You may or may not have a private civil tort against the medical provider, separately from HIPAA.
I consider intentional breaches of medical privacy to be in the same league as physical assault and as such would expect a society to respond to these kinds of crimes with swift and severe punishments including jail time and fines.
Why not just arrest these people and take the profits from their crime instead of adding civil lawyers and bureaucracy to the mix?
Can you point to any country with a law on the books like this?
But of course that's not what TFA was about.
[0] https://inspiredelearning.com/blog/hipaa-101-guide-violation...
Right, there are criminal penalties possible under HIPAA (I don't know if anyone has actually gone to jail under them) but they explicitly don't apply to the situation I was replying to (or I misunderstood it).
I specifically linked to an injury lawyer to show the types of current HIPAA violation civil suits that have succeeded. My reasoning is that it’s lucrative enough for lawyers to solicit business.
Disclaimer: I work for a company that uses this data to match terminally ill patients with niche treatments and clinical trials, and the work literally saves and prolongs lives.
Talked with a company that made similar claims about what they are doing, but it turns out they were really ensuring that their users where choosing the medication from the highest bidder rather than the one that was really in the the patient's best interests.
The mental gymnastics they did to justify they were doing what was in the patient's best interests was fun to observe, but in the end they were just a tool of a large pharmaceutical company, exploiting sick people for profit.
Quick cynicism sanity check: who pays your company, your users or the "niche" treatment provider?
If it's the former, that sounds like it's good work.
If it's the latter I would recommend being a bit more skeptical of the business motives of your employer and their customers.
Insurers. They don’t want to pay for the expensive product.
Of course, not only is it distinctly possible to contribute to society and make a profit—it’s basically the only way. In the real world loads of researchers and engineers and other employees aren’t going to work for free to appease random Internet cynics (who rarely if ever make positive contributions to society of their own, mind you), so capital is required which entails investors and returns on investment. Yeah, that means insurers or someone else paying money.
Marketing drugs better isn’t exactly saving lives. Researching drugs should be done through IRB and include patient consent. Of course, there’s great benefit to bypassing ethical controls, but they are still worthwhile.
I have literally yet to see a medical-adjacent company not default to assuming they’re on the moral high ground.
When I see companies say “we save lives” my initial reaction is no different from companies that say “we hire the best” or laws that “are for the children”.
Maps Street View of 1428 Bush St, San Francisco is more of what I have in mind. But maybe I’ve just passed that building one too many times.
It's surprisingly hard, which is why there is a cottage industry built up around it for clinical trials.
Regardless, getting informed consent for data acquisition is great if you are doing a clinical trial or really looking forward, but for a lot of things you want a ton of retrospective data that can be difficult or impossible to consent.
It's a hard problem. I hope in the future it will be an easy problem, but we aren't there.
I hope for all our sakes you are in the business of buying de-identified medical data :)
The Expert Determination data would likely be released to you with an agreement that you would not attempt to re-identify the data. So if you then attempted to re-identify the data, even yourself, you would be breaking the terms of the license and I would think liable to civil action from the entity that gave you the data (and their upstreams). I don't think you would win here.
Conflict of interest regulations should be applied for data, If my data can be used to cause harm to me then you shouldn't have it that's all.
I’m not sure how to defend against this as it seems based on HIPAA and what it allows. Since de-identified data can be legally sold, I think it will.
The theoretical defense I’ve thought up is a class action lawsuit for synthetic breaches. Since these data are deemed de-identified by expert determination [0] and that’s hazy, if I could reidentify myself after de-id, and I didn’t authorize it, then I could be eligible for breach damages for HIPAA violations up to $50k per person [1].
Since these sets have millions of people, likely everyone in the country. And since expert determination can possibly classify an acceptable re-id risk as less than 1%, this could be a million or two people. So a big enough pool to attract big legal investments.
That would increase the cost and risk of doing this to outweigh the benefits. But currently it’s “free money” for any healthcare system that’s kind of impossible for me as a patient to opt out.
[0] https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/special-... [1] https://www.injuryclaimcoach.com/hipaa-violations.html