News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by xoa on Friday June 18, 2021 @09:57AM (#27550356)
For the USN (and other military's) ones at least there are many other differing issues and design goals that are divergent enough from civilian usage that it's definitely more then just cost. For example on the most basic issue of fuel, the A4W reactors (found on current USN super carriers) run on highly enriched U235, designed around 93% and as high as 97%. In other words, the fuel is flat out weapons grade by itself. A typical civilian plant is more like 3-5%. Very high enrichment allows more density and very long times between refueling, they can go something like 10 years vs 1-2 years for civilian. But obviously that would be a big proliferation concern even ignoring cost, nor are there many places to get that kind of fuel. For the military that is irrelevant, it's not a limiting problem since the vessels these reactors live on tend to also carry literal nuclear weapons. But it means it won't just transfer to other usage. There are plenty of other differences in naval reactors, like they also formulate with high burn up fuels (metal ceramics, u-al/u-zr) rather then uranium dioxide.

Military vessels also have ample trained personnel to throw at maintenance and operations, they can make tradeoffs for things that are more finicky but provide higher performance. They're anything but "self-contained" really, and even the Navy wanted to simplify that. A major goal for the new A1B reactor in the Gerald R. Ford-class supercarriers, as well as normal stuff like "more power, weighs less" was to cut the number of people needed to run the reactors and propulsion.

I mean, yeah, all this certainly does add to the cost too. But it's not just about the cost, or rather the design goals and missions are divergent enough that they necessitate costs for military reactors that would be a waste, dangerous, or both elsewhere. Where the Naval reactors might well carry over to I think would be future space usage, a lot of what the navy is worried about with sending a reactor out on a carrier or sub for years seems to overlap with challenges and goals faced by a reactor on a spaceship sent to the outer solar system.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by jabl on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:18PM (#27553238)
Except for the USN and RN (which uses US-derived designs), other navies using nuclear propulsion don't use such highly enriched fuel. Russia AFAIK uses somewhere around 30-40%, which is still classified as HEU, so problematic for civilian use, but most likely not directly usable in a bomb.

France runs on 7% enriched UO2 (although using plate-based 'caramel' fuel rather than cylindrical pellets in rods like typical civilian nuclear fuel). This requires them to refuel every 10 years rather than having life-of-ship reactors like the latest generation US submarine reactors, but OTOH French law requires reactors to be defueled and inspected every 10 years anyway.

As for space usage, launch weight restrictions make LWR style reactors impractical. Look at something like the NASA Kilopower as an example of what a (very small) space-based power reactor might look like. For nuclear propulsion like a nuclear thermal rocket, that's again a different kind of reactor pretty different from both LWR's and Kilopower.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by xoa on Friday June 18, 2021 @03:16PM (#27553825)
>As for space usage, launch weight restrictions make LWR style reactors impractical.

OK, so this is a reply to both you and @nickelpro (your comment is newer but also higher), who wrote:

>Space-based nuclear energy is all based around RTGs, reactors have no place in space

You both seem to have an image in your heads regarding future long duration deep space vehicles (I explicitly mentioned "outer solar system") here that is a mixture of old space assembly and soft science-fiction, wherein industrial capacity is all terrestrial and any ship is built entirely on Earth, launched and off it goes. All-in-one. Even SpaceX with its use of pure chemical rockets to Mars and terrestrial construction plans to break with that: in-orbit refueling is an absolutely key part. And for going farther then that (and as Starship and successors/competitors kick starts a new era of space economics and industry) the clear and necessary next step will be in-space assembly (be it in LEO or a Lagrange point dock or whatever ends up being most practical at a given time).

In the same way we don't expect our ships to somehow be built hundreds of miles inland and then make their way to the ocean or fit entirely on a single semitruck, stay indefinitely on what can be launched out of Earth's atmosphere makes no sense either. The important aspects are all at cross purposes. Aerodynamic considerations are a waste in vacuum and constrict design in very important ways. Engines to get out of a strong gravity well need high thrust, whereas for long distances in space one really wants very high ISP. A torch drive that can do both necessarily bears a striking resemblance to a high energy weapon system to whatever happens to be facing the business end of it, and all known practical models (nuclear salt water, thermonuclear pulse) are ludicrously polluting. And outer solar system ships will need strong variable electric sources with high power/mass too despite solar being entirely impractical. RTGs won't cut it.

So sure I don't think we'll ever see one launch off Earth's surface (I hope not anyway, if humanity is willing to light one of those off here it means we're facing a threat big enough that trashing our home is considered worth it). But that's a-ok, because what we'll do is built empty reactors, or reactor components, and launch those separately from fuel, and put it all together in space. Or for that matter far enough down the road maybe we build that stuff on the moon or in the asteroids or who knows. It obviously wouldn't be a copy/paste, but to the extent that USN reactor designs will get used outside of the military that's where I see it making sense.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by perl4ever on Friday June 18, 2021 @05:55PM (#27555430)
>So sure I don't think we'll ever see one launch off Earth's surface

Are you saying you don't think a nuclear reactor powered spacecraft will ever be launched into space on a chemical rocket in the forseeable future, or that you don't think nuclear powered rockets will ever be used to get from ground to orbit?

You're probably aware, but nuclear power in space has not been limited to plutonium powered RTGs that output a few hundred watts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/US-A

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BES-5

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TOPAZ_nuclear_reactor

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RD-0410

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_space

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by jabl on Friday June 18, 2021 @05:00PM (#27554995)
My point is that the requirements on a space reactor are sufficiently different than a naval reactor that I'd think you're better off looking for inspiration at things like Kilopower than the PWR's currently used in naval vessels. Yes, if you build the thing in space weight isn't such a critical factor as if you're launching it from Earth's gravity well, but weight still matters as it's mass you have to accelerate and decelerate as you zip around the solar system. A PWR is inevitably extremely heavy due to having to withstand the 15 MPa pressure (assuming naval PWR's have about the same pressure as civilian ones, I suppose they could be somewhat lower). Further, a critical issue for a space reactor is how to cool it. Radiative cooling in space is very bad compared what we can do down here. Thus to minimize the size of your radiators you want a reactor that operates at high temperature. Also in this respect a PWR is a very poor choice.
Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by m4rtink on Friday June 18, 2021 @03:39PM (#27554072)
In some cases you want sorta aerodynamic vehicles even if they are space only, as you then can do aerocapture and aerobreaking, possibly reducing quite a bit the delta-v needed for a flight.

Also high thrust engines if you can get them can make use of the Oberhausen effect & some maneuvers, like specific orbit captures or crewed radiation belt transits need them as well.

Still no problem to build that thing in space if you can pull it off. :)

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by wpietri on Friday June 18, 2021 @11:09AM (#27551163)
This is the kind of comment that keeps me coming back to HN. Thoughtful, nuanced, and full of information from a field I know very little about. Thanks!
Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by nickelpro on Friday June 18, 2021 @10:59AM (#27551055)
Can't put a traditional naval reactor or anything that resembles one on a spacecraft.

1) If it explodes on takeoff you're fucked

2) Naval reactors (and all reactors) require massive heatsinks to dissipate entropy. There's no ocean in space.

Space-based nuclear energy is all based around RTGs, reactors have no place in space

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by acidburnNSA on Friday June 18, 2021 @11:32AM (#27551415)
Almost all space reactor concepts have fresh fuel at takeoff and then start-up once they're launched. You can hold fresh nuclear fuel in your hand with very little hazard. It's only once you start splitting atoms that the radiation levels get high. So you launch the fresh and mostly inert reactor to avoid this risk.

RTGs, on the other hand, are radioactive from the get-go, but are usually quite small.

The USA did run a reactor in space (SNAP-10A) and the Soviets did a few dozen.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by nickelpro on Friday June 18, 2021 @11:46AM (#27551574)
SNAP was a scaled up RTG, as are the soviet examples. You can call these reactors if you want but then we're just playing a semantics game. I tried to head this off by saying "traditional naval reactor or anything that resembles one".

Also the problem isn't running the reactor on the launch pad, the problem is if the launch vessel explodes and the fuel load gets spread out over your launch area. The enriched uranium used in naval-style propulsion is absolutely not "safe to hold in your hand" and the weight requirements for using natural uranium, which is safe, would be prohibitive for use in space.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by acidburnNSA on Friday June 18, 2021 @12:02PM (#27551763)
Most SNAPs were RTGs but SNAP-10A was an honest to goodness fissioning nuclear reactor [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SNAP-10A

Highly enriched uranium is still barely radioactive, very similar to natural uranium. The half-life of U-235 is 703 million years. As half-life approaches infinity, atoms approach stability. The dose rate of holding navy nuclear fuel is modest compared to the hazards of fission products.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by djcapelis on Friday June 18, 2021 @12:47PM (#27552286)
I don’t disagree that in comparison to many other nasty byproducts of the U235 chain, most Uranium isotopes are not that “hot” but the danger of HEU comes partly from the increased presence of the U234 isotope, not just U235. So that isotope solely is not the right half life to do math around. While U235 is about as stable as U238, most purification techniques result in selecting the lower weight isotopes, which selects the hotter U234 as well. And while there is less of it, if I recall correctly eventually U234 dominates in terms of radiation output.
Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by nickelpro on Friday June 18, 2021 @12:17PM (#27551909)
Again this is a semantics game, SNAP 10A was still driving a thermo electric converter, thus "scaled up RTG", nothing resembling a traditional naval reactor.

The on-contact for a HEU billet is over 10mrem/hour. You and I have very different ideas about nuclear safety apparently and I presume you haven't worked professionally in the field with that attitude.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by mumblemumble on Friday June 18, 2021 @12:35PM (#27552139)
Frankly, it seems to me that you're the one trying to make it a semantics game, by trying to define what is and is not a nuclear reactor based on how you collect power from the device.

According to that Wikipedia article, SNAP 10A was centered on a device that created and maintained a controlled, sustained nuclear fission reaction. I would call that a "nuclear reactor" even if no attempt were made to harvest the power. I think that the rest of the world is probably with me on this. The Chicago Pile 1 is widely regarded as the first nuclear reactor, and nobody particularly cares how it generated electricity. What they care about is that it demonstrated a controlled, sustained nuclear fission reaction.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by ceejayoz on Friday June 18, 2021 @12:38PM (#27552174)
10 mrem/hour seems to confirm the "barely radioactive" argument; the CDC says (https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/radiation/air_travel.html) that a cross-country flight exposes you to 3.5 mrem. No one's saying you should hold said uranium in your hand for weeks at a time; they're saying the risk of chucking some around after a (very rare) spacecraft crash is pretty minor, especially as it'll be launched over water.
Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by ClumsyPilot on Friday June 18, 2021 @01:23PM (#27552674)
>"Again this is a semantics game, SNAP 10A was still driving a thermo electric converter, thus "scaled up RTG""

You are getting the absolute basics wrong, so you have no standing to question the OP's atittude.

Nuclear reactor runs a nuclear chain reaction, hence the name, RTG does not. There is no scope for debate here. The difference is night and day and is obvious if you look at fuel, power to weight ratio, or do physics 101.

RTGs run on decay heat and use plutonium 238, they cant be turned off, their power slowly drops off over decades. Reactors use U235, have active control and starting/stop procedure and 10-100x higher power to weight

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by Retric on Friday June 18, 2021 @01:39PM (#27552823)
The issue is these designs are ~3% efficient like RTGs and have few moving parts unlike ~35% efficient nuclear reactors on earth. While they sidestep most of the complications of traditional nuclear reactors like radiation shielding, they really aren’t useful designs having low energy output, terrible energy density, relatively short lifespans, and extreme cost.
Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by mumblemumble on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:34PM (#27553401)
According to https://www.etec.energy.gov/Operations/Major_Operations/Majo... it's even worse than that; 1.83%.

That said, it seems like, all by itself, conversion efficiency is a tricky measure of the usefulness of a design for spaceflight purposes. Wouldn't it be more useful to consider the total cost to deliver a given energy production capacity to space? In that case, rocket fuel itself, and the tyranny of the rocket equation, becomes a major consideration. If an efficiency gain comes at the cost of increasing the weight of the energy generation system in some way, then perhaps it doesn't end up being a net win over the less efficient design.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by Retric on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:50PM (#27553575)
Efficiency is a big deal in part because you need to radiate out all that thermal energy. A radiator that’s dumping 100kw of thermal energy for 1.3kw of electricity is much heavier than a 1.3kw solar panel anywhere near earth. Add 50kg for fuel and and things look even worse.

By comparison the voyager probe RTG used ~1/10th the fuel for a little over 1/10th the power. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MHW-RTG So the only advantage was cheaper fuel.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by ClumsyPilot on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:56PM (#27553637)
They have same radiation shielding and powet output as any other reactor, electricity generation is a separate concern that should not be confused with the reactor itself.

The same reactor couod be hooked up to a 20% efficient stirling engine to keep it low maintenance, to a >50% efficient convined cycle or have 0% electricity output and be used for heat or water desalination.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by Retric on Friday June 18, 2021 @03:24PM (#27553903)
Nuclear reactors aren’t plug and play, and you can sell they skipped a lot of radiation shielding simply from the weight of these systems.

By comparison SL-1 a 400kw thermal design so 4x power used a 12,000 kg pressure vessel including shielding. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SL-1

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by cameldrv on Friday June 18, 2021 @12:02PM (#27551750)
The odd numbered SNAPs were RTGs. The Even numbered ones were reactors. SNAP-10A was the only reactor from that program to fly.
Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by marcinzm on Friday June 18, 2021 @11:25AM (#27551344)
The soviets launched a bunch of reactors (not RTGs) into space.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TOPAZ_nuclear_reactor

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BES-5

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by deeviant on Friday June 18, 2021 @12:08PM (#27551816)
> Space-based nuclear energy is all based around RTGs, reactors have no place in space

It is true that RTGs are the only type of nuclear power used in space now, but that is more to do with type of craft we send to space rather than practical limitation of nuclear power in space.

A large spacecraft will have enough surface area mount enough radiative heatsinks to dissipate the heat from a nuclear reactor. Designs exist that have the math worked out for this since the 50s.

Re:Nuclear Power at McMurdo Station, Antarctica by discordance on Friday June 18, 2021 @11:13AM (#27551208)
Except for the sun