News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by esja on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:43AM (#27603303)
Most people have no idea just how massive the biological advantage is. Movies and popular culture have conditioned people to think that females can hold their own against men. Individuals can, in some contexts, where the statistical distribution overlaps. For example a mediocre middle aged man can be beaten in strength or speed sports by an athletic 20-something woman. But at the tails of the distribution, where the competitions occur, the advantages of the Y chromosome and male puberty are insurmountable.

Just look at these female world records compared to 13-15 year old high school boys: https://boysvswomen.com/#/world-record

Hubbard is also 43 years old. There is no precedent for any human female being competitive in this sport at this age, not even the most freakishly talented female weightlifters in history, not even the Soviet drug cheats.

Kuinini Manumua, the Tongan woman who would have been given this place if not for Hubbard, is 21 years old.

Feagaiga Stowers, who placed second behind Hubbard in the Pacific Games in her native Samoa in 2018, is 20 years old.

This problem cannot be solved or even properly discussed without properly acknowledging biological reality.

This disparity is why women fought so hard for sex-based separation in the first place. I cannot understand why we would roll back those protections by considering “gender” equivalent to sex. It can only hurt women.

[dead]
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by kQq9oHeAz6wLLS on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @09:43AM (#27604489)
There will always be edge cases, and they should be addressed on an individual basis. Changing the rules that affect 99% of the athletes to benefit the 1% edge cases doesn't make sense.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by zaarn on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:50AM (#27605180)
Why not find a set of rules that works for 100% of people instead of leaving out the 1% for no other reason than "we have to continue with the rules we established as tradition".
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by alisonkisk on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:55AM (#27605257)
Because there are no such rules. It's a competition. Only a few people can win, and any rules are biased.

If you rolled back the clock and tried again, Michael Phelps would never be a champion weightlifter, and the best weightlifter would never be a champion swimmer.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by zaarn on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:59AM (#27605313)
There are in fact rules.

Currently for olympic distance running at 400 meters or further, a female must present with a certain maximum level of testosterone. This rule was specifically made to exclude an intersex female-presenting runner who excelled. Due to medical complications, she cannot take medication to surpress her testosterone levels on a long term basis.

So yes, such rules exist.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by jjk166 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @02:04PM (#27607805)
And a boxer who for medical reasons can not reduce their weight to a lower weight category just competes in the higher weight category. It shouldn't matter why you exceed a certain threshold, so long as the thresholds are consistent and relevant you should compete in your category.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by flippinburgers on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:05AM (#27604698)
This what-about mentality that fragments the population into increasingly small groups while expecting everyone else to adhere needs a course correction.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by zaarn on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:49AM (#27605175)
I don't want to fragment, I want these people to be recognized as what they identify; women. Even if they don't have the right chromosomes, there is atleast a dozen reasons someone might still have grown up as female or identifies female.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by alentist on Thursday June 24, 2021 @12:03AM (#27613857)
Do you feel the same way about race?
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by zaarn on Thursday June 24, 2021 @01:05AM (#27614141)
What does this have to do with race?
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by alentist on Thursday June 24, 2021 @02:51AM (#27614659)
> I want these people to be recognized as what they identify; women. Even if they don't have the right chromosomes, there is atleast a dozen reasons someone might still have grown up as female or identifies female.

Replace gender with race. Do you feel the same way about race?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by zaarn on Thursday June 24, 2021 @03:33AM (#27614869)
Well, I didn't know that race is determined by your chromosomes. TIL I guess. And I don't see how someone would identify as black if they aren't, it's a melatin level in the skin.

The issues about race have less to do with the issues about transgender people, and more with their struggles faced by fault of modern society, in addition to the struggles one would face as transgender and/or female, which can intersect quite badly.

I'm honestly astounded that HN apparently doesn't have any idea about intersectional discourse in the slightest, should be pretty obvious stuff.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by selimthegrim on Sunday June 27, 2021 @09:59AM (#27651611)
You do realize there are descendants of black people with fair skin that look almost European otherwise but identify with their ancestors kept down under segregation?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._K._Butterfield

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by zaarn on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:43AM (#27658197)
Yes, I know about edge cases, but I think it's fair to count that as a cultural association with their ancestors over them being PoC.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by alentist on Thursday June 24, 2021 @08:22PM (#27625641)
> Well, I didn't know that race is determined by your chromosomes. TIL I guess.

Is that sarcasm? Do you know what chromosomes are?

> And I don't see how someone would identify as black if they aren't

By simply claiming they do. Is that not the criterion you're using for gender?

"I don't see how someone would identify as female if they aren't."

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by zaarn on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:44AM (#27658201)
>By simply claiming they do. Is that not the criterion you're using for gender?

And you still fail to see the difference between gender and sex and how that is different from culture and skin color. Congratulations.

>Is that sarcasm? Do you know what chromosomes are?

I didn't skip Biology 101.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by alentist on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:43AM (#27658501)
So your position is that a person is female simply by virtue of claiming that they "identify as" female. Is a person black simply by virtue of claiming that they "identify as" black?

> I didn't skip Biology 101.

Looks like you did. Chromosomes carry the genome.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by zaarn on Monday June 28, 2021 @06:08AM (#27659891)
I am aware Chromosomes carry the genome, but leading the question is not quite fair as well. Since sex and gender were topics, it was well evident that I was talking about Chromosomal differences between humans, NOT gene-level differences.

It looks like you skipped out on Biology 101, otherwise the difference would be clear in context and upon my elaboration.

Good day.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by alentist on Monday June 28, 2021 @02:10PM (#27665407)
> I was talking about Chromosomal differences between humans, NOT gene-level differences.

Since the former includes the latter, your excuse makes zero sense. It sounds like a convoluted attempt to obfuscate the fact that you thought "chromosomes" was synonymous with "allosomes".

> It looks like you skipped out on Biology 101

How so? This is a weird projection. You're the one who clearly didn't know what chromosomes are.

Finally, you still haven't answered the question: Is a person black simply by virtue of claiming that they "identify as" black?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by stnmtn on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @02:50PM (#27608466)
I fully believe trans women are women, but I'm genuinely curious as to what the feminist response to stuff like these competitions should be when it's clear that trans women have a distinct and irrerperable advantage over biological women.

What potential problems would there be from having a biological women competition, and a trans women competition? Genuinely curious as to your answer and I am asking this in good faith

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by zaarn on Thursday June 24, 2021 @01:31AM (#27614276)
And what is the response that people who undergo female hormone treatments will have a distinct disadvantage over men who've not done that? Should they have to continue in a field they have this disadvantage in?
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by dirtyid on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @01:19PM (#27607126)
2 divisions:

XX only division.

Unlimited division for everyone else.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by alisonkisk on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:52AM (#27605213)
Why should women's championships even exist? Isn't that just a pity prize? Either design a game where women tend to perform better (like certain forms of gymnastics) or where they tend to be more interested due to the cultural aspects (like cheer/dance), or let women compete in other areas of endeavor.

Why have leagues for women in basketball but not "men under 6ft tall"?

Is it to encourage girls and women to be physically active for a health life? If so, so we need competition for that? (I'd say no -- boys and men who aren't eite talent are also pushed out by the focus on competition)

Now if people like women sports due to the style of play in WNBA or Women's soccer or whatever, that's great; just make the rules and marketing and such to promote that style, and women will tend to be the participants.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by bagacrap on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:15AM (#27605479)
This post is generally ridiculous, but I will point out that we do have weight categories for boxing. I suppose we don't have height categories for basketball because no one wants to watch that.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ajuc on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:30AM (#27605662)
> I suppose we don't have height categories for basketball because no one wants to watch that.

I would. Then it would be more about skill than strength and height, like football.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:41PM (#27612018)
IIRC in the early days basketball teams had a maximum average height, which I think might be neat to bring back.

If you want a giant on your team, you'd need to balance him out by recruiting an exceptionally talented shorter guy.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by golergka on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:42AM (#27605812)
But wouldn't you, in a 160-180cm bracket, for example, end up with nearly all players being 178-180cm? And then 158-160cm for the next one. Imagine what drama would happen if a promising teenage athlete would not stop growing at 159 and got 2 extra centimetres, for example: he would completely lose his shot to be a professional. People can adjust their weight with a diet, but they can't really change their height.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ajuc on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:46AM (#27605861)
3 cm isn't that much of a deal. 20 cm is.

And if 10 cm categories are too wide they can be adjusted to 5 cm.

I would actually change the rules in olympic basketball to have 1 player from each category :)

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by void_mint on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:49AM (#27605908)
It’s already this way. It hasn’t been “about” height in a long time. The best players in the league aren’t the tallest by a long shot. Steph Curry is 6’4.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ajuc on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:53AM (#27605952)
This is the distribution apparently: https://i.imgur.com/v0QRyDr.png

Average is at 200 cm compared to 175 cm in general adult male US population:)

Compare this to football: http://www.twolfanger.de/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/Average-...

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by void_mint on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @12:27PM (#27606364)
Not sure what your point is?

The argument presented was that height mattered more than skill. If that were true, the tallest players would also be the best, no? Instead, very clearly, the best players are usually _not_ the tallest, sometimes not even close.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ajuc on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @01:08PM (#27606953)
My point is that height clearly matters more.

It doesn't mean that skill doesn't matter at all.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by void_mint on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @01:25PM (#27607232)
> My point is that height clearly matters more.

Sorry, in what way is that clear? The best players aren't the tallest, so isn't it clear that your statement is false?

The attribute that defines success is skill, not height, which is evidenced by a look at the most successful NBA players.

You're saying "Because NBA players are taller than average, tall = success", which is just not really true.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ajuc on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @02:09PM (#27607892)
This is a very simplistic understanding of statistics. Basketball success doesn't need to be correlated linearly with height for it to be the single most important factor.

In fact it's pretty obvious there would be a tipping point because extreme height is inversely correlated with health and mobility.

In similar fashion weight matters more than skill in boxing that's why we have weight categories. 120 kg boxer will win over 80 kg boxer 90% of the time or more assuming basic competency. But it doesn't mean that the most obese person in the world would be the best boxer.

And the correlation is even more obvious with basketball than with boxing which you can see comparing the height distribution in basketball with height distribution in adult male population [1]. Average for basketball is higher than 97th percentile for general population. That's not an accident :)

If skill is more important than height where are the 160 cm basketball players? None of them got enough skill?

In soccer 2 players widely recognized as the best in last decade are 170 and 187 cm. Different sides of the general height average.

In basketball this histogram for ALL professional players STARTS at the general average (5'9).

[1] https://www2.census.gov/library/publications/2010/compendia/...

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by void_mint on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @02:26PM (#27608158)
If your argument is "Height of a random person decides whether they could be an NBA player", that statement is incorrect.

If your argument is "Height of an NBA player is the most significant factor in determining their success", that statement is also incorrect.

> In similar fashion weight matters more than skill in boxing that's why we have weight categories

A 220 lb boxer is more capable of knocking out a 140 lb boxer, yes. A 6'10 basketball player is not more capable of outperforming a 6'3 basketball player. Also using single-player sports as a comparison to team sports is a waste of time and energy.

Skill is the determining factor. Not height.

I'll say, it really really seems like you don't know about/watch/care about _actual_ professional basketball. In which case, maybe you shouldn't just guess your way through a conversation about professional basketball?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by cko on Thursday June 24, 2021 @06:43AM (#27615898)
I have to weigh in on this.

Based on my observations, on offense (and in a team situation), skill trumps height.

On defense, there's no way a much shorter player can reliably guard a taller player. And definitely not one on one. I've watched many one on one clips and thought 'wow size is everything.'

Sure, Steph Curry is probably the most skilled player in the league. But do you think a team with five Steph Currys can beat a team with, say, five Paul Georges? I'm not so sure.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by void_mint on Thursday June 24, 2021 @12:39PM (#27620101)
One on One is again not really a worthwhile topic given that's not how basketball is played at high levels.

> there's no way a much shorter player can reliably guard a taller player.

Just flatout false. Clint Capela isn't the tallest center in the NBA but is an absolutely dominant defensive player. It's not about guarding all five players on the other team, it's about winning your matchup and providing help. In both scenarios, height isn't the most important thing at all. Jrue Holiday is also an elite defender but isn't very tall at all.

Height is a red herring; sometimes height can be used as a proxy in place of skill. The thing about elite levels of play, is that the skill level is so high that you can't really get away with lacking skill.

> Sure, Steph Curry is probably the most skilled player in the league. But do you think a team with five Steph Currys can beat a team with, say, five Paul Georges? I'm not so sure.

Steph's ability to set picks and create mismatches isn't nearly as good as his ability to use picks and exploit mismatches. Steph's playstyle is enabled by a totally different archetype of player. PG is a more "complete" offensive and defensive player.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @12:04PM (#27606097)
Pun intended? If so, nicely done.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by names_are_hard on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @01:26PM (#27607250)
> because no one wants to watch that.

So... like the WNBA?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by faeriechangling on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:30PM (#27608941)
For the same reason that weight classes exist and cause people to pay millions and millions to watch Floyd Mayweather box when a super heavyweight could pound him into pulp.

It allows more people to compete in sport.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by raffraffraff on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:22PM (#27608851)
Why should they exist? Sounds to me like you're suggesting that female people should be forbidden from organising their own sporting competitions unless it's mudwrestling, foxy boxing and such-and-such (to quote Homer Simpson).