Re:World’s First 3D-Printed Steel Footbridge Unveiled by Que...
by Grakel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @06:40PM
(#27850962)
Absolutely no reason to 3D print this. Even if that ugly POS is what you wanted, you could mold it cheaper.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:World’s First 3D-Printed Steel Footbridge Unveiled by Que...
by credit_guy on Thursday July 15, 2021 @08:33PM
(#27851821)
> you could mold it cheaper
Do you mean cast? You can mold steel, but not at that scale. Per wikipedia: “Due to current equipment limitations, products must be molded using quantities of 100 grams or less per shot into the mold.”
Re:World’s First 3D-Printed Steel Footbridge Unveiled by Que...
by Grakel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @11:10PM
(#27852689)
I did mean casting, I didn't know the difference here, thanks for this info!
Re:World’s First 3D-Printed Steel Footbridge Unveiled by Que...
by chrisseaton on Thursday July 15, 2021 @06:44PM
(#27850985)
> Absolutely no reason to...
It's art. There's never any reason for art.
Re:World’s First 3D-Printed Steel Footbridge Unveiled by Que...
by Grakel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @06:59PM
(#27851100)
Art is a communication expressed in a specific media in order to color or give further meaning to the message. The message of an artistic bridge should be "the harmony of material and engineering evoke beauty in the work of mankind." The message here is "we pooped a bridge!"
Re:World’s First 3D-Printed Steel Footbridge Unveiled by Que...
by chrisseaton on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:03PM
(#27851127)
> The message of an artistic bridge should be
Why should it be that? Why's that the only approved message in your mind?
> The message here is "we pooped a bridge!"
You're just being abusive.
Re:World’s First 3D-Printed Steel Footbridge Unveiled by Que...
by Grakel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:23PM
(#27851260)
You said there's never any reason for art. That's not just abusive, it's wrong. Without a reason, it's not art. And the reason here is weak. It's "because we could." That's what makes this objectively bad.
Re:World’s First 3D-Printed Steel Footbridge Unveiled by Que...
by chrisseaton on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:27PM
(#27851284)
You’re confusing reason as in technical requirement with reason as in why they chose to do something. They can choose to do something without it being a requirement.
And you’re changing your comments after they’ve been replied to - please don’t do that.
Re:World’s First 3D-Printed Steel Footbridge Unveiled by Que...
by Grakel on Thursday July 15, 2021 @07:39PM
(#27851391)
I'm not confused at all. You're constructing a very unusual meaning of "reason" in your first reply in order to...?
I was editing while you replied, I had not read your reply when I hit submit.