News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by cptaj on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:07PM (#27801980)
I've never understood why most millionaires don't use the money to do interesting things at all
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by burlesona on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:13PM (#27802043)
Millionaires don’t have enough money. Branson is a billionaire.

Most Millionaires do all kinds of interesting things, it’s just that those things are in the same realm that ordinary people can. Eg they go to Aspen and ski, which lots of non-millionaires do, but unlike the plebes they stay in a super high-end hotel or condo, or just buy a vacation home there if they visit often enough.

Being a millionaire, < 10M net worth, is not actually that rare or exceptional.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by cheschire on Sunday July 11, 2021 @04:24PM (#27804293)
Billionaires’ doors open like this \o/ and not like this —o—
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by brianwawok on Sunday July 11, 2021 @10:18PM (#27806251)
Three comma club
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by jfengel on Monday July 12, 2021 @01:55PM (#27813093)
8% of American adults, according to another article on HN today.

Though it didn't break that down further by age. I suspect a good number of those are retirees with significant savings (and paid-off real estate) to be spent down over the next few decades.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by nine_k on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:16PM (#27802073)
Bringing SpaceX to the first spaceflight only took about $100M, firmly in the "millionaire" range. Falcon-1 was not capable of carrying a human to space though.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by spacedcowboy on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:20PM (#27802113)
That's 100x what you need to be a millionaire. I'm a millionaire, a few times over in fact, but there's no way I'm launching a space plane.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by lifty on Sunday July 11, 2021 @03:57PM (#27804108)
Are you doing anything else interesting? Genuine question out of curiosity.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by Gravityloss on Sunday July 11, 2021 @03:58PM (#27804116)
You could probably get to single passenger VTVL flights in Armadillo / XCOR style with a few million and starting from scratch.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by nine_k on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:33PM (#27802271)
Still $100M is a literal order of magnitude away from a billionaire status, mentioned upthread.

In any case, a millionaire can technically have wealth spanning 3 orders of magnitude; no way this could be a homogeneous category regarding what's a "millionaire" is capable of financially.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by Johnny555 on Sunday July 11, 2021 @01:01PM (#27802563)
Pretty much the only person who can throw $100M at a "fun" project that may never amount to anything more than a hobby is someone at the billionaire level.

Few hundred millionaires are passionate enough about something to spend their entire fortune on it.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by KineticLensman on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:26PM (#27802190)
Technically, my wife and I are millionaires. This is a combination of the (anticipated) value of our house, our pension funds and some investments. We are retired and living comfortably but within our means.

Our funds have to last for the rest of our lives. There is no way we could suddenly use our 'wealth' to fund a 'millionaire' project.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by throwaway803453 on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:46PM (#27802408)
I have argued this point with my old married former union-employee relatives that see themselves as "poor". Combined they have a $6000/month pension. When I explain I will need to save $2M+ to achieve that income they suggest that I am just greedy/out-of-touch millionaire who should be giving more money away.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by Applejinx on Sunday July 11, 2021 @01:24PM (#27802795)
This math seems wrong. In particular, I can't tell whether your $6000/mo is meant to be interest: in which case you expect to be paid forever and die without ever touching the principal.

If you earn no interest and expect to spend $6000 a month forever without ever gaining any passive money accumulation on your principal, you'd go for 27 years before you'd spent your two million.

There are also many things you can do with your life if you have $2M (or indeed $1M) that aren't available to pensioners. I'll grant you, they've got some pretty sweet pensions: that seems unusual, but hey, collective bargaining gets better terms for workers and that certainly qualifies.

They're not poor unless they're catastrophically bad at money management, but you are indeed a little out of touch: the idea of living off the interest on your wealth is pretty insane and unattainable to any remotely normal person.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by fma on Sunday July 11, 2021 @01:49PM (#27803007)
It's called safe withdrawal rate...and usually 4% is what people use. $2 million safe withdrawal rate = $6666 per month. Not sure why you are seem to be offended and saying they are out of touch, or insane and unattainable when this is the goal for many people who wish to, and are, living financially independently.

Also I'm not sure why you say someone with $2M can achieve something that someone with $6000 pension a month can't...you can definitely borrow against your pension and grab a large lump sump...

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by ixacto on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:45PM (#27803533)
This is the clashing of two different life paths ideologies' e.g. the union/public service employee. Of course people will have opinions on this, because they will be somewhat resentful of those on the other side.

The elephant in the room is that say you have $2MM in the bank and are living off that interest, or are a retired union/public service worker and then you look at how long it took at how long it took to achieve your financial success.

If you save 1/2 of salary in VTI (say 100k-150k range) coming out of a bachelors degree and work for 10-15 years at one of the large tech companies you will have 1.5-2MM USD, which is easily enough to retire on. And you'll be like 32-37years old and still be able to climb Mt. Everest, hike the PCT or AT and probably still have your health.

However if you are a teacher starting out in California, that would be a 44-50k year range https://www.cde.ca.gov/fg/fr/sa/cefavgsalaries.asp which yes is really low. Then you work for 40 years and hopefully are able to make enough pension contributions to be able to retire at age 62 and have a decent pension of that 5-6k/mo. By this time lots of people are starting to have health issues and will not be able to go on the adventures that a 32-37y/o would be able to. Also you kinda have to work an extra 30 years.

TL;DR: Incentive structure for being a teacher is not really there, also benefits are not really there. Maybe Scandinavian countries have a better compensation and work life balance?

Incentive to work in tech industry or similar high-paying jobs is there, as financial independence is readily obtainable within 10-15 years.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by nly on Sunday July 11, 2021 @03:10PM (#27803759)
It still quite hard to achieve FI early, even on a tech salary.

I can't speak for San Fran, but I'm on a pretty good (by UK standards) tech salary in London. The cost of living (rents mostly) still make putting a high % of salary away every month a challenge. If you have kids as well, it's almost a non-starter.

The marginal tax rate means the only mechanism to do this efficiently are via pension contributions (similar to a US 401k), and these are locked until age 55 (60 by the time i get there).

Financial independence in your 30s is an enormous privilege.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by ixacto on Monday July 12, 2021 @12:53AM (#27807157)
It’s [fire in 30s] doable in the United States in any major city if you follow relatively restrictive schedule and don’t have any kids, not exactly privilege just takes a good amount of discipline.

Also salary’s are much higher and taxes are a bit lower than uk/eu. Housing is not too expensive if you rent a room for a couple years, but this is different between a 22/yo and 35/yo.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by brianwawok on Sunday July 11, 2021 @10:22PM (#27806266)
US vs UK tech pay is an entirely different game though. I’m pretty sure there is a reason most of the FI early retire guys live in the US (heck mr money mustache moved here from Canada)
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by nly on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:50PM (#27803585)
> the idea of living off the interest on your wealth is pretty insane and unattainable to any remotely normal person.

I'm not sure why you say that when this is now the dominant form of pension/retirement planning in countries like the US and the UK. People generally buy annuities with their pot, or keep it invested and go in to 'drawdown', living off the returns.

The couple with $6000/mo pension are probably guaranteed that income for life. It may even be inflation adjusted annually.

Someone aged around 60 who wants a inflation adjusted lifetime annuity here in the UK is going to start on around 2%/yr these days[0]. This isn't unreasonable given a 3% inflation expectation, 30 years of life expectancy, and 30 year UK gov gilts yielding just 1.2%[1]. So $6000/mo on equivalent terms could require a $3.6M pot

You can invest your lump sum more aggressively of course, but if you're not disciplined enough to keep withdrawals below a safe rate (widely believed to be 3-4% for a stock portfolio), and suffer a bad run of variance, you'll risk running out of money and dying in poverty.

[0] https://www.hl.co.uk/retirement/annuities/best-buy-rates

[1] https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/Bond/TMBMKGB-30Y?count...

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by gunapologist99 on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:29PM (#27803381)
If you have $1M and have it invested in a no-load S&P tracking fund (historically approx 9%, and hope you don't have a down year), then you'd have $90k/year income on the interest alone.

After taxes (long-term capital gains, let's assume the 15% or 20% bracket, unless Biden gets his wish to increase that), most likely around $13,500 (@ 15%) per year, that would be reduced to $76,500/year, which is $6,375/month.

On the other hand, if you have a "safe withdrawal rate", as fma suggested, (and which seems to be very wise to protect against down years which could permanently reduce your nest egg) then that income would be halved, requiring approximately double the initial investment to result in a $6k post-tax income.

And as far as it being "the idea of living off the interest on your wealth is pretty insane and unattainable", this is just categorically untrue; many mid- to upper-class families in the U.S. with two incomes make in the $300k to $1M range, so even if they only put away 4% to 10% in their 401(k) or other retirement plans for 30 years, they'd easily make that number.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by mlyle on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:40PM (#27803475)
Safe withdrawal rate accounts for inflation and taxation related effects, too.

If you have $1M returning 9% per year, and withdraw $90k/year, you're either going to be spending less in real money in each year -- as inflation reduces the value of $90k and the amount of tax increases each year-- or you're going to be withdrawing more each year and depleting the principal.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by Applejinx on Sunday July 11, 2021 @04:31PM (#27804346)
"to any remotely normal person'. How normal is this in the grand scheme of things? Roll a million-sided dice and select a random person: let's say, somewhere in the USA to steelman the argument. How often will you get a person in a two-income family where the incomes combine to the $300k and up range?

I'm not at all sure $300k will get you to that 'living on your interest' point in all places in the USA, either, and that makes it tougher on the argument. There are plenty of places where $300k will not let you put away a blessed thing in any retirement plan, and those are the places where people earn these 'insane' sums.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by bigyikes on Sunday July 11, 2021 @09:50PM (#27806116)
In San Francisco at least, if you make even 100k you can still make significant retirement contributions. I can’t really think of any place where you could not save up on 300k income.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by dboreham on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:10PM (#27803197)
I suspect your math didn't account for inflation.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by inglor_cz on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:22PM (#27802146)
Some interesting things are scary, though.

If I were a millionaire, I would still be afraid to try out deep diving or rock climbing, even though I greatly enjoy reading about them or watching the videos. My experience is that I will panic in certain situations and that could easily be fatal.

Just yesterday we had a thread about the famous cave rescue here. Brrr, the very idea is attractive and repulsive at the same time.

Perhaps Branson has a lower than average threshold of risk aversion.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by spfzero on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:28PM (#27802207)
Well, he did wait until the fourth flight, so he is doing some risk assessment.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by nradov on Monday July 12, 2021 @06:36AM (#27808910)
Deep scuba diving is quite safe as long as you don't push the limits. It's not even particularly expensive as long as you don't travel to luxury dive resorts.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by adamvalve on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:11PM (#27802026)
Seriously, most billionaires are so fucking boring. Imagine all the interesting things you could do. Most of them just buy homes and yachts. Who’s spending billions on a future tech iron man suit or building a utopia under the sea? Not that those are worthwhile but it would at least be interesting.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by Johnny555 on Sunday July 11, 2021 @01:09PM (#27802638)
That stuff is only interesting if you find it interesting.

I like the idea of an undersea utopia, but I don't think I'd enjoy the reality of funding and developing it enough to want to spend my fortune on it. It sounds like a lot of work and more than a full time job, you can't just throw $100M at your cause and expect it to be done in a way that meets your vision, you need to be there to oversee and guide it and make sure your money is being spent wisely. (a good example is Disney's EPCOT -- Disney's vision was to make it a real living city, after his death it was turned into just another theme park)

A home in the Mediterranean and a yacht sound much more inviting, not to mention less risky than living in an undersea habitat that I just built.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by themodelplumber on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:29PM (#27802223)
Do you happen to know most billionaires or something? Asking because this summary of "most of them just buy homes and yachts" sounds curiously like one of those straw man POVs.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by jdavis703 on Sunday July 11, 2021 @03:57PM (#27804103)
It’s quite possible that billionaires are doing low-cost, low-profile activities that fly under the radar. But for the expensive ones that leave behind accessible evidence we see them owning sports teams, sailing and yachts and purchasing art.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by jeffreyrogers on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:32PM (#27802262)
Most people are boring. Even the moderately wealthy with plenty of disposable income.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by burlesona on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:17PM (#27802082)
Most Billionaires are only Billionaires because of the value of the company they own a huge number of shares in, and they’re busy running that company which consumes all their time and energy. They also can’t cash out their shares (or at least not most of them) without risk of losing control of their company, so they don’t actually cash in on their vast wealth. Instead they’re happy to be a Billionaire on paper and “merely” live as a Millionaire.

Edit since I’m getting downvoted: yes the ultra rich can and do live off debt with their stock as collateral, but that gets you to the “merely” living a luxury lifestyle point. It’s not a viable mechanism for funding SpaceX, Blue Origin, Virgin Galactic, etc, which is the kind of “interesting stuff” this thread was talking about.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by v7p1Qbt1im on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:29PM (#27802220)
Not really. They just get loans at incredibly low interest rates, using their equity as collateral.

They can deduct dept/interest payments from taxes and never actually have to sell a lot of their stock. That way their wealth can accumulate and they don‘t really generate income. Almost like the tax code is skewed in their favor.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by jdavis703 on Sunday July 11, 2021 @03:58PM (#27804115)
How does the interest deduction work? I thought mortgage interest was the only interest people can write off their taxes.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by v7p1Qbt1im on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:34AM (#27831546)
I’m not really familiar with US tax laws tbh. But even if you can’t you would only ever need to liquidate equity to pay the interest. Only those payouts would count as income.

Maybe an accountant can chime in.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by heliodor on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:48PM (#27803568)
You too can take out a loan against some collateral and have the same tax treatment.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by v7p1Qbt1im on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @06:30AM (#27831520)
You can yeah. But you’re not gonna get anywhere near the rates/types of loans you can get as a billionaire.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by heliodor on Wednesday July 14, 2021 @11:38AM (#27834321)
The parent comment was complaining about unequal tax treatment, not about interest rates.

The interest rates aren't particularly important in this concept. Just that you have enough collateral so that you can life off the loan while the collateral appreciates in value, so that you're not forced to sell it.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by dempseye on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:36PM (#27802306)
They have the ability to borrow vast amounts against the value of their equity.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by alisonkisk on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:28PM (#27802216)
This is not true. They can sell a fraction of shares, or get loans against collateral, and have $billion of cash is to spend.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by duped on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:13PM (#27802039)
Why go to space when you can influence elections and government policy without accountability
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by nine_k on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:14PM (#27802048)
Maybe they do, but those things are not very interesting for us, or not very showy.

(Also, a millionaire is technically someone with at least $1M net worth; thanks to inflation, this title is now more accessible than ever. Just owning a semi-decent house in the Valley affords you that.)

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by Johnny555 on Sunday July 11, 2021 @01:03PM (#27802582)
Just owning a semi-decent house in the Valley affords you that.

Of course, many of those people don't really own the house, the bank does... and for many of them, their million dollar equity in their house exists only on paper.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by zeroonetwothree on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:19PM (#27802103)
Rather owning any house
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by jdavis703 on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:11PM (#27802018)
An average house in most Bay Area counties costs over $1,000,000. That’s even outside SF and Silicon Valley. Being a millionaire is hardly enough money to do interesting things that require intensive capital.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by dragonwriter on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:09PM (#27803184)
> An average house in most Bay Area counties costs over $1,000,000.

Not unless 2 (San Francisco and Santa Clara) is more than half of 9.

> That’s even outside SF and Silicon Valley.

Nope, its pretty much exactly SF and Silicon Valley.

https://cdn.nar.realtor/sites/default/files/documents/2021-q...

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by chacho on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:18PM (#27802096)
In the US. Different story in Europe or other places
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by akvadrako on Sunday July 11, 2021 @01:22PM (#27802774)
A million is not much for a flat in many major cities worldwide, but it is a lot for most places in the US.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by mbroncano on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:06PM (#27803164)
Most decently sized apartments in any major European city are in that range.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by alisonkisk on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:30PM (#27802237)
Land is expensive, not houses. Land is non depreciating, financed by loans, not substantially part of wealth. Houses are mostly under $300K depreciating consumables.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by orzig on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:14PM (#27802055)
Then you will love this documentary of an early Google engineer jumping from the edge of space in a custom suit: https://www.space.com/alan-eustace-stratospheric-skydive-fil...

His wife’s commentary is the best part

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by odiroot on Sunday July 11, 2021 @01:38PM (#27802909)
David Solomon, the CEO of Goldman Sachs is an electronic music producer.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by sobellian on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:25PM (#27802177)
There's a joke that the quickest way to become a millionaire is to be a billionaire with a rocket company. Musk certainly bucked the trend in that regard.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by dragonwriter on Sunday July 11, 2021 @02:00PM (#27803113)
Because a million dollars isn't that much money compared to the cost of interesting things.

Multibillionaires are a different story.

Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by ausudhz on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:10PM (#27802010)
Fear or loosing them all
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by xwdv on Sunday July 11, 2021 @12:43PM (#27802375)
Because being a millionaire simply is not enough to do “interesting” things. Most people in tech become millionaires around age 30. It’s not uncommon.
Re:Branson and crew reach space, return in runway landing by SeanBoocock on Sunday July 11, 2021 @01:09PM (#27802643)
No they don't? Most people in tech don't live/work in SV, or even the United States. Even for those that do work in SV, most aren't working for FAANG or elsewhere for comparable comp.