News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by ithkuil on Monday July 19, 2021 @01:38PM (#27885242)
Unfortunately doing bad and good things is not mutually exclusive when talking about a single person, let alone when it's a group of people.

Whether the bad parts should be tolerated because of the good parts it's another matter (and given the things you're listed, I personally don't care about what good policies you do if that's the price to pay). that said we must be able to talk about policies and outcomes it their own right without tainting them with who has brought them.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by wolverine876 on Monday July 19, 2021 @02:16PM (#27885652)
> we must be able to talk about policies and outcomes it their own right without tainting them with who has brought them

I disagree. First, these are policies. Second, I don't care about the other policies unless human rights, including freedom and self-determination (democracy) are maintained.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by ithkuil on Monday July 19, 2021 @04:21PM (#27886869)
This is exactly what I said in my comment (the part in parenthesis), but not phrased against the impersonal policies but against the people who happen to put forward awful things along with policies that would be otherwise good.

I think you don't really disagree, because disagreeing would mean that once somebody does something against human rights, everything else they touch must be also bad by definition, thus depriving all future generations of the possibility of doing something good just because they accidentally mentioned it? When it's claimed that Mussolini made run trains on time (which it's very likely a myth, but it doesn't matter for this argument), does it mean that having trains that run on time is a bad idea that can no longer be pursued least we associate ourselves with fascism? That would clearly be silly.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by trs8080 on Monday July 19, 2021 @07:02PM (#27888280)
> disagreeing would mean that once somebody does something against human rights, everything else they touch must be also bad by definition, thus depriving all future generations of the possibility of doing something good just because they accidentally mentioned it

what on earth is this argument? to simplify this for you: if you deprive a subset of your population human rights and freedoms and allow a different subset to benefit from that injustice, it isn't a net good - it's supremacist.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by ithkuil on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @08:50AM (#27893086)
It seems you're intentionally misunderstanding me.

Let me try again: Mr X invents the lightbulb, then kills his wife. I'm not saying Mr X invention of the lightbulb excuses him for having commited murder; I'm saying that the ligthbulb is a good invention despite the person who invented it and that other people can keep using it (while the inventor rots in jail).

This is an intentionally silly example because nobody sane will cancel a useful invention because of where it came from, but when we're talking about social policies they are often inextricably tainted by who proposed them and embraced them.

You're free to say "I don't care about this subtle point you're making because I'm so concerned about this freak depriving people of human rights that we don't have time to talk about this crap you're talking about". Fair enough. What I don't accept is that you're insinuating that I'm defending this kind of behaviour just because I'm making point you're not interested in.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by r00fus on Monday July 19, 2021 @04:25PM (#27886899)
Modi is a fundamental nationalist, and this is one of literally a hundred other bad things that has been done.

Basic playbook for this kind of ruler is to dismantle democracy - and illegally spying on his opponents is the first step (to remove all opposition).

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by naruvimama on Monday July 19, 2021 @05:08PM (#27887274)
Nationalist in the European context is clearly one language, one religion and one culture.

In the India context, nationalism is a unifying force finding a commonality beyond the hundreds of diverse languages and cultures that India is made of.

I do not see why that is a bad thing.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by random314 on Monday July 19, 2021 @09:38PM (#27889253)
> In the India context, nationalism is a unifying force finding a commonality beyond the hundreds of diverse languages and cultures that India is made of.

You skipped the key plank of nationalist Indian politics - religion. Who are the new Jews of India? The backstabbers of the nation?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stab-in-the-back_myth

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by naruvimama on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @01:50AM (#27890481)
Unlike the Jews in Germany, the Muslims and Christians in India are very much Indian.

As the recent PEW survey shows, a large percentage hold Hindu values and think of it as culturally superior.

Hinduism is also the culture of converted peoples, as the vast majority were coerced to convert.

Importing the experience of Europe into India is meaningless.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by random314 on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @10:50AM (#27894442)
Virtually every thing you wrote is false.

1. Jews were also German

2. Indian muslims don't think of Hinduism as culturally superior

3. The vast majority were not forced at all. There have been only very few events of this nature.

Conservatism, all over the world, follows the same methodology. Fake and fantasy made up "history", identification of the "other" that must be eliminated, innate sense of superiority of the in group that the state must enforce, innate belief in hierarchy with little sympathy for those at the bottom.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by naruvimama on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @12:17PM (#27895700)
1. Jews were ethnically not white.

2. PEW research states that.

3. The vast majority of the Islamic and Christian conversion happened under Islamic and Christian colonial rule.

I guess the problems you are referring to is the hallmark of Christianity & Islam which preach for the wiping out of nonbelievers.

If anything must change it is the Bible and quaran.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by random314 on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @04:03PM (#27898549)
You are very consistently lying

1. Jews were German

2. False. PEW research doesn't state that

3. The vast majority of conversion from native animist and dravidian religions also happened under hindu rule. Same holds for Buddhism in India. Islamic rule was not colonial.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by naruvimama on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @05:04PM (#27899309)
1. Jews are semite people, you are confusing nationality with ethnicity.

2. ....... a significant percentage of xtian/Muslims mention somewhere around 30%

3. Syrian Christians in India pre date Christianity in Europe, yet it was insignificant until colonization. Buddhism in my view is a subset of Hinduism.

Islamic rule involved massive destruction of heritage, universities, libraries, temples, tributes to Perssia and the Caliphate, genocides and impossition of Persian script and Arabic, imposition of jizya.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by r00fus on Monday July 19, 2021 @08:12PM (#27888750)
India had all that before Modi. No, I definitely don't think Modi is a good guy.
Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by naruvimama on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @01:43AM (#27890448)
That is because Indians have always been patriots inspite of the poverty.

You may think that, but the people of India think otherwise and that if why he has an overwhelming popularity.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by addicted on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @05:29AM (#27891617)
He has overwhelming popularity because he is good at lying to people.

When it comes to state elections the Modi government has been getting creamed because his subordinates at the state level are not as good as lying to people.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by returnInfinity on Monday July 19, 2021 @10:14PM (#27889446)
India is a large diverse country. Every state has its own set of local rulers. Nothing can change this.
Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by ithkuil on Monday July 19, 2021 @04:32PM (#27886964)
I'm not saying the opposite or otherwise supporting Modi. I was trying to make a more subtle point about our ability to discuss things without always being reminded of the all too important political struggles we all have to pay attention to. Your comment seems to prove my point that we all have this instinct of making sure everybody is reminded that if you just hint that somebody awful could perhaps accidentally have stumbled upon a policy that could make sense, you should never talk about that, otherwise you'll give your opponent a validation. I know, that's how we humans work. I'm just saying that sometimes it's a bit unfortunate that we do work that way.
Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by r00fus on Monday July 19, 2021 @04:50PM (#27887110)
No, that's not my intent at all - but wouldn't it be considered offtopic to bring up some other positives just to "balance" the discussion?

If it's pertinent, by all means bring it up - but you're just bringing up theoretical seems all a bit ivory tower.

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by ithkuil on Tuesday July 20, 2021 @04:15AM (#27891166)
Please look at the nick names of who makes comments. I was not the one bringing up the positives, I have no idea about anything in Indian politics, not indian, not living there either. I was just pointing out a logical fallacy in one replay because this is a forum of nerds and nerds love to pick nits. The world would be such a nicer place if people political fumes wouldn't intoxicate brains of otherwise sensible people.
Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by wolverine876 on Monday July 19, 2021 @04:52PM (#27887132)
In fact, my experience is the opposite with right-wing nationalist populists (Modi, Netanyahu, Orban, Trump, Boris Johnson to a significant degree, etc.): People don't talk about the political catastrophes; they talk about everything else.

One reason is that if you try to talk about the political catastrophes, people try to shut you down.

> could perhaps accidentally have stumbled upon a policy that could make sense

'but how did you like the play, Mrs. Lincoln?'

> I'm not saying the opposite or otherwise supporting Modi.

So what do you say about Modi?

Re:Key Modi rival Rahul Gandhi among potential Indian target... by ithkuil on Monday July 19, 2021 @05:58PM (#27887740)
> So what do you say about Modi?

Oh that's easier to answer; there is thread above. TL;DR

The GP of my first comment said:

"the best policies are that of the government in power"

The parent answered:

"Taking away Indians' freedoms, brutalizing minorities,..."

I just said that it's a bit unfortunate that most of these discussions never really touch whether what GP said is true or false, i.e. whether the policies of the government are indeed best. Instead the answer points out how other policies are awful.

Now, I personally agree that those things listed are awful and I'd never support such political party.

But, logically, that is not an argument against what original GP said. I find it unfortunate that we are unable to talk about those things candidly.