News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by wrren on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:23AM (#27641591)
Literally no part of this comment is true. They’re not hidden and they’re not malicious.

They’re also very much required, because a user mode anti-cheat is trivially circumvented by a kernel mode cheat. The only way to defeat cheats is to wage continuous war with them, adapting to their tactics and stamping them out. It’s like collecting trash; trash will keep accumulating, your goal is to keep homes and streets clean in spite of that.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by ithinkso on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:35AM (#27641670)
Every part of that comment was true. They are rootkits with a non-hidden persona, they are not malicious unless it's worth being malicious.

I don't give trash collectors access to my bank account so that they can better estimate the amount of plastic I'm about to produce and better prepare themselves to make streets even cleaner

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by Spivak on Saturday June 26, 2021 @12:00PM (#27642966)
That’s such a weird point when people to complain about bots and cheaters in games a lot. It almost killed Fall Guys because games stopped being fun.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by jhgb on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:24AM (#27642134)
> They’re also very much required

That's a weird notion of "required". Very few things are "required", notably food and oxygen. Saying "no" to bullshit like rootkits is very easy in comparison.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by zdragnar on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:38AM (#27642238)
That's a pretty strong take. One could easily have read it as "required for the game" as in, the multiplayer experience drives the replay value of the game, ama prolific cheating destroys the community.

Of course, it still makes me avoid such games, but saying the argument is invalid because required only means air and water is absurd.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by DethNinja on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:30AM (#27642727)
As a gamedev that develops online games I have to disagree that they are required.

Whatever type of anti-cheat you want, you can implement it at server-side with today’s hardware capabilities. However, that would increase server requirements and bandwidth considerably, and as companies don’t want to pay for that they install rootkits to people’s computers.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by AndriyKunitsyn on Saturday June 26, 2021 @02:50PM (#27644712)
I’m going to be Bill Gates for a second and ask for your definition of “can”.

If you mean they can implement a fully server-side anti-cheat without compromising gameplay experience and without requiring the player to have a super-duper fiber connection with 5ms ping to the game server - no. They certainly can’t do it, not for fast-paced online shooters at least, not in this day and age.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by neatze on Saturday June 26, 2021 @02:31PM (#27644549)
While I agree with you to a large degree, from my limited perspective there is one problem with server side cheating detection, such detection would be inherently reactive (eg. it will take few cheating actions, before it is detected by service side anti-cheat) versus on client anti-cheat that is deliberate (eg. cheats can be detected before game is initialized, potentially)
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by Spivak on Saturday June 26, 2021 @12:02PM (#27642989)
And if cheating can’t be detected via statistical inference on the server inputs like texture hacks to see through walls?
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by DethNinja on Saturday June 26, 2021 @12:18PM (#27643169)
You can actually raycast at server time and only send the location of players visible to client back. So wallhacks are definitely detectable on server side, in fact one of the games I’m making uses this system, it isn’t even that expensive.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by AndriyKunitsyn on Saturday June 26, 2021 @02:58PM (#27644776)
Scenario: I step around a corner. There are enemies behind the corner which I didn’t see previously because they were hidden behind the corner for me.

Will I see enemies behind the corner instantly, or do I have to wait for round-trip time for the server to acknowledge that I stepped out of the corner and tell me where the enemies are?

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by DethNinja on Saturday June 26, 2021 @03:41PM (#27645115)
Wall scale would have to be reduced around 10% less for visibility check on the server-side, so that player view info would be sent without RTT problems especially for the cases you mention.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by AndriyKunitsyn on Saturday June 26, 2021 @06:22PM (#27646492)
This makes sense. However, what if we consider another scenario: a cheating player just staying behind the corner. He/she would have no problems receiving information about enemies behind that corner, so this would be much easier for the cheater to push the corner. Basically, the portion of the wall that you cut off for purposes of this visibility check can be considered transparent for cheaters, and opaque for legitimate players, putting legit players in disadvantage.

Can this happen in the game you make? If yes, do you consider this a vulnerability?

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by DethNinja on Sunday June 27, 2021 @12:43AM (#27648664)
It definitely can happen, it is a vulnerability but an acceptable one:

1. There is no such thing as perfect anti-cheat solution with today’s resources. Even client side rootkit based solutions can be overcome.

2. My solution completely eliminates wall hacking at 90% of the cases, same can’t be said for the rootkit anti-cheat solutions.

3. Game can be designed to put corner campers to disadvantage. But honestly no need to think extremely deep about such cases, you would first release the game then check the player complaints about wall hackers. If it is a major issue then you can implement a double ray-cast solution for most reported players, use correct size wall for their ray-casts and ban them statistically. Even if you can ban players accidentally it wouldn’t be a huge portion of your player base.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by AndriyKunitsyn on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:00AM (#27660725)
Yes, but nonetheless, we either get a solution that affects gameplay experience, like enemies popping out with a delay, or that works only partially - in a variant with reduced walls, in 100% of cases, a cheater will have a bit more time to prepare for what's around the corner.

It is true that there is no silver bullet. Anti-cheating solutions are all about compromises. Ring-0 anti-cheats are just another compromise that enable anti-cheat developers to scan for cheats efficiently, with some risk of privacy abuse added (and not as big risk as some may think - I believe Microsoft would revoke driver signatures from any anti-cheat developer that tried doing shady stuff, after which the developer would go bankrupt, most likely). This is not a compromise that most of HN would take, but I don't see a problem if users are well-informed about the risks.

False-positive bans of legitimate players can become a legal liability, especially for users that paid real money for the game.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by squeaky-clean on Saturday June 26, 2021 @02:50PM (#27644714)
This doesn't 100% fix the vulnerability. If your game has footstep sound effects the hack can detect the location of the audio sources playing footstep clips.

(I agree though that low-level anticheat also doesn't 100% solve cheating, and causes lots of problems for legitimate players. Just that cheating is always going to be a game of cat and mouse)

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by a1369209993 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @05:52PM (#27646256)
> the hack can detect the location of the audio sources playing footstep clips.

You don't need a hack for this; the whole point[0] of having footstep sound effects is that the player can detect the location of the audio sources playing footstep clips.

Edit: 0: well, and ambiance, but if your ambiance is impacting your tactical considerations, that's a game design issue in and of itself.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by xfer on Saturday June 26, 2021 @12:16PM (#27643142)
You also add a report system and do additional inference based on reports, add a system where random player review matches. When your multiplayer games become very popular and making you money, you have to put the effort in, not install rootkits on paying customers computers.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by nsgi on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:36AM (#27641680)
Or just accept the fact that you'll never completely stop people cheating? Have your server prevent obvious cheaters but maybe people should just accept that the only way to avoid people cheating against them is to only play with people they trust
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by feu on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:35AM (#27642212)
That completely destroys a whole class of games. How do you suggest I get 60 of my friends together at once for a game of Apex Legends?

You'll never completely stop people cheating, but that doesn't mean that game developers should just give up. Thankfully the people clamouring for less, rather than more, anticheat is relegated to a vocal minority.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by COGlory on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:39AM (#27642253)
When I was younger, we used to play on community servers with active moderation. That worked pretty well.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by feu on Saturday June 26, 2021 @04:42PM (#27645645)
Active moderation is still a thing now, people are just actively employed by the game companies to do that job. The cheating situation in multiplayer FPSs is generally much better now than it was back in the day I was a mod for CS:S servers.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by schmorptron on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:41AM (#27642807)
Cool, young people today prefer more competitive environments.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by slipframe on Saturday June 26, 2021 @01:43PM (#27644051)
When one of your 60 friends refuses to stop cheating, maybe stop inviting him to the party. Lots of games and lots of circles of gaming friends get on just fine without kernel-mode anti-cheat.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by feu on Saturday June 26, 2021 @04:45PM (#27645675)
You missed the point. The idea of coordinating games between 60 trusted people is ridiculous. Anti-cheat and matchmaking between untrusted players is essential in modern (FPS) gaming.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by zdkl on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:43AM (#27641752)
That wipes out any trust in public rankings and some very big games are entirely built around those. Not going to happen while competition is a major income source.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by gbrown on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:38AM (#27642239)
Then why do we still see cheats in these games? In this day and age, surely they could just use ML and human supervised cheat detection teams, and set up the incentives to make account bans more painful.

Instead, we get security theater and everything must be F2P to get the maximum number of people in the door.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by evh on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:02AM (#27642451)
Valve is working on using ML for anti-cheat but it's still quite a way from being ready.

https://win.gg/news/8115/is-ai-the-future-of-csgo's-anti-che...

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by schmorptron on Saturday June 26, 2021 @01:59PM (#27644223)
It's "ready" in the sense that it runs, analyzes every single shot in every single game played on valve matchmaking servers, and submits the suspicious ones it finds to the player-controlled overwatch system. At John McDonald's GDC talk he showed them achieving a 98%+ success rate, which while not enough to start banning people outright since any false positives are too many, is super promising.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by ta988 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:22AM (#27642659)
If I had to take a bet I would bet it will never work.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by rolph on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:05AM (#27642471)
how about

1) if you want a challenging game sign into normal game server

2) i you want a cheat game sign into cheat server

3) if you cheat on a normal server, you are banned for life no questions asked from ever using a non cheat game server

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by josephcsible on Saturday June 26, 2021 @12:40PM (#27643389)
> banned for life no questions asked

If a 13-year-old cheats at a game, do you really think they should still be banned when they're 30? Permanent punishments for things people did as minors are essentially unheard of for anything less serious than murder or rape.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by sodality2 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:17AM (#27642599)
HVH servers exist for CSGO, which are hack vs hack. It's a great alternative. The problem is Steam accounts can be generated en masse and CSGO is free.

Or accounts with the Prime upgrade that makes cheaters less common are often stolen ("cracked primes") and sold to cheaters for a few bucks.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by KingMachiavelli on Saturday June 26, 2021 @12:09PM (#27643056)
Why can't the user mode anticheat just check if any unsigned kernel mode driver's are active?

In any case, I'd argued the integrity of the OS is far more important than a game's anticheat. Game devs could ship kernel mode anticheat but user's should be at least more aware that they giving full control over to these programs.

Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by Bancakes on Saturday June 26, 2021 @09:59AM (#27641902)
Sure. Give me the denuvo anti-tamper and anti-cheat source code, and then we can negotiate.
Re:Microsoft admits to signing rootkit malware in supply-cha... by slipframe on Saturday June 26, 2021 @01:38PM (#27644004)
> They’re also very much required,

The games I play don't have these sort of anti-cheat features; the anti-cheat is handled entirely on the server side. A server admin who is attentive and ready to rollback griefs helps a lot too. But kernel-mode anticheat on the players' computers is not "very much required."

(The game I play most is minecraft, and I think it's more popular than any of the games with this sort of invasive anticheat.)