News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by rorykoehler on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:01PM (#27834600)
Underwhelming. No more petrol and diesel cars in 20 years? That should have been the policy 20 years ago.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by f6v on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:06PM (#27834653)
You remind of those developers that say “You have a Rails monolith? Let’s just tear everything down and rewrite it in microservices!” When in reality it takes years to move small parts of the backend into standalone services.

Now imagine dismantling the whole industry with its R&D, supply chains, people’s pensions, etc.

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by Daishiman on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:08PM (#27834675)
We have seen with existing electrification measures that once certain tipping points are reached entire industries roll over to new technologies. No reason to think it wouldn't apply for this either.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by rorykoehler on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:11PM (#27834704)
The counterpoint is that Telsa managed to emerge from nothing in that time. Incumbent ICE car companies had no incentive to start the transition so it's necessary to introduce an artificial constraint.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by paganel on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:19PM (#27834797)
Many, many EU citizens can not afford Teslas or equivalently priced EVs. Even the electric version of the common VW Golf is 30-to-50% more expensive than its ICE counter-part (which is not that cheap, either).
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by xyzzyz on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:23PM (#27834848)
Yeah. If you’re American, imagine being being 25% poorer, and cars being 50% more expensive (due to excise taxes, displacement taxes, 20%+ VAT and more) — that’s the reality faced by Europeans.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by SECProto on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:06PM (#27835413)
Make sure you also imagine that competent public transport and/or active transportation options are pretty widely available as alternatives.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by xyzzyz on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:47PM (#27836798)
This is not the reality that most Europeans live in. Europeans who live in major cities might enjoy their good public transport options, but in minor cities, towns and rural areas, public transport is crap to non-existent.

US has 800 cars per 1000 people, but Italy and Spain have 650/1000 and even Poland, which is significantly poorer than US, has over 700 cars per 1000 people. In Europe, car ownership is only slightly less of a necessity than it is in the US, and I think if you look at the data that measure cars not per capita, but per household, the gap in car ownership between US and European countries would be even smaller.

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by SECProto on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:23PM (#27837243)
> Europeans who live in major cities might enjoy their good public transport options, but in minor cities, towns and rural areas, public transport is crap to non-existent

I just opened up google maps, picked out two random small towns in Germany, and the driving distance between them is 200km/2hrs, while the transit length is 3hrs (with a transfer in a major city). Doing the same in the Northeast, one of the best areas for transit in the US, resulted in two towns 120miles/2hrs drive distance, and 18hr/6 transfers transit distance. So yes, a car is more convenient in both cases, but transit is a competent alternative (which is what I said). France and Italy had comparable results to Germany, Spain did not. Germany, France, and Italy makes up roughly half of the EU population (add in Belgium or the Netherlands if you wanna be precise, they've got decent transit too).

> US has 800 cars per 1000 people, but Italy and Spain have 650/1000 and even Poland, which is significantly poorer than US, has over 700 cars per 1000

You appear to have taken this article [1], and picked out the top three EU countries.

> In Europe, car ownership is only slightly less of a necessity than it is in the US, and I think if you look at the data that measure cars not per capita, but per household, the gap in car ownership between US and European countries would be even smaller.

"Owning a car" is not the same metric as "Needing to own a car to do literally anything because there are no alternatives". Germany, France, and Italy all rank higher than the US in annual passenger-km's of rail travel, despite each having populations 1/5th to 1/4th the size of the US[2]. Or look up modal share by country for other info - there's no handy Wikipedia summary, unfortunately, but for example, Germany is about 30% transit commutes.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_vehicles_...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_rail_usag...

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by xyzzyz on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @07:06PM (#27839595)
> I just opened up google maps, picked out two random small towns in Germany, and the driving distance between them is 200km/2hrs, while the transit length is 3hrs (with a transfer in a major city).

Now add the time it takes you to walk to the transit stop (rail station), the time to wait for the train/bus (remember, if you were driving, you could have departed immediately), and time to walk to your actual destination at the city you're going to. In practice, door-to-door trip using public transportation will almost always take twice as long as driving, unless you're lucky and have a non-stop train/bus that departs from right in front of your home and gets you right in front where you want to be. Of course, you also need to be on train's schedule, not your own, and that having 2-3 transfers each way is exhausting and annoying.

> transit is a competent alternative (which is what I said).

If your time is worthless, that is. That's why these trains and buses are usually packed with students and retirees.

> You appear to have taken this article [1], and picked out the top three EU countries.

And your point is? These countries are more representative of Europe at large, not two of the wealthiest places there.

> "Owning a car" is not the same metric as "Needing to own a car to do literally anything because there are no alternatives".

Alas, "owning a car" is very much the relevant metric in this discussion, which, allow me to remind you, was about how it is more difficult for Europeans to afford the car than it is to Americans.

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by f6v on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:51PM (#27838259)
I lived in a rural area in Germany. My experience was that grocery shopping and just getting around using public transport is much less convenient than in a big city. I almost felt handicapped without a car, and the majority of people around me drived one. Having children completely tips the scale.

And yes, there’s biking, but doing that while it’s raining is a complete different story.

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by SECProto on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @05:51PM (#27838871)
And if you want to compare that to the North American standard: I lived in a small town in Canada. Grocery store was 2km away - walk or drive or bike, they were all fine (though no infrastructure existed for the pedestrian or cyclist). But public transport was non-existent. A single intercity bus line had a stop ~25km away, and it came once per day.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by davidhbolton on Thursday July 15, 2021 @05:00AM (#27842699)
In the UK about 9 million (roughly 1 in 15) people live in the countryside. My nearest supermarket is 7 miles away. There is no public transport to speak of. The nearest railway station is 6 miles away.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by f6v on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:02PM (#27836153)
Major cities such as Berlin, Hamburg, Paris, and Vienna have good public transport network. But many people live in smaller cities/outskirts where car is mandatory.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by rorykoehler on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @04:49PM (#27838234)
Only because we haven't priced in the externalized costs of ICE (anywhere in the world).
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by kergonath on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:41PM (#27835849)
Tesla is a useful idiot. It's a toy for rich people who like to buy shiny things and pretend they care. It isn't a solution to anything.

What we need is lots of small and cheap cars that can be built easily and on a massive scale. Something akin to the original Volkswagen, or an automobile equivalent of the liberty ships.

Or even better, more public transport, and more remote work.

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by closeparen on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:19PM (#27834796)
Emerging from nothing is a lot easier and faster than migrating the long tail.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by rorykoehler on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:24PM (#27834871)
One of the German ICE CEO's was going on about how they have over a century of experience and Tesla will never catch up. There is something in this as most parts of the car don't change when becoming electric and the bits that do become simpler. They surely have the resources, architects and design teams to do this migration (which they have proven as they all now have electric car platforms in production). It was a matter of will not inability.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by aerique on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:59PM (#27836106)
No, the person you're replying to is right: we've had decades and decades of warnings.

Small steps could have been taken 30 years ago but now it's too late for that.

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by blooalien on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @03:01PM (#27836967)
> "Small steps could have been taken 30 years ago but now it's too late for that."

^^^ So much exactly this! ^^^

I watched a mess of climatologists warn society on public TV about the consequences of climate change (global warming) and explain why it was a real issue to be acting upon, way back when (my late teenage years mebbe?) and apparently we've had some inkling of it bein' an issue decades longer'n that even… Truth is stranger'n fiction, I suppose.

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by kergonath on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:38PM (#27835811)
You're right, this is a challenge. But it will happen, global warning will see to it. The earlier we do it voluntarily, the better we can accommodate the consequences of this transformation.

Also, such a transition would not be unprecedented, see for example how western societies adapted to the war efforts during WWI and WWII. These were radical changes of industrial production on a truly massive scale. The sort of things we need now.

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by junon on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:09PM (#27834683)
20 years ago would have been great. Not doing it for another 20 years would be worse.

Let's take the victories where we can.

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by rorykoehler on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:12PM (#27834724)
Considering where car manufacturers are now with their electric platforms I think 10 years from now would be ok and 5 years possible. Sometimes you just have to rip off the plaster.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by foepys on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:04PM (#27835383)
I bet all EU car makers would be very happy to do that. The only problem is: where do you get the batteries and renewable energy from?
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by adrianN on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:07PM (#27836245)
The lobbying efforts done by car makers paint a very different picture.

You get the batteries and the renewable energy by building factories that produce batteries and by building wind turbines and solar panels. It's not rocket science.

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by 0xffff2 on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:31PM (#27835723)
This is not a victory. We are already past the point where passive measures are enough. We need to take all possible passive measures immediately (i.e. within the current term of whatever political bodies are relevant), and start looking at what active measures can be safely and economically deployed. Allowing politicians to promise action in the future (i.e. beyond their current term of office) is an absolute and total defeat.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by junon on Thursday July 15, 2021 @03:10AM (#27842149)
And we've been saying this for decades, nothing happens. That's the sad reality. Any progression on this front is, in my book, a victory.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by estaseuropano on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @12:30PM (#27834947)
Easy for the Netherlands or Finland, hard for Romania, Latvia or Greece. The EU is quite diverse and individual countries will hopefully be more ambitious if they can.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by aerique on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:55PM (#27836066)
The Netherlands will not be ambitious. Our (NL) climate policies have been a dumpster fire. We're like in the bottom of the EU when it comes to that.
Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by rscoots on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @01:44PM (#27835887)
This part was always the most surprising to me. How are people expected to travel long distances individually in the future?

Wouldn't other carbon-reducing initiatives lessen the need for banning gas-powered calls altogether?

Re:EU unveils sweeping climate change plan by adrianN on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @02:09PM (#27836276)
We need to implement all carbon reducing initiatives simultaneously.

People are expected to travel long distances either by using fast charging and taking slightly longer breaks than before.