News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by jerf on Friday July 15, 2011 @03:15PM (#2768665)
But some traffic is favored over others, by sheer network topology. Internet traffic costs money or peering agreements (which is ultimately just money that happens to cancel out). Traffic from the network you are currently connected to is much, much cheaper for the ISP.

I offer the opposite argument, which is that charging you for data sourced within the same network the same as external traffic is what would be the bizarre, anti-consumer behavior. If you want force anything on the ISPs, force them to allow others to home their services directly on their network for some reasonable fee, and then treat it also as uncharged traffic.

(I'm not sure it carries the day, so debate away. It should be put out there, though.)

Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by oasisbob on Friday July 15, 2011 @05:10PM (#2769115)
Traffic from the network you are currently connected to is much, much cheaper for the ISP.

That's not always true. Eyeball networks are often spectrum-constrained and congested on the last mile. When a DOCSIS network becomes congested, the most common relief is a node-split, and those are very expensive.

Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by IgorPartola on Friday July 15, 2011 @03:24PM (#2768699)
For what it's worth, often times if you rent a server, you get no charges for communicating with other servers in the same data center.
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by windsurfer on Friday July 15, 2011 @04:30PM (#2768957)
This is slightly different since the company you rent the server from is paying an ISP for internet traffic. If you don't use that bandwidth, the server company isn't charged and they pass the savings to you.

With this issue, you're still using the network bandwidth you paid for, it's still going on the internet, but its end point is a server owned by the ISP. You are not accessing a special subnet IP - you're using internet DNS and internet infrustructure to pass this "free" data. I would even bet that if there was damage to the network and there was no direct route to the server, your packets may end up routing outside of the ISPs inrastructure.

Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by ramy_d on Friday July 15, 2011 @03:30PM (#2768727)
how much money does internet traffic cost?

how much cheaper is local traffic from the ISP versus traffic coming from a server 1500km away?

how much money does it cost to send internet traffic to varying distances.

there's no problem with the argument, but "much, much cheaper" doesn't mean anything in an industry where every byte can be measured and tracked.

we're not asking how much does Shaw feel like billing us today, we're asking how much does 1 Mb of data cost them to send over distance.

Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by IgorPartola on Friday July 15, 2011 @03:35PM (#2768753)
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by ams6110 on Friday July 15, 2011 @04:43PM (#2769012)
Anyone remember posting to USENET with 'rn' and you'd get a stern lecture that your post would "cost the network hundreds or thousands of dollars" are you sure you want to do this (Y/N).
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by ramy_d on Friday July 15, 2011 @03:53PM (#2768827)
I would gladly pay per gig at that rate, and then some.
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by JamesPeterson on Friday July 15, 2011 @10:31PM (#2769935)
If you want to pay for the infrastructure and fixed costs too, go right ahead.
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by amalcon on Saturday July 16, 2011 @09:55AM (#2770755)
Remembering, of course, that it's typically 95/5 billing. So only near-peak traffic matters, but it matters a lot.
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by warfangle on Friday July 15, 2011 @03:50PM (#2768812)
So Comcast's 250gb limit costs them $2.50?
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by corin_ on Friday July 15, 2011 @05:38PM (#2769236)
Don't forget costs such as network infrastructure, staff, etc etc.

To take an anology from the pharmaceuticals industy, the second GB costs one cent, the first one is a fair bit more expensive.

Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by IgorPartola on Friday July 15, 2011 @03:58PM (#2768842)
I doubt it. This is just the cost of transmitting data from say Netflix to Comcast.
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by scottbessler on Friday July 15, 2011 @03:20PM (#2768683)
There is a lot more complication and loophole-ability in forcing ISPs to allow others to home their services than there is in forcing net neutrality in its traditional definition.
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by tybris on Friday July 15, 2011 @06:35PM (#2769404)
That's not how the Internet business model works. Receiving data is effectively free. Transit providers charge the sender for the bitrate (high for the web host, low for the web user) and a fixed fee for the connection, which you will have to pay regardless. Peering is paid for per connection and often by the web hosts who want to avoid transit and get better latency to the ISPs customers. In terms of traffic, there is effectively no difference in cost between sending traffic internally or receiving it from an external source. The reason for data caps is that ultimately networks are capacity constrained, but mostly at the last mile, not at the peering and transit links.
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by Locke1689 on Friday July 15, 2011 @06:46PM (#2769429)
This is totally false. Inter-AS traffic is often priced using bandwidth in peered connections. In a bandwidth discrepency situation one isp will usually have to pay a lot more for the inter-AS traffic.
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by tybris on Friday July 15, 2011 @06:54PM (#2769455)
Right, and that's the sender, which is what I said. Note that the amount of traffic is effectively irrelevant since the connection is supposed to be dedicated. The only reason why the amount of traffic matters is that you need to decide which side pays what.
Re:"Very bold or very dumb": data caps don't apply to ISP's ... by Locke1689 on Friday July 15, 2011 @07:13PM (#2769509)
No. Generally the agreement works like this: "we'll set up a peering agreement between us. As long as the traffic differential is within 3%, peering is free. Beyond that point, the exceeding party will pay an excess penalty of x/GB."