This also depends on luck, search for the fundamental attribution error.
One can't decide where one is born, and in some places the hostile environment you live in, can cause you to take those decisions/behave like so.
That denies that people have agency. Nobody makes anyone make those choices.
Following your logic, could we explain all crime the world just because criminal 'dont have agency'?
I doubt it
On a personal level, I think what you're saying makes sense and is a good healthy approach to life and maximizing potential by not doing stupid things. It is good to hold yourself to account and those around you as well.
From a social/macro perspective though, I think it's important to look towards the data on things like crime in a scientific and empathetic mindset if we want to build a stronger society and optimize for bringing out the best in people and making sure everyone has a fair shot.
Crime happens for all sort of reasons, probably a non-negligible amount is committed by people channeling the abuse they received as children and their abusers probably never got held to account in any explicit way. Or say you're a young kid raised in Sinaloa without much education, your parents actually poked fun at you for going to school and talked down at the things you learned in the classroom. Around you, not only are the most successful and powerful people narcos, but your economy is defined on the gains from crime. Of course the line blurs, are you a criminal if you join up with the traffickers, are you a coward for not and choosing to do 'honest' work?
If the world is waging war against you and your options while telling you it's your fault for being in the position you are in, maybe you stop thinking like a middle class civilian and more like a soldier on a dead man's mission.
[0] https://www.cdc.gov/childrensmentalhealth/features/mental-he...
High schoolers are not children. The justice system properly gives a lot of breaks to juvenile delinquents, in recognition of their immature judgement. But that doesn't mean they aren't responsible for their choices. I remember being that age, and I clearly made choices.
> choices a person feels capable of
When people say they had "no choice" they are making excuses.
> raised in Sinaloa
I'm talking about America. I don't buy that Americans are forced into crime, taking drugs, and dropping out.
I'd be interested in your response to this article that focuses on the American city of Baltimore: https://www.npr.org/2019/02/13/693972661/a-high-crime-neighb...
I'm not sure if I have heard that point before, but it's very interesting. At different points in my career I've tried to be consistent about packing my lunch to save money, but I guess that might be an example of being penny-wise and pound-foolish.
It also depends upon who you are going out to lunch with. If you're only going out to lunch with other peons, it's probably not going to help you much.
You'd be surprised. Today's peons are often tomorrow's movers and shakers. But yes, going to lunch with diverse people in your organization helps.
This is also a huge problem with WFH. WFH doesn't build valuable social/work connections. It's easy to overlook the contributions of WFH people. It's easy to forget their names. They're often the first to get laid off in a downturn, and last to get promoted. Meeting your customers face-to-face is far more likely to end in a sale, than with zoom.
This is definitely true. I started working from home a year before the pandemic to help take care of a sick family member, and I felt like I was forgotten about. When COVID hit and everyone was forced to WFH, it was actually a boon for me because I was now on an even playing field with my coworkers and they suddenly remembered my existence.
My life circumstances have changed somewhat so that I probably could go back into the office, but our company is still fully remote so I'm glad to be at home. I'm really just trying to figure out what I'll do once our offices open back up. I'm thinking going into the office 1-2 days a week is probably enough to help me capture some of those opportunities while still keeping the benefits of WFH.
Dressing cheaply also saves money. But it's a mistake for one's career. Wearing clothes that are a cut more expensive than your peers and competitors is a good investment in your future.
People adamantly deny that they're so shallow as to be affected by this, but I've seen it happen too often to discount it.
Back in my Zortech days, we decided on a policy that our employees would wear a suit whenever meeting customers. We even paid for the suits. Initially, there was a lot of grumbling about it. But it paid off. Our customers loved it, because they were sick of seeing software people dressed like slobs. For many of our employees, it was their first suit, and they loved the effect it had on their interactions.
(Joking, but what you've written is largely true.)
I did all that. It was fun. Doing OK now, I think. How do I check and see if I have a successful life?
Last year "60 Minutes" profiled a guy who spent maybe 10 years in prison. He used his time to study law, and became a successful lawyer when released. He was profiled because of how unusual this was, not how common.
For example, if you drop out of school, do drugs, and commit crimes, what are your odds of a successful life? Zilch.
If you stay at home playing video games all day, what are your odds of meeting the partner of your dreams? Zip.
If your startup does no marketing, does not attend trade shows, and doesn't write a decent manual, what are the odds of business success? Zero.
If you bring a sack lunch to work every day, and eat at your desk instead of stepping out to lunch with the gang, what are your odds of promotion? Pretty meager.
And so on.