News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by atlgator on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @11:06AM (#27984687)
Is it odd they are going after SpaceX? The funding they received was earmarked to support unserved census blocks. If any company is in a position to help unserved rural areas it is SpaceX, no?
Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by SloopJon on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @11:11AM (#27984737)
If up to $100 million of that was to places like highway medians and a "parking garage ... surrounded on all sides by multiple companies offering gigabit service," then no, it's not odd at all.
Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by TheParkShark on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @03:49PM (#27988857)
If I understand correctly SpaceX internet is from a satellite. Surely it would would in a larger area than a parking garage or a median right?
Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by ogjunkyard on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @11:14AM (#27984776)
I feel like the lean on SpaceX in this article is because it's a popular name at the moment. In the article, it mentions that SpaceX received grants for urban areas for things like airport parking lots. Also mentioned were areas already served by one or more companies with 25/3 broadband. Those were the types of locations that funding was being pulled for.
Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by g_sch on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @11:33AM (#27985011)
It looks like they're only trying to claw back a small portion of the overall award to SpaceX ($111m out of $885m), so on its own, this doesn't look like a move to kneecap SpaceX. At least not on the scale of what we see with AWS vs. Azure on the JEDI contract.
Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by TheParkShark on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @03:50PM (#27988869)
Compared to others (Charter) they are having a larger portion pulled back from them. They didn’t even receive the largest contract.
Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by drooby on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @11:11AM (#27984734)
It only effects something like 6% of blocks that SpaceX would get the funds for… so basically instead of SpaceX getting $880m they’ll get $825m.
Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by duxup on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @11:52AM (#27985257)
Is it 'gong after SpaceX' or just a case of questioning if they should have gotten the money or not?

I'm not sure any contact or such is 'going after'.

Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by simiones on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @11:31AM (#27984992)
> If any company is in a position to help unserved rural areas it is SpaceX, no?

Not really - it is very unlikely that SpaceX will be able to cost-effectively serve high-speed internet for any interesting amount of people in a relatively small geographic area, such as the United States, as at any one time only a very small number of satellites can serve a particular area. This becomes especially problematic with any realistically achievable size of the constellation, which is going to be much closer to the current size (~1700 satellites) than to the "promised" size (~42k satellites).

Laying cable seems much more achievable and maintainable than launching 42k satellites every 2-5 years as Elon is "promising" (remember that the maximum life span of any satellite in LEO, as mentioned by SpaceX, is 5 years, after which it will de-orbit naturally).

Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by kaiju0 on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @12:09PM (#27985477)
The new starship platform should be able to launch 400 satellites per launch. They would only need 30 launches a year to support the constellation.
Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by tsimionescu on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @01:05PM (#27986139)
Sure, and each launch will only cost $2 million, and the same rocket will do earth-to-earth travel. In 10 years they'll have 3 colonies on Mars connected by hyperloops, and they'll rescue those kids with the mini-sub.

I'm sure Starship will fly in a few years and carry more satellites at a better cost per ton than existing rockets, but there is no reason at all to believe anything close to the announced timelines, sizes, and costs. At any cost per launch per ton that is even somewhat comparable to any existing rocket (say half of), 42k satellites is far too expensive.

Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by vincnetas on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @11:06PM (#27992373)
"Only 30" launches :) this reminded me about factorio where it takes you 95% of the game to launch first rocket, and then if you built your automations right, just sit and relax and watch rockets ascend one after another without you doing anything :)
Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by josefx on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @11:19AM (#27984849)
Maybe they currently don't meet all the requirements?[1]

[1] https://www.fcc.gov/auction/904/factsheet

Re:Ajit Pai apparently mismanaged $9B fund–new FCC boss star... by giacaglia on Wednesday July 28, 2021 @11:09AM (#27984720)
Not odd. Expected