News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apps Getting Worse by WhatIsDukkha on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:01PM (#28110076)
This is one of the reasons my desktop and as much of my phone as possible are opensource.

"outdated" "old" is an actual stable experience with bug fixes and responsiveness to actual users and not product managers.

The migration to swipes for everything on the phones is mind boggling.

Super cool for the tweens and twenty year olds that are used to being pushed to the next thing every 2 months.

My older relatives have no concept of what a swipe is and why it should do anything.

Total chaos and brokenness for them and millions of others.

Re:Apps Getting Worse by flenserboy on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:30PM (#28110293)
Here is where OSS could really shine - make clones of old programs and give them modern features while keeping the old-school, actually-working interfaces. Rather than cloning the current (or near-current) iteration of Office, make a file-compatible version that's a snap to use and avoids as much interface fluff as possible. Applications are for work, and should facilitate work.

Imagine a Word 5-equivalent WP (and no, AbiWord is nowhere near that), a WP 5.1 clone, a XyWrite that knows OpenType, a dBase-style interface (definitely not a clone) for a modern, free database system. Those older programs simply worked, had command systems that could be explored and learned (shoot, before the Ribbon even Office could be sussed out through experimentation), and were about work. As much as I appreciate what I can do, capability-wise, with modern systems, the people who design them don't seem to be the people who use them.

Re:Apps Getting Worse by dmitriid on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:36PM (#28110331)
OSS doesn't have money for good design, because good design costs money and commitment. Both are the things OSS projects struggle with.
Re:Apps Getting Worse by HKH2 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:21PM (#28111787)
Also, why bother with GUIs when you've got a CLI and a decent-sized keyboard?
Re:Apps Getting Worse by zozbot234 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:42PM (#28110382)
OSS has the best designs, at least on the desktop. And it's becoming quite competitive in mobile and touch interfaces, too.
Re:Apps Getting Worse by the_duke on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:30PM (#28110746)
Which apps are you referring to?

I couldn't name a single open source desktop apps which has good UX or design.

It's natural, since these are built by developers, not designers, and they primarily care about functionality and don't have to entice users with good looks and UX.

I do know some Android apps that are pretty good, eg RedReader for Reddit.

Re:Apps Getting Worse by akho on Monday August 09, 2021 @06:23AM (#28114839)
Functionality is part of UX.

Also, “good” is a very high (and ambiguous) bar. Can you name any commercial apps you believe to be good?

Re:Apps Getting Worse by HKH2 on Monday August 09, 2021 @08:20AM (#28115842)
Handbrake is probably the best I've seen at balancing simple and advanced options.
Re:Apps Getting Worse by HKH2 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:17PM (#28111762)
Does Syncthing count?
Re:Apps Getting Worse by tonyedgecombe on Monday August 09, 2021 @05:21AM (#28114314)
No, I found it really cumbersome to use.

Although I will say that is the case for every sync product I've tried and I have tried most of them.

Re:Apps Getting Worse by sprkwd on Monday August 09, 2021 @04:05AM (#28113769)
VLC?
Re:Apps Getting Worse by HKH2 on Monday August 09, 2021 @08:17AM (#28115816)
In Linux, VLC won't quit. It will just minimize to the tray, but block anything else from being opened. It seems the only option is pkill-ing it.
Re:Apps Getting Worse by na85 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:11PM (#28110606)
>OSS has the best designs, at least on the desktop.

I guess you haven't used GIMP

Re:Apps Getting Worse by dmitriid on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:23PM (#28110696)
I'll admit I haven't used in a long time. It's definitely been improving for a long time, but my recollection of it has always been as being somewhat messy.

Compare, say, to Affinity, Pixelmator, Procreate...

Re:Apps Getting Worse by dmitriid on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:56PM (#28110490)
> OSS has the best designs, at least on the desktop

Where? OSS is consistently a mish-mash of unfinished ideas.

Re:Apps Getting Worse by EthanHarv on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:17PM (#28110648)
Blender 2.8+ has done a pretty good job. I think in general OSS UX is pretty bad, but there are some stand-out exceptions.
Re:Apps Getting Worse by dmitriid on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:21PM (#28110682)
Yes, Blender is one of the really good ones
Re:Apps Getting Worse by nebula8804 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:27PM (#28110265)
I keep trying to adopt this workflow and it ends in disaster. For example: Yesterday I installed a clean copy of the latest release of Ubuntu. Lets ignore the numerous annoyances that are unpolished such as the mouse tracking or the OS filled with apps that are worse than its Windows/Mac counterparts. No one seems to want to produce a cohesive OS + apps anyway.

The one thing that is absolutely unforgivable is an app that you expect to trust instead ends up failing you.

My example: After installing I needed to compress a folder of important code and pictures. Just use Archiver right? Well I compressed the folder into a zip file. Something seemed strange. Ubuntu's file manager was reporting 0 bytes for the file after compressing. Strange, so I copied it to another folder. OK 8.5MB. Maybe the file manager was just not able to automatically refresh. The file size seemed small given the input was 300MB. Me being a little worried after seeing this and having been burned in the past, I opened the file and attempted to decompress. First, I was able to see the files so I could have stopped there thinking the file is fine but I continued and clicked extract. It failed. Turns out the file was corrupted.

Imagine if I had not done this sanity check and 6 months later I go to uncompress and the archive is corrupted. That is a potential anxiety attack.

This is not a joke, if you cannot ever trust the damn system to do basic things, you will constantly feel like you are walking on thin ice. Its 2021 how is this still an issue? When you go to complain you are treated with an uncaring groups or more likely an actively hostile group of people.

I have been going back and forth from Linux(various distros) for 15 years now. Not once have I ever felt that I could fully trust my system. The people who develop this stuff don't seem to care about basic quality. If it works for them, ship it. I don't know how to solve this problem without a financial incentive. There are no consequences to shipping regressions and thus even though the software is free as in freedom the incentives are not really aligned with many users.

Maybe I need to sit down and read through as much of the code of the OS and associated apps as possible and set specific version that I "FREEZE" on that are good known versions. But then I will not be able to get any help when something does break since im on old versions and typically googling issues returns fixes for the latest version...so now I would be left with fixing the code myself.

Re:Apps Getting Worse by zozbot234 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:39PM (#28110352)
Swiping gestures/actions are actually a very natural affordance in mobile "touch" interfaces. They're based on the Accot-Zhai steering law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accot-Zhai_steering_law a natural extension of Fitt's law that was developed as early as the 1990s.
Re:Apps Getting Worse by CRConrad on Monday August 09, 2021 @05:46PM (#28122707)
The problem with swiping and gestures is precisely that it has no affordances.