I suspect DMCA is for big companies with a legal department only.
How? If anything, the biggest complaint about the DMCA is that it has no penalties even against people acting in obviously unreasonable ways.
> I suspect DMCA is for big companies with a legal department only.
No? Looks like you just send a certified letter to the address listed at https://www.redventures.com/legal/cmg-terms-of-use.html under "Legal Complaints" and you're done.
(IANAL, of course, but nothing here seems special)
The US justice system encourages anyone with deep enough pockets to freely step over the law when their opponent can't outspend them.
Unlike the usual YouTube situations, CNET is both the online service provider and the party accused of infringing so the content can only go down if CNET agrees to take it down, or a court decides this.
So "backfire" is definitely not the right word, and "misfire" is true but not a reason to discard the best, cheapest weapon in this fight.