And to clarify, I don’t believe the “check boxes” are completely meaningless, rather the issue is that it provides room for gaming of the system to achieve a rating. This of course will probably always occur to some extent.
Thank you for edifying me.
What is objectively true vs. what is subjectively understood and expected from "Green" as an ideology, are generation two completely different things.
Expectations are unreasonable in the latter. So that causes the judgement of "success" to be unreasonable.
Most people do not have an objective understand or perspective of what being Green under LEED would mean.
Most people think and act as though you can throw up a few solar panels and then run an iron blast furnace with the Green energy. The numbers simply don't work. Most people do not understand how much energy is required to provide their current lifestyle!
The level innumeracy and its universality of that innumeracy is that Epic Fail.
It's the worst in places that are the most religiously strident places like California. In general, you'd need land for solar panels equivalent to your entire neighborhood to merely duplicate and provide your current energy use just from your own home. And that doesn't even cover EVs being charged!
So how much did that house cost you? And now you need 10x that much land just to be Green? And what about the energy inputs to build and keep the Grid going so you can use cheap land for that? It's a lot more than anyone typically is aware of! Try 20x-500x depending on specifics of things like thermodynamic efficiency and resulting impact on supply chains!
And a 10x-20x puts you into fossil fuel, nuclear power territory being optimal.
That's false because it is based on the assumption that you should convert the input BTUs of your natural gas heater directly to hypothetical kWH consumed if substituted with electricity, which is silly because if you are trying to generate 100% of your energy consumption locally (a goal of questionable value itself), you would change your mechanical systems to electrical ones that are 3-5x more efficient at delivering space heating than natural gas furnaces.
The most efficient nat gas furnaces are 96% efficient, but heat pumps routinely achieve 300-400% efficiency. That works out to far lower energy input for space heating.
A far more sensible approach to local electricity generation is to move to more efficient building and mechanical systems and only generate enough electricity via solar+storage to power critical loads during a grid outage.
> And that doesn't even cover EVs being charged!
Given, the average American commute distance, EVs will always be a grid coupled technology due to their huge energy requirements. This is a good thing because they will needed to provide buffers for grid and home resiliency to less predictable power supply and demand patterns.
Which people?
> It's the worst in places that are the most religiously strident places like California.
Like the prior quote, this characterizes and denigrates a different set of people. It tells us nothing but your willingness to insult and ignore them. Let's stop dismissing people (probably not coincidentally, a certain political grouping being dismissed using the language common to another political grouping) and use genuine curiosity about the world - and other people - to further our knowledge. Maybe some people in CA know something important; maybe they should be treated with respect and listened to, being other genuine people.
Math please. A 100 square foot solar panel would generate around 150 kWh per month given around 5 hours of sunlight a day. The average household uses under 1000 kWh per month. So you'd need around 700 sqft of solar panels to cover that which fits on the roof of a single story house easily.
edit: And plenty of people sell electricity back to the grid on average while having rooftop solar panels.
Electrowinning iron takes about 4kwh per kg. So maybe $200/ton worth of electricity.
The LEEDv4 marketing materials don't have the tone I would expect if LEED has actually evolved into something more useful than a greenwashing marketing program. Maybe they've improved it but I would need to have some third party say "earlier versions of LEED didn't actually mean any of the things you would expect, and LEEDv4 has corrected that in a meaningful way."
Society is extremely inefficient
it seems to me that we could still provide more with less (resources and time), without going in analysis paralysis
Well, western society didn't adopted central planning, in a good part as central planning's failure to meet society's needs.
Anyway, I don't think it's fair to criticize these efforts by depicting them as some sort of failure or the result of incompetence or shortsightedness. We have to have some humility when discussing these topics specially if they are from a field where we have no insight at all. In this case, we should keep inind that valuing energy efficiency and externalities is something that's extremely novel where society as a whole is just starting to take it's first steps. It's quite literally a highly transformative change that involves changes in all steps of an entire industry, including in building regulation and even urban planning. Change is happening as we speak, but what you are looking at, and criticizing, is society's first step in a much needed direction.
I think it's fair to at least voice it out, I'm just trying to dig out what are the real reasons and potential new ideas.
An example: Instead of talking about green buildings, you 'captured' the conversation into politics, repeating well-worn cliches that don't inform us - everyone has heard them before, as you know - but do signal something.
There is nothing 'inherent' about your individual actions. Instead of being interested and curious and talking about science, you dismissed other people's perspectives with political stereotypes.
We analyze the benefits and costs of our choices, but only on some specific metrics. We remain (sometimes intentionally) blind towards what we might not know. And if others justify things the same way, then we feel more secure in our choices.
If everyone says that x is green and green is better then we believe it. We don't question whether it's actually better. Eg promises of recycling vs actual recycling.
In the case of the building where I lived, they were required to retain the original windows for historicity: rickety, drafty, single-pane affairs that leaked prodigious quantities of heat. These windows were very large and the ceilings high, so in winter you essentially needed to run the heater non-stop. To offset that, they unnecessarily and often quite uselessly over-engineered other parts of the building construction for green-ness, which I presume helped with whatever scoring system made the building "green". None of which changed the fact that the building fundamentally leaked energy like a sieve.
It was always a mystery to me how they managed to LEED certify one of the most poorly insulated buildings in which I've ever lived. Nothing else you do to a building should be able to offset that fact.
The process you’re describing is called lifecycle analysis and it’s complicated.
The greenest building is something like a giant tent, high on total resource efficiency but lower on comfort.
There are tradeoffs to consider and a lot of them are lifestyle choices, like wearing a sweater indoors.
Triple pane glass? Check. Green materials? Check. High efficiency heat pump? Check. Etc. Etc.
If you check as many boxes as possible your building is labeled green and everyone applauds.
The real way to measure this would be energy used to construct the building, factoring in supply chain and then ongoing energy usage per square foot. You would also need to factor in what the building was being used for and perhaps, depending on the building, the output and production of said building.
All of this is to say, it is complicated. I suspect many modern buildings are space inefficient leading to less production per square foot. Therefore even if it is a green building that is well designed there is a certain level of inefficiency in that it is a larger than needed building that has to be lit, heated, cooled, etc.