But as others have pointed out, in real life NL would probably be happy to have up to 100% of their actual employees immigrate so it may be just well-intentioned virtue signaling.
Which is also a valid recruiting strategy!
I also wonder what their precise definition of "underrepresented" is.
https://about.gitlab.com/company/culture/inclusion/#gitlabs-...
https://about.gitlab.com/company/culture/inclusion/#definiti...
>Underrepresented Group This can be defined as a group whose percentage of the population in a given group is lower than their percentage of the population of country, community, organization or otherwise.
I don't know what the "given group" is here. Is it Gitlab employees? Gitlab software engineers? Software engineers in the US? Software engineers in the Netherlands? Software engineers in the world?
I also don't know what larger population they're referring to. The cities with Gitlab employees? The US? The Netherlands? Countries with Gitlab employees? The world? Gitlab employees?
For some pairs of values atheist is likely underrepresented, but for most pairs I think atheist wouldn't be underrepresented.
Women is [a] gender term based on self-identification.
but then immediately after when defining Privilege we get On average women were paid $0.78 for every $1 a man makes.
Pretty likely that what they mean here is female and male rather than man and woman - the person writing this is probably not that used to talking about women and females differently.[1] https://www.ilga-europe.org/sites/default/files/before_and_a...
You seem to assume trans women make more than cis women. Wage data is collected by gender.
So basically they dictate policy based on population representation instead of what's actually coming through education. Sounds like a recipe for disaster.
I would’ve thought that population representation is the definition of underrepresented because it shows they are underrepresented in the population. But I am interested if there is another way to measure this.
What if less woman want to be engineers?
Does that mean less qualified woman get jobs that based on merit alone rightfully are deserved by men?
What about Asians? They're over represented in engineering roles, should we stop hiring them and hire more white males to "even it out"? Or is it because they're a minority it's ok to have over representation? Do you realise that makes white people under represented? Do you just not care because they have privilege and this evens it out?
Don't get me wrong, I love seeing woman in tech, I'm aware of the history of toxic behavior that prevents them from joining and pushed them out in the 70s and I do encourage initiatives to improve their representation but I draw the line at negative discrimination, that Marxist crap does nobody any good ever.
I wouldn't be too thrilled having my career advancement sacrificed in the pursuit of 50/50 men/woman representation.
Your comment assumes that Gitlab can't find as many qualified women as they can men.
You've decided (knowing nothing about the women except their gender) that they are only being hired for those roles because of their gender.
It could equally have been a fear that if more than 50% of women are qualified for the job some will have to be excluded.
It could not equally have been that.
Tech executives are vastly more male than female, and Gitlab specifically is trying to increase the ratio of women to men.
That means if Gitlab considers a group of similarly qualified men and women for an upcoming opening in "senior leadership" (whatever that means), a woman is guaranteed to get the job.
The only reason this would be unfair is if you pre-suppose that, more than 50% of the time, the "most qualified" person is a man.
The ratio is not based on ideology, it's based on the ratio of humans.
The "ideology" that makes them care about that ratio is the belief that someone's gender is not a determining factor in their qualification for senior leadership at GitLab.
If you also consider the number of adult men who are in prison or don't have an advanced education, you would actually expect to see more than 50% women to be representative of the general eligible population.
> shouldn’t the board have the same proportions as the population of people who want to work at GitLab?
No. "Want to work at GitLab" is also going to encode undesirable traits, such as "perceives GitLab to be a bad place for women to work".
If you know the company is mostly men at the top, you might assume women have a hard time getting promoted -- regardless of the reasons. That means you might not want to work at GitLab as much as an equally qualified man.
For the candidate: that's fine! No problem, there are lots of other places to work.
For GitLab: it's something they have decided is not desirable, and their quota system is how they are attempting to fix it.
What you're proposing would just be a vicious cycle that would reinforce what GitLab sees as a problem.
I don't agree. The tech industry is predominantly male and everybody knows it. Anybody who's ever been to a computer science class knows why- more men are interested.
If you assume that male and female employees have a similar distribution in merit, than you'd expect the top of the company to have a similar percentage to that of women interested in technology in general, which is to say it would mostly be men and you'd still assume that promotions are fair.
But promotions aren't fair or strictly meritocratic, and there's often good reasons for that. For instance, if you get more women in leadership the tail can wag the dog and you can get more women interested in tech.
It's also true that men are vastly more likely to be autistic, and the social challenges with autism can make someone a fantastic engineer, but not a fantastic manager.
That's not true of all autistic people, but there's certainly a correlation.
Again, GitLab is talking about senior leadership -- not people who are writing code or ever needed to have done it well. Most tech execs don't even have CS degrees, because most senior leadership positions are in organizational things (operations, management, HR, sales, etc.)
> I don't agree. The tech industry is predominantly male and everybody knows it. Anybody who's ever been to a computer science class knows why- more men are interested.
If this were true, and gender were the only variable, then we'd see stable ratios of men to women in computer science. We haven't seen that. There used to be far more women up until the 1980s.
> If you assume that male and female employees have a similar distribution in merit, than you'd expect the top of the company to have a similar percentage to that of women interested in technology in general
You're assuming many things here:
A. "interest in tech" is a stable personality trait and not influenced by opportunity
B. "senior leadership" at a tech company like GitLab is mostly technical roles
C. merit at tech companies is primarily a function of interest in technology
All of those are debatable at best, although I'd say they tend more toward the side of being obviously false once you actually write them out.
> The only reason this would be unfair is if you pre-suppose that, more than 50% of the time, the "most qualified" person is a man
I actually think discriminatory promotions is pretty unfair. Just because you think it's justified doesn't make it "fair". You can tell it is because of the term "discriminatory".
Meritocracy is not an objective, defined term, even in rote, technical jobs.
Further, people are very, very bad at hiring based on merit. There have been tons of studies showing that people tend to hire people who are like them (culturally, racially, gender, etc.)
Quotas are not harmful unless there are too few qualified people to meet the quota, resulting in a less-qualified person getting a job.
GitLab has hundreds of millions of people to choose from. They're not going to run out of qualified women.
neither is race or gender, yet these initiatives still manage to exist.
> There have been tons of studies showing..
there are tons of studies that are non reproducible too, so which studied are the strongest evidence of this claim?
> Quotas are not harmful unless there are too few qualified people
if you reduce it to a binary definition of "qualified", maybe. But if the best person for a role, their qualification, is a continuum, then you can do harm simply by hiring qualified candidates over better qualified candidates.
> GitLab has hundreds of millions of people to choose from
by what criteria?
Citation needed. I'm pretty sure discriminatory behavior is harmful. Just because you think it's justified doesn't mean it isn't harmful.
I just assume that in the situation where I was interviewing for a promoted role alongside an equally qualified female candidate also interviewing for that promoted role that I would have 0% chance of getting it.
Why would anyone ambitious want to put themselves in that position?
Here's a couple of examples from other areas:
* a university department in the EU announced that they will no longer hire males until they fulfil their quota.
* the German Green party has a rule that only women can occupy the top position at various levels.
Both of these are clear cases of sexual discrimination.
Uh, no.
The party is co-led by a man and a woman. The leaders of their parliamentary group is a man and a woman. The Green Party minister-president of Baden Württemberg is a man.
They do support quotas on executive boards, but that is a damn far cry from your claims of "only women can occupy the top position".
Internally in the party, they strive towards a 50/50 quota, but it's not a strict policy and the actual membership composition varies between elections.
> a university department in the EU announced that they will no longer hire males until they fulfil their quota.
Which university and which department? Also, a single department at a single university does not a widespread policy make.
Cite your sources.
This is confirmed for example by the situation in Saarland, where a man was chosen on the first spot. In the end there was so much pressure on that person from party colleagues (including one of the co-leads that you mentioned) that they had to step back, even if they had won fair and square.
The party-internal positions are mostly irrelevant, as the male co-lead of the Greens has found out when they had to make place for the chancellorship candidacy for his equal footed colleague with no government experience. And Kretchmann is probably one of the most successful Greens, it would be political suicide not to let him run loose :)
I don't remember which University, it was in a newspaper article. I have no idea if it's wide spread or not, the point was that the department(?) lead was comfortable not just mentioning, but advertising that practice in a newspaper, whereas the reverse would have gotten him in trouble immediately.
Reverse discrimination is still discrimination.
I believe they would have grounds to sue for discrimination in such a case though.
It's something that could crop up all over the show.
And no, I disagree that other countries pale in comparison to US on human rights abuses. To me, for example, the very existence of the 2nd amendment (at least its current interpretation) is a human rights abuse.
Which human right is being abused by the 2nd amendment?
> these countries do not conduct terrorist activities or war crimes in a foreign soil
Are you sure you comment on a good faith here?
South Sudan's civil war ended last year.
Venezuela is not at war but is being embargoed by the US while facing an economic crisis.
I have no idea what Honduras is supposed to be doing except that it's overrun with crime.
Belarus is facing civil unrests and political upheaval.
I'm not sure what you're referring to with your claim of "several" of them being in the middle of "actual wars". The US is in the middle of several actual wars and military actions outside war in foreign territories (mostly drone strikes). The comment you responded to clearly stated:
> No these countries do not conduct terrorist activities or war crimes on foreign soil like the US does.
The US does both of these things. As do several of its allies. We just tend to not to think of these things this way because we're "the good guys". Let's not forget Guantanamo (which despite Obama's promises still exists) and that US prisons routinely use "solitary confinement" which is considered torture by the UN.
Syria? Lebanon comes to mind again
Russia, Armenia, Azerbaijan? All of them are involved in "foreign soil" in some way
Egypt and Turkey vis-a-vis Libya (and Cyprus)?
Serbia/Albania vis-a-vis Kosovo
Morocco (Mali, Western Sahara)?
All of them are better than the US?
Not to mention that the behavior of a country "on foreign soil" is often very different than its behavior with its own citizens. That's why this division of good/evil countries often does not make sense.
The US is the most privileged country on the planet, just look at the per capita CO2 emissions with their private AC and swimming pools, SUVs, etc.
...for some of its population. For others, no.
That's what happens when you work hard to build a world leading industry. I don't get why other countries whine instead of innovating themselves!
Yes, US citizens get accepted into asylum processes. No, not all countries offer transparency into their asylum process or metrics.
Which countries are those? While the UK was an EU member, it required that asylum applicants not work, and I believe that's not an unusual restriction.
Somehow the idea that someone who flees to Germany because they lost their home and livelihood and then lives her for a decade may want to go on living here and that barring people from being productive members of society guarantees crime and illegal work. Germany learned nothing from the surprise of "guest workers" from Turkey and Italy moving to Germany to help us build cars suddenly having families and staying here forever back in the 70s.
Of course arguably the slowness and arduousness of the process is intended as a deterrence in itself, regardless of what that says about Germany's ideas about human rights and how they apply to foreigners.
Edit: I'm in Europe now, my former domestic worker would earn her monthly salary in 2-3 days here and she was paid well relative to others in Africa.
All women in America, for starters, per their definition. Not that qualified Americans have any problem moving to Europe. But maybe Arabs in Israel, Copts in Egypt, Russians in Ukraine, Zoroastrians in Iran, lots and lots of ethnicities in China, atheists in most countries…
Nice to know their training materials are free from bias though!
https://about.gitlab.com/company/culture/inclusion/#definiti...