If it's pertinent, by all means bring it up - but you're just bringing up theoretical seems all a bit ivory tower.
One reason is that if you try to talk about the political catastrophes, people try to shut you down.
> could perhaps accidentally have stumbled upon a policy that could make sense
'but how did you like the play, Mrs. Lincoln?'
> I'm not saying the opposite or otherwise supporting Modi.
So what do you say about Modi?
Oh that's easier to answer; there is thread above. TL;DR
The GP of my first comment said:
"the best policies are that of the government in power"
The parent answered:
"Taking away Indians' freedoms, brutalizing minorities,..."
I just said that it's a bit unfortunate that most of these discussions never really touch whether what GP said is true or false, i.e. whether the policies of the government are indeed best. Instead the answer points out how other policies are awful.
Now, I personally agree that those things listed are awful and I'd never support such political party.
But, logically, that is not an argument against what original GP said. I find it unfortunate that we are unable to talk about those things candidly.