macOS has, however, been making superficial changes that people don’t care about. A free macOS desktop alternative would build on a stable set of core technologies, and let people do the crazy things that they want, and not do the crazy things that they don’t want.
I was once critical of ReactOS for similar reasons, but I’ve realized just how beneficial that project has been to OSS as a whole. Even if they fail they will uncover a lot of interesting stuff if the project continues long-term.
What if you spend your entire career innovating and the result is still worse than Snow Leopard?
(/me kicks GNOME into a bottomless pit)
No, they won't. MacOS and Windows are both going backwards in innovations (according to many HN commenters at least). At some point this project (and ReactOS) will get better than the originals.
Similarly, I don't see much difference between Ubuntu desktop distros in terms of differences across versions , say from 16 to 20.
Therefore... I don't see a being "one step behind" as any kind of issue. I've never run into an issue with past versions (such as those menntioned above) of OSes not running what I need them to run.
Personally, I'd like to see a Linux version which is very close to Apple so I can use it (such as OP's), instead of expensive Apple computers.
I’d argue that there is room for both.
But, who is attempting anything better?