Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by ezekg on Friday July 23, 2021 @03:22PM
(#27934578)
What a crazy edge case. I wonder why it thinks an object that is not actually 'moving' (i.e. getting closer) is a traffic light.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by walrus01 on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:19PM
(#27935136)
The real world is full of 'edge cases' that humans can deal with through their intuition and understanding of context. Humans are unlikely to mistake a yellow-ish moon for a yellow traffic light unless very intoxicated.
I'd like to see a Tesla on full autonomous autopilot take a drive in Calgary or Edmonton a few days after a heavy snow, when it's been mostly plowed but the lines are missing from the roads, all the lines at the side of the road are covered in snow, etc.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by Retric on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:23PM
(#27935182)
At level 3 they just reject things back to the driver if they can’t see road markings. Longer term GPS makes that an easier problem for self driving cars than bad weather. The post blizzard random trails through deep snow seem like a more difficult challenge, largely because it’s so rare.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by jvm_ on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:42PM
(#27935393)
Lanes in heavy snow covered roads are more of a suggestion. You can either drive on the bare 'wagon tracks' of road, or on the proper lane (that you can't even see) with 6-12 inches of snow on them.
Often when driving like this, you see a glimpse of the middle-yellow line inside one of the wagon tracks, and you realize that you're actually driving in part of the other lane. Fortunately the opposing traffic's wagon tracks are also shifted so that they're driving partially on the shoulder.
A GPS guided car would make a mess of the wagon track pattern that all the humans decided to just go with.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by Retric on Friday July 23, 2021 @05:00PM
(#27935583)
I am not talking 6-12 inches, when it’s 4+ feet of snow even pickup trucks need to stick to the valley’s which rarely have much to do with traffic lanes.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by version_five on Friday July 23, 2021 @03:41PM
(#27934784)
You highlight the big challenge with computer vision and other computerized identification of things, regardless of the underlying technology. There is no "mental model" of what makes sense against which to check observations. There can be coded rules, but if something passes them, there is no extra sanity check like a person would do. Put another way, models have no common sense, and we don't really have a meaningful way to give it to them. This is going to remain a problem for self driving cars and is a big part of the reason why they have not lived up to expectations.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by aabhay on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:06PM
(#27935008)
Humans use stereo vision to overcome things like this. I think some kind of stereoscopic strategy would be a feasible strategy, no? Why revert to the age-old argument of "common sense"?
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by nyx on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:11PM
(#27935058)
Humans have more than just stereo vision sensors. Like GP said, we also have robust schemata, seeded by biology and improved over our entire lives, that allow us to make sense of the things we see. These heuristics are trivial for us to access, but relatively difficult to describe and implement in a software system. That's what "common sense" means in this context.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by patch_cable on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:07PM
(#27935018)
I have one eye and have no problem not making these kinds of mistakes.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by clon on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:12PM
(#27935067)
Stereo vision is overrated. One of my buddies is a pilot with 1 eye (since birth) and around 11 thousand landings. Top of his game. There is more to depth perception than stereo vision for sure
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by jazzyjackson on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:30PM
(#27935255)
We have a lens that has to flex to bring far away objects into focus, so I figure that can give us some feedback.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by wizzwizz4 on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:34PM
(#27935312)
For sufficiently distant objects, this is completely irrelevant. This lets us roughly gauge the reciprocal of distance.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by blakesterz on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:08PM
(#27935022)
Funny, when I saw that I thought how did they miss this one? It's the moon, how is it possible no one has driven a Tesla at the right time in the right direction to have picked up the moon? The moon is out quite often. It doesn't seem like that much of an edge case to me, though I could be wrong.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by Retric on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:43PM
(#27935402)
The exact situation with the moons coloration changed by atmospheric conditions and being in just the right location over a long straight road to trigger this on a long stretch of straight road is probably quite rare. The software eventually does reject it as not a yellow light, only to change it’s mind back to the moon. I am wondering if this relates to the image classification system starting over from scratch regularly for some reason.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by jazzyjackson on Friday July 23, 2021 @04:30PM
(#27935269)
Californians mostly drive north and south, so facing the moon head on would be rare xD
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by dingaling on Saturday July 24, 2021 @12:46AM
(#27938465)
A friend has a 2018 Honda with auto-dipping headlights, it mistakes a near-full Moon low to the horizon as an oncoming car and switches the headlights to low-beam.
Re:Tesla Autopilot thinks the moon is a yellow traffic light
by jazzyjackson on Saturday July 24, 2021 @01:06AM
(#27938549)
To be fair to the Honda, what do you need high beams for when the full moon is out?