Re:Tesla’s ‘Knight Rider’ Steering Yoke Is Getting Panned in...
by throwaway0a5e on Friday June 18, 2021 @01:26PM
(#27552702)
Regardless of steering ratio they're designed around people who can be expected to want to hold the steering wheel a certain way for a certain task.
Normal people doing normal driving want to grab the top, bottom, etc. depending on what's most comfortable and natural in the moment.
Re:Tesla’s ‘Knight Rider’ Steering Yoke Is Getting Panned in...
by erpellan on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:05PM
(#27553100)
Same with indicator stalks - not all road junctions are at 90 degrees - I'd love to see a video of activating a yoke-mounted turn signal with it turned. I don't want to do trig just to find the turn signal and then have right and left switched around because the yoke is upside down.
Re:Tesla’s ‘Knight Rider’ Steering Yoke Is Getting Panned in...
by vanekjar on Friday June 18, 2021 @03:26PM
(#27553925)
True, a lot of fun with signaling right while leaving roundabouts.
Oh wait, nobody does that anyway
Re:Tesla’s ‘Knight Rider’ Steering Yoke Is Getting Panned in...
by sunstone on Friday June 18, 2021 @05:04PM
(#27555034)
Not sure why you're getting the down votes but here, have an up vote :)
Re:Tesla’s ‘Knight Rider’ Steering Yoke Is Getting Panned in...
by avereveard on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:01PM
(#27553054)
Immagine this thing autoparking. A round wheel spinning has no edges to bump or catch on things. This yoke makes hard to judge whether your knees are enough away from it.
Re:Tesla’s ‘Knight Rider’ Steering Yoke Is Getting Panned in...
by xiphias2 on Saturday June 19, 2021 @09:41AM
(#27560386)
When my friend was telling me how stupid the yoke wheel is, I told him, and was just assuming that Tesla will just implement dynamic steering and it will be pretty cool.
Now what I think is that Elon may not have listened to his engineers, but at least he's really good at listening to sales numbers.
Re:Tesla’s ‘Knight Rider’ Steering Yoke Is Getting Panned in...
by NegativeLatency on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:07PM
(#27553129)
Makes sense if you care about marketing over actual usability.
[dead]
Re:Tesla’s ‘Knight Rider’ Steering Yoke Is Getting Panned in...
by hef19898 on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:22PM
(#27553272)
Well, Elon gave us 50s style rockets. And Spaceballs flame throwers. So why not KITT?
Re:Tesla’s ‘Knight Rider’ Steering Yoke Is Getting Panned in...
by ArcturianDeath on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:13PM
(#27553186)
Exactly. Theyre dummies
They’re designed for small race cars with fast steering ratios that never have to make small, tight turns like a U-turn or a parking maneuver. If you almost never need to turn the wheel more than 90 degrees, you don’t need the top and bottom of the wheel. That’s not the case on a daily driven street car.
Even the professional race car driver who reviewed the car insisted that the Yoke be switched back to a normal wheel so he could actually drive it properly on track.
This feels like the industrial design team fell in love with the looks and marketing aspects of the yoke wheel and ignored the total lack of practicality.