News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thousands of scientific papers uploaded to The Pirate Bay by sitkack on Thursday July 21, 2011 @03:30PM (#2790912)
Please don't conflate the pay walls with public domain, these journal articles are clearly in the public domain. And they should not be behind a pay wall.

Locking in of the worlds historical knowledge is even worse, I think, than locking in current research. The economic return to the holders of the keys to the garden have no moral or legal right to assert control over the this knowledge, when their articles of incorporation most likely expose the oposite of their actions. These organizations are greedy wholesale hypocrites.

Re:Thousands of scientific papers uploaded to The Pirate Bay by pestaa on Thursday July 21, 2011 @04:47PM (#2791215)
I'm no legal expert, but I'd guess it's illegal to sell what is in the public domain. Why hasn't anybody done anything?
Re:Thousands of scientific papers uploaded to The Pirate Bay by jemfinch on Thursday July 21, 2011 @06:03PM (#2791486)
You've really never seen a Dover book?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dover_Books

Publishing works that are in the public domain is their bread and butter.

Re:Thousands of scientific papers uploaded to The Pirate Bay by pestaa on Friday July 22, 2011 @07:44AM (#2793115)
Kudos for compensation to the downvotes I received. I don't know what happened to the "ask and learn" culture.

I am not a native English speaker, and the term public domain was not self-explanatory (rather, it explained itself in the wrong way).

In Hungarian, public domain means közkincs, which is roughly equivalent to "treasure of the public". So the question seemed reasonable to ask.

Re:Thousands of scientific papers uploaded to The Pirate Bay by zaphar on Thursday July 21, 2011 @04:52PM (#2791240)
I am not a lawyer or expert either but I do not believe it is illegal to sell something in the public domain. That's sort of the point of Public Domain. No one can tell you not to sell it.
Re:Thousands of scientific papers uploaded to The Pirate Bay by keeperofdakeys on Friday July 22, 2011 @03:30AM (#2792715)
You can sell works in the public domain. Go to your book store, I'm sure you can buy a copy of Frankenstein, which is in the public domain. The whole purpose of public domain is that no one owns the copyright, so there are no restrictions to anyone on what may be done with them. I could publish Frankenstein and sell it to people, but I can't stop other people from selling it.

If these documents really are under public domain, then JSTOR can't stop people from distributing the copies obtained from them. However, it is possible for JSTOR to claim copyright on the form of the distributed copies, but not the content (assuming the papers are in the public domain). That is, if they had a JSTOR logo on the papers, or something 'unique', JSTOR may have a basis for claiming copyright infringement. This is assuming they were actually obtained legally, and JSTOR didn't have a strange TOS.

Re:Thousands of scientific papers uploaded to The Pirate Bay by sitkack on Thursday July 21, 2011 @06:48PM (#2791633)
Don't downvote this question, it is valid.
Re:Thousands of scientific papers uploaded to The Pirate Bay by kotrin on Thursday July 21, 2011 @05:31PM (#2791396)
We sell water don't we?
Re:Thousands of scientific papers uploaded to The Pirate Bay by MiguelHudnandez on Thursday July 21, 2011 @05:48PM (#2791444)
Exactly, you can charge for providing access to anything, as long as you are not obstructing public property to do so.

Even if the works are in the public domain, the copies that you maintain are yours and you can charge for access to those copies.

Re:Thousands of scientific papers uploaded to The Pirate Bay by mtogo on Thursday July 21, 2011 @06:53PM (#2791649)
I'm not sure if you're joking. I'm going to, for my own sanity, pretend that you are joking.