News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Friday July 02, 2021 @12:05PM (#27713279)
In the face of the alternative being "it's ok to be a dick sometimes, kids".. no. Say please.

You've not presented any kind of argument. "This is a terrible idea" .. why?

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by noduerme on Friday July 02, 2021 @07:21PM (#27718047)
I thought the arguments would be obvious to a programmer, but if you insist...

First off, everyone deserves basic respect and to be treated with dignity. Animals deserve respect and dignity as well (although we don't say "please" and "thank you" to them - I'll get to that in a moment). But you said "everything" deserves respect. That is not true.

You don't teach politeness, or manners, or anything else, as a series of actions to repeat unthinkingly. You teach by forcing them to consider the reasons for doing certain things. There are obvious reasons to be polite to other people. First of all, other people understand what "please" means. Animals don't, and computers aren't sentient. But over-archingly, the value behind treating others with respect and animals with dignity is that life has value. Degrading other living things is ultimately degrading ourselves. If we don't treat them with dignity, what can we expect in return?

Now, if you want to argue that Amazon Alexa is a sentient being worthy of polite respect, that would be a different question. But the argument against teaching a child to be respectful to a machine goes beyond just the obvious dystopian implications. The ultimate reason it's a bad idea is that like any form of obedience training that leads to irrational outcomes, it is ultimately rejected and ignored, because the logic and rules behind it were not inculcated, only the actions.

To sum up: You don't teach rules by teaching how to follow them. You teach rules by teaching why they exist, and when to apply them. A child who says "please" and "thank you" to a machine has not learned any values or learned the point of why we say those things to each other. In fact, it makes the words meaningless. If all you want is obedience and you think your kid isn't bright enough to learn when and when not to apply certain behaviors, then you can try a shotgun approach, but you won't end up with someone capable of thinking for themselves. To me, raising an autonomous person capable of making judgments about new situations is the goal of child-rearing, but then again, I'm not an authoritarian.

[edited for typos]

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Friday July 02, 2021 @07:41PM (#27718157)
> You don't teach politeness, or manners, or anything else, as a series of actions to repeat unthinkingly.

Yes you do. Everyone and everything is deserving of respect at all times, especially the ones/things you disagree with, or dislike. The same is of every thing from animals to material objects, lest they wantonly waste and/or damage stuff.

This is why _every_ democracy in the world demands their politicians act with respect to their opposition. Some honor these rules more than others, yes, before you quote some breakdown of the process somewhere.

Which renders the rest of your post pointless nonsense.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by noduerme on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:04PM (#27718270)
Political opposition is human. And there again the principle is human-to-human behavior. Do you thank your front door for unlocking? If not, does that mean you're wantonly damaging it? No. It's not sentient.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Saturday July 03, 2021 @09:05AM (#27721371)
My door doesn't speak so is incomparable to Alexa. I do treat it, and every other door I meet, with respect though.

You sure aren't shy of expending the effort to rationalize your decision to be be a baseline dick, reserving politeness for special circumstance, on the internet to strangers.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by noduerme on Saturday July 03, 2021 @05:11PM (#27724960)
So if your toaster started talking you would treat it like a person? It's not about being a baseline dick at all. I could be baseline the nicest guy you ever met. I take the time to make the point because I believe teaching unthinking compliance with senseless rules - in the guise of "respect for everything" no less - is ugly, disrespectful of thought and actually immoral. It's also highly contrary to a coder's ethos.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:37AM (#27728398)
> So if your toaster started talking you would treat it like a person?

Strawman.

> unthinking compliance with senseless

Neither unthinking nor senseless.

> ugly, disrespectful of thought and actually immoral

Absolute hogwash. What terrible reasoning you're just now coming up with.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by anoncake on Sunday July 04, 2021 @08:09AM (#27729068)
> > So if your toaster started talking you would treat it like a person?

> Strawman.

You explicitly said the difference between Alexa and a toaster is that the toast doesn't speak. It's reasonable to assume that you believe that the difference between Alexa and a toaster is that the toast doesn't speak.

> > unthinking compliance with senseless

> Neither unthinking nor senseless.

Following rules you were taught without evaluating whether they actually make sense in context is the definition of unthinking.

> Absolute hogwash. What terrible reasoning you're just now coming up with.

That is disrespectful. I'm starting to believe you don't actually understand the concept of respect.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Monday July 05, 2021 @11:51AM (#27739159)
> Following rules you were taught without evaluating whether they actually make sense in context is the definition of unthinking.

Like your rule for being polite at all times being "senseless" or "ridiculous" or any other superlative you could think of without any rational reasoning whatsoever, you mean?

Sure. I can agree with that.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Dylan16807 on Friday July 02, 2021 @04:25PM (#27716437)
There's no such thing as being a dick to a voice assistant of this type.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Friday July 02, 2021 @04:30PM (#27716493)
Ja just ignore the obvious point of mistakenly being impolite to a person, eh?
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Dylan16807 on Friday July 02, 2021 @04:50PM (#27716695)
How's that obvious? And does the rule of "be polite if it might be a person" not work?

Also it's pretty normal to phrase things less politely to close acquaintances a lot of the time, and that's not being a dick either. "Be polite all the time" is overkill.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Friday July 02, 2021 @05:03PM (#27716833)
> How's that obvious?

> Just teach them to say please to Alexa et Al. Much easier and generally better to be polite when you don't need to be, than to be impolite when you're supposed to be, by mistake.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by noduerme on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:57PM (#27718486)
What's even better is to be able to differentiate between people and computers.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:27AM (#27720179)
Which is orthoganol to the point, anyway.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by anoncake on Saturday July 03, 2021 @06:46AM (#27720678)
No, it isn't. By teaching children to treat machines like people, you teach them they are like people.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Saturday July 03, 2021 @08:56AM (#27721321)
I'm not teaching them to treat machines like people, I'm teaching them to be polite at every opportunity to be polite.

Jesus wept at how contrived you are making this.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by anoncake on Saturday July 03, 2021 @09:32AM (#27721514)
Talking to a machine is not an opportunity to be polite because you cannot actually be polite to a machine. The point of being polite is to be respectful of other's feelings. Machines have none. The only thing you can do is mimic politeness by inserting filler words like "please" and "thanks" at the appropriate, but ultimately arbitrary, times. Which isn't the right lesson to teach either.
[dead]
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by anoncake on Saturday July 03, 2021 @12:32PM (#27722799)
I, too, like selectively quoting claims while omitting the arguments behind them so I can dismiss them more easily.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by noduerme on Sunday July 04, 2021 @12:40AM (#27727263)
I started off thinking this writer was being willfully dense and trolling, but now I'm pretty sure they just can't grasp the concept. At the end of the day, it's a bit like arguing with Alexa =D
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Saturday July 03, 2021 @02:13PM (#27723595)
Yes we're all aware of that given I explained right from the start that the entire purpose of being polite to machines is to be polite always, such that one is less likely to be impolite when it actually matters. So whether or not machines are receptive of your politeness ort not use utterly and wholly immaterial to the argument.

But don't let that get in the way of your little "victory" eh?

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by klyrs on Friday July 02, 2021 @12:20PM (#27713499)
OTOH, this does highlight the "other people's children" barn door in your proposal
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Friday July 02, 2021 @02:02PM (#27714693)
Does it? You sure?

"Be polite all of the time" has certainly been a lot easier to teach my own kids than "only be polite some of the time, because being polite all of the time is a bad thing"

It goes right up there with the philosophy of every thing deserves respect, even the things you don't like.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by klyrs on Friday July 02, 2021 @02:10PM (#27714791)
You and I share these values, and that's how I teach my kid (not that we have voice assistants hanging around).

What I'm saying here is that you're teaching your values, but your values aren't universal. Other parents will teach their values, or simply set examples of behaviors that you disagree with. You can't simply solve the problem by teaching your kids. And if my experience is at all typical, your kid will also pick up values from those other people's kids.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Friday July 02, 2021 @02:44PM (#27715204)
Ah, noted and agreed.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by noduerme on Sunday July 04, 2021 @05:07AM (#27728256)
Just because it's easier to teach your kids how to conform and behave without thinking doesn't mean it's better for them, or for society, does it? The fact that it's easier probably means it's lazy and wrong.

There's no difference between telling children to always be polite to machines and telling children to always beware of foreigners. Both require obedience and shutting off critical insight. You are dehumanizing the world to them. This is why I took the time to write so many responses.