News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by teddyh on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:05PM (#27723062)
> (license violation and copyright violation are similar but not 100% the same thing)

How? Absent a license, there is nothing permitting the redistributing of software. There is no such thing as a “license violation”; if you do not fulfill the terms of the license, you have no license to distribute, and are violating copyright.

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by dataflow on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:20PM (#27724039)
One example: "If the licensing agreement states that a licensee will have to pay additional fees for use beyond the scope of the agreement, a breach of the licensing agreement on these grounds generally will be considered a breach of contract, rather than copyright infringement."

https://www.romanolaw.com/2020/01/13/is-breach-of-a-licensin...

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by teddyh on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:42PM (#27724210)
IMHO, that kind of thing is a contract, not a copyright license. And a contract is only valid if certain conditions are fulfilled, like if you signed it, if both parties are actually aware that a contract has been established, etc. (Exact conditions vary with jurisdiction.)

The main point is, you can’t be party (and bound) to a contract if you only downloaded something without the direct knowledge of the provider.

EDIT: To clarify: You are still always bound by copyright law, and always need a license to distribute. If you don’t fulfill the terms of a license you were given, then you don’t have permission to distribute, and are violating copyright if you do.

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by dataflow on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:51PM (#27724303)
You're gonna need to back that up with legal text (by which I mean a lawyer's interpretation matching yours).
Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by belorn on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:17PM (#27724550)
(Jumping into the discussion with an example)

Let's say a person buys a train ticket from A to B, let say from Brussels Airport to Brussels Central Station. The ticket states that in order to be valid, you need to pay a second fee, a special fee because this is the airport transportation route. The person refuses and goes onto the train anyway. What crime did the person commit? A ticket violation or Fare dodging?

You get a similar situation when it comes to parking. If a person has a valid parking ticket but are parking when they are cleaning the street (i.e. during a no-parking period), the violation is not a parking ticket violation. It is a parking violation, just like any other parking without permission. The fact that the person has an ticket doesn't change anything.

Breach of contract against the ticket holder is very unlikely. Breach of contract against the ticket seller is possible. In the end, the most likely outcome of a person without a valid ticket is that they get treated exactly the same as a person without a ticket at all.

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by dataflow on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:41PM (#27724735)
I can't really tell if you're agreeing or disagreeing, and I'm not even sure a ticket violation is a "crime"? But regardless, I don't understand the need to stretch analogies from other domains when there is so much case law out there specifically about EULAs. I'm pretty sure it's well-established [1] that EULAs can be enforceable contracts and breach of them can be treated as a breach of contract. This doesn't depend on there being copyright violations, e.g. there can be different licenses depending on commercial usage vs. non-commercial usage despite the copying being done in exactly the same manner. There should be no need to draw analogies from fare dodging to see what the law says here. I find countless links on this when Googling (and I'm basically leaving a different link in each comment), but see for example [1].

[1] https://www.mondaq.com/unitedstates/licensing-syndication/84...

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by belorn on Saturday July 03, 2021 @08:04PM (#27726079)
An EULA is not a copyright license, nor does it give permission. The practice of EULA comes from Shrink wrap contracts, i.e. a contract that dictate how a product is used after a person have physically bought it. The origin of those are Standard form contracts.

One major difference between copyright law and contract law is that one is defined under international agreement, and the other is defined by each nation. There is no Berne Convention for contracts and EULA's. There is no obligation between nation to recognize EULA "rights".

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by teddyh on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:55PM (#27724348)
Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by dataflow on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:58PM (#27724379)
Yeah, that's not gonna fly, sorry. I've wished the contract world worked that way, but my understanding has been it doesn't, and you're gonna need a lawyer's interpretation matching yours to back up your claim, not your own interpretation of a link to Wikipedia.
Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by teddyh on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:04PM (#27724432)
You’re being very dismissive and condescending when your link does not back up your claim either, from what I could tell.

Also, from what I understand, this kind of thing varies from place to place. You might be correct about your own situation, but not about mine.

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by dataflow on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:25PM (#27724606)
Wow. I said you need a lawyer's interpretation. You just left me a 5-second link to Wikipedia and yet I'm the one who's condescending?

I'm not going to put any more effort into my comments than you are, except I'll leave one more link in case it's helpful and leave this at that: https://toslawyer.com/are-end-user-license-agreements-enforc...

P.S.: This is obviously all about the US; if you're arguing about another country then we're speaking past each other rather pointlessly.

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by teddyh on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @10:47AM (#27749359)
Here’s a link for you:

https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/enforcing-gpl

Eben Moglen is professor of law and legal history at Columbia University Law School.

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by ivraatiems on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:58PM (#27724872)
With regards to US law, and again, IANAL, so if an attorney chimes in I'd defer to them:

"License" is a very general concept. You can give somebody "license" to do almost anything. See e. g. https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/license

"Copyright" is a specific thing that you can possess - see the definition here: https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq/definitions.html

You can therefore grant somebody license to use something over which you hold copyright. You can also grant them license to do all sorts of other things, and you can breach the license in all sorts of ways. See for instance:

https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=e4b1226a-b6b4...

My main point, though, is that simply informing CNET that they are in violation of a program's license should be enough to make them stop, in theory. You may not need a DMCA takedown to do it, though one wouldn't hurt.

> Absent a license, there is nothing permitting the redistributing of software.

That's not true, because of fair use: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use.

> if you do not fulfill the terms of the license, you have no license to distribute, and are violating copyright.

You may still have a license to distribute. You just aren't, in this case, distributing in accordance with that license. Licenses don't necessarily terminate upon violation (though they often do).

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by srtjstjsj on Saturday July 03, 2021 @08:17PM (#27726155)
Can you find one case ever where distributing an entire copyright-protected unlicensed software program was ruled fair use?
Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by ivraatiems on Saturday July 03, 2021 @08:31PM (#27726261)
Sure, though it may depend on how you define "entire program".

https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/a-short-history-of-the-fai... has a few, including Sony Computer Entm’t, Inc. v. Connectix Corp., where the entirety of the BIOS for the PlayStation was copied. I think that counts as an entire, copyright-protected, unlicensed piece of software.

I suppose one could argue the BIOS were not necessarily "redistributed", depending on how you define that term, but I think it counts. There are some other examples in there as well.