This is what happens when a central bank keeps on preventing moderate recessions necessary for correcting a nation’s economic failures. The US and Europe should study the case of Japan very closely these days.
An alternative view might be that the excessive returns in the US are due to outright financial manipulation using share by backs funded by low interest rates (amongst other things) leading to an insane concentration of money in the stock market and financial sector to the detriment of large sections of US society, its basic infrastructure, and its democracy.
This is what happens when white collar crime is institutionalised.
Buying back shares is neither "financial manipulation" nor is it a "white collar crime".
When interest rates are low and you are bullish on the company, it makes perfect sense to buy back shares.
https://www.hbr.org/2020/01/why-stock-buybacks-are-dangerous...
Course, if financial incentives for the c-suite are tied to share price, that's just another example of choose the reward, choose the consequences.
Do you know what share buybacks even are?
The high cost of health care in the US is due to a large number of factors, one of which is lack of transparent pricing, anti-competitive practises in insurance companies, and lack of public-purchasing power for health care. Very little is due to "corruption".
The subsequent 30 years look bad, but the alternative was Great-Depression-style deflation, 25%+ unemployment, and potentially societal collapse.
That 40k was a fake, not true in the sense japan was not actually 2x more productive than the US. Instead it was the product of a super massive bubble. It took over a decade for the US to "catch up". To be more honest: it was japan which needed time for reality to catch up to nominal values.
At this point in time the US is now well past Japan in GDP per capita, which frankly makes sense. The US is much more innovative, with creative destruction occurring everywhere.
By the way. QE has literally no impact on an economy by definition. It's entirely psychological. I don't know why central banks keep doing it. There isn't any private demand left over for credit at current interest rates. Central bank reserves are counted as part of the money supply but their velocity is 0 for practical purposes. You can't withdraw them and you can't use them to purchase goods. The only thing they do is let banks lend out more money which counts for nothing if interest rates are too high.
>This is what happens when a central bank keeps on preventing moderate recessions necessary for correcting a nation’s economic failures.
No such thing is necessary (enduring recessions for no reason). Also, USA is suffering from having the worlds reserve currency and Europe is suffering from having an incomplete euro.
Possibly largely unrelated solely to this, Switzerland is amazing on another thing - very strong middle class that is not dwindling, unlike most of the western world.
Yeah, expats often complain to no end that services and food are expensive compared to where they came from, but thanks to that tons of folks are not desperate, we don't have slums of poor serving the rest, and you know that even person filling the shelves in supermarket is getting decent wage.
Low criminality, high education, generally very smart general population (which allows to have frequent public votes on important things without shooting one's foot like some other places), tons of personal freedom that average US person can only envy, EU is even worse. It all ties together, and middle class is one of the pillars of this.
Are we talking about the same Switzerland I lived in for two years? Not being able to do laundry on Sunday was actually a big hit to my personal liberty. There are also a lot of little rules that sneak up on you, all perfectly fine if you are willing to conform to basically being Swiss, but if you aren’t it can get uncomfortable.
But what we do have is general respect for everybody else living here (unlike f*k the rest like in many other places) - which means we for example don't run wash machine during late evening/night in our apartment, within building having some 50+ apartments.
There is also shared wash machine area in the basement, with dedicated time slots for each family if they want, and there are plenty of slots for Sunday, just like any other day. So much for the restriction you faced.
Some might find some restrictions annoying and infringing on their basic human rights, but the general Swiss logic is more about 'your rights end where other's rights begin'. As a parent of a newborn I definitely like this approach.
* https://cowbellsandchocolate.com/sundays-and-quiet-rules/
* https://www.reddit.com/r/askswitzerland/comments/asqw9o/law_...
* https://www.englishforum.ch/other-general/22277-really-forbi...
* https://www.newlyswissed.com/sydney-international-food-festi...
Now, almost every rule/law in Switzerland is local, so it is definitely possible that you lived in a canton or commune without such rules on the book. I most definitely lived in places where that was the rule.
this is actually hilarious. thank you for sharing.
It does have a rather larger number of temporary workers than was historically the case.
but they do? bernanke was a scholar of japan's central bank policy.
If I remember correctly then Japan was about to take over the USA in terms of the GDP, but started to become strong in many key industries, and then Raegan, who was running under "Let's make America great again" slogan, initiated the anti-Japanese trade war.
And if I am not mistaken or am not simplifying too much then Trump was even hiring the same consultants from that "anti Japan" trade war to start the trade war with China.
> a large unemployment rate
what is japans current unemployment rate?1) Noting that the stock market was boring I think is real indicator of the mass psychology of that time. There is definitely a inverse correlation between enthusiasm for markets and future returns.
2) Noting the returns of standard Oil is a reasonable take. There was a massive expansion of combustion engine production in the preceding two decades and inferring that this would be correlated with increased demand for oil based products is not hot take. Also it doesn’t take a genius to understand a oil is better business that automobiles, recurring revenue and all.
3) Tax rates have historically influenced valuations.
4) I’m not sure how to extrapolate the the German currency situation but I think looking at the relative attractiveness global markets makes sense.
A sector can shrink from 63% of the total market to less than 1% and outperform the market over the time that happened. See the US railway sector from 1900 to 2020:
https://www.credit-suisse.com/media/assets/corporate/docs/ab...
In the 1920’s standard oil subsidiaries were still an effective monopoly for petroleum in the us market. Therefore a reasonable proxy for the future profitability of the entire industry in that market assuming that their ruthless anticompetitive behavior allowed them retain their market dominance. Additionally they were profiting off the same disruption in transportation that you are citing, which as we are both acknowledging was massive.
The book Titan is awesome context for this. Wonderful read.
Unlike the technology such as railroads, natural resource commodities and vertically integrated supply chains tend to not be disrupted as easily (very unfortunate for us).
I’m not saying that it couldn’t have gone wrong, but clearly an asymmetrical risk reward at 3-5 PE. So in general you are right, but I think if you find a company that has a great business model, is a monopoly, and is disrupting a massive market, at reasonable price, you have a recipe for outlier returns.
In 1921, you did not know DJI would have done so well over the next 100 yrs.
A very real counter example is the Japanese stock market. The Nikkei peaked at 39,000 in 1989. Thirty yrs later, it's only 28,000. Many blue chip stocks on Tokyo Stock Exch have never recovered their previous high.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias