Google's Android Market is crippling small development teams
Out of Milk started off as a dedicated Android project as our attempt to create an application for Android phones that absolutely screamed quality. We looked at the apps currently available on Google's Market and realized that there is a lack of quality applications with dedicated developers. We have spent a lot of money and a lot of time trying to prove that Android is a robust and high-quality platform. Unfortunately, Google is making this extremely difficult.
I am a developer / co-founder of one the most popular Shopping List and Productivity applications on the Android Market. Our application is called Out of Milk (https://Market.android.com/details?id=com.capigami.outofmilk). As of right now, we are currently nearing 1 million downloads, a gigantic install base of users, and over 6000 ratings, nearly all 4-5 stars. Over the past several weeks, it is almost as if Google is working against the people contributing applications to their Market. Google is consistently releasing updates to the Market that is consistently and thoroughly making it impossible to be profitable in one of the most aggressive and fast-moving markets on the internet. I'd like to outline the bevy of issues we have been facing.
1) Statistics - Developers get to see statistics for their applications in the Developer Console which are updated regularly (usually on a daily basis). These statistics include how many downloads you have had, how many users have your application installed, how many ratings you have, and other important metrics for your application. The stats showing the total number of users who have your app installed will randomly freeze. For the past month, it's only been updated a few times due to issues with the Developer Console. At the same time this is happening, your competitors may or may not be experiencing the same issue. The stats are a factor in your apps ranking on the Market so if your stats stagnate it may give your competitor an unfair edge in the Market. Once the statistics start working again, they do not work retroactively, it just starts where it originally froze. The last time it froze for us, 3% of our install base magically disappeared because we got a ton of downloads but no installations over a 2 week period.
2) Market Search - This is the big killer. Before the updates to the Market over the past few weeks, searching for our application by its content type would consistently put us near the top of the results. I believe that this is correct due to the fact that we are extremely popular and well-reviewed. However, now when searching in our application category, we are result #227. We are consistently being beaten by hundreds of application that have 10-50 downloads, zero ratings, and absolutely no Market history. This has caused our purchases to fall from doing very well to almost getting no purchases at all. Google's Market updates are effectively making sure that Out of Milk cannot continue development due to not making enough to cover operating costs.
3) Comment Sorting - When visiting applications on the Market, the comment ratings consistently display in a very strange manner, almost as if there is no sorting at all. Instead of showing the most recent reviews that may praise us for adding a new feature or condemn us for a bug, it is displaying reviews from the beginning of the year that may or may not be relevant to the application by this point in its lifecycle. Users who visit the application and read reviews that are extremely out of date do not get a good overview of what this application is about.
4) Google Support - This is a complete joke. I am not even sure why Google is providing support at all. We contact Google on a regular basis trying to find out about our issues and how we can recover from them. If Google replies, it usually takes well over 3 days for them to reply with a canned response. After asking as to how we can fix our Market ranking results in the search and for a status update if they are working on it, the reply was, and this is almost an exact quote, "Google is always working to make the Market even better.".
The four issues I have detailed above are game breakers. How can Google expect developers to get involved in the Market if the success of their application is completely based on the whim of broken updates to their software? Out of Milk went from doing extremely well to dead in the water almost overnight. We are working as hard we can to try and figure out solutions from our own end, but Google is the guy driving this bus and we can only do so much on our own.
My advice to people who are currently looking to get into developing for Android: wait. There is absolutely no benefit to spending your time, money and effort on getting involved in the Android Market place at this time. Google is actively working to make sure that you, the developer, cannot and will not succeed in their Market. That sounds like a bald-faced lie, I know, but it is the only conclusion I can come to in this matter. Visit the support forums for Android Developers and look at the hundreds of threads about these same issues with absolutely zero replies and it all becomes a little clearer.
I mean, have you noted that almost all the applications that rank in front of you have either "shopping list", "shopping" or "list" in their titles? I bet search gives more relevance to titles than to categories/descriptions, and you are getting bitten by this. Note that "Mighty Grocery Shopping List" which is the first paid app on the shopping category ranks on the first page when searching for "shopping list".
This doesn't sound like a market problem so much as a business model issue. If one of the free apps does what people need, they won't pay for a $5.00 version, even if it's slightly prettier. Hell, a quick look at the Apple app store lists apps that range from free to $3.00. I'd suggest changing your business model.
Try in-app ads with a lower cost ad-free version (say $1). Or add features that are both extremely useful and hard to duplicate for a competitor that is working for free. Some ideas: GPS proximity alarm when passing a grocery store, or a tie in to a desktop client or website.
You completely missed the point.
He's not complaining about his business model, free competitors, or price.
He's venting his frustration with dealing with the Android Market as a developer:
1) Stats seem to keep breaking which seem to affect visibility and rank of his app.
2) Search is a problem. He went from top 10 to 200+ and with no understanding as to why that would happen - and so abruptly.
3) The comments system on Android is a mess. (sorted strangely, randomly?)
4) Google has a serious lack of good support for its developers.
I'd like to add:
5) There needs to be more game categories.
6) We want to be able to reply to comments in order to support our customers.
For ME, I want 2 things, and have been BEGGING Google for them for a year now.
1) Let me reply to comments so I can SUPPORT my customers.
2) More game categories. If there were more categories my apps in Sports would not be LOSING to chess and penguin games.
Similarly, a bug reporter/tracker in Market might discourage people from posting negative reviews to report a bug.
Google needs to step up their game, or it will stop attracting quality developers. There is so much crap on the market in the form of malicious apps and low quality 1 day development duplicates. Without the quality teams/companies contributing to the app market, Google will dig the android grave.
Well, one hoop. Settings -> Applications, click the "Unknown sources" box. I think this just disables signature checking on .apk's or something.
This isn't MUCH different from what market was not that long ago, but now that Google's market does seamless background updates, Amazon's at a bit of a disadvantage. Even updates require the user interact with the system dialog.
It's a small thing, but it does make a difference.
I expect Amazon to "fix" that with their phones coming out, since they will control the firmware. I'm actually surprised they haven't worked with ROM developers to get their market app trusted by the aftermarket ROMs, too.
You might also be interested in our developer stats, which also update daily: http://www.appbrain.com/info/developer-dashboard
Any suggestions of what you'd like to see more (if it's available for us to engineer) are welcome!
FYI, I have a new Android phone (Galaxy S2) and I would have never realized this had I not been on HN! I wonder how you can get yourself more publicity? Maybe advertise more?
good job guys!!
But #4 is baked into the Google culture and is very unlikely to change.
On #2 I've always found it crazy that Android market is an also ran in app search and discoverability -- Apple has not set the bar very high and that's supposed to be Google's forte anyway.
Gmail is great, but it's search is appalling, and it's even worse that it's coming from Google.
My bigger question is how is a $5 app that #2 in its category for paid apps struggling to be profitable (especially since I believe the top paid list are counted by installs)? All of your complaints seem to be about competing with other apps, but you seem to be mostly winning that competition. Are Android app sales so low that #2 in its category app is unprofitable?
As for the first part of your reply, trust me, I completely agree. We have done nothing for the past week except tweak our market text, change our name to various things, and so forth to figure out how to work with the new system. We are not just watching it idly and going "OH WOE IS ME!".
The problem is that it is not a level playing field. Extremely popular apps, not just ours, are appearing hundreds of results away while other extremely popular applications are staying right up in the front. It really seems kind of random. Why are some extremely popular apps in the first results, then hundreds of crappy / average apps, then more exceptional applications? It doesn't make a lot of sense.
My post is a bit of a rant, I admit, but it is also meant to be informative so that other developers can see what it means to play in the market.
for an exact search on our app we were 50 out of 50 with the other results being totally unrelated.
it seems as of yesterday they sort of fixed the problem and were ranking first for our terms. have u seen any improvement?
the last 2 weeks have been stressfull!!
I think you missed this line. Presumably they were doing quite well for themselves, got nailed by some change Google made, and now are not recouping any costs due to all the lost sales.
Sadly, bryanlarsen is correct about Google's culture, especially when it comes to the code they've written: the search code is doing what we told it to and there won't be any reconsideration of decisions made about code.
google has access to more valuable data here than they do with web searches. if the majority of users search for "shopping list" and end up installing 5 different apps, which do they usually keep installed? rank that one higher for future searches. you can't fake the number of app installs like spammers can gain junk inbound links for pagerank.
the algorithm was totally broken. luckily for most of us they started fixing it yesterday and today.
Swap to Win7Phone. You may be the only person in your category still. The developer outreach is hilariously good (Shout out to Atlanta's Glenn Gordon [Microsoft] for treating the community right).
It actually looks like I've mispelled his name:
https://twitter.com/#!/glengordon
Glen Gordon.
#3 seems like its in the new market and hopefully google will fix this problem soon because it makes no sense at all. Its def a new bug in this transition to the new market that goog is probably aware of.
#4 google support has always been horrible. try calling the android market reps in support. the more devs call and express bugs they can usually foward issues to the dev team. Also stalk people on the android team on quora/twitter/google+. this works too! tried and tested ;)
#1 stats have always been bad. they go up and down and don't work for large periods at a time. our stats froze for about 2 weeks. hopefully this doesnt effect our ranking but with the secret algorithm we will never know. luckily we use google analytics and other tracking methods to account for this.
#2 market search is prob the most stressfull thing we had to deal with. for the past two weeks nobody could find out app in the market. it simply just dissapeared. we had 1000's of downloads a day that went to under 100. this def hurt our revenue and app usage decreased due to the lack of new users. prob end up costing a couple thousand in revenue. luckily it seems like they are making an effort to fix this as today we started appearing again and the search results seem to be improving by the hour.
Is the market perfect? hell no! the android market is def bipolar and has alot of problems. For us we cant live with it cant live without it. the past couple of weeks have been crazy due to the all the problems our app was having with the search bugs, etc.
Hopefully as developers we can continue to help each other find ways to overcome the bugs and help google build a quality market. Having a market that works is def a win win situation that I'm hoping to be a part of.
On the flipside these bugs have caused me to develop IOS versions of my app which I probably woudlnt have done if these bugs didnt exist. So looking foward to try that new venue ;)
(That is a link to the 12th page of results)
Look at the applications that are ranking in front of us. As for how we show up in the category view, it bounces around - alot.
However, I rather disagree that Amazon will ever provide a panacea. The Amazon market currently poses its own problems to app sellers. Once your app is on their market, you do not control it. Amazon sets the price, Amazon sets the description and classification. If Amazon hires some marketing copy-writer to write your app's description and that person doesn't know anything about your app, guess who gets to deal with angry customers who didn't get what they were expecting? It won't be Amazon.
Amazon has had some technical hangups that be explained by 'early product bugs'. While I expect such problems to be eventually ironed out by better QA and development processes, my understanding is that they have not yet been ironed out.
Finally, the Amazon market is tiny compared to Google's. If I told you that putting your software on Amazon's market would net you 5% of the sales you get on Google's, but you'd spend just as much time fighting through problems in the market itself, would you jump on that opportunity? I probably would not.
"Google is the guy driving this bus" <-- yes, it is, it's sorta like owning a website who's only source of visitors is SEO. It's just waiting and hoping Google doesn't mess up in anyway. When you're so reliant on 1 company for your revenue, something's wrong. You shouldn't put all your eggs in 1 basket.
Maybe it's time to branch out. Explore other money making opportunities.. Maybe, just maybe building a very very good app isn't enough to build a sustainable business. Yes, it makes you proud as a developer to build an app. But we're talking about building a business.
There won't be a lack of developers developing for Android, trust me... when the audience is so huge, it doesn't matter how much friction there is. Huge companies will pay ppl tons of money to deal with the BS. They're 10+ abstraction levels away from the bullshit. They'll just tell the developer team: DEAL with it, develop this in 1 month or you're all FIRED.
Everyone, please understand the following:
We understand that putting all of your eggs in one basket is dumb. There is no success there. But when the largest portion of your market all of a sudden starts screwing with you in ways you can't figure out, that is a problem and it is something worth discussing.
Release your game on the Apple market and let us know how well you do trying to get traction or downloads there.
>We looked at the apps currently available on Google's Market and realized that there is a lack of quality applications with dedicated developers.
This is completely untrue, and stop spreading this FUD. Most developers support both platforms and there are plenty of high quality applications.
*edited to address rant of high quality apps.
Google's market problems aren't app developers responsibility to overcome just because they are 'sort of known'.
Ummm yes they are. When apple changes their policy for subscription, you either quit or adjust.. When twitter says no in stream ads to an ad company like ad.ly, they either quit or adjust, when facebook says no to an app that notifies users of changing relationship , you either quite or adjust... etc, etc.
One thing is a shift in direction from Google and another is bugs that prevents developers and users from finding apps.
On a other post you talk about marketing as if would make any difference. There's a lot of developers complaining users couldn't find their apps after they were told to look for them on the market. How would a marketing campaign solve this problem?
It's Google's duty to provide developers and users with a reliable market experience.
I disagree, if it weren't for the complains of developers and users google wouldn't fix the search algorithm like it's doing right now. If we developers didn't complain about issues with the Developer Console things would have been much worse than it is now...
If something isn't right we have the obligation to speak and not just accept it like it's a done deal and we can't do anything about it...
especially in the support forums. hes just stating the truth. i know because im experiencing the exact same thing.
Considering it's a shopping/todo list and the apple store is already filled to the brim with high quality software in that space (it's always been one of the most crowded spaces in the store), unless they have something very, very compelling to offer I can't see it do much.
If you google enough times you will find names and email and position titles(ie what areas of developer relations they handle) In fact there is a specific page listing all this stuff even..
this has seem to work for me and escalates the prob very fast! :)
I welcome his advice for other developers to wait, that means more opportunity for developers that do want to develop on the Android marketplace.
> "A lot of these issues have been known issues and if he did any sort of diligence would be fully aware of these by now"
Oh, so these are known issues now and not "his fault." Becoming "aware" of these issues doesn't make them magically go away. This issues are still on-going despite what Google's Known Issues page says. Whatever argument you are trying to make here you're doing a horrible job at it.
Second, working on any platform changes occur all the time.. example: Twitter and Facebook developers get screwed all the time, Apple just changed their subscription policy, Google changed their regular search algorithm to take down content farms.. Yes companies change their policies constantly its up to the developers to adjust or quit.
How is changing the algorithm so low quality apps are always first on the results taking down content farms? Sorry but you don't know what you're talking about....