News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can we survive technology? (1955) [pdf] by spodek on Friday July 23, 2021 @07:48AM (#27929626)
Regarding the environment and humans decreasing the Earth's ability to sustain life, the tech community doesn't seem to pick up on the pattern that technology augments the users' goals and values. As long as our culture values growth, extraction, externalizing costs, comfort, and convenience, technology that makes that system more efficient may decrease pollution in one element, but it makes the system more efficient. That is, we pollute and decrease Earth's ability to sustain life more efficiently.

When Watt made his steam engine, coal use went up. Uber was supposed to lower congestion and miles driven but they went up. We repeat the pattern over and over. The "father" of the Green Revolution, on winning the Nobel Prize said

> "The green revolution has won a temporary success in man’s war against hunger and deprivation; it has given man a breathing space. If fully implemented, the revolution can provide sufficient food for sustenance during the next three decades. But the frightening power of human reproduction must also be curbed; otherwise the success of the green revolution will be ephemeral only.

> Most people still fail to comprehend the magnitude and menace of the “Population Monster”. . . Since man is potentially a rational being, however, I am confident that within the next two decades he will recognize the self-destructive course he steers along the road of irresponsible population growth…"

He understood the value of technology as well as anyone in theory and practice. He recognized that we have to change our values from growth to enjoying what we have, from externalizing costs to responsibility, and so on or technology will keep exacerbating and augmenting our problems. That pattern includes nuclear, electric vehicles, and space travel. They may solve local problems, but they exacerbate the systemic effect. Electric vehicles, for example, make sense as a tactic under the strategy of reducing vehicles. Nuclear makes sense only as a tactic under the strategy of lowering power consumption. But we keep valuing producing more cars and energy.

This community seems over and over again to miss the systemic and unintended side effects. If we had clean fusion under our current values, we wouldn't live as we do today only cleaner. We would grow again until we hit more limits and had to live again under scarcity or natural calamity. Borlaug worked the second half his career to help people see the consequences of helping solve only part of our system but not the system.

If we have to stop growing at some point, at least acknowledging the laws of thermodynamics, the sooner we do it, with the smaller number of people, the more abundance we can live with. The more people we have, the harder to limit ourselves. If we don't, nature will, as we all know.

Re:Can we survive technology? (1955) [pdf] by wfn on Friday July 23, 2021 @08:29AM (#27929928)
Yup, very much agree.

> If we don't, nature will, as we all know.

In a way, it's already happened, it's just that there is a delay effect and it takes time for things to... unravel ("the future is already here - it's just not evenly distributed yet")

I recommend this lecture https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7WRojM9_uAI by Pablo Servigne (agricultural engineer, PhD in ethology and behaviour of complex systems).

I'd say we've basically known since at least https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Limits_to_Growth (but in many ways much earlier than that) and have simply been in denial. Yes we adapt and leverage technology and innovation, but there are rather hard time limits and we've exhausted our window quite some time ago. The correction (to use a friendly word) will be very painful.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7WRojM9_uAI

Re:Can we survive technology? (1955) [pdf] by Nasrudith on Saturday July 24, 2021 @04:42AM (#27939299)
The number of people is /not/ remotely the limit on abundance or efficiency. Do you know when Holocene extinction occured? During human population bottlenecks from localized depletion of food sources. No overpopulation - we were endangered and bear the scars of it genetically to this day. No technological efficiency there to blame. And no mythical elyium values - they didn't have that priveledge. Any uncontacted tribe that managed to live hunter gatherer by definition was extremely lucky at the time. They had an environment capable of supporting them stationary and no rivals as threats. If they were nomadic over any significant area they would have been known and exposed to human networks.

Efficiency is our only way out of it. Farm acreage shrinking isn't from shortage of housing but an abundance of productivity.

Re:Can we survive technology? (1955) [pdf] by titzer on Friday July 23, 2021 @11:02AM (#27931450)
> If we had clean fusion under our current values, we wouldn't live as we do today only cleaner. We would grow again until we hit more limits and had to live again under scarcity or natural calamity. Borlaug worked the second half his career to help people see the consequences of helping solve only part of our system but not the system.

It's almost as if a population of apes that evolved to live in groups of 200 individuals maximum and has survived only by constantly spreading to new areas once resources are depleted can't run a sustainable planetary society.

Every single trait that we need to run a sustainable planetary society is selected against in the local incentive system of both evolution, capitalism, and technological advancement.

Frankly, our greed is eating this planet. And we are greedy because the greedy strategy worked best (evolutionarily) up until now, and greed was baked into our genes by all the selection pressures of the many systems we are a part of and set up ourselves.

Re:Can we survive technology? (1955) [pdf] by narrator on Friday July 23, 2021 @08:54AM (#27930109)
The more efficiently a resource is used, the more of it will be used. This is known as Jevon's Paradox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
Re:Can we survive technology? (1955) [pdf] by Robotbeat on Friday July 23, 2021 @11:03AM (#27931459)
Jevons Paradox is often misunderstood and misapplied.

Improving efficiency of coal burning and extraction can increase use of coal, especially if no alternative exists and it is the bottleneck for economic development. But if you develop a more efficient technology that doesn’t burn coal, it’s not going to automatically mean more coal will be used. Natural gas, wind, and solar have all increased in absolute terms in the last two decades in the US while coal burning has halved in absolute terms, reducing overall absolute grid emissions in the US.

Anyway, just wanted to point that out. (But I will say Jevons Paradox is a good argument against just relying on improved internal combustion engine efficiency in hybrid cars and buses vs using another energy source for transportation entirely, like renewable and nuclear electricity for trains, electric buses and electric cars.)

Re:Can we survive technology? (1955) [pdf] by not_jd_salinger on Friday July 23, 2021 @11:22AM (#27931687)
> it’s not going to automatically mean more coal will be used. Natural gas, wind, and solar have all increased in absolute terms in the last two decades in the US while coal burning has halved in absolute terms, reducing overall absolute grid emissions in the US.

In a tightly interconnected global economy it is disingenuous to disconnect the energy usage of one country or region from another.

US coal usage goes down because the things we used to build with that energy are now built in China. Solar panels in the US are cheaper than ever because manufacturing has switched to being 80% Chinese production, and guess where the energy to build those solar panels comes from? Coal.

The only way to understand energy is at a global scale as you can see here: https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-consumption

As you can clearly see no source of energy has decreased overtime globally.

Looking at local energy production is just an accounting trick, but the planet doesn't really care. You can't combat global warming by saying "look, technically we didn't produce that energy on our shores!"

If you forced China to decrease its use of fossil fuels you would immediately feel the impact on the global economy. Just because the power plants aren't within our borders doesn't mean that's not energy being consumed for our benefit.

Re:Can we survive technology? (1955) [pdf] by spodek on Friday July 23, 2021 @10:04AM (#27930770)
Unless we choose not to use it. Our culture values growth and extraction. Other cultures have lived far longer than the period from the Industrial Revolution until now, often with higher marks of health, longevity, abundance, and prosperity without lowering their environments' ability to sustain life. Only very recently did our lifespans pass typical ones for other cultures, but in the US they're already dropping again.

We sometimes do so protect. We have national parks and protect endangered species, for example. We can do plenty more. Jevon's Paradox and rebound effects don't have to happen.

Re:Can we survive technology? (1955) [pdf] by formerly_proven on Friday July 23, 2021 @02:48PM (#27934266)
Growth-oriented states of being naturally lead to induced demand.