Re:A proof P = NP was accidentally published in TOCT
by spicybright on Monday July 19, 2021 @05:15PM
(#27887333)
We need a lot more peer review for academic papers.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A proof P = NP was accidentally published in TOCT
by 542458 on Monday July 19, 2021 @05:20PM
(#27887376)
The paper in question was desk rejected. This isn’t a failure of peer review, it’s a clerical error.
Re:A proof P = NP was accidentally published in TOCT
by DrBenCarson on Monday July 19, 2021 @05:52PM
(#27887670)
Or the author did solve P=NP, saw the rejection, and then broke the journal’s security to prove it was actually solved.
Re:A proof P = NP was accidentally published in TOCT
by omaranto on Monday July 19, 2021 @07:24PM
(#27888423)
Does "desk-rejected" mean it was rejected by an editor who decided the paper was so wrong it wasn't even necessary to get a referee report? (I am familiar with the scientific publication process being a mathematician, but have never seen the term "desk-rejected" before, it may be a CSism.)
EDIT: Huh, "desk-rejected" is a common term not just in CS but also in medicine and other fields. It means, as I thought, rejected by an editor without even getting a referee report. I do think even though that thing does happen in math, the term "desk-rejection" is not used.
Re:A proof P = NP was accidentally published in TOCT
by shusaku on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @05:26AM
(#27891590)
Just an FYI, desk rejected can happen even for a good paper if the editor doesn’t see it as being in the scope of the journal. But in this case you’re surely right.
Re:A proof P = NP was accidentally published in TOCT
by paulddraper on Monday July 19, 2021 @09:11PM
(#27889103)
> Does "desk-rejected" mean it was rejected by an editor who decided the paper was so wrong it wasn't even necessary to get a referee report?
Yep.
Re:A proof P = NP was accidentally published in TOCT
by Jtsummers on Monday July 19, 2021 @05:16PM
(#27887341)
From the tweet linked by gberger, it seems this was rejected but ended up in the publish queue by error. Sounds like a procedural error, I'm curious what their process looks like now.
Re:A proof P = NP was accidentally published in TOCT
by bryanrasmussen on Monday July 19, 2021 @05:37PM
(#27887529)
Luckily the AIs we will be able to build now that P = NP means that this kind of error can be caught by the machines in the future.