I offer the opposite argument, which is that charging you for data sourced within the same network the same as external traffic is what would be the bizarre, anti-consumer behavior. If you want force anything on the ISPs, force them to allow others to home their services directly on their network for some reasonable fee, and then treat it also as uncharged traffic.
(I'm not sure it carries the day, so debate away. It should be put out there, though.)
That's not always true. Eyeball networks are often spectrum-constrained and congested on the last mile. When a DOCSIS network becomes congested, the most common relief is a node-split, and those are very expensive.
With this issue, you're still using the network bandwidth you paid for, it's still going on the internet, but its end point is a server owned by the ISP. You are not accessing a special subnet IP - you're using internet DNS and internet infrustructure to pass this "free" data. I would even bet that if there was damage to the network and there was no direct route to the server, your packets may end up routing outside of the ISPs inrastructure.
how much cheaper is local traffic from the ISP versus traffic coming from a server 1500km away?
how much money does it cost to send internet traffic to varying distances.
there's no problem with the argument, but "much, much cheaper" doesn't mean anything in an industry where every byte can be measured and tracked.
we're not asking how much does Shaw feel like billing us today, we're asking how much does 1 Mb of data cost them to send over distance.
So roughly a penny a gigabyte as of 2011.
To take an anology from the pharmaceuticals industy, the second GB costs one cent, the first one is a fair bit more expensive.
For example... Guarantee me "unlimited" 5Mbps internet at a 20% duty cycle. That's 300GB a month. The cap is there by convention, but the internet is still "unlimited". Alternatively, give me 8640 "Bandwidth minutes" a month with the option to auto-throttle if I might go over, or disconnect for the month at 8640.
Unfortunately, most customers are in fact stupid, and a data cap is often the best way to say "We let you use our internet resources at up to NN% duty cycle per month"
Until then, stop being patronising and calling people outside of your area of expertise "stupid". It's not going to win you any arguments.
Why do you not agree with it? Is it because you feel that you have no choice in the matter, or because you think it is somehow wrong to charge for some things and not others. Once again, this is the ISP's house, and their rules. They can charge $10 billion per byte. You don't have to pay of course.
The big problem I see with this is if they deliberately slow down services like Netflix. Or if by providing their own streaming service, they are exhausting the bandwidth, thus effectively throttling services like Netflix. Otherwise, they have a natural advantage: they are transmitting data from a much closer location. Otherwise, it would be like requiring that your water company deliver you water sourced in the Alps for the same price as from your local reservoir.
EDIT: Back to data caps issues: I love them. Because now if there is any question on what I can or cannot do, there is no fuzzy wording about "appropriate network use", etc. I get 100GB a month or I do not. Anything "unlimited" is evil. My big issue is that companies like Verizon, AT&T, etc. only sell plans that are capped very low: 2GB a month is nothing for the way I use data. Give me 200GB a month and I'll pay $30-45/mo for the privilege. And while you are at it, drop the silly minutes notion. Just provide data.
This, combined with borderline draconian pricing schemes, makes for horror stories where someone had a $30/month plan and they end up getting charged $300 for using 2x their rate.
When you decide to use your hair dryer, you don't have to wonder if it's going to cost you $0.15 or $15.00. Electricity or water utilities are billed generally flat per-usage, the pricing schemes that come with bandwidth caps are not. So you paid $30 for X amount of data, which should indicate that the cost per data is $30/X, but if you use Y amount of data you have no idea what the price of it will be; it depends on your historical usage (and that of your teenage kid or neighbor who was on your open wifi or ...)
Bandwidth caps are a perfectly reasonable concept; higher usage actually does cost the company more to provide. But it is simply not the case that sending 1000 texts costs the company $10 but sending 2000 texts costs the company $100. It seems extremely likely to me that the plans are deliberately obtuse so that they can fleece customers of their money without any way of the user knowing until very far after the fact.
ISPs easily could redirect users to a page that says "You have used your quota for the month, would you like to continue at our per-byte rate of XXXX?" and block all their traffic until the user sees the page in the browser and click yes. I'm fairly certain that anyone who actually uses a capped plan would greatly prefer having the choice. They do not do this because they don't actually care about overages, they are being underhanded to trick people into using an expensive service without their knowledge.
If you are a commercial customer, you actually might. Often times big consumers will have tiered rates based on time of day or caps that trigger punitive rates when they are exceeded.
Perhaps it is just me, but I have heard many instances of people getting charged 10x as much as their base plan for data overages, and I've never heard someone complain about power overages (though I have heard people complain about getting a higher bill than they original expected because they were loose with their power usage across the whole month).
This would be true if there was competition in the marketplace, or if the internet is a substitutable good.
If Evian decided to raise the price of their bottled water to $50 a bottle, I don't have to play - there are many other brands out there. Not only that, even if all the bottled water manufacturers out there decided to price fix, I can substitute bottled water for tap water, or melted snow from my front yard, etc etc.
The internet doesn't work like that - there is no easy substitute for internet access, and in modern life is downright a necessity. Exclusivity agreements with both municipal and federal governments (exclusive operating zones/bandwidth allocation) means they own a monopoly over the market.
When you have a service that is a life necessity (or damn near it) and a monopoly, bad things happen.
The infrastructure was paid for by taxpayers.
Your libertarian logic does not apply here.
Also, it's not quite right: the tax payers did not pay for the infrastructure. The local government did, based on lobbyist pressure from the ISP. While you and are are shooting shit on HN companies like Time Warner Cable do this: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2011/05/op-ed-north-...
The ISP can charge whatever they want... unless we decide to break up their monopoly.
http://www.mrsc.org/franchises/A5o2774.pdf
See section 3.1 This town gets 5% of Comcast's subscriber revenue.
Trust me, I understand how taxes work. I also have seen how, despite great opposition from the people, the bill that basically guarantees Time Warner Cable a monopoly in NC was passes through all the hoops and not a single politician stepped up and said "WTF is this?"
This article was about Canada
So my point is that the individuals making the decision to give an ISP money, at least theoretically do not always represent your interests. This is clearly what happened with TWC in North Carolina, as mentioned in the post I linked.
Face, meet palm
No-one "labor[s] under the impression that [you] don't know how taxes work", they simply dismiss your comment, or downvote it, as someone who doesn't know what they are talking about, unless you are some kind of celebrity, which you are not.
I can think of two times in my life when, if this were the case, I would've been without internet for a very long time.
I won't accept bandwidth caps unless a) usage is determined by an open, transparent and verifiably accurate method and b) there exists an appeals process by which one can appeal erroneous cutoffs. Without that, the power inequality between ISPs and regular consumers is an invitation for abuse.
With practices like these it will become increasingly rare for startups to be able to compete with large companies because customers won't want to spend extra money to use a startup's service.
There is a distinct difference between capping a customer's traffic after a certain point (which I don't agree with either) and favoring some traffic over another.
This is bad for everyone.