News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stupidity is a specific cognitive failing by oblio on Monday August 09, 2021 @05:09AM (#28114191)
They could force a drawn-out engagement, though, which in many cases the attackers couldn't support. You needed a lot fewer people to defend a castle than to assault it.
Re:Stupidity is a specific cognitive failing by sokoloff on Monday August 09, 2021 @06:16AM (#28114765)
It seems much easier for the attackers to supply themselves (even in a foreign land) such that encircle-and-wait would virtually ensure an attacker victory if no one came to the defender’s aid.
Re:Stupidity is a specific cognitive failing by earthbee on Monday August 09, 2021 @07:02AM (#28115142)
Even where besiegers outnumbered the besieged by a huge margin it still often took months or even years to defeat a castle by siege, yet if the same two forces met in open battle it would be over in an hour or less. This clearly shows that in castle warfare the defence has a huge advantage.
Re:Stupidity is a specific cognitive failing by bzbarsky on Monday August 09, 2021 @01:44PM (#28119865)
> It seems much easier for the attackers to supply themselves (even in a foreign land)

That's a modern-transportation perspective. Unless the siege happens to be on a waterway and you supply that way.

Land-based logistics for pre-modern armies was _hard_. The standard solution was to keep the army on the move and forage as you went, so you kept stealing food from new peasants, but that's not an option for an army laying a siege. On the other hand, if the castle/town knew a siege was coming they would move things like livestock from the surrounding countryside inside the walls, and the grain stores were likely _already_ inside the walls.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Nuremberg explicitly mentions supply as a problem for the besieging army in that case, and that's an early-modern army, not premodern. http://hundredyearswar.com/Books/History/Sieges.htm also says "the siege was often lifted because the besieging commander ran out of food to feed or money to pay his troops".

In practice, what this meant is that you would not even start a siege unless you had some idea that you could ensure supply, which was the common situation.

Re:Stupidity is a specific cognitive failing by oblio on Monday August 09, 2021 @07:14AM (#28115247)
Supply wasn't the only factor: disease, troop morale, sabotage, etc. Few generals would have prolonged a war if they could do anything about it.