News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by gruez on Saturday July 03, 2021 @12:22PM (#27722713)
Bacfire how?
Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by buran77 on Saturday July 03, 2021 @01:39PM (#27723336)
Maybe misfire is a better term. The DMCA process ends up with a lawsuit if the 2 parties don't agree. This means that the submitter of the complaint has to be ready for an expensive legal battle even if they win, or can drop the whole thing.

The US justice system encourages anyone with deep enough pockets to freely step over the law when their opponent can't outspend them.

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by eli on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:18PM (#27724023)
There’s no plausible scenario where sending a DMCA notice gets you into a lawsuit you don’t want to be in.
Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by buran77 on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:41PM (#27724198)
I said nothing about "lawsuit you don’t want to be in". A DMCA claim either ends in an agreement (CNET agrees it's infringement or the submitter agrees it's not), or else the submitter has to go to court to prove their case. As I said they can of course "drop the whole thing": avoid any lawsuit but also drop the claim. Which is where the "misfire" rather than "backfire" analogy comes from.

Unlike the usual YouTube situations, CNET is both the online service provider and the party accused of infringing so the content can only go down if CNET agrees to take it down, or a court decides this.

Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by colejohnson66 on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:37PM (#27724165)
No. If CNET refuses to take it down, you (OP) could file a lawsuit, but CNET has no grounds to sue you for a DMCA notice that you are legally correct in sending.
Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by buran77 on Saturday July 03, 2021 @03:48PM (#27724269)
No to which part exactly? Nothing in "ends up with a lawsuit if the 2 parties don't agree [...] or can drop the whole thing" suggests CNET can file a lawsuit. Without an agreement the only way to take down the content is a lawsuit.
Re:Ask HN: How to stop download.cnet.com from hosting my app? by macintux on Saturday July 03, 2021 @06:05PM (#27725321)
I think the fundamental dispute is this: sure, CNET could ignore the DMCA notice, but in that case the developer is in no worse shape legally than if they don't file the notice at all.

So "backfire" is definitely not the right word, and "misfire" is true but not a reason to discard the best, cheapest weapon in this fight.