day, and the population who can decide whether to turf that government.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by Pet_Ant on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @11:49AM (#28143532)
> Rights aren't universal, and no serious person argues this. There is always an emergency that's bad enough.

I feel like this is the point of contention. Many people truly don't consider things that can be taken away a right. Is the constitution a suicide pact a serious question that has been argued in the US Supreme Court (that phrased originated by a justice arguing that it wasn't... he was in the minority opinion).

I will try to keep this neutral, but people say things like "driving isn't a right, it's a priveledge"... what distinguishes between rights and priveledges?

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by stavros on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @07:50AM (#28140839)
So, in your view, human rights cannot be suspended, even if there is an emergency? So things like banning indoor meetings should be allowed to continue, even when there is a pandemic?

I didn't protest the lockdowns because it seems reasonable to me that you'd want to ban proximity to curtail the spread of a disease that spreads by proximity. That doesn't mean I won't protest a dictator just declaring an emergency and violating everyone's rights.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by eightails on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:11AM (#28141026)
> So, in your view, human rights cannot be suspended, even if there is an emergency?

This does seem a pretty common misconception. People seem to forget that even the most liberal countries still regularly and systematically infringe on people's rights, e.g. by imprisoning criminals. But you don't see many of the anti-lockdown types protesting the existence of prisons.

In both cases, it's a matter of proportionally balancing the loss of individual rights with the interests (and indeed, other conflicting rights) of the community as a whole.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by lethologica on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @06:53PM (#28148995)
The imprisonment of criminals is a governments way of fulfilling one of its primary duties, keeping its citizens safe. It’s not 100% accurate of course but I’d much rather take that than wondering if my neighbour will kill me.

If you’re saying a government shouldn’t be locking people up so that an individuals rights aren’t violated, then you’re saying a government shouldn’t be looking after the wellbeing of its people. In which case, you’re essentially talking about anarchy.

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by stavros on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:42PM (#28150206)
But you're agreeing with the GP. Similarly, governments have a responsibility towards the citizens to protect them against COVID, even if that means some temporary lockdowns.
Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by jaywalk on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @09:32AM (#28141740)
"Just do what you're told and you'll get your rights back when the dear leaders decide you've done enough. But they'll still reserve the right to take them away whenever they feel like it."

How's that boot polish tasting?

Re:Australia is becoming a surveillance state by onethought on Wednesday August 11, 2021 @08:09AM (#28141008)
Which rights would those be? The ones that were given up in order to join the EU?

Most EU countries are not sovereign states, given by the fact they don’t control their borders nor their economy (See Greece, or the other affectionately named PIGS countries). There is an insane amount of influence from Germany and Belgium.

This is a glasshouses and stones situation.