Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by bko on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:02PM
(#27632462)
> A manager sits behind a table and decides he’s going to fire a woman because he doesn’t like her skin. If he fires her because her skin is brown, we call that racism and there is legal recourse. If he fires her because her skin is female, we call that sexism and there is legal recourse. If he fires her because her skin is pockmarked and he finds her unattractive, well, we don’t talk about that much and, in most places in America, there is no legal recourse.
This is such a straw man argument. Who is this person that fires people arbitrarily? Does he not have a business to run? Does it not cost him thousands of dollars and probably a few dozen hours of his company's time hiring someone?
The only reason I could see him firing someone because of appearance is where it matters. For instance, if you let yourself go and you're in a high visibility role where it could be argued that it affects your job performance (e.g. actress, cocktail waitress)
Why do we keep discussing these arbitrary scenarios?
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by techbio on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:26PM
(#27632875)
Describing the three scenarios in parallel is a rhetorical technique to raise the question of why some are protected by law and custom, and some are not, in roughly similar outcomes.
The article links to several studies purporting to show this effect in professions that ostensibly have nothing to do with attractiveness.
I get your point. It can be (often is?) reductive to generate a protagonist/antagonist sketch and then extend its implications beyond reason. I don't quite see that happening here.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by Zababa on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:35PM
(#27633059)
> in professions that ostensibly have nothing to do with attractiveness
I can't access the article, but I think attractiveness can be a factor in many jobs. People are called "ugly" because they create a negative emotion when you look at them. Having to be around people like that is objectively a bit worse than being around regular/attractive people. It's a bit like talking to someone who's always a bit abrasive vs someone who's always a bit kind.
I do agree that compared to other forms of discrimination, there are no legal protections for these people and that maybe that should change.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by bko on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:24PM
(#27633759)
It's not clear cut in case of "ugly". The term could be defined as unpleasant to look at or be around. They could be unpleasant because of past decisions that reflect on their personal choices and attitudes. If someone is morbidly obese, they likely have an issue with over-eating. If someone is un-groomed, it likely reflects on other aspects of their personality.
So "ugliness" doesn't exist in a vacuum. And these social science studies especially around something so subjective as appearance are not reliable IMO.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by techbio on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:45PM
(#27634022)
I also tend to mistrust social sciences studies, and I'd agree that they could be any of those things. Or, the person could be an otherwise perfectly well-kempt child of alcoholics, the victim of assault, or anything else divergent from the subjective preferences of whoever calls the shots.
If you are familiar with the old HotOrNot.com or today's swipe-judgement dating apps, you can imagine some pretty large, quantitative datasets about peoples opinions of attractiveness, so I see these as plausible, without having looked into them much.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by snet0 on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:38PM
(#27633114)
It's not a strawman, it's a hypothetical. Depending on your culture, you might struggle to imagine a manager firing a black employee for their skin colour. We still have legal protections for this, though, and I'm doubtful there's much disagreement about them.
Imagine some universe where a manager fires an employee purely for their attractiveness. Is that acceptable? Like you mentioned, maybe there are justifiable cases, but should these cases not require this to be stipulated somewhere in contract?
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by naasking on Friday June 25, 2021 @03:09PM
(#27635000)
> This is such a straw man argument. Who is this person that fires people arbitrarily? Does he not have a business to run?
It's a thought experiment intended to contrast the justification for the rules we live by.
> The only reason I could see him firing someone because of appearance is where it matters.
Except statistics show that attractiveness is correlated with success in every career. The thought experiment you dismissed steps through the reasons why, say, the stats showing gender disparities are taken as evidence of sexism. There is no comparable -ism for ugliness despite the obvious parity of reasoning.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by thedailymail on Saturday June 26, 2021 @10:31AM
(#27642179)
> There is no comparable -ism for ugliness despite the obvious parity of reasoning.
The articles uses "lookism," which admittedly is nowhere near as well known as racism, sexism, etc., and is probably a non-starter as a word to build a movement on. But I guess some equivalent term will show up in the vernacular at some point (maybe along with heightism?)
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by BugsJustFindMe on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:12PM
(#27633588)
> The only reason I could see him firing someone because of appearance is where it matters. For instance, if you let yourself go and you're in a high visibility role where it could be argued that it affects your job performance (e.g. actress, cocktail waitress)
You think that an ugly person can't bring you cocktails just as competently as a pretty one? Job performance indeed.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by BugsJustFindMe on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:43PM
(#27664962)
I guess the argument there is that almighty profit justifies cynically discriminatory means? I can understand that libertarian perspective, but it's not the world that I prefer to support. "Business reasons" is sometimes code for prejudicial behavior that we would not otherwise countenance.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by edmundsauto on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:08PM
(#27633521)
Do you think that person (who fires people arbitrarily) doesn't exist for ugly people, but does for sexism/racism? Oe do you think this is a strawman argument for all 3 (ugly/sex/race)? If it's the latter, then we probably are too far apart to continue the conversation. If it's the former, then I'm really curious to know more about why.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by bko on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:18PM
(#27633659)
"Ugly" is a bit of a broad term. What does it mean? It's basically someone who is unpleasant to be around or look at. So if the person is unkempt, has physical ailments from substance abuse, doesn't practice regular grooming, or is obese, he or she would be considered "ugly". But is that an innate characteristic or manifestations of personal decisions? And where do you draw the line? Do you have a right to show up to work without showering (something Steve Jobs did at Atari and they dealt with it without laws!)
It's a lot simpler with gender and race and if someone says I don't hire race X, that's pretty clear that its morally wrong and reprehensible. But if someone expects employees to portray a certain image, then that's different. But again, in a well functioning market, you don't have this luxury. Every company I've worked for, especially the low paying ones, went to great trouble to hire qualified employees. I can't imagine one of my employers ever denying someone a position because they think they'll find someone better looking.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by edmundsauto on Friday June 25, 2021 @03:31PM
(#27635238)
There are words for these other things, so while "ugly" is a broad term, there are significant genetic components. Facial symmetry, body shape, skin color and tone.
I have been involved in hiring discussions at many companies. At the small/medium sized ones, especially startups before the #metoo world, the execs liked to explicitly talk about a persons attractiveness in the hiring stage.
It's less of a "don't hire this person for being ugly" and more of a "hire this person because they are attractive".
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by ladyattis on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:44PM
(#27634013)
I have a similar problem with being seen as not attractive and being treated poorly for it (not fired, though that's a new one to me). And I've found it really comes down to a variety of factors. Obviously, beauty is in the eye of the beholder but sometimes it gets really weird when someone can't work with you or trust you because you're not exactly well made (one eye is off, you're fat, or your voice doesn't fit your build, etc). It really gets to a point that working becomes unbearable. I don't even consider the termination aspect as a major issue. Just being able to not get brushed off while doing your work would be a huge boon for me. Luckily, I'm a software developer now but when I was younger and worked in many public facing jobs it really got annoying. But I guess my point is that societies worldwide really need to get over aesthetics when it comes to work. If I'm not applying to be a model then what I look like shouldn't matter all that much.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by ElijahLynn on Friday June 25, 2021 @07:39PM
(#27637570)
Also, watch episode 1 of 100 Humans. The experiment gives the same crime to a sampleset of non-attractive and attractive humans and has the 100 humans give them jail sentences. The non-attractive criminals (actors) get nearly twice as much jail time in this experiment.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by MeinBlutIstBlau on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:32PM
(#27633867)
If it benefits you. For example, if there are people in a specific group that you'd like to be a part of, defending the persons honor they they are condemning will not earn you points at all. I know people like to act like you can get through life being a damn saint all the time but that is such a facade. The reason the people in power are where they are is because they made fun of the right people with the "right" people. Their status grew and they could eventually form themselves how they wanted to because they had enough power to influence how others figured out who was appropriate to make fun of and such.
It's a subtle trust mechanism between people. It determines who you are and what you're willing to partake in but with minor repercussions involved if it's discovered by someone else who may care. I mean think of this, if you participated in the #metoo movement and your case did not lead to any convictions, do you seriously think anybody will not come up to that person without any trust reservations from the start? It's public knowledge you will go public with something you perceive as wrongdoing against you. So if I accidentally offend you, now I might be concerned you may use that to damage my reputation down the line.
As a former "always follow logic and be nice christian" person, you will never get anywhere butting heads with people for the sake of righteousness. You will go the way of Thomas Moore, get your head chopped off, and the world will proceed without your input interfering again.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by arkad on Friday June 25, 2021 @11:36AM
(#27632112)
Not exactly related, but some time ago I realized it's not ok to make fun of people with physical disabilities but somehow it's totally acceptable to make fun of people with lower IQ.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by caymanjim on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:22PM
(#27633734)
I think others are confusing your "lower IQ" comment to mean "people with intellectual disabilities", which I don't think you're defending. It's obvious that "stupid" people (those seen as "normal stupid") are one of the last publicly-acceptable targets of ridicule. It's common for even the most well-mannered public personalities to speak derisively and dismissively about the stupidity of others. The most common insult toward someone you disagree with is to call them "stupid" or "an idiot". No one says "retarded" in polite company anymore, but it's essentially the same thing.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by Dracophoenix on Friday June 25, 2021 @09:07PM
(#27638087)
Funny that you mention it, but at one point "mentally retarded" was a gentler term for the then rather harsh clinically-used terms "idiot", "moron", and "imbecile". Now these three words are considered much less offensive than their one-time euphemism. What a world.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by Zababa on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:29PM
(#27632941)
I don't think it is? Making fun of people that do one stupid action is I think okay, but making fun of people that have a harder life than other people because of how they're born doesn't seem okay to me.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by acuozzo on Friday June 25, 2021 @04:14PM
(#27635700)
Not OP. FWIW, I think OP isn't referring to individuals with intellectual disabilities; just those with an IQ one standard deviation down from the mean e.g. 85.
In my experience, there's often no backlash against jokes or even serious talking points about "stupid people".
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by snet0 on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:33PM
(#27633010)
>In survey after survey, beautiful people are described as trustworthy, competent, friendly, likable and intelligent, while ugly people get the opposite labels.
Does this actually provide value without being contrasted to "objective" measures? Are attractive people actually more intelligent, friendly or trustworthy? If they are, this sounds more like a useful heuristic rather than an unfair stereotype. I know I can find this research myself, but it seems weird to not even make reference to any objective measures in this context.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by inglor_cz on Friday June 25, 2021 @04:48PM
(#27636068)
> Are attractive people actually more intelligent, friendly or trustworthy?
You are getting downvoted, but this seems to be a very non-trivial question, especially if historic context is taken into account.
For example, a mere 100-150 years ago, syphilis was widespread in the population, and it often resulted in face deformities [0] and deterioration of the mind [1] at the same time. For someone living in that era, avoiding people who looked ugly and unhealthy might have been a useful heuristic.
Maybe we still use an outdated heuristic from the age of syphilis.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by snet0 on Saturday June 26, 2021 @06:06AM
(#27640632)
I think a problem with my line of reasoning is that, as a society, we don't really want to care about the objective measures. I don't pick sides in this argument, but there is an ongoing argument about things like "women have a lower population standard deviation in intelligence, so we'd expect them to be underrepresented in high-demand fields like software engineering, and low-demand fields like <politely left blank>", and the other side (ignoring those who doubt the empirical basis) just say "who cares? as a society we ought to treat people equally regardless of the hand they were dealt".
That being said, I think your analysis is correct. I think, if you removed a lot of the technology-based attractiveness (make-up, haircut etc.), attractiveness is probably just a heuristic for genetic or general health. Of course, this is an empirical statement, so I imagine it is something that could be/has been studied, I was more commenting on the fact that the article totally ignores this thinking.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by MeinBlutIstBlau on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:19PM
(#27633673)
If I had to wager a guess, it could signal that you have wealth, time, energy, apply effort into bettering yourself, and you care about things that do matter. Ugly people can reflect often that they aren't putting effort in their lives whether it comes to being fat. Genetic issues can signal basically, you have bad genes. If you see someone with down syndrome, your first instinct isn't "They are so attractive!" because it is an enormous detriment to your survival and future offspring.
It's all a show. But wisdom isn't what you know, it's knowing how to exploit what others don't to your benefit. It's not nefarious but part of the game.
Now this is clearly speculative and based off my own observations. It's significantly more nuanced than this and more than just one unconscious decision people make. It is however ingrained in us to know culturally what "success" looks like, and we meter others based on that.
Re:Why Is It OK to Be Mean to the Ugly?
by caymanjim on Friday June 25, 2021 @01:17PM
(#27633654)
The NYT isn't a single mind. It's perfectly fine to present conflicting ideas. All of us hold conflicting ideas ourselves. I don't like that I discriminate against unattractive people. I'm an unattractive person. But I still pursue attractive people for romance, and I even fall under the spell of attractive people in a professional context. Charisma/mojo/whatever you call it goes a long way, and physical attributes are a big part of it.
This is such a straw man argument. Who is this person that fires people arbitrarily? Does he not have a business to run? Does it not cost him thousands of dollars and probably a few dozen hours of his company's time hiring someone?
The only reason I could see him firing someone because of appearance is where it matters. For instance, if you let yourself go and you're in a high visibility role where it could be argued that it affects your job performance (e.g. actress, cocktail waitress)
Why do we keep discussing these arbitrary scenarios?
The article links to several studies purporting to show this effect in professions that ostensibly have nothing to do with attractiveness.
I get your point. It can be (often is?) reductive to generate a protagonist/antagonist sketch and then extend its implications beyond reason. I don't quite see that happening here.
I can't access the article, but I think attractiveness can be a factor in many jobs. People are called "ugly" because they create a negative emotion when you look at them. Having to be around people like that is objectively a bit worse than being around regular/attractive people. It's a bit like talking to someone who's always a bit abrasive vs someone who's always a bit kind.
I do agree that compared to other forms of discrimination, there are no legal protections for these people and that maybe that should change.
Discrimination against people for unalterable characteristics can affect theirs in pretty obviously damaging ways.
So "ugliness" doesn't exist in a vacuum. And these social science studies especially around something so subjective as appearance are not reliable IMO.
If you are familiar with the old HotOrNot.com or today's swipe-judgement dating apps, you can imagine some pretty large, quantitative datasets about peoples opinions of attractiveness, so I see these as plausible, without having looked into them much.
Imagine some universe where a manager fires an employee purely for their attractiveness. Is that acceptable? Like you mentioned, maybe there are justifiable cases, but should these cases not require this to be stipulated somewhere in contract?
You get stuff like this:
https://www.colorlines.com/articles/pseudoscience-black-wome...
https://www.npr.org/2018/01/09/575352051/least-desirable-how...
You could easily end up with a claim/thought process like this:
"They weren't fired because they are black. It was because they were ugly. And they were ugly because they are black. "
A bit tangental, but an interesting article nonetheless:
https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/apr/08/dark-sk...
It's a thought experiment intended to contrast the justification for the rules we live by.
> The only reason I could see him firing someone because of appearance is where it matters.
Except statistics show that attractiveness is correlated with success in every career. The thought experiment you dismissed steps through the reasons why, say, the stats showing gender disparities are taken as evidence of sexism. There is no comparable -ism for ugliness despite the obvious parity of reasoning.
The articles uses "lookism," which admittedly is nowhere near as well known as racism, sexism, etc., and is probably a non-starter as a word to build a movement on. But I guess some equivalent term will show up in the vernacular at some point (maybe along with heightism?)
You think that an ugly person can't bring you cocktails just as competently as a pretty one? Job performance indeed.
However, a fair establishment would hire for overall attractiveness, not just physically attractive.
The funny, clever, quirky, friendly, classily deferential, product knowledgeable, etc. all have aspects attractive to cocktail purchasers.
It's a lot simpler with gender and race and if someone says I don't hire race X, that's pretty clear that its morally wrong and reprehensible. But if someone expects employees to portray a certain image, then that's different. But again, in a well functioning market, you don't have this luxury. Every company I've worked for, especially the low paying ones, went to great trouble to hire qualified employees. I can't imagine one of my employers ever denying someone a position because they think they'll find someone better looking.
I have been involved in hiring discussions at many companies. At the small/medium sized ones, especially startups before the #metoo world, the execs liked to explicitly talk about a persons attractiveness in the hiring stage.
It's less of a "don't hire this person for being ugly" and more of a "hire this person because they are attractive".
It's a subtle trust mechanism between people. It determines who you are and what you're willing to partake in but with minor repercussions involved if it's discovered by someone else who may care. I mean think of this, if you participated in the #metoo movement and your case did not lead to any convictions, do you seriously think anybody will not come up to that person without any trust reservations from the start? It's public knowledge you will go public with something you perceive as wrongdoing against you. So if I accidentally offend you, now I might be concerned you may use that to damage my reputation down the line.
As a former "always follow logic and be nice christian" person, you will never get anywhere butting heads with people for the sake of righteousness. You will go the way of Thomas Moore, get your head chopped off, and the world will proceed without your input interfering again.
Here's an article explaining it further: https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/moron-idiot-im...
In my experience, there's often no backlash against jokes or even serious talking points about "stupid people".
Does this actually provide value without being contrasted to "objective" measures? Are attractive people actually more intelligent, friendly or trustworthy? If they are, this sounds more like a useful heuristic rather than an unfair stereotype. I know I can find this research myself, but it seems weird to not even make reference to any objective measures in this context.
You are getting downvoted, but this seems to be a very non-trivial question, especially if historic context is taken into account.
For example, a mere 100-150 years ago, syphilis was widespread in the population, and it often resulted in face deformities [0] and deterioration of the mind [1] at the same time. For someone living in that era, avoiding people who looked ugly and unhealthy might have been a useful heuristic.
Maybe we still use an outdated heuristic from the age of syphilis.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syphilis#Tertiary [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurosyphilis#Neuropsychiatric
That being said, I think your analysis is correct. I think, if you removed a lot of the technology-based attractiveness (make-up, haircut etc.), attractiveness is probably just a heuristic for genetic or general health. Of course, this is an empirical statement, so I imagine it is something that could be/has been studied, I was more commenting on the fact that the article totally ignores this thinking.
It's all a show. But wisdom isn't what you know, it's knowing how to exploit what others don't to your benefit. It's not nefarious but part of the game.
Now this is clearly speculative and based off my own observations. It's significantly more nuanced than this and more than just one unconscious decision people make. It is however ingrained in us to know culturally what "success" looks like, and we meter others based on that.
Is it ok? No. Check.
Does it happen anyway? Apparently yes.
I think it raises interesting questions about human nature and society.