News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by kraf on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @05:41AM (#28059064)
Protest is an important form of participation in a democracy, it's not petty at all. Forcing developers to add Apple ID as a sign-in method is the petty thing. The developers have no power unless they unionize in some form which seems absolutely impossible. So it seems to me that it's all a developer can really do to make a statement and I think it's brave.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by nyuszika7h on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:29AM (#28060199)
Nobody is forced to add Apple ID login if they don't have any other social logins. Personally I stick to direct signup but if I were forced to do social login, Sign in with Apple would be my first preference as it's the most privacy-preserving compared to Google, Facebook, Twitter, etc.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by sandworm101 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:20AM (#28060688)
>> but if I were forced to do social login

I wonder what it would take to "force" me into doing a social login? It would have to be something drastic, like a website that provides me with needed oxygen.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by dasyatidprime on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:50AM (#28062437)
Anything else that would ‘force’ you to Have an Account somewhere, combined with that somewhere happening to outsource their identity framework to “social” of any kind. Or: the same things that would ‘force’ you to have a social network account to start with, potentially.

To get on my hobbyhorse some: what about a platform that your employer uses to distribute relevant documents and updates which you need for your job, which has become sufficiently well-known and implicitly available that hesitating about the dependency is perceived as bizarre?

Note that the response of “don't deal with them then” runs into market information and churn amplification¹ issues when it is a social assumption that picking up a ‘tool’ (which is actually a relationship with a third party, but where this is close to invisible in the steady state) is essentially a free action which requires no consideration, because the information about “does this employer require me to use this tool” neither propagates efficiently nor stays stable.

Past source: wound up changing the email address on one of my Google accounts recently for exactly that reason. They actually asked me up-front whether I had a GMail account they could use instead, which turned out to be because they use restricted Google Docs for critical material. Not naming them, but in a broad sense, this is one of the more ethical companies I've ever dealt with, by the way.

Future source: I should probably be considering digging into LinkedIn soon despite their past abusive behaviors, because as it turns out, if I want to dig myself out of this hole…

¹ I assume there's a ‘real’ term for what I'm thinking of, but I don't know what it is, so I cobbled that one together out of the most relevant-seeming bits.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by pier25 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:33AM (#28060823)
Apple is extremely hostile to developers. After a couple of bad experiences with the app store I simply refused to do any development for iOS.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by HWR_14 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @12:40PM (#28063116)
Apple is extremely restrictive to developers. As a developer, I hate it. As a consumer, I love it.

Apple has never shown me hostility. On the contrary, I found Apple to offer reasons why they do things and how to work around them. Have they sometimes forced me to do things I don't want (and felt were worse)? Yes. But it was obvious what I needed to do to comply.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by pier25 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @02:04PM (#28064207)
> Apple is extremely restrictive to developers

Restrictive is not the appropriate word.

For example, this whole forcing devs to use "sign in with Apple" is not about imposing restrictions as you can decide to not use a third party sign in (on a new app).

Apple is saying "hey if your users can sign in with Facebook they should be able to sign in with Apple, we want a piece of the pie". Some iOS users are happy about the privacy aspect of this but fundamentally (IMO) this is not about privacy or restrictions, it's about making users and devs more dependent on the Apple ecosystem.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by HWR_14 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @02:59PM (#28064819)
What's the "pie"? FB makes money off their data. Apple seems to be providing me the service I paid for.

If they made it optional, a large percentage of apps would force you to use Google/FB to login. That's not acceptable to me.

One of the major reasons I give Apple money is to because they can stand up against the privacy invading FB/Google and I, as an individual, cannot. So they are very much doing what I want in this instance.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by pier25 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @04:35PM (#28065974)
> What's the "pie"?

It's explained in my previous comment.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by HWR_14 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @04:50PM (#28066127)
> It's explained in my previous comment.

Not well enough for me to understand, because I asked what you meant.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by pier25 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @05:27PM (#28066571)
If a dev uses a Facebook login on an app then it will never be able to remove it again as users won't be able to log in. Similarly, if it uses Facebook comments, these cannot be removed from a website as the content would be lost.

Apple does the same thing. As a dev once you open the door to using Apple you're forever stuck with that. As a user, it entrenches you further into the Apple ecosystem which is ultimately the whole Apple product strategy.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by HWR_14 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @12:07AM (#28069762)
I don't really think lock in is Apple's primary goal. I think they are opposed to Google/FB spying on us, and therefore there has to be an alternative. You don't have to implement Apple SSO, you just cannot use any other SSO without adding it as an alternative.

I like this result as a user.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by sbuk on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:29AM (#28071214)
Again, the point that you as a developer are missing is that your behavior is atleast as, if not more abusive towards your end user than Apple are being. Why should your user have to use an anti-privacy 3rd party like Facebook to use your app or service? Where is the users choice other than to not use your product?

I have to be honest here and say that I amazed, but sadly not surprised by the level of entitlement on display from a very small but extremely vocal set of developers.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by pier25 on Thursday August 05, 2021 @03:34PM (#28078447)
> your behavior is atleast as, if not more abusive towards your end user than Apple are being

My behavior? You have no idea what I do. I don't even develop for Apple platforms.

> Why should your user have to use an anti-privacy 3rd party like Facebook to use your app or service?

I would never use anything by Facebook. Not sure where you got that from.

> Where is the users choice other than to not use your product?

That is choice.

> I amazed, but sadly not surprised by the level of entitlement on display from a very small but extremely vocal set of developers

As a dev shouldn't I be able to have control over my application?

Re:My small revenge on Apple by willseth on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:04AM (#28061822)
What is hostility to you is customer service to me.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by elzbardico on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:55AM (#28061724)
As a consumer, I really don't care about it.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by user-the-name on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @05:59AM (#28059177)
It is not "petty", it is a way to ensure all users get access to a privacy-conscious method of logging in without giving up your privacy to Google or Facebook.

Being this angry at having to give users the option of better privacy really isn't a great look.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:05AM (#28059607)
No one is forcing users to use Google or FB. They can do traditional email signup
Re:My small revenge on Apple by nyuszika7h on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:30AM (#28060211)
That is definitely not true for every app. There was never any clause in the App Store guidelines that you must provide traditional email signup. At least this way, the social-only apps will be forced to provide you a more privacy-preserving alternative, and for ones that don't use social logins anyway, nothing changes.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @08:45AM (#28060347)
Of course, my comment was related to the app of the post Groups specifically

Which used to offer both social sign-up (FB and Google) and a traditional email sign-up option

You probably don't know that in this case, Groups was also forced to include AppleID or risk being removed from the App Store

Removing all social logins from this point to ensure compliance would have definitely affected all users who had originally signed in with FB/Google, way before AppleID ever existed

Re:My small revenge on Apple by Twisell on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:48AM (#28061625)
>Removing all social logins from this point to ensure compliance would have definitely affected all users who had originally signed in with FB/Google, way before AppleID ever existed

Yet it would have been more consistent! What is the point of going to war against Apple while embracing the private-data-broker model at the same time?

Just send a warning e-mail requiring password change because you decided to remove all social login as a protest.

And provide a password reset mechanism for formerly social-login users that haven't defined a password in time.

That would have been a true act of resistance.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:06AM (#28061842)
Amen
Re:My small revenge on Apple by user-the-name on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:00AM (#28060508)
No one is forcing users to use Sign in with Apple either.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:02AM (#28060527)
But Apple is forcing devs to include Apple ID and that's what's wrong here. They could have made it optional. Given how Apple users can be it likely would have ended up being in demand and devs would have included it out of their free will
Re:My small revenge on Apple by qwytw on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:30AM (#28060791)
Well it is optional if you only have email sign up..
Re:My small revenge on Apple by user-the-name on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:11AM (#28060601)
There is basically no benefit to app developer in including it. It is more work, and you may get only an anonymised address. However, there is massive benefit to actual users.

Apple decided to prioritise users over developers here.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:29AM (#28060789)
Trust me, I say this as a developer, if there is any indication that I am losing out on users because I don't have Apple ID, I will make sure to add it asap. That is pretty much the reason why I first included FB and Google. I first only had Google, then some people aksed for FB. The natural course would have been that then some other guys ask for Apple and I add it. But Apple decided to abuse its position and force it on us developers
Re:My small revenge on Apple by user-the-name on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @05:12PM (#28066376)
Doesn't really matter what you would have done. It matters what the entire ecosystem would have.

As a user, I am very satisfied that Apple made this a requirement.

As a developer, I just implemented it without throwing a tantrum.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by thiagocsf on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:18AM (#28062008)
Going by this rationale, are you going to add Apple ID to your website when users request it?
Re:My small revenge on Apple by webmobdev on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @06:15AM (#28059278)
Yes. It is important that more developers stand up to this kind of bullying. Apple needs to respect developers more and, if it wants them to integrate Apple services they should instead offer incentives rather than threats to them. As both a developer and an Apple user, I don't care about Apple ID and so why would I wish to waste my precious time adding features I am not interested in? (I use Apple products but I never use Apple ID anywhere because I believe it weakens my privacy - why would I want to share more personal data with Apple, a company that was part of PRISM and used to sell user data to the government?)
Re:My small revenge on Apple by sbuk on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @06:53AM (#28059527)
Equally, developers need to respect their users. I don't want to have to have a Facebook or Google account to use your product. Why should I be interested in your app if you force me you use either of those options? They were also involved in PRISM and both have far worse track records with privacy than Apple. More importantly, why should I trust you with PII?
Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:02AM (#28059589)
Having your email address boils down to password recovery. For instance, I only ever send 3 types of emails:

1 - Activation email with activation code to ensure the person actually owns the email address (non-OAUTH sign-up)

2 - Password recovery for when they have forgotten their password. Yes, a user doesn't need this with OAUTH but sometimes they will have forgotten that they used OAUTH to start with and need to sign in with email & pss

3 - When push is turned off and someone has messaged you

I don't think this is beyond reasonable but I'm willing to take criticism

Re:My small revenge on Apple by p2t2p on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:45AM (#28061589)
> Having your email address boils down to password recovery. For instance, I only ever send 3 types of emails

I don't care. I don't trust you. I don't trust any of modern devs, I see every other new shiny crap on the internet only as an attempt to extort me of data and/or money (subscription) now. Before Apple introduced that feature I was using email aliases in my Fastmail. Need to register in new service - go to Fastmail, generate an alias for some weird domain they've got, setup filter for it to go to "dodgy" folder and then register.

Now I don't need to do that anymore, Apple automated that for me.

And thank's Apple it also forced guys like you to allow me to use that automation. At least on their platform.

For same reason the only way I buy a subscription is through an in-app-purchase - because I can just to go App Store and cancel it and don't need to deal with people like you. I remember like an year ago I was waiting for a refund for a cancelled subscription and my emails were ignored and the only way to get the attention was to open a dispute in PayPal. Yet another supplier-hostile but consumer-friendly company. Thanks god they exist.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by handrous on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @04:47PM (#28066097)
I think some smaller-time devs don't appreciate that if they "win" against Apple and make them significantly loosen restrictions, users' wallets will tighten, especially for small developers and companies that no-one's heard of. Keeping the App Store low-friction, low-risk, and UX consistent, is a huge benefit for those kinds of devs (the ones selling software or subscriptions, anyway).
Re:My small revenge on Apple by qwytw on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:28AM (#28060774)
The messages sent to the "anonymous" Apple id mail are just forwarded to the user's inbox, aren't they? How is that any different from any other email address.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by jackson1442 on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:39AM (#28060871)
There is an email origin restriction- that's how they keep devs from selling them, emails can only come from the right domain. That still shouldn't be a problem though.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:39AM (#28060872)
It isn't. My problem with AppleID is nothing more than that they forced AppleID on me. I would have voluntarily added it otherwise. But now because of this, I really really dislike it to the point that I will refuse to implement it in other platforms where it is not mandatory

And I think Apple's behavior should change so I am making this public

Re:My small revenge on Apple by haswell on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:14AM (#28061226)
Asking an honest question: if Apple didn’t force this, would you really add this voluntarily?

Because this response tells me you’re willing to compromise your user’s experience because of your personal issues with Apple.

As a user, this does not give me confidence in your decision making.

It’s somewhat understandable to be annoyed, even angry at Apple. But the moment you decide to pass that on to your users is the moment you’ve forgotten the most important humans in this story.

Of course, it’s your right to do what you want, and if that means taking a stance against Apple ranks higher than your user base, I suppose that’s your prerogative.

But that definitely would make me hesitate to use the app.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:46AM (#28061601)
Honest answer: yes

I don't even hold a grudge against Apple. This is just me trying to make the world a better place. It's in everyone's interest that Apple doesn't gain authority to force us to do things (don't forget, devs also are Apple customers)

Re:My small revenge on Apple by askafriend on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:13AM (#28061939)
As a user, I don’t trust your “honest answer”.

On the other hand, I absolutely trust Apple - my relationship with them spans over a decade and countless products/experiences.

I’m happy that they’re forcing devs to offer Apple Sign On as an option when other social logins are also offered. As a user, I trust Apple far more than any 3rd party dev.

I pay a premium to Apple because of their platform and the types of things they enforce.

I want you to understand that as a user, this is exactly what I want Apple to do and I pay extra for it.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by haswell on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:28AM (#28062145)
But what you're telling me is that your opinion about Apple here supersedes my own wishes/wants/goals as an end-user.

This reads like "I know what's best, despite what Apple users say they want, and I'm going to make the world a better place by ignoring my users and telling them what they want is actually bad for them", despite the fact that this is actually a beneficial feature to users, even if it could be construed as a benefit to Apple as well (arguments can certainly be made).

> It's in everyone's interest that Apple doesn't gain authority to force us to do things

The rulebook to participate in this ecosystem is a mile thick. Why is this the issue that you choose to make a fuss over? There are a a myriad of other rules that are even more heavy handed, that actually are to the detriment of end users to protect Apple's walled-garden.

Picking a feature that arguably makes user's lives better seems tone deaf at best, and actively harmful to a broader message about openness at worst.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by sbuk on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @12:36PM (#28063067)
The thing is, Apple only 'force' you to add their option if you have an app on the store and offer another form of public federated identity provider. If you don't want to offer Apple as an option, then don't offer anyone else. Look at the context of why they have enforced it. Privacy is hard. The concern is that that the majority identity providers/brokers in use are Facebook and Google. I'll happy listen to the 'competition' argument as it does have a little merit. However, when weighed up against the notion that these two are the only real choice for a significant volume of apps, it is extremely worrisome from a privacy point of view. Neither have a reason to respect end users, or you as a developers privacy because that's how they make money.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by spacedcowboy on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:50AM (#28061655)
This.

Petulance does not become a developer. The last time I saw a tantrum thrown this much was when my kid was 5 and had a major meltdown over a lack of chocolate ice-cream.

He didn't get any ice-cream for a week, a response that taught him meltdowns don't work.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:12AM (#28061936)
You can judge my post as a tantrum, and I won't even take offense, friend

Now I ask you this: how far are you willing to go to further a good cause? Watching from the sides feels more comfortable, but we are being decimated and doing nothing won't change a thing. We need to act now, or watch our profession/hobby/passion be used to fatten the already morbidly overweight big tech companies

Re:My small revenge on Apple by haswell on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:22AM (#28062059)
> how far are you willing to go to further a good cause?

But what, exactly is the "good cause" here? Is the good cause to force Apple to stop delivering an experience that we've already established throughout this thread is an experience Apple users want?

There are so many problems and battles to be fought in tech, so much abusive behavior, so many dark patterns. This is not that. If this is the cause you're fighting, I fear you've missed the forest through the trees.

Unless you had something else in mind, in which case I'm genuinely curious.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by ratww on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:29AM (#28062151)
What is the “good cause” here? You’re just being user hostile and fighting a feature that is highly beneficial for users! If anything, it is Apple that’s fighting a good cause here.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Thursday August 05, 2021 @09:49AM (#28073690)
Does something being beneficial for users justify anything?

Enslaving the entire Uber driver or deliveroo poor sod population is arguably beneficial for users. But, is it right? Plenty of jurisdictions have already spoken that these workers have rights. Nobody has made a ruling regarding developers yet

The "iMentality" can't possibly extend to wishing that Apple treats other human beings like **. Can it? If so, we may have gone back in time to even before the 1860s

Re:My small revenge on Apple by user-the-name on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @05:12PM (#28066373)
So this is all about your feelings and not one single bit about your users.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by raxxorrax on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:45AM (#28060927)
It should also be mentioned that email doesn't generally provide any information.

[email protected] doesn't carry much info.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by hombre_fatal on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:45AM (#28061592)
You're underestimating email. People reuse their email address, so it's not as benign as you think.

Just googling someone's email is a start. But worse actors can find your email on a combolist or figure out what other services you use. Just knowing someone's email is the first step to social engineering a customer service backdoor, for example.

AppleID specifically helps users avoid all this with trivial per-app email address generation, and that's something our tools should have given us a decade ago.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by sbuk on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:09AM (#28059620)
There are other ways to do password recovery. Email is categorically not the only solution to this problem.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by collaborative on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @07:17AM (#28059667)
You mean "secret questions" or phone number?
Re:My small revenge on Apple by webmobdev on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:09AM (#28060587)
Yes, developers need to respect users too. But that should be between the developers and the user. If a user asks me to add Apple Id as an option in an app I make, that is something that I would seriously consider as I care about my users. Why should a developer care about something no user has requested but Apple is forcing them to use?

Apple could be considered a genuine neutral arbitrator if it didn't take money from both the developers and its users. What it has done instead is to force itself between the user and the developer, and exploiting both in the name of the users (developers lose money to Apple's extortion, and the money it extorts from the developers is ultimately passed to the user, and thus they end up exploited too).

Re:My small revenge on Apple by handrous on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @10:46AM (#28061603)
Who forced you to write an iOS app and release it on the App Store? This whole thread is bizarre.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by webmobdev on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @11:36AM (#28062243)
The bizarre thing is the ignorance here that this whole thing is a matter of choice! I am glad that there are developers who recognize that they do not have to accept unfair, and even unethical, practices from corporates. And are willing to speak about it and fight it.

Like minded developers are not just fighting Apple, but the whole attempt by "big tech" to move to the business model of exploiting developers by controlling distribution of softwares, and dictating terms that favour them. This ends up harming both developers, as they earn less, and users, as ultimately it the user who ends up paying the share of profits that Apple (and others) extort from the developers.

Re:My small revenge on Apple by elzbardico on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @12:20PM (#28062854)
Yes. you don't have to accept anything that is unfair. You can just refuse to develop for the platform.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by fennecfoxy on Thursday August 05, 2021 @04:57AM (#28071365)
Privilege.
Re:My small revenge on Apple by dmitriid on Wednesday August 04, 2021 @09:21AM (#28060696)
It doesn't work like that. Users can't ask about options they don't know about.

And even if they do, too many developers couldn't give two shits. Great example is how users overwhelmingly opt-out of tracking when the OS warns them about it (because "developers thinking about users" never even considered not tracking)