News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by uniqueid on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:03AM (#27601619)

  sports has everything to do with sex and nothing 
  to do with gender
Dividing by sex is a substitute for dividing by the things that really matter: height, weight, strength, bone density, etc. If sports grouped competitors by a combination of those attributes, it would solve a lot of issues, including debate over transgender athletes.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by nimbleal on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:23AM (#27601759)
Hmmmm. At that point are you not simply beginning to divide by ability? Basketball for short people? Weightlifting for weak people? It would seem to both go against the spirit of sport and be impossible to implement in practice (for e.g how many different ways do you cut it?)

Perhaps the more fundamental question — once again leaning on apparently somewhat flimsy terminology — would be: is biological sex something worthy of celebration and note? Half of our species is born a certain way, whatever we call it. Is that grouping to be given certain opportunities to demonstrate their talents that would not be afforded them on a level playing field?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by crowf on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:29AM (#27601799)
Many sports have many categories. Boxers and wrestlers are separated based on weight
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by nimbleal on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:36AM (#27601830)
Yes, but as mentioned elsewhere weight alone would do little to solve this issue. Males would still dominate.

So presumably you include other factors — but then you are simply dividing by ability. You could conceivably attempt to divide by innate ability (theoretically allowing competitors to compete against one another based on nurture, not nature) but that would be impossible to do fairly or in a way that would make sense to audiences.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by a-and on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @12:41PM (#27606521)
> but then you are simply dividing by ability

While I understand the sentiment, but I think we need to speak of skill vs physical factors. The division of weightlifters in weight classes is to deal with the latter rather than the former.

Similarly - WADA does this already by banning doping. PEDs don't make you a high-skill athlete, they enhance physical capabilities (stronger, faster recovery etc).

Laurel Hubbard is in an unfortunately unique position, where she's at a natural advantage due to higher testosterone levels earlier in life.

It might be impossible to end up with a fair division, but I don't think "no division" is a good answer.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by trhway on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @06:50AM (#27602992)
>impossible to do fairly

we're at HN - run PCA and clustering on the totality of athletes' results and biological data for the last N decades with end result being the groups based on identified parameters similar to boxing/wrestling weight groups.

>that would make sense to audiences.

we're already in situation which is harder and harder to make sense. Putting it on the firm basis of scientific analysis is the only way to move forward which would avoid all the pitfalls we're going to hit otherwise.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by jefftk on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:55AM (#27603380)
What happens if you run PCA and it groups trans women in with men?
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by trhway on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:24AM (#27603617)
trans women by their nature already defy the classic notions of sex and gender (i.e. that classic match of software and hardware), so why does it matter whether they would get grouped with the men (i suppose you meant the classic notion of "men"), trans men, women or with any cross boundaries cutting group as long as the competition is honest (i.e. similar blood oxygen carrying capabilities with similar muscle mass with similar bone density or whatever PCA would point to)?

Also, if trans women are supposed to go to women competition, does it mean that trans men are supposed to go to men competition? Wouldn't that mean pretty much condemning them to having no chance of winning from the start in the most sports where sheer mass, power, etc. play major role?

Anyway, if we don't put it on the firm scientific basis today, i can see how tomorrow a number of male athletes form China and Russia would suddenly start to feel like they are women, may be would take some hormones to satisfy some doubts/requirements (giving the doping already going on i don't see any obstacles here), and that will be the end of female sports.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by GhostVII on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @09:01AM (#27604035)
Boxers and wrestlers are also separated based on sex, because even at the same weight males will dominate.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by belorn on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:02AM (#27602364)
A while back I wondered how much of elite sport is determined by genetics. The answer I got back was unsurprising that genetics play a very heavy role in many sports 90%+. We have basically already dived the population based on those traits when it comes to some world championships.

Is it fun to watch a bunch of length skiers that all have a similar rare medical conditions that enables an endurance and oxygen uptake that is way beyond what is possible for the wast majority of the population? Dividing by genetics seems as a good option, but would that then go against the spirit of the sport?

Sex is simply just a bunch of common genetic traits, but they are not the only traits that matters in sport. There are a long list of them, especially in extreme strength or endurance sports.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by GhostVII on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @09:12AM (#27604154)
When you segment based on age and sex you are dividing up people based on their starting conditions - people who were born in the same year, and with the same sex, compete to see who is the best. When you divide based on the attributes that matter for the sport, you are basically just pre-ranking everyone and bucketing them so you only compete against those who we predict will do as well as you. Which is fine for more casual levels of sport, but isn't particularly interesting to watch.

No one wants to watch a competition to see who is the "best of people we think are ranked 100-200" since it is an arbitrary grouping. They want to see people compete to be the best woman or man in the world.

Dividing based on weight makes sense for some sports since it is an added constraint that people compete to optimize their strength against. But dividing based on strength just moves the competition from the actual competition, into the ranking process.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by belorn on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @06:30PM (#27611376)
A problematic aspect of segmenting based on age is that you get a very large bias towards people with specific birth months. Getting 11 more months compare to the competition is huge, and the data shows it.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24886927/

https://danielkiikka.com/performance/birth-month-athletic-pe...

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by yerwhat01010 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @04:13AM (#27602081)
Olympic weightlifting is already divided into weight categories. What you're advocating is the abolition of women's sports.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by uniqueid on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @04:31AM (#27602187)
Not that I made an argument for using weight alone, but it depends on the sport in any event. To avoid injuries, the physical attributes that matter to billiards differ from those that matter to rugby.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by 3grdlurker on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:07AM (#27602405)
> Dividing by sex is a substitute for dividing by the things that really matter: height, weight, strength, bone density, etc.

You crucially missed an important variable which competitive sports of any kind fully hinge upon: skeletal muscle density… which hugely differs across biological sexes.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by Someone on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:35AM (#27603727)
In many sports, there’s selection for the level one competes at. You won’t see Messi play in third division football, for example, or me being offered a job by a top team. Top athletes want the challenge/fame/money of competing with better players.

In other sports, there’s a rating system that effectively places people with competitors at their level (ELO in chess, tennis rankings)

Either would work in any sport, except for the fact that huge classes of people wouldn’t ever be represented at top level. Prime examples are women and people with disabilities.

In para-athletics, they try to solve that with an elaborate classification system (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Para-athletics_classification)

Problem is that training can sometimes move you between categories. For example, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T42_(classification) has “impaired muscle power or impaired range of movement” as criteria. Those can get better with training.

For women, it seems easier, but even ignoring transgenders, there’s various genetic rarities such as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/46,XX/46,XY that can put women at an advantage (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foekje_Dillema) that we may or may not choose to call unfair (we don’t think it’s unfair for men over six feet to compete in basketball, though, even though that’s largely genetic)

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by xupybd on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @04:45AM (#27602276)
I think life time testosterone levels would help too. Hard to define and monitor but a huge performance impacted
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by sundvor on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @06:26AM (#27602854)
On a related note:

One of the advantages of weightlifting (at least for a middle aged cisgendered male) is that it increases testosterone production.

Significantly lowered levels can have some really bad outcomes as one age, ie killing energy levels, libido, physical strength etc.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by xupybd on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @06:39AM (#27602931)
Yeah it really helps. I'd recommend heavy deadlifts to any middle aged male. It's a huge energy booster.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by sundvor on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @09:12PM (#27612712)
I just wanted to say thanks for reminding me that deadlifts is the really big one.

I've been mainly focusing on my squats in my garage gym (full Olympic barbell/bench/rack with spotter bars/extra Olympic EzyCurl bar) setup, but looking at my history I've let the big deadlift slip - 14 days since last session.

So I took the 20 second trip to the gym last night to start fixing that, warmed up with squats and then just deadlifts - and can definitely feel the energy today (on top of the fatigue!).

I've been struggling with energy lately due to a lot of change and stress, so hopefully a renewed focus on the deadlift will be helpful. Cheers.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by nerdponx on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:16AM (#27601704)
I agree, but unintended consequences abound.

I wonder how this would apply in sports that don't typically have weight classes, like track & field. I imagine you'd start seeing athletes in pretty much every sport cutting weight like in boxing and wrestling, which I don't think is a healthy outcome.

Are we at a level of biological science yet to create reliable divisions/classes on anything more sophisticated? And what about non-professional sports in schools?

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by rjmunro on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:11AM (#27603102)
The Paralympic movement does something like this, and it's hard, e.g. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-57404811.

There's actually a campaign in wheelchair tennis to allow players who don't actually need a wheelchair to be allowed to compete. https://www.theaccessibleplanet.com/able-bodied-playing-whee...

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by robertlagrant on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:26AM (#27603201)
> There's actually a campaign in wheelchair tennis to allow players who don't actually need a wheelchair to be allowed to compete

I've wondered about this - it's an interesting idea. Then the sport is just "Wheelchair tennis" and anyone can try.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by ryanwinchester on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @01:18PM (#27607115)
I think people not confined to a wheelchair have more options for physical training. You could say that's an unfair advantage to people actually requiring the chair.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by robertlagrant on Thursday June 24, 2021 @04:41AM (#27615222)
True, and also it's possible that they would be able to get leverage from their legs in a way that not everyone could. It's a tricky topic.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by germinalphrase on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:51AM (#27603908)
While absolutely common, cutting weight is not universal in combat sports and wrestling. There are distinct athletic costs to cutting weight.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by mastazi on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:19AM (#27601734)
Most combat sports have weight classes so what you are suggesting is not completely unheard of.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by splithalf on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:04AM (#27604690)
I like this idea. It could also make the nba and nfl more racially diverse.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by caeril on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:10AM (#27604746)
Reaction times and spatial reasoning matter very significantly in sports, as well.

These are things for which there are also rather persistent differences in distribution between males and females.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by jhgb on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @06:04PM (#27611078)
I strongly suspect that you'd discover that your data forms two major clusters.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by raffraffraff on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @04:18AM (#27602107)
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by uniqueid on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @04:28AM (#27602171)
That tweet addresses solely weight, but I'm not arguing for categories based solely on weight.
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by raffraffraff on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @04:35AM (#27602207)
https://mobile.twitter.com/Scienceofsport/status/12979157895...

Tweets are a dreadful way to read something like this, which would be easier to suggest in a blog post or paper. But I suppose Twitter gives people the right to respond, so swings-and-roundabouts.

Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by uniqueid on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:04AM (#27602384)
Thanks, the entire thread makes more sense! I want to avoid sounding any more opinionated about sports medicine than I already do, since it's not a subject in which I have any expertise. That said, when I consider that a 'mens' category alone includes both Andre The Giant and Peter Dinklage, it's hard for me to understand how a richer mix of physical attributes could do any worse :)
Re:Rival weightlifter speaks out on transgender Hubbard's Ol... by raffraffraff on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:39AM (#27603289)
Well, you're not picking people at either end of a normal size scale. You're picking people with gigantism and dwarfism. But let's take Andre as an example: what sports Andre would truly excel at? He made a name in wrestling, but his gigantism was as much a cause of health problems as an "edge" in sport. And if size was the deciding factor, then why wasn't the largest woman with gigantism (Tanya Angus, 7 feet 7 inches and weighed 400lbs) beating the shit out of wrestlers like The Undertaker (6 feet 10, 309lbs)? Because size isn't all.

Edit: now I'm taking weight!

Ross Tucker made a point about safety, but also about fairness, about which he said (paraphrasing) that females would disappear completely from mixed sex sports, even with weight categories. His point about "fairness" categories is more like "how would that even work?"