News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by andrew_eit on Friday July 30, 2021 @09:25AM (#28007691)
I wish we as a culture/society, acknowledged the luck and timing factor more as a factor in career development.

Idolizing people like Musk, Bezos and Gates, brilliant though they certainly are, only serves to put "just work hard/smart" blinkers on young career professionals, when sometimes, you really just need to introduce some chaos, roll the dice again, or divert effort into opening new pathways for yourself via networking or some such activity, instead of spending those extra hours on polishing technical skills.

Case in point, I've had several internships as a student. My first one, I landed in a team that effectively did product management of a backend system, whilst my coursemate landed into a role assisting a high-up VP on innovation projects.

Later, as a consultant, my first project was on some dying database system that needed to be kept alive a short while longer. In this case, I'd learned already, that you don't have to always accept your circumstances as they are. I politely complained to management that this is not what I was hired for and did not match my skills, and was transferred to a way more interesting and career rewarding project.

I think the cornerstone of luck in career comes down to a few things:

1) Always Ask / Register interest - good things can't come your way if no one knows that you're looking

2) Keep an ear to the ground - so much information spreads via word of mouth. Being in chatrooms/groups or just having friendly relationships with various people in a company or sector, is like having sensors planted all around, alerting you to new opportunities

3) (polite) STUBBORNNESS - I can't emphasize this enough. Rejections, or unanswered job applications don't have to mean anything. After looking objectively at yourself and your attempt, to see if anything could have been improved, it pays you to then be stubborn and just keep trying. I recently got a brilliant job because my application was rejected from the 10th job posting of my favourite company, but a recruiter saw my application and forwarded it to another internal position that was based in another location and offered remotely. Everything clicked from there and I eventually got an offer. This happened because after the 9th rejection and I said "F*k it" and sent out another CV.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by josephorjoe on Friday July 30, 2021 @10:45AM (#28008526)
> I wish we as a culture/society, acknowledged the luck and timing factor more as a factor in career development.

How's this?

I'm a self taught programmer who did not start to learn programming til I was in my 40s. It was not super easy to get my first full time job.

One day, I went to a tech meet up. Got a t shirt.

Six months later, I wore that t shirt to a hiring fair. Someone recognized the t shirt because he was at that meet up too. We started talking. I end up joining the start up he worked for.

Two years later I'm looking to leave and start job hunting but completely fail on my first phone technical interview. Decide to study some more "interview questions" before applying to another job.

Find out the next month our start up is in acquisition discussions with Big Tech Co. Decide to stop job hunting.

The acquisition happens. I now work for Big Tech Co. They never would have hired me if I had applied cold for the job. I'm doing well there.

So, the secret to my success: a t shirt and flubbing an interview.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by Taylor_OD on Friday July 30, 2021 @01:57PM (#28010551)
Great story. I think a lot of people would have a similar story if they cared to analyze their success a little more critically and be willing to give a little more credit to luck rather than their own efforts.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by throw_nbvc1234 on Friday July 30, 2021 @05:42PM (#28012731)
The other perspective of this is that luck is "hard work meets opportunity" or that "you make your own luck" or "you miss 100% of the shots you don't take".

There was a conscious choice made to go to a meet-up (networking) and going to a career fair (or conference or further meetups) where you could run into people you've networked with in the past. Without that choice, none of the downstream lucky events would have mattered. So you can acknowledge the role of luck in those uncontrollable downstream aspects (T-shirt, career fair meetup) while also acknowledging what OP's role in creating that situation.

You're not "unlucky" if you had decided to play video games instead of going to either the meetup or the career fair. You could be unlucky if you did both of those and the opportunity never arrived. The former is (bluntly) making excuses about somebodies lack of success.

Or you can just say that someone was lucky to not be born in a country where they're forced into military conscription as a child at which point everyone is back to being lucky. It's all a matter of what you decide to focus on and what perspective you bring into things looking forward or backwards.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by ibeckermayer on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:00PM (#28011774)
When I read a story like this, I don’t think mere luck/timing.

You taught yourself programming in your 40s. That’s hard work and discipline to gain a skill. There’s plenty of other stuff you could have chosen to do with your time, but you chose to do this instead.

The very fact that you were going to meetups is a sign of diligence and eagerness, which are both conscious traits that can be consciously nurtured.

Yes, there’s an element of chance involved in that person recognizing your shirt and him having a job to offer you and that company getting acquired. But you put yourself in the position to take advantage of that serendipity through working hard at your skills and spending your time wisely at meetups.

There are things we can control and things we can’t, and both play a significant role in our outcomes.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by rufus_foreman on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:46PM (#28013820)
>> Six months later, I wore that t shirt to a hiring fair. Someone recognized the t shirt because he was at that meet up too. We started talking. I end up joining the start up he worked for

And if that hadn't happened you would have just.....given up?

Re:Some career advice (2019) by ssully on Friday July 30, 2021 @11:59AM (#28009372)
Maybe I am missing the sarcasm, but this sounds exactly timing and luck.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by Noumenon72 on Friday July 30, 2021 @01:07PM (#28010045)
"How's this?" meant "How's this for an example of acknowledging timing and luck?"
Re:Some career advice (2019) by josephorjoe on Friday July 30, 2021 @12:16PM (#28009550)
no sarcasm intended

i know that timing and luck really helped me out and i am grateful for it.

so when people say "wow, you taught yourself programming and now you work as a software engineer at Big Tech Co -- that's impressive" i don't think "it is because i'm awesome!".

i think "i did work hard to get here but i sure had some lucky breaks along the way and if the timing had been different i could be in a very different spot right now".

Re:Some career advice (2019) by PragmaticPulp on Friday July 30, 2021 @01:28PM (#28010270)
> I wish we as a culture/society, acknowledged the luck and timing factor more as a factor in career development.

I've been mentoring young people and college students on and off for years. The influence of luck on their success is a constant topic. Definitely not ignored.

If anything, they tend to overestimate the role of luck and external factors in career development. Each year it seems like I talk to more students who have been convinced that success can only be the result of pure chance. I watch a lot of them lose motivation because they think they need luck and nepotism and connections and wealthy parents to be successful.

For example: All of them have heard the phrase "It's not what you know, it's who you know." Some of them take it so literally that they lose motivation to learn things, instead assuming that their career success is going to come down to whoever their parents or friends can introduce them to. This leads to a lot of frustration come internship time when they see a couple of their less-knowledgeable friends land great internships at their parents' or friends' parents' companies.

I feel like I spend a lot of time convincing some of these students that they do, indeed, have a lot of influence over their career trajectory. Their outlooks tend to change quickly when they arrive at a job and realize that what they know really does matter a lot more than who their parents are when it comes to getting anything done. I also have to emphasize that "who you know" isn't some fixed quantity, and that they will meet a lot of people in their career. The more they deliver good results, the better the impression they leave on the "who you know" and the more valuable their reputation becomes. You're never going to expand your network without putting yourself out there.

It's tough to compete with the constant onslaught of cynicism they consume on TikTok, Reddit, and other websites every single day, though.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:09PM (#28011229)
I see that cynicism on HackerNews a lot, too. I consistently point out opportunities, and people just argue with that.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by username90 on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:55PM (#28011716)
They don't even view making 200k per year as "making it". Joining a top tech company doesn't require luck or connections, anyone can do it if they got the talent and just practice programming enough.

Of course when you confront them they retreat to their motte and say that talent is also luck, and not getting cancer is luck etc, and therefore everything in life is actually luck, so they weren't wrong!

Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:20PM (#28011942)
> not getting cancer is luck

I read years ago that 40% of cancers are attributable to lifestyle choices. For example, your odds of mouth/throat cancer increase steadily the more you drink. Getting the HPV vaccine reduces your chances of the associated cancer by a factor of 22.

I post often here about "getting your share" by buying stocks in successful companies, that you can get started at no cost, and can buy fractional shares if you don't have much to invest. I get lots and lots of push back. Last year, stocks increased what, 30%? All those missed opportunities.

(Of course, stocks don't go up 30% every year, and often go down. But you can't get lucky investing in stocks if you never invest .)

Re:Some career advice (2019) by lliamander on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:56PM (#28011722)
People would rather complain about the opportunities they don't have than exploit the ones they do have.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by 908B64B197 on Friday July 30, 2021 @05:35PM (#28012657)
> This leads to a lot of frustration come internship time when they see a couple of their less-knowledgeable friends land great internships at their parents' or friends' parents' companies.

On the positive side, they now have a friend at the company that can refer them...

Re:Some career advice (2019) by zz865 on Friday July 30, 2021 @11:52AM (#28009290)
> Later, as a consultant, my first project was on some dying database system that needed to be kept alive a short while longer. In this case, I'd learned already, that you don't have to always accept your circumstances as they are. I politely complained to management that this is not what I was hired for and did not match my skills, and was transferred to a way more interesting and career rewarding project.

This is important. I used to think that you're supposed to be doing what you're told, but this is often very bad for your career. You should do what will get you your next job. Introduce new technologies that are hot because you'll get to work on them, it doesn't matter so much if its good for the employer.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by dasil003 on Friday July 30, 2021 @12:46PM (#28009832)
I think it's a bit more subtle than this. You won't get promoted for just doing what you're told, but you might get fired if you don't do your job or you do overtly selfish things (like unilaterally introduce new tech that may not a good fit for the team/company). The key is to understand your bosses incentives and motivations and be proactive about making things better from their perspective.

Of course there are a lot of reasons not to follow this advice: maybe you don't want to be promoted, or your boss is an idiot, or you fundamentally hate your role, etc. In that case other tactics may apply, but be aware there's a glass ceiling if you only rely on job-hopping for your growth opportunities.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by planet-and-halo on Friday July 30, 2021 @10:46AM (#28008547)
These are great points, but I think it's crucial to include the second part (which you did) about how to harness luck and randomness. Too often I see people go "these guys were just lucky, it's all chance," and I think that leads to unnecessary defeatism and missed opportunities.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:10PM (#28011246)
> missed opportunities

My dad told me that most people did not recognize opportunity because it came disguised as hard work.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by dahfizz on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:02PM (#28011144)
Shuffle a deck of cards and draw a hand of 5 cards.

The odds that you drew those exact 5 cards are very low. You were lucky to draw those cards.

However, the odds that you end up with 5 cards anyway is 100%.

Its the same with your career. The odds that you ended up taking the exact path that you did, with all the serendipity and chance involved, is lucky. But the chance that any halfway decent programmer ends up with a high paying job is damn near 100% right now.

There are a lot of forks in the road on the way to success. Looking back, each of those forks looks lucky to you because they landed you in you current success. But you could have taken the opposite road at any of those forks and still been successful.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by kqr on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:24PM (#28011374)
As Feynman put it,

> You know, the most amazing thing happened to me tonight... I saw a car with the license plate ARW 357. Can you imagine? Of all the millions of license plates in the state, what was the chance that I would see that particular one tonight? Amazing!

Re:Some career advice (2019) by alex504 on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:57PM (#28011743)
I agree with this 100%, just want to add that the key is to be proactive and take the forks. If you are a halfway decent programmer and can navigate the job market in a halfway decent way you will end up with a high paying job. Some people are terrible at the latter and it is painful to watch.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by vagrantJin on Friday July 30, 2021 @10:10AM (#28008157)
> This happened because after the 9th rejection and I said "Fk it" and sent out another CV.

This is bold and I approve. Not many of us have this fck it mechanism built in. So we make excuses not to impose ourselves which is first class BS. My last agency gig was with an award winning agency with massive clients, I was interviewed with a director in the room. The meeting was scheduled for 20 minutes. It ended up lasting 2 hours.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:06PM (#28011191)
Smart people place themselves in a situation where luck can find them.

For example, if you drop out of school, do drugs, and commit crimes, what are your odds of a successful life? Zilch.

If you stay at home playing video games all day, what are your odds of meeting the partner of your dreams? Zip.

If your startup does no marketing, does not attend trade shows, and doesn't write a decent manual, what are the odds of business success? Zero.

If you bring a sack lunch to work every day, and eat at your desk instead of stepping out to lunch with the gang, what are your odds of promotion? Pretty meager.

And so on.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by Sxubas on Friday July 30, 2021 @06:06PM (#28013004)
> For example, if you drop out of school, do drugs, and commit crimes, what are your odds of a successful life? Zilch.

This also depends on luck, search for the fundamental attribution error.

One can't decide where one is born, and in some places the hostile environment you live in, can cause you to take those decisions/behave like so.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @06:10PM (#28013040)
> can cause you to take those decisions/behave like so

That denies that people have agency. Nobody makes anyone make those choices.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by Sxubas on Friday July 30, 2021 @06:21PM (#28013142)
That's exactly the fundamental attribution error. You're under-emphasizing situational explanations, and over-emphasizing disposition/personality based ones.

Following your logic, could we explain all crime the world just because criminal 'dont have agency'?

I doubt it

Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:41PM (#28013771)
People choose to commit crimes. That's what agency means.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by alexanderdmitri on Friday July 30, 2021 @10:35PM (#28014714)
You don't have agency as a child when the largest chunk of emotional and physical development take place. Parents and environment play a huge role in defining the sense of personal agency and choices a person feels capable of. Increasingly it's being found that mental health issues can be passed down generations[0].

On a personal level, I think what you're saying makes sense and is a good healthy approach to life and maximizing potential by not doing stupid things. It is good to hold yourself to account and those around you as well.

From a social/macro perspective though, I think it's important to look towards the data on things like crime in a scientific and empathetic mindset if we want to build a stronger society and optimize for bringing out the best in people and making sure everyone has a fair shot.

Crime happens for all sort of reasons, probably a non-negligible amount is committed by people channeling the abuse they received as children and their abusers probably never got held to account in any explicit way. Or say you're a young kid raised in Sinaloa without much education, your parents actually poked fun at you for going to school and talked down at the things you learned in the classroom. Around you, not only are the most successful and powerful people narcos, but your economy is defined on the gains from crime. Of course the line blurs, are you a criminal if you join up with the traffickers, are you a coward for not and choosing to do 'honest' work?

If the world is waging war against you and your options while telling you it's your fault for being in the position you are in, maybe you stop thinking like a middle class civilian and more like a soldier on a dead man's mission.

[0] https://www.cdc.gov/childrensmentalhealth/features/mental-he...

Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Saturday July 31, 2021 @12:33AM (#28015328)
> child

High schoolers are not children. The justice system properly gives a lot of breaks to juvenile delinquents, in recognition of their immature judgement. But that doesn't mean they aren't responsible for their choices. I remember being that age, and I clearly made choices.

> choices a person feels capable of

When people say they had "no choice" they are making excuses.

> raised in Sinaloa

I'm talking about America. I don't buy that Americans are forced into crime, taking drugs, and dropping out.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by alexanderdmitri on Saturday July 31, 2021 @01:52AM (#28015636)
You're missing the point if you think it's about people being forced. It's more like people being set up to fail or being in an environment that increases the exposure to crime, drugs and where dropping out isn't taken as seriously.

I'd be interested in your response to this article that focuses on the American city of Baltimore: https://www.npr.org/2019/02/13/693972661/a-high-crime-neighb...

Re:Some career advice (2019) by lliamander on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:00PM (#28011776)
> If you bring a sack lunch to work every day, and eat at your desk instead of stepping out to lunch with the gang, what are your odds of promotion? Pretty meager.

I'm not sure if I have heard that point before, but it's very interesting. At different points in my career I've tried to be consistent about packing my lunch to save money, but I guess that might be an example of being penny-wise and pound-foolish.

It also depends upon who you are going out to lunch with. If you're only going out to lunch with other peons, it's probably not going to help you much.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:14PM (#28011893)
> If you're only going out to lunch with other peons, it's probably not going to help you much.

You'd be surprised. Today's peons are often tomorrow's movers and shakers. But yes, going to lunch with diverse people in your organization helps.

This is also a huge problem with WFH. WFH doesn't build valuable social/work connections. It's easy to overlook the contributions of WFH people. It's easy to forget their names. They're often the first to get laid off in a downturn, and last to get promoted. Meeting your customers face-to-face is far more likely to end in a sale, than with zoom.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by lliamander on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:24PM (#28011971)
> This is also a huge problem with WFH. WFH doesn't build valuable social/work connections. It's easy to overlook the contributions of WFH people. It's easy to forget their names.

This is definitely true. I started working from home a year before the pandemic to help take care of a sick family member, and I felt like I was forgotten about. When COVID hit and everyone was forced to WFH, it was actually a boon for me because I was now on an even playing field with my coworkers and they suddenly remembered my existence.

My life circumstances have changed somewhat so that I probably could go back into the office, but our company is still fully remote so I'm glad to be at home. I'm really just trying to figure out what I'll do once our offices open back up. I'm thinking going into the office 1-2 days a week is probably enough to help me capture some of those opportunities while still keeping the benefits of WFH.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @04:31PM (#28012023)
> packing my lunch to save money

Dressing cheaply also saves money. But it's a mistake for one's career. Wearing clothes that are a cut more expensive than your peers and competitors is a good investment in your future.

People adamantly deny that they're so shallow as to be affected by this, but I've seen it happen too often to discount it.

Back in my Zortech days, we decided on a policy that our employees would wear a suit whenever meeting customers. We even paid for the suits. Initially, there was a lot of grumbling about it. But it paid off. Our customers loved it, because they were sick of seeing software people dressed like slobs. For many of our employees, it was their first suit, and they loved the effect it had on their interactions.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by mixmastamyk on Friday July 30, 2021 @05:11PM (#28012424)
"You’re gonna like the way you look, …..I guarantee it!"™

(Joking, but what you've written is largely true.)

Re:Some career advice (2019) by lliamander on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:02PM (#28013489)
I actually recently started investing in better clothes. Not suits, per se, since that would be out of place for most work contexts for me. But clothes with good fit, quality, and appropriate (or even slightly more formal) for the dress codes I work under.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:42PM (#28013776)
Smart move. Hope it works for you!
Re:Some career advice (2019) by rufus_foreman on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:40PM (#28013760)
>> if you drop out of school, do drugs, and commit crimes, what are your odds of a successful life? Zilch

I did all that. It was fun. Doing OK now, I think. How do I check and see if I have a successful life?

Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:46PM (#28013811)
It's up to you to decide if your life is successful.

Last year "60 Minutes" profiled a guy who spent maybe 10 years in prison. He used his time to study law, and became a successful lawyer when released. He was profiled because of how unusual this was, not how common.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by rufus_foreman on Friday July 30, 2021 @07:57PM (#28013885)
10 years? Sounds like he unsuccessfully committed crimes.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by ekster on Friday July 30, 2021 @11:12AM (#28008859)
I really think doing contracting and changing jobs every year for the first ten years of my tech career (receiving a raise and promotion every time) was the biggest single factor to my success. It ensured progression and allowed the dice to be rerolled, which is a great way to think about it.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by ZephyrBlu on Saturday July 31, 2021 @07:42AM (#28017236)
How did you get promoted 10 times? There are nowhere near 10 SWE levels.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by ekster on Saturday July 31, 2021 @10:07AM (#28018246)
I started at the very bottom (build engineer) and transitioned on the other end to management. It wasn’t SE0-SE10.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by halayli on Friday July 30, 2021 @10:22AM (#28008297)
right time and right place is always a major factor.

However, we are always in the right time and right place for a breakthrough. But it's unfair to not give credit to those that saw the opportunity, believed in it, and made it happen.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by WalterBright on Friday July 30, 2021 @03:15PM (#28011302)
For example, I worked for a startup in the 70's that had every piece of the puzzle to build a stellar PC, much better than the Apple. We had the expertise, the technology, and the talent (even Hal Finney worked there, yes, that Hal Finney, he wrote a BASIC interpreter to fit in a 2k EPROM). Except we didn't. Jobs/Wozniak did. They got rich, we didn't.
Re:Some career advice (2019) by 908B64B197 on Friday July 30, 2021 @05:46PM (#28012783)
> Later, as a consultant, my first project was on some dying database system that needed to be kept alive a short while longer. In this case, I'd learned already, that you don't have to always accept your circumstances as they are. I politely complained to management that this is not what I was hired for and did not match my skills, and was transferred to a way more interesting and career rewarding project.

If it looks like a cost center, it's a waste of your time.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by seahawks78 on Friday July 30, 2021 @01:32PM (#28010302)
> I wish we as a culture/society, acknowledged the luck and timing factor more as a factor in career development.

I would argue that this would be too cruel for the "unwashed masses" to digest/fathom. The myth of meritocratic rise in a capitalistic system rests on the fundamental premise that luck plays little to no role in one's success. That is why you often hear bunkum like "the harder I work luckier I become" and others in desperate attempts to trivialize externalities. The very fact you you won/or didn't win the genetic lottery (born to rich/high IQ/hard working parents) could be a big strike in favor/against you. Furthermore, there is also ample anecdotal/research evidence to show that people who think that they are self made or downplay the role of luck in their success also tend to be more selfish and more uncaring for the less fortunate. I don't exactly recall who said this (most likely a leader from some socialist country a while back) that: since majority of life's success (wealth/riches) is mostly due to luck it can't be morally wrong/unjustifiable to take some of that away through high taxation.

Re:Some career advice (2019) by lliamander on Friday July 30, 2021 @02:36PM (#28010897)
It is true that successful people often discount the role of luck in their success, but the fact is that even while we don't get to choose what opportunities come our way, we do have control over how we choose to exploit those opportunities.

I find your moral calculus about taxation rather odd. Just because someone didn't earn something doesn't mean other people have a right to take it. For example, just because someone is blessed by genetic lottery with a luxurious head of hair doesn't mean I have a right forcibly take that hair and make a wig to cover my own balding head.