News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by CodeGlitch on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:13AM (#27601687)
But it doesn't change your skeletal structure, or the size of your lungs. Both of which dramatically affect your performance.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by prox on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @04:52AM (#27602314)
I think the core question is, does Hubbard have an advantage so she will win 95% of the time? If so, it’s not really a competition, especially if that result derives from her innate male physiology giving her an unfair advantage. We don’t allow doping either.

If there is a way to level it out, that might be a solution, if it’s possible.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ivanbakel on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:02AM (#27602367)
>I think the core question is, does Hubbard have an advantage so she will win 95% of the time? If so, it’s not really a competition, especially if that result derives from her innate ... physiology giving her an unfair advantage.

But this is true of lots of sports. Most recently, Simone Biles was punished by scoring judges for a gymnastic move that only she is able to perform, due to her height and musculature. "Genetic freaks" who train hard but still have an unalterable physical advantage tend to dominate any individual sport, to the detriment of their competitors - what makes Hubbard different?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by buran77 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:01AM (#27603055)
While it's hard to draw a precise line, there's a clear difference between having some genetic features that give you an advantage, and having most genetic features that give you an advantage.

Growing up under the influence of male genetics and hormones gives an individual a massive advantage in such a sport, that simply cannot be compensated for or against with just training or medical solutions. There's nothing that will take that edge away from such an individual because human intervention later in life can't entirely undo the course nature took when building that body.

The evidence is in the performance which falls squarely in line with male performance [0].

And to everyone thinking of a parallel with motorsports and whatnot, there is none. Those sports rely on technology developed by humans so anything is entirely reproducible and reversible. Nature on the other hand still does things that we don't understand, can't reproduce, or can't fully compensate for. We have no way to change the gender with all the associated factors so we focus on the critical and obvious ones like physical look and hormonal balance, which get a person 95% there. But when it comes to peak performance the 5% makes a difference and it's clearly an unfair one to every other participant.

[0] https://i.redd.it/vv4ws1848t671.jpg

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by dagw on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:26AM (#27603629)
The evidence is in the performance which falls squarely in line with male performance

The article seems to make clear that while she is in the top 10, she's not in the top 3 and is in no way a favorite to win. So I'm not sure what that graph is supposed to be showing.

Two women in this weight class have scored a 300+ in competition while Hubbard's best is a 285 from 2019.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by buran77 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:02AM (#27605348)
It's supposed to say that she's exhibiting typical male level performance, which happens to be substantially above typical female performance at that level. This means she's taking full advantage of a body which developed and trained as male for 35 years to get ahead of women who have to rely "only" on training.

You wouldn't let an adult compete in a junior competition because they feel young at heart. You wouldn't let someone compete while on performance enhancing drugs just because they needed them. You would ban athletes who who are repeatedly caught using steroids because it's well known they provide an unfair advantage even years later. And that absolutely pales in comparison to having a trained male body in a women's weightlifting competition.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ivanbakel on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:30AM (#27605663)
Equally, you wouldn't ban a child from a junior competition just because they were able to achieve an adult's performance out of "fairness" to the other children. Hubbard may have a physical advantage over cis women - but lots of athletes have physical advantages over each other. What is different about the kind of advantage you might obtain by being trans?

Also, comparing a trans woman to someone who "feels young at heart" is a false equivalence, and an offensive one. One is an identity, the other is not.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by buran77 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @02:48PM (#27608451)
If you read the very first line of the first comment I made above [0] you'll see why the "but some are better than others" is a very unrealistic and uncharitable take on the topic. The whole reason we have separated men and women trials in almost every sport is that the difference between men and women goes far beyond "lots of athletes have an advantage over each other". Having a male body for 35 years is much more than your average advantage.

You decided let your personal sensibilities get in the way of understanding my arguments that are much stronger than anything you presented. Sports aren't about gender identity but about sex. As entitled as any individual is to decide on a body that reflects their identity, their biological sex is still very much unchanged. And so are the advantages years of being a male provide.

As you can see from actual athletes, this situation is offensive for those women who after a lifetime of training and hard work see themselves competing against effectively a biological male body with a massive advantage that dwarfs even years of performance enhancing drugs would give.

And to your last point, saying gender identity is OK, age identity is not [1], and that it's OK to identify as a different gender or even no gender at all but anything else is not acceptable is grossly hypocritical and might be as ignorant as people were 50 years ago about gender related topics. Time will tell. I honestly do not feel like my age, and do not identify with that number but rather with a much younger age for many of the reasons you can read in the article linked. This being said, even if the law allowed me to change the number either way, I would not consider this to be a valid differentiator for sports.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27603055

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/nov/08/dutch-man-69-s...

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by CRConrad on Saturday June 26, 2021 @06:56PM (#27646775)
> Also, comparing a trans woman to someone who "feels young at heart" is a false equivalence,

How, exactly?

> and an offensive one.

Proof?

> One is an identity, the other is not.

And then we're back to the very first comment, "sex not gender": Sports are categorised into male and female by biology, not identity.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by mensetmanusman on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @02:39PM (#27608329)
Your last point is one that people don’t agree on though, which makes the topic challenging.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by prestigious on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:23AM (#27604881)
I think the point is they took the spot from somebody who deserves to represent their country in Olympic competition and they aren’t even likely to win.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by belorn on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @06:37PM (#27611440)
Just to take one example of a genetic feature in the wild, there is a gene receptor which if you have the right mutation will cause an 25-50% increase in oxygen carrying capacity of red blood cells. Some people call it a naturally occurring blood doping.

The definition of fairness is difficult when dealing with even single genetic features.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by faeriechangling on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:42PM (#27609087)
I feel something being overlooked is the fact that it's relatively easy to dope without detection when your natural state is "doping" when weightlifting is one of the dirtiest sports out there.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ivanbakel on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:07AM (#27603479)
> While it's hard to draw a precise line, there's a clear difference between having some genetic features that give you an advantage, and having most genetic features that give you an advantage.

I don't see the clear difference. In what qualitative sense does Hubbard's genetic advantage differ from the genetic advantage of any athlete at the top of their sport? There are many competitions which are dominated by one individual, regardless of the training or medical help which every other competitor can afford. Should those people be excluded from competing for reasons of fairness?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by prox on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:22AM (#27602487)
Yeah, so is it unfair? Simone Biles has a genetic advantage, something she probably didn’t have any control over or influence in.

Hubbard does, to some extend?

In Formula 1, Mercedes has dominated for the last 7 years or so. Is money their unfair advantage? Or is Hamilton just that good? It did make for a less attractive sport, if you already kind of know who will win.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by t_sawyer on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:16AM (#27603555)
Except... gymnastics won't end up being dominated by a bunch of people like Simone Biles.

Female sports will continue to be dominated by biological males if we continue to let this happen.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ivanbakel on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:26AM (#27605624)
So? What would be the downside of trans women dominating womens' sports, if that were even the eventuality?
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by llimos on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:49AM (#27605909)
The downside is that the whole point of having women's sports was to give women a chance to win, which they would usually be unable to. What you are suggesting will again put biological women in the position where they cannot win. So you have defeated the whole purpose.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ivanbakel on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @12:01PM (#27606053)
>What you are suggesting will again put biological women in the position where they cannot win.

We should remember that most cis women cannot compete at an Olympic level anyways. That's the point I'm trying to make in this thread - physical outliers are already responsible for lots of non-competitions at the top level of many sports.

Every athlete with a physical advantage precludes some other athlete from the top of the competition. If the "point" of womens' leagues is to provide a level playing field for cis women, then maybe we should be more open to introducing level playing fields more generally - because there are large parts of the population that cannot win in the system we already have, either. Otherwise, the "point" of womens' leagues is just to provide a space for women to compete, and trans women should be allowed in those spaces.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by unrealhoang on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @12:56PM (#27606754)
Because what you are suggesting will not only affect the top level, every single other level below will face the exact same situation. Genetically normal with determination female are still winning and trying at championship, scholarship, etc.. Let crush that because they are genetically inferior from a mediocre biological male right?

The point of male/female separation is to protect biological female from the genetic advantages of biological male, not from genetic outliers.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by llimos on Thursday June 24, 2021 @07:33AM (#27616160)
> the "point" of womens' leagues is just to provide a space for women to compete, and trans women should be allowed in those spaces.

This is patently false. In sports such as archery (which is an Olympic sport), where strength does not provide an advantage, men and women do compete together. So it's clearly not about providing a "space" for women to compete.

And in weightlifting, the subject at hand, all competitors are on their own, they might never be in the same room as each other. So again, what is this "space for women to compete"? It's clearly about the physical advantages of the sex, and I can't believe we're even having this discussion.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by CRConrad on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:07PM (#27646841)
> So? What would be the downside of trans women dominating womens' sports, if that were even the eventuality?

That non-trans women have no fucking chance of being champions in pretty much any sports at all anymore, obviously. You're bending over backwards to be "fair" to a tiny minority, and not giving a shit that in order to do that you're being as utterly unfair as one could possibly be to half of humanity. The much eaasier solution, if you want people born as males to hold all the records, is to just simply abolish womens' sports altogether.

Honestly, this question is so horrendously disingenious that I'm shocked you even had the gall to ask it.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by orestarod on Thursday June 24, 2021 @02:37PM (#27622009)
Does one have to undergo surgery and hormonal therapy to be a trans woman?

Can one change their mind about whether they are a man or a woman whenever they want?

Which is the third party who should have the right to judge if you are a man or a woman?

Can a male self identify as a female when they wish and enter a women competition?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by llimos on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:26AM (#27603628)
The big difference is that these are genetic differences that already have a separate category, to compete against others with those same genetic differences.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by rocqua on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @06:14AM (#27602786)
Are there any examples of this worry about "genetic freaks" in non-women categories? It seems much less relevant to me in a category where everyone can enter than one that is restricted to a subset to give that subset 'fair' competition.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ivanbakel on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:02AM (#27603442)
>Are there any examples of this worry about "genetic freaks" in non-women categories?

There are lots of examples at the Olympic level, some of which can be found elsewhere in this thread. Usain Bolt and Michael Phelps are probably the most well-known recent cases - both dedicated athletes who also had some physical quirk which helped to ensure that they totally dominated their respective sport for the period that they were in their physical primes.

To be clear, the point is that nobody is "worried" about genetic outliers in mens' sports. If you were unlucky enough to be competing in a national Olympic swim team at the same time as peak-fitness Phelps, you were expected to suck it up and accept that you very likely had no chance of getting a gold medal. A great deal is made out of training and mentality, but at the end of the day, physicality is still a big silent factor in these competitions that the athletes simply have no control over.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by chopin on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:54AM (#27603376)
Not directly related to your question but we have weight classes in certain sports. This levels out at least some of genetic advantages.

I always found it odd that there are not, let's say height classes for high jump. It always seemed unfair to me that I had to lift my center of mass higher than others for the same performance.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by chupasaurus on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:30AM (#27603232)
Aleksandr Karelin instantly comes to mind.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by yerwhat01010 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:39AM (#27602573)
> does Hubbard have an advantage so she will win 95% of the time?

This graph would suggest she does:

https://i.redd.it/vv4ws1848t671.jpg

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by dagw on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:12AM (#27604774)
If you read the article you'll see that Hubbard is top 10, but not top 3 in her weight class, and in no way a favorite to win. Even her scores pre-transition wouldn't guarantee her gold at the Olympics.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by unrealhoang on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @01:01PM (#27606833)
Yes, comparing a 43 years old who is in no way at the peak of their physical performance to a bunch of 20s shows the degree of unfairness. And no, Hubbard doesn't need to win gold for this to become unfair.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by yerwhat01010 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @04:42PM (#27610058)
Can you at least spare some sympathy for the young woman who's unable to compete at the Olympics because Hubbard has taken her place?
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by MaxBarraclough on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:56AM (#27605988)
To be clear, are you saying the graph is inaccurate?
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by dagw on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:38PM (#27610777)
I'm assuming it is accurate, it is still misleading. It makes it look like she should be breaking records and crushing the competition, when in truth she is doing neither.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by unrealhoang on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @09:08PM (#27612675)
She is crushing the competition by winning 95% of the time and got placed 4th at the age of 43, stealing the place & glory of another top-tier athlete at their peak performance. How is that not an extraordinary feat had she been a biological female? So no, there's nothing misleading about that chart, you just read it wrong.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by CRConrad on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:10PM (#27646863)
How many women over 40 regularly beat Hubbard?
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by nasmorn on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:21AM (#27605555)
Also Hubbard is old and probably not the best make weightlifter previously. So the best woman in the world will likely be beaten by someone who would under different circumstances have already retired and was never that great in the first place.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by dagw on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:23AM (#27603614)
does Hubbard have an advantage so she will win 95% of the time?

The article suggests that she's top 10, but not top 3 in the world. She almost certainly won't win, but might get a medal (since 2 of the 3 best lifter in this category won't be competing in the Olympics for various reasons).

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by stefs on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:56AM (#27602666)
there are athletes who might suffer from abnormal genetic mutations that might give them an advantage. the most popular example might be usain bolt who is, technically, too tall - but in combination with his abnormal muscularity ...

then there is robert förstemann, a track cyclist who might suffer from a myostatin deficincy (a hormone that restricts muscle growth).

[dead]
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by maybeOneDay on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @06:01AM (#27602700)
It's possible to be against the idea of trans women competing in female competitive sports without intentionally misgendering all trans athletes/humans.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by memling on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:51AM (#27603351)
> It's possible to be against the idea of trans women competing in female competitive sports without intentionally misgendering all trans athletes/humans.

Genuine question, one about which I haven't seen much in the way of conversation—although my experience is relatively limited.

Why is the subjective experience of gender privileged over the objective biology of sex?

I can anticipate a couple possible responses for which I'm not sure I have very clear thoughts, either—maybe someone can contribute more light than heat here?

1. Biology isn't actually all that objective: one's subjective experience is at least partially determined by biology, too.

2. We can turn the question on its head: why should objective biology be privileged over subjective experience?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by maybeOneDay on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:21AM (#27603599)
2. Is definitely the counter argument I would use - if people have preferred pronouns then what is the ethical argument for ignoring those and using words that would cause them harm? If nothing else it seems to me to come down to basic decency and respect for others.

It's less about one term being "privileged" (I must confess that word seems slightly unclear to me in this context) over another and more about the ease of treating people the way they would like, with no real downsides that I can see.

Anecdotally, refusing to use a trans person's pronouns seems typically to be a dogwhistle for not respecting the existence/legitimacy of transgender people.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by atq2119 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:33AM (#27605004)
> Is definitely the counter argument I would use - if people have preferred pronouns then what is the ethical argument for ignoring those and using words that would cause them harm

So I think a natural conservative argument there would be that the primary reason why we have sex-based (not gender-based!) pronouns in the first place is so that we can talk about biological categories that are important for the continuation of our species: while some men cannot father offspring, certainly no transman can. So why should we call them men, if it is in fact the reproductive function because of which we use these terms in the first place?

Messing about with mechanisms that are crucial to our survival should at least not be done lightly.

Even as somebody who is non-conservative on most issues, the lack of acknowledgment by trans activists that that's what they're doing rubs me slightly the wrong way.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by maybeOneDay on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:51AM (#27605189)
That logic would also state that we should no longer call a man a man if he becomes infertile through choice (or otherwise), no?

> Messing about with mechanisms that are crucial to our survival should at least not be done lightly.

I disagree with this. Unsurprisingly so, given that I am non-conservative. I believe in personal choice over reproduction and I believe that this choice simply is more important than any tiny effect on societies survival - something that in fact means very little to me other than the 'coincidental' lack of suffering in people I care about/humanity in general. I'm not sure there's any objective value in the human race surviving, in fact if I could push a button that meant all humans would be incredibly fulfilled and lead happy lives and then naturally (peacefully, painlessly, etc) die out in 3 generations time I would certainly strongly consider doing so... I'm rambling now, though.

> the lack of acknowledgment by trans activists that that's what they're doing

I think that's because it's largely incidental - indeed, it doesn't stop them from becoming adoptive parents. It doesn't stop them from freezing sperm/eggs and creating children through more modern means. It may not even lead to infertility in many cases - I'll admit I don't know any detailed knowledge on that.

But most importantly their right to lead their life in whichever way they want, and to choose not to have children, is not especially relevant to anyone else. Nobody should be forced (or be guilted into) to have(ing) children.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by atq2119 on Thursday June 24, 2021 @01:25AM (#27614247)
> That logic would also state that we should no longer call a man a man if he becomes infertile through choice (or otherwise), no?

I don't think that's necessarily the case. The argument is less about individual cases and more about keeping the overall categories intact as traditionally perceived, which isn't really endangered in that case.

By the same argument, calling transmen men if they are passing perfectly would probably be fine. And that's likely what's been happening forever anyway, and is the point of "passing": those individuals don't threaten the general categories. It's a kind of "Don't ask, don't tell" policy.

[...]

> > the lack of acknowledgment by trans activists that that's what they're doing

> I think that's because it's largely incidental

Is it? What you write about personal choice is all(?) true and does not contradict the argument.

My impression is that while transphobia is definitely a thing, a lot of the backlash against trans activism isn't about trans people's individual rights and choices but about trans activists wanting to impose certain beliefs that they have on others. For example, for the purpose of this discussion, the belief that the categories of "man" and "woman" must be defined differently than many (most?) people intuitively define them based on some of the most deeply rooted perception and pattern recognition of the brain.

So it may feel incidental to trans activists, but the people who react likely don't feel the same because it's the aspect (or one of the aspects) of trans activism that affects them the most personally.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by memling on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:44PM (#27610851)
> It's less about one term being "privileged" (I must confess that word seems slightly unclear to me in this context) over another and more about the ease of treating people the way they would like, with no real downsides that I can see.

Sorry for any confusion.

By privileged, I simply mean that one's gender identity instead of biological sex should govern pronoun usage.

> 2. Is definitely the counter argument I would use - if people have preferred pronouns then what is the ethical argument for ignoring those and using words that would cause them harm? If nothing else it seems to me to come down to basic decency and respect for others.

I mean I guess that is part of the reason that pronoun usage is a controversial topic, right? Why are people uncomfortable with using others' desired pronouns? It may be deeply rooted beliefs or other identitarian characteristics (religious or political convictions for example) that could cause someone psychological harm if they use preferred pronouns instead of biological sex.

In areas where legal agency is at issue—in children, for example—use of pronouns could potentially elide complex challenges and lead to irreversible physical changes that don't correspond with later preference (i.e., sex reassignment surgery or puberty blockers may have permanent effects even if the child decides later that it was a bad idea).

Now I don't know that these are particularly good arguments, but they are two ideas that I've seen online or that arise from applying a subjective-experience argument to other identity characteristics.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by nandhinianand on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:13AM (#27603527)
1. is pretty close for ex: most brain functions can be called subjective, and therefore not that relevant. 2. is relatively a trend in how civilization has been moving. The cavemen bashed a skull that seemed unfamiliar or they didn't like, we don't we try to setup a legal system and judge a sense of justice. I don't think every subjective experience should be allowed to be used over other person's choices. I guess we would need something like "your right to swing your hand stops a feet/inch from my nose" kinda principle.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by memling on Friday June 25, 2021 @12:08PM (#27632582)
> 1. is pretty close for ex: most brain functions can be called subjective, and therefore not that relevant.

Sorry for the delay. HN is not a great forum for long discussions (on purpose, I guess). I've been noodling on this for awhile, and so maybe just blathering into the ether.

I'm not sure that subjective and irrelevant necessarily go together.

I guess the argument I'm thinking of is more this: my pronoun preference is biological, so if my chromosomes disagree with my pronoun preference why should my chromosomes govern communication protocols instead of the rest of my biology?

If these things are truly irrelevant, then the notion of gender identity is itself irrelevant and so, too, are pronouns, aren't they? (I mean, maybe not, but I don't see how one could say chromosomes don't matter but preferences do.)

One of the real challenges gender identity raises is that it acknowledges that the body actually means something. It also implies that language means something. Mind and body go together, and when they disagree some kind of resolution is needed. Language shapes reality, so when language contradicts that resolution the reality of my existence, my very identity, is threatened or negated.

If we stipulate that, I think we have to admit pronoun use really isn't neutral. It's not merely a matter of common decency and respect (although it certainly is part of that), but about what we think it means to be human and how we attempt to shape and react to reality.

My own thoughts here aren't super well formed, hence my line of questioning and (perhaps poorly worded and thought out) reasoning...but I do think it bears some critical examination.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by nandhinianand on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:08AM (#27734795)
I think we're on the same page..I was collating subjective and irrelevant together for the sake of the parent comment. and it is quite common in the "objectivist philosophy/meta-physical" view .

> Language shapes reality, Sorry I have disagree on this one. I don't think language shapes reality. It definitely shapes our perception, filters, and biases but shapes reality only in a very Probabilistic graphical model sense. And even then it shapes(as in cavemen---> civilization) reality as much as say, air shapes reality, mathematical formulae and theories shape reality . My usual stance on the gender identity debate comes along with the "freedom to swing your arm but not hit my nose" sense. In this case of weightlifting for ex: I recently saw a twitter mention comparing the same athlete before starting HRT therapy and now.(along with a co-competitor in the male category she used to compete with) It pointed out how much the gap between both the lifters progress has been because of the Hormones.

Anyway, I don't have a clear stance on trans-people competing in their gender category .. I think the gender based categorization in sports has to move further, but I'm ambiguous even about how the sports laws work on even doping. So since I don't have skin-in-the-game I only try to add clarity to the discussion without taking either stance strongly.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by memling on Monday July 05, 2021 @08:23AM (#27737221)
> > Language shapes reality,

> Sorry I have disagree on this one. I don't think language shapes reality. It definitely shapes our perception, filters, and biases but shapes reality only in a very Probabilistic graphical model sense. And even then it shapes(as in cavemen---> civilization) reality as much as say, air shapes reality, mathematical formulae and theories shape reality .

Sorry if it's not clear: I'm not trying to say what's true, despite having opinions on the subject; I'm interested in best arguments.

What I think the implications are in assuming that gender is as much state-of-mind as state-of-body (if not more) is two-fold:

1. The body really does matter. It's inconsistent to say that the body has to align with the mind if the body doesn't matter. Surgical and hormonal intervention make no sense if the mind and the body aren't somehow connected in a very deep way.

2. The desire for pronoun usage is more, too, than mere courtesy, but the desire for consensus on reality. If I'm a woman trapped in a man's body or have no particular gender, when I ask someone to use pronouns of my preference I am actually asking them to make a statement about what is real and true. This implies in no small way that language shapes and makes reality in some nontrivial way.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by realityking on Thursday June 24, 2021 @12:37PM (#27620066)
Adding a third option, proposing sex being the superior categorisation completely ignores the existence of intersex people.

Take Hanne Gaby Odiele (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanne_Gaby_Odiele). They (their preferred pronoun) have an XY chromosome but due to an androgen insensitivity looks traditionally female - to the point of being a fairly successful model for woman's fashion. They'd certainly be very out of place in a mens bathroom if forced there due to their chromosome.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by memling on Friday June 25, 2021 @10:31AM (#27631236)
> Adding a third option, proposing sex being the superior categorisation completely ignores the existence of intersex people.

This is another assertion that I also don't quite understand. (I want to emphasize I'm not trolling here—I'm genuinely interested. Topics like this are obviously highly charged and challenging to discuss in a fruitful way.)

Vocabulary exists for discussing intersex characteristics, so the existence of intersex people is known and acknowledged. Is there something special about pronouns?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by realityking on Friday June 25, 2021 @03:55PM (#27635483)
How would you address an intersex person? Their physical characteristics might have been decided by a doctor shortly after birth without any input from themselves. Their chromosomes might be ambiguous or just don’t match their physical characteristics. Like Hanne Gaby Odiele having an XY chromosome, looking (to me) physically female and preferring the they/them pronoun.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by memling on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @09:31AM (#27688287)
> How would you address an intersex person? Their physical characteristics might have been decided by a doctor shortly after birth without any input from themselves. Their chromosomes might be ambiguous or just don’t match their physical characteristics. Like Hanne Gaby Odiele having an XY chromosome, looking (to me) physically female and preferring the they/them pronoun.

My default is to use appearance in the absence of other factors; I understand there are cases in which this is challenging at best.

Even so, I'm still not quite sure how this addresses my question about how using biological pronouns instead of preferred pronouns somehow "ignores the existence of the intersex" as you earlier asserted. (Indeed, it seems as though the question of pronouns actually rather highlights the existence of the person, if in an uncomfortable and potentially discriminatory way.)

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by realityking on Thursday July 01, 2021 @07:04AM (#27697980)
> I'm still not quite sure how this addresses my question about how using biological pronouns instead of preferred pronouns somehow "ignores the existence of the intersex" as you earlier asserted.

My point, perhaps poorly delivered, was that not every person has a “biological pronoun”. How do you even define it?

There are people with XY chromosomes and female genitalia (and usually female identity): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/XY_gonadal_dysgenesis

There are also people with male characteristics and two X chromosomes: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/XX_male_syndrome

Addressing these folks by their “biological sex” (of you mean chromosomes) would be hugely insulting, besides the fact it’s not like we got our chromosomes written on our forehead.

Lastly, there are people with ambiguous physical characteristics. Often gender assignment surgeries are performed shortly after birth. Those folks usually get addressed by the gender a doctor chose for them when they were infants - and sometimes this turns out to be the wrong choice and doesn’t actually match their identity. They also don’t have a “biological sex” that neatly fits into the male/female schema.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by memling on Friday July 02, 2021 @04:05PM (#27716199)
> My point, perhaps poorly delivered, was that not every person has a “biological pronoun”. How do you even define it?

My understanding is that historically the presence of the Y chromosome was considered determinative. One was male (therefore "he") if the karotype was 46,XY or 47,XXY or 48,XXXY, etc. Indeed, in discussions of the more common abnormal karotypes (e.g., Klinefelter), most of the literature I've seen uses the word "male."

> Addressing these folks by their “biological sex” (of you mean chromosomes) would be hugely insulting, besides the fact it’s not like we got our chromosomes written on our forehead.

With respect to chromosomes and forehead, that's not exactly true. There's sufficient divergence between male and female skulls that some gender expression surgeries target them.[1] I do understand what you mean, and I'm not trying to be snarky. Sexual differentiation is more than just genitalia, and we're well adapted to noticing those differences.

It seems like you're making two points:

1. Those with abnormal karotypes can have an experience similar to the normally karotyped: their self-perception and their anatomy might not line up, and they may prefer to be called by a pronoun that doesn't correspond with karotype or anatomy.

2. The experience of those with abnormal karotypes can and should be generalized to those with normal karotypes.

(I'm a bit fuzzy on (2) but I think I'm representing you correctly on (1). By all means correct me if I'm wrong.)

I could pretty easily see someone relatively conservative on the issue of pronouns (for, e.g., medical or religious reasons) agreeing that those with abnormal karotypes should be allowed pronoun preference but disagreeing with the second because chromosomal abnormalities are the exception that proves the rule.

I'm not sure how it helps resolve the initial question because it requires generalizing from a small set to a substantially larger one. It also offers a more clear reason why one's subjective experience doesn't quite line up with one's body (i.e., a clear abnormality on the chromosomes).

[1]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7994012/

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by realityking on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @01:53PM (#27751994)
We‘ve taken this conversation pretty far over the past 12-days (thanks for sticking with it!). I think it‘s fair to circle back to your original question that I responded to:

> Why is the subjective experience of gender privileged over the objective biology of sex?

My point was that biology is not all that objective and if we were to use pronouns in accordance with your thesis, we‘d eliminate the identity of many intersex people.

Whether gender-identity can be out of sync with your body in the absence of conditions described as intersex (which, for the record, I do believe in) and whether it should be respected is somewhat orthogonal to that. I believe the examples I’ve given of conditions where biology is either ambiguous or actively out of sync are sufficient to illustrate that using “ objective biology” would eliminate the identity of many intersex people. It’s my opinion, that that alone is reason enough to privilege gender over sex.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by memling on Thursday July 08, 2021 @07:20PM (#27778807)
Thanks for the consistent and thoughtful replies. It's been helpful for me as I think about these hot-button topics. I'll certainly leave here but will probably reference the thread for my own sake for some time to come; thanks again.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by CRConrad on Saturday June 26, 2021 @07:13PM (#27646884)
> How would you address an intersex person?

"You."

HTH!

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by nandhinianand on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:05AM (#27603462)
And there's a bunch of trans people anecdotally debating it claiming things like height reduction and others. The truth trans people on (long-term) hormones have not been studied on physiological characteristics to be sure they're affected or not.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by anaisbetts on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:09AM (#27602418)
Why would having the same muscle but heavier bones as your competitors be an advantage in almost any sport?
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by Supermancho on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:50AM (#27602636)
Increased bone density means less prone to injury and more momentum in pivots and swings/punches.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by CodeGlitch on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:39AM (#27605075)
Not only that - but look at the shape of the hip bone between men and women - the latter have wider hips to cater for child-birth. This means men have a massive advantage when running/swimming/cycling/lifting. The same applies to the arms (men have straighter arms) which obviously changes the mechanics when lifting. No amount of hormone therapy will change this.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by hutzlibu on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:20AM (#27603165)
If it would be as simple as "having the same muscle but heavier bones" - then there would be advantages in climbing for example. But the worlds top climbers are male, too.

(but the gap is in climbing seems to be smaller)

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by samatman on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:30AM (#27603670)
Grip strength is another easily-measured physical metric where there is practically no overlap between the bell curve for male and female humans.

The applicability of higher grip strength to success in climbing is obvious, I hope.