News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by prophesi on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:18PM (#28038658)
The title is a bit clickbaity. This is for Android versions 2.3.7 and lower, which was released in September 21, 2011.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by toast0 on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:35PM (#28038937)
It's Android, release date of the OS doesn't matter so much as when was the last device that doesn't upgrade past 2.3.7 released and/or when did that device leave mass retail. Or some other threshold.

A ton of 2.3 devices weren't upgradable to 4. And there were a lot of devices made with 2.3 well after 4 was available. The numbers are probably small though, WhatsApp (where I used to work) ended support for 2.3.7 in early 2020 because the user numbers no longer justified the effort to keep that working. Usage was enough to justify almost a two year notice period though.

Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by kllrnohj on Monday August 02, 2021 @02:37PM (#28040841)
The number of 2.3 devices still alive is under 0.1%. Independent dashboards like https://www.appbrain.com/stats/top-android-sdk-versions and https://gs.statcounter.com/os-version-market-share/android/m... don't even list Android 2.3 at all anymore the population is so small.

According to https://www.phonemore.com/systems/android/2-3-6-gingerbread/ it looks like ~2014 was the last new Gingerbread device released?

Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by citrin_ru on Monday August 02, 2021 @01:34PM (#28039873)
It's a sad state of Android ecosystem that on 10 years old hardware you can run only 10 years software because vendors rarely provide updates after end of sales date and at the same time they make it very hard to install something like LineageOS (e. g. use locked bootloader and closed-source drivers).

I have a 15 years old notebook and can install a modern Linux/FreeBSD versions on it, but I cannot upgrade 7 years old smartphone.

Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by zozbot234 on Monday August 02, 2021 @01:47PM (#28040073)
That's really an issue with the embedded ecosystem in general. Pre-Android devices were far worse.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by blihp on Monday August 02, 2021 @02:46PM (#28040959)
Sure, pre-Android devices dropped support shortly after you bought them, but they were often still functional. Disabling Google login on an Android (non-AOSP) device effectively bricks it for most users.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by ainiriand on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:20PM (#28038699)
I think the title is perfectly accurate. That is exactly what's going to happen.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by yupper32 on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:34PM (#28038922)
It's click-baity because it withholds necessary information in order to get you to click on it.

Saying the version number or release date would stop most people from clicking on it, because it matters much less.

Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by tantalor on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:46PM (#28039118)
That's how all headlines work.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by dave5104 on Monday August 02, 2021 @01:06PM (#28039401)
Not really, and they don't have to. A simple change would suffice:

> Old Android versions [from 2011 and earlier] will no longer be able to log into Google account

Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by KoftaBob on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:59PM (#28039309)
Nowadays, yes, but that’s not necessarily how they’re supposed to work.

A headline should give a reader actionable information, with the article itself serving to give more detailed context.

This headline doesn’t give actionable information, because you have no idea whether your android version is affected.

Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by rhdunn on Monday August 02, 2021 @01:57PM (#28040251)
By that logic you have headlines like "Windows installs will now require a Microsoft account", with the article saying it only applies to Windows 11 Home. I tend to avoid reading articles where the headline deliberately avoid information in an attempt to get clicks.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by n4bz0r on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:22PM (#28038721)
I wouldn't go as far as saying "perfectly". What is "old"? I clicked thinking my Android 4 device (which I use daily) is fucked.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by mdp2021 on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:51PM (#28039185)
Stochastic language ("Topitanians are strong"), "S is P" = "The median of S is P" = "Android 7 will..." (Very stretched interpretation.)

Logical language ("[All/Some] Topitanians are strong"), "S is P" = "All S are P" = "All old Android versions...". Without an explicit quantifier, a statement to be interpreted in logical language easily defaults to using the universal "All": the statement "Coal burns", if not stochastic (envisaging exceptions) but logical, is meant to express that all of the instances do.

"Old Android versions" does not default to "Some old Android versions".

Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by ainiriand on Tuesday August 03, 2021 @06:20AM (#28047497)
This is very interesting, thank you for teaching me a bit about logic today. Also, it looks like the headline was amended.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by jfoster on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:27PM (#28038786)
It could be much more exact by mentioning the version & date that it was released on.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by eptcyka on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:24PM (#28038755)
I wonder if iOS5 devices can still log into the apple store.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by EvanAnderson on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:33PM (#28038913)
For kicks I pulled out an iOS 5.1.1 device and I was able to sign-in to the App Store and install an old version of an app using my current Apple ID. I'm genuinely surprised it worked.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by dspillett on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:36PM (#28038966)
Not as direct a question as it may seem: the iPhone 4s (IIRC the first device released with iOS5) could be upgraded as far as iOS9 but many Android devices never saw much by way of upgrades unless you count rooting them to install something manually. Though how well those devices run newer versions of the OS and newer apps is likely a question with many answers (most, but not all, negative).
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by virgilp on Monday August 02, 2021 @01:34PM (#28039869)
That's typically an argument that "iDevices have more value because you can use them longer than Android". You can't have it both ways - "old android devices" in this context are devices older than iPhone 4s, and iPhone 4s themselves are not very much in use today, so it's that much less likely that Android phones would be.

Realistically, very few people will be affected, and the business backlash for Google is going to be 0. BUT, on the other hand, if anybody at all is going to be affected - those are probably some of the poorest and most vulnerable members of the society (which is also why they're going to not have a strong voice). The social cost, if any, will only be known by Google.

Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by ainiriand on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:28PM (#28038812)
Good question. Maybe someone here can confirm. Is the app store covering so much ground as not being able to access the Google account? Maps, Gmail, analytics...
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by eptcyka on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:35PM (#28038942)
Actually, even though iOS5 was released in 2011, all devices that supported iOS5 were able to update to iOS6. I wonder, how functional an iOS6 device could be today.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by Doctor_Fegg on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:57PM (#28039270)
The original iPad is stuck on 5.1.1 I think.
Re:Sign-in on Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed sta... by dpwm on Monday August 02, 2021 @12:23PM (#28038740)
The title of the page conveys more information, albeit in more words:

> Sign-in on Android devices running Android 2.3.7 or lower will not be allowed starting September 27