News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by jagger27 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:08PM (#28108724)
Glenfiddich makes some damn fine Scotch.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by marban on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:13PM (#28108757)
I'm into wine but my sense was that GF is more like gas station Scotch in Europe.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by smcl on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:02PM (#28110077)
Ehh not really. Some cheaper blends like Grant's (same parent company and bottle shape!) would be what you're thinking of. But Glenfiddich is generally considered to be an accessible, affordable single malt and is often recommended for beginners as an introductory Highland malt.

I happily drink Glenfiddich 12 when I'm in the mood for a whisky in a bar that doesn't have a great selection, and I have a Glenfiddich 15 in my cabinet which is really pleasant

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by FridayoLeary on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:33PM (#28108931)
my thoughts exactly. But at least it isn't Jack Daniels..
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by staticassertion on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:21PM (#28108827)
I like Glenfiddich (15)... but apparently others disagree. I like Laphroig a lot as well, though they're totally different.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by bdcravens on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:30PM (#28108911)
I don't drink anymore, but the GF15 was always my favorite scotch.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by orf on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:10PM (#28108734)
Honestly, not really. A lot of the blended export stuff isn't great. Some of the older single malts are good (but then again which aren't?), but there are much better ones out there.

It's just got a good recognizable name that is easily marketable to consumers in the US and Europe as a "good" Whisky.

Edit: So it's not bad, it's just super mass-produced. You find it in every single place that sells Whisky (corner-stores, supermarkets, petrol stations, etc etc) alongside Famous Grouse, Bells and the like. They make it for a particular audience is all I'm saying, and IDK if I'd define it as "fine".

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by ravenstine on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:03PM (#28109226)
It depends on what you're looking for. I've seen so much "trash" wine and spirits turn out to be total hits with people that I don't think anyone can outright say that any drink is objectively good or bad other than perhaps absolute bottom-shelf spirits. I was at a party back on fourth of July where someone brought this incredible scotch that literally everyone there found to be amazing. My parents decided to get a bottle and we shared it with a group of relatives who unanimously poo-poo'd it.

Maybe a connoisseur looks for certain taste and smell profiles most people couldn't discern, but that doesn't mean a given whisky is bad.

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by jagger27 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:31PM (#28108917)
That's fair, and I'll say I've only recently been getting into scotches. I recently tried a flight of the following which influenced my above comment:

- Glenfiddich (18)

- Highland Park (18, my personal favourite of these)

- Oban (14)

- Auchentoshan (21)

- Lagavulin (16)

Yeah, a Glenfiddich 12 year old isn't anything near any of those.

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by orf on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:47PM (#28109077)
I’d highly recommend trying Laphroaig if you can, it’s really smokey and delicious.

But sorry, I didn’t mean to crap on your taste in whisky. I live in a foreign country and I see all kinds of “genuine Scottish whisky” for sale that is absolute piss (hello Scottish Meadow). Something is wrong with places charging extortionate prices for not-great, young mass produced whisky.

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by dexterdog on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:55PM (#28109161)
I really like Laphroaig, but it's definitely an acquired taste. It's like eating moss so most people don't enjoy their first taste and many don't come back for a second.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by dctoedt on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:25PM (#28110715)
My nephew-in-law's groom cake (at his wedding) was in the shape of a Laphroaig bottle. The whisky always struck me as like drinking diluted roofing tar.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by gmac on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:57PM (#28109590)
Moss? Peat smoke, certainly. There’s a hint of it even in the drinking water if you ever stay on Islay.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by ecommerceguy on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:21PM (#28109769)
Bruichladdich Islay Barley, while being an nonpeated Islay, is the best deal in all of whisky.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by birdyrooster on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:56PM (#28109167)
Or just get some liquid smoke and pour it into your scotch and ruin it the old fashioned way. Have had lafrog and it’s like cancer with a hint of cancer.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by maqp on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:34PM (#28110781)
HP18 is pretty damn good.

Few other fine experiences from over the years

- Aberfeldy 12y

- Powers John's Lane 12y

- Glenfarclas 40y

- Glen Garioch 1994

- Old Pulteney 21y

- Old Pulteney 16y Bourbon Cask strength

- Imperial 16y (Signatory Vintage / Rare Auld Duncan Taylor bottling)

- Glen Moray 24y cask strength (Duncan Taylor bottling)

- Port Ellen 27y

- Bushmills 1988 14y (Cask strength, Rum Barrel)

- Ardbeg Uigeadail/Corryvreckan

- Laphroaig 18y (excellent; the 10yo tastes like exhaust fumes)

- Laphroaig 1989 Vintage 23y

- Royal Brackla 1976 (Mackillop's Choice bottling)

- Caol Ila 1990 Mackillop's Choice bottling, single cask sherry wood

- Evan Williams Single Barrel Vintage

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by qeternity on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:51PM (#28109981)
A few must haves:

- Bunna 12

- Nikka FTB

- Craigellachie 13

- Springbank 10

- Ardbeg 10

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by jdsully on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:26PM (#28108877)
I don’t understand the infatuation with single malts. The distiller has a lot more control when making a blend and assuming equal skill and care can make a better product
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by twic on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:57PM (#28109176)
Not quite: "blended whisky" is a blend of malt and grain whisky. Grain whisky has very little flavour. Hence, blended whiskies invariably have less flavour than single malts.

There is also "blended malt whisky", which is made entirely of malt whisky, but from more than one distillery. As you say, that can be very good, but for whatever reason it isn't a huge category. I think it's growing, though - Monkey Shoulder is a fairly new blended malt that has become a de facto standard workhorse Scotch in cocktail bars, and Compass Box has been grinding out good blended malts for years.

Bear in mind that there is enormous variation between individual casks even at a single distillery. The blender at a distillery has an adequately broad palette to work with, even within the constraints of making single malt.

Indeed, it is often the case that a blender will decide that some particular cask in their stock is too far outside the parameters of their house style to use at all. These casks go to independent bottlers, who put their own name on it, and try to find some niche to market it to.

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by dogma1138 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:07PM (#28109251)
That really depends on the country/regulation, Irish blended whiskey is indeed a blend of Grain and Malt whiskey, Scottish blended is a mix of single malts and is usually labeled as blended malt whiskey instead of just blended.

But indeed people tend to classify blended whiskeys as inferior for some reason they aren’t, especially in tightly regulated countries or from good distilleries.

Blended whiskeys allow for a much wider flavor spectrum and most importantly consistency which you can’t get from single malt/single cask whiskeys as each batch and even cask will have quite a bit of variance.

Once you get to the few £1000 per bottle often from brands you never heard off including a lot of private clubs, the whiskeys are nearly always blended and they basically are blends of some of the most rare and sought off single malts.

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by smcl on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:14PM (#28110171)
Just to add a bit more regarding what we call Scotch, since there's a bit of confusion here. We have a few terms which are quite strictly legally protected:

Single malt = a single distillery blending various barrels of malt whisky they produced themselves

Single grain = a single distillery blending various barrels of grain whisky they produced themselves

Blended malt = a whisky produced from barrels of malt whisky from various distilleries

Blended grain = a whisky produced from barrels of grain whisky from various distilleries ... I don't think I have ever seen this :)

Blended scotch = a whisky produced from barrels of grain or malt whisky from various distilleries

If you were to randomly choose a cheaper whisky it'll likely be a blended scotch, if you were to randomly choose a more expensive whisky it'll likely be a single malt. There are exceptions of course - there are cheap(er) single malts and there are pricier blends - and "blended" does not necessarily imply bad whisky (nor does the presence of grain whisky necessarily imply bad!). And indeed there are pricey single grains (Arbikie in Arbroath were doing a Rye whisky for a few hundred pounds a bottle). The only way to know anything for sure is to sample for yourself, which is a delicious and fun thing to do :D

Edit: oh and "grain" refers to a bunch of things that aren't barley - it could be corn, millet, wheat, rye, rice or other things.

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by twic on Sunday August 08, 2021 @06:02PM (#28110531)
How could i have forgotten Royal Salute Tribute to Honour:

https://robbreport.com/food-drink/spirits/taste-royal-salute...

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by fuzzfactor on Sunday August 08, 2021 @10:30PM (#28112169)
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by scarytom on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:05PM (#28109238)
A single malt is not made from a single cask, and each cask behaves slightly differently. The distiller therefore has a lot to work with, and will very carefully blend multiple casks to create the desired single malt product before bottling.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by OJFord on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:36PM (#28108970)
I think in general (i.e. not just w.r.t. whisky) it comes from the constituents being non-vintage, since not many vintage crops declared a {relevant mark for 'good year'} wind up blended, and then since correlation of course equals, er, backwards causation, we end up with this 'all blends are worse than any single X'. Which of course isn't true.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by te_chris on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:55PM (#28109158)
Urban legend I've heard is it was a marketing ploy dreamed up by the Guinness company to charge Americans more. Seems to have worked.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by FridayoLeary on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:35PM (#28108960)
I'm also not sure why almost every whisky out there seems to be watered down to 40%.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by bboreham on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:47PM (#28109080)
Bound to be for tax reasons.

However, if you haven’t read this story it’s quite interesting.

https://www.newscientist.com/article/2144353-why-adding-a-dr...

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by dageshi on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:00PM (#28109202)
40% is the legal minimum to call it Whiskey in the UK. It's watered down to increase profit.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by chrisseaton on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:50PM (#28109111)
Doesn't it get pretty hard to actually drink it above 40%?
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by te_chris on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:57PM (#28109177)
Not at all. Acquired taste perhaps, but high-strength, well-made spirits can be wonderful. Need to treat them with respect though, as the downsides are obvious. Loads of the over-proof whiskys and rums are glorious.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by smcl on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:23PM (#28110233)
The strongest you'll likely see is 60% (I have a Glenfarclas 105 at that ABV) but you are right it gets a little challenging at a higher ABV. However between 43-46% is a little richer in flavour without being too nippy even for beginners.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by FridayoLeary on Monday August 09, 2021 @01:49PM (#28119929)
depends on the whisky. I understand some do well being diluted and others are fine at cask strength.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by randallsquared on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:28PM (#28108898)
"blended export stuff"? Does Glenfiddich even have a blended expression? (Does the Solera vat count as a blending method for your statement?)
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by twic on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:43PM (#28109046)
"Blended" means a whisky combines both malt and grain spirit. Glenfiddich make malt spirit, but not grain spirit [1], so there's no way a "blended Glenfiddich" could exist. There could be blended whiskies containing Glenfiddich and grain spirit from another distillery, but those are just blended whiskies like any other; you couldn't consider them to be Glenfiddich.

"Blended malt" means a whisky combines malt spirit from multiple distilleries, so "blended malt Glenfiddich" would be an oxymoron.

A Solera system doesn't count as any kind of blending, as long as all the inputs are malt whisky from a single distillery.

[1] these are the grain distilleries: https://www.whiskyinvestdirect.com/about-whisky/grain-whisky...

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by GavinMcG on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:46PM (#28109507)
Blended doesn't mean malt + grain. Blended means producer + other producer. That's why, as you said, blended malt means malt spirits combined from multiple distilleries.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by twic on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:26PM (#28110255)
That had been my belief up until i started to write that comment, at which point i went to look it up. Having done so, i am moderately confident that the definition of "blended whisky" in the context of Scotch is that it combines malt and grain whisky. Since there are (almost) no distilleries that produce both, this also implies combining different distilleries. But it's the malt plus grain aspect which is essential.

Note that if you combine malt whisky from two producers, you get "blended malt whisky" not "blended whisky".

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by GavinMcG on Monday August 09, 2021 @07:22AM (#28115309)
Ok, I partially stand corrected and partially renew my objection. The word "blended" on its own does not mean malt + grain, and leading off an explanation of scotch categorization with that definition is confusing. "Blended" is part of the name of three different categories of non-single-distillery products, only one of which is "blended scotch whisky"; the word itself simply denotes non-single-distillery products.

"Blended scotch whisky" is the term of art that denotes scotch whisky blended from single malt and single grain whiskys, according to the SWR.

Particularly when one's audience isn't experienced in this area, it would be helpful to flag terms of art, and to clarify that you're talking about specific labeling standards. The commenter had said "blended export stuff" which made it clear (to me) that they weren't speaking that technically.

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by randallsquared on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:53PM (#28110005)
This was my understanding as well, but I was confused about the statement that Glenfiddich produced blendeds, and wanted to draw @orf out about what they meant, but it turns out that they might have just been mistaken about a previous purchase.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by orf on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:31PM (#28108920)
I've not seen one locally, but I've definitely seen them in the USA and in a couple of airport duty free sections. Unless I'm going crazy
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by detaro on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:34PM (#28108943)
Glenfiddich is used in Monkey Shoulder, but other than that?
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by orf on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:42PM (#28109031)
Well this is weird. I have this distinct memory of seeing a blended bottle in NYC from them, and concluding that it’s some export version that they don’t sell to the domestic market because it’s not very good.

This was quite a few years ago though, so it must be a false memory or another brand entirely. And I can’t find anything on Google…

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by Gibbon1 on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:23PM (#28109351)
I bought a bottle of some random scotch whiskey. I t was young and raw but not actually bad. I did a bit of research and it's common for distilleries to sell excess under a popup brand label or sell it for blending.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by twic on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:44PM (#28109054)
They sell an awful lot of it, so someone must like it!
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by fergie on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:35PM (#28109423)
The Speyside malts are pretty underrated in my opinion. Equally, Bells and Famous Grouse, _are_ the purest expression of what Scotch is, and in fact not that easy to get hold of outside of Scotland as we scots might presume.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by chrisseaton on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:37PM (#28109881)
> Bells and Famous Grouse, _are_ the purest expression of what Scotch is, and in fact not that easy to get hold of outside of Scotland

Pretty sure you can pick them up at any basic petrol station anywhere in England, 24 hours a day. Sorry to shatter that illusion.

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by orf on Sunday August 08, 2021 @03:44PM (#28109489)
Bells and Famous Grouse are available everywhere in the UK? Everywhere that sells any whiskey sells them almost by default.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by fergie on Monday August 09, 2021 @01:51AM (#28113122)
Sorry, should have said "outside of the UK" then.

I have been living overseas for a couple of decades, and Bells/Grouse/Teachers are not that easy to come by. Internationally, at least in my experience, Johnny Walker and Chivas Regal seem to be the more common "name" blends, supplemented by all sorts of weird "only for export" brands. You can also get hold of the big single malts pretty easily.

Its actually not always that easy to get hold of the standard Scottish "cooking whiskies" which means that a lot of people outside of the UK have a different starting point for defining what Scotch is.

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by ecommerceguy on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:22PM (#28109777)
When I think Speyside I think Macallan.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by lostlogin on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:12PM (#28108751)
What do you rate?
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by orf on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:13PM (#28108763)
Anything from Islay is my jam, with Laphroaig having a particular place in my heart.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by ericmay on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:57PM (#28109182)
Same here. Laphroiag, Caol Ila, Bunna, and though not Islay, Talisker has a special place in my heart
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by nyx-aiur on Sunday August 08, 2021 @04:52PM (#28109988)
That's the I don't know anything about whisky but I read on pretentious blogs that these are good list.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by ericmay on Sunday August 08, 2021 @09:04PM (#28111699)
Those are the ones I’ve enjoyed (I’ve been to Scotland. Also don’t care about what others - blogs- opinions are on things). Sure I don’t know anything. Any recommendations? Why does liking those mean I don’t know anything about whiskey?
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by jahewson on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:35PM (#28108959)
If you’re after Speyside then Balvenie and Glenrothes make some good bottles. Overall it’s probably the least interesting variety of Scotch but it’s light and drinkable.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by purple_ferret on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:50PM (#28109109)
Heh, be careful. There are no bigger connoisseurs than American whiskey/whisky drinkers. Scotch is out. Small batch bourbon and Japanese whisky are in.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by smcl on Monday August 09, 2021 @08:05AM (#28115690)
For now the “proper” Japanese whisky is just too hard to find to make a dent into Bourbon, let alone Scotch. For me at least it’s possible to get my hands on a few very nice bottles, but for the price they’re just not worth it - I can get a couple of really good Scotch or Irish for the price of one bottle of, say, Hibiki Harmony. Many of the “Japanese” whiskies you’ll see that seem available and reasonably priced are simply Scotch whisky with Japanese labelling heavily implying or outright claiming it’s a product of Japan (such as Nikka From The Barrel, distilled at Ben Nevis distillery). The situation might get better - some producers have agreed to label their products more honestly - but there’s still not enough real stuff available, which is a problem when it takes years to mature and your product is red hot at the moment.

I can’t speak for small batch Bourbon, we don’t get much where I am which is a real shame.

Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by smcl on Saturday August 14, 2021 @04:40PM (#28183761)
Ha, so 5 days later the Japanese whisky mistrust issue got covered here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gFtTPp9rD2g
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by divbzero on Sunday August 08, 2021 @07:43PM (#28111253)
That is the true headline for this article.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by 1MachineElf on Sunday August 08, 2021 @02:28PM (#28108897)
Their 15-yr Solera is one of my favorites.
Re:Glenfiddich will use its own whisky waste to fuel its trucks by smcl on Sunday August 08, 2021 @05:27PM (#28110262)
Seems there's a few of us here who are into the 15 :)