News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by Zelphyr on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:31PM (#27542827)
Can someone provide a ELI5 for this?
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by guffaw5 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:41PM (#27542975)
Banks have a ton of cash, and they're worried about inflation. So, they store their cash with the fed (through a repo [repurchase] agreement) temporarily.

[0] What is a repo? - https://www.richmondfed.org/publications/research/econ_focus...

[1] Repos in charts - https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RRPONTSYD

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by wtn on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:47PM (#27543048)
The immediate situation is a problem of money market funds having more inflows than they could allocate (without nominal losses) in a zero interest rate environment. It's not about inflation per se.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by MrStonedOne on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:58PM (#27543183)
That does not explain what a reverse repo is.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by ffggvv on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:56PM (#27543159)
that doesn’t really explain why they’d give the fed money for 0 percent interest if they are worried about inflation
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by dragontamer on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:20PM (#27543441)
A 30-year bond is 2.20% APY yesterday.

If inflation happens, the 30-year bond will likely rise with inflation: maybe 3% or 4%. It is better to store your cash today, than to "lock in" to 2.2% APY.

Next month, if inflation starts to kick in, maybe you'll get 3% over the next 30 years instead of 2.2% over the next 30 years.

-----------

Obviously, a 30-year bond is 'different' than cash. However, when you start looking at 6-months, 3-months, 1-month, and overnight lending rates... things look more-and-more like cash.

No one ever holds "cash" per se, its always better to lend it out (even for only 1 day, you wanna have that cash generate more cash). By betting on shorter timescales (ex: 1-month), you're really betting that the longer-time scale bonds (ex: a 30-year) will rise up.

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by MuffinFlavored on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:19PM (#27543421)
> they store their cash with the fed (through a repo [repurchase] agreement) temporarily.

What does this gain them? Are they paid interest?

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by eloff on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:23PM (#27543478)
They pay for the privilege of having the Fed hold their cash.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by notahacker on Thursday June 17, 2021 @05:27PM (#27544653)
Contrary to the other two replies, yes, they are paid interest (it's a reverse of the standard repo where they borrow money from the Fed and pay the interest)
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by selectodude on Thursday June 17, 2021 @06:51PM (#27545342)
Reading the comments on financial articles on HN makes me question the comments on the stuff I don't actually know something about.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by professoretc on Thursday June 17, 2021 @04:11PM (#27544025)
Banks don't like holding cash (because it doesn't belong to them, and could be withdrawn at any time). So it's actually the opposite: they pay for the privilege of not having to hold onto that cash.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by rawtxapp on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:39PM (#27542938)
This was a good and simple explanation on why this might be happening: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O0fSPO7AW7k.

tl;dw: too much money in the system, big banks don't want the liability, push it to money market funds which use short term treasury while treasury is trying to increase their long term debt and reduce the short term ones. essentially, not as scary as it sounds.

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by MuffinFlavored on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:19PM (#27543428)
> big banks don't want the liability

How is holding lots of cash a liability?

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by joosters on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:39PM (#27543690)
To the banks, it's a debt and hence a liability. If you put money in your bank account, then the banks owe you money.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by rsp1984 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @04:37PM (#27544283)
Yea, but you gave the bank the money first. Which brings us back to the first question: How is holding cash a liability? Are they worried about deflation?
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by jkhdigital on Thursday June 17, 2021 @08:19PM (#27545960)
SLR: recently imposed capital requirements on large banks. Banks don't hold cash, they hold reserves at the Fed. And reserves are included in the bank's leverage ratio, so by accepting too much cash the bank can end up pushing their leverage ratio beyond the SLR limit which is bad for business.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by edgyquant on Thursday June 17, 2021 @05:24PM (#27544631)
Deflation would be a good thing (as the cash would be worth more.) Cash is a depreciating asset due to inflation (it isn’t a liability.)
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by imtringued on Friday June 18, 2021 @04:27AM (#27548462)
If nobody spends their money then your economy will end earlier than it should have.

People advocating for deflation say they will still spend their money but what they really mean is that they will spend the money on basic living expenses and that is it. They will save the rest. How else would they benefit from deflation? If they spent all their money they wouldn't benefit from deflation as their incomes stagnate or even fall.

Deflation isn't just a fall in prices of goods, it's also a fall in cost of labor because the price of goods is what pays for the labor.

It's pretty easy to illustrate how deflation ruins the profitability of companies. You have a production line that generates $5 million revenue a year. You have fixed costs of $4 million. Your profit is $1 million. As the population gets older, demand for your products goes down by 20%. Now you have $4 million in revenue and your costs went down slightly to $3.5 million. You're making half the profit even though revenue only fell by 20%. Running the production line at below capacity makes the production line increasingly less profitable until it no longer makes sense to run it.

A fixed % reduction in revenue can result in a much higher loss in profitability. Low profitability is a self reinforcing cycle as companies stop borrowing money and the money creation process is being interrupted leading to further deflation that cuts into profitability until you reach the smallest possible economy. That economy would have a GDP significantly smaller than $22 trillion USD but the level of savings didn't change meaningfully.

Despite the illusion of deflation, your money is actually losing value over time as the economy gets smaller because your dollars are just a claim to the output of the economy and if the economy shrinks so does the ability to serve your claims. When people realize that the money they are holding onto wasn't risk free after all it's too late and we get very high inflation or even hyper inflation as people get rid of dollars that have no counter part in reality.

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by edgyquant on Friday June 18, 2021 @12:29PM (#27552069)
I don’t advocate for deflation there’s a reason why we have targeted inflation I was just clarifying that deflation doesn’t make cash lose money (except for in the meta way you’ve described) while inflation does.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by choeger on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:35PM (#27543638)
Well, banks do not hold cash. Cash is always held by the central bank (that's where the other banks have their accounts). Nowadays, this can easily involve negative interest rates. So if a bank now buys some security back from the central bank, they effectively remove money from the system (and get that security in return).
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by MuffinFlavored on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:58PM (#27543902)
> Nowadays, this can easily involve negative interest rates.

Source? Does it? I thought negative interest rates were a thing in the EU but not in the US yet?

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by jkhdigital on Thursday June 17, 2021 @08:21PM (#27545969)
The Fed is adamant about preventing negative rates, which is in fact what the reverse repo facility is accomplishing--if market participants could not go to the Fed and had to conduct repo with banks, then the overnight repo rate could easily go negative when there's too much cash sloshing around.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by neilwilson on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:16AM (#27547829)
It costs you to process people’s bank transactions. However the balancing cash asset (bank reserves) doesn’t pay enough to cover those costs. So you close the bank account and ask them to go elsewhere.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by ketzo on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:38PM (#27543678)
Because it's not actively generating value, and is in fact actively losing value thanks to inflation. It's legally considered a "liability" in the context of a lot of banking regulation.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by stryker7001 on Thursday June 17, 2021 @04:53PM (#27544421)
is it more fair to say one reason they don't like holding cash because they have to pay interest to their depositors on it without getting any return on it?

So putting the cash to work (in a reverse repo) even at 0.05% allows them to convert it to an asset and generate some return.

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by rawtxapp on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:35PM (#27543644)
It increases their regulatory obligations without increasing their profits.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by devin on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:42PM (#27543735)
In the case of inflation, your purchasing power will decrease. For example, there was a period during the 1940s (1941-1951) where if you held cash, t-bills, cash in a bank, or t-bonds instead of equities, you would have seen your purchasing power decrease by 30-50% over that time period.[0]

[0]: https://www.lynalden.com/may-2021-newsletter/

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by devin on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:37PM (#27670643)
More of a fun fact than a direct answer to the question at hand.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by jnorthrop on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:10PM (#27543305)
Great link. Thanks
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by BenoitEssiambre on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:19PM (#27543420)
Central banks raised interest rates a tiny amount from 0 to 0.05%. Banks were like: we no longer want to borrow all this cash we weren't doing anything with anyways please take it back central bank.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by BenoitEssiambre on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:26PM (#27543522)
To add to this, central banks don't lend out cash without banks pawning an asset in return. And they only do so on a limited time basis. The banks have to promise to repurchase the pawned asset at a certain date, hence the name "repo" (reverse repo from the central bank's perspective).

Central banks are basically pawn shops that get to create their own cash to lend out.

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by jkhdigital on Thursday June 17, 2021 @04:05PM (#27543970)
At a very high level, this is one among many Rube Goldberg-esque interventions in financial markets that the Fed uses to try and whip markets into behaving how it wants.

In more concrete terms, banks (i.e. members of the Federal Reserve System) keep USD reserves on deposit at the Fed. The only thing they can do with these reserves is loan them overnight to other member banks at a market-determined interest rate--the Federal Funds Rate--which is targeted to a certain range by the Fed's policymaking committee. The Fed also pays interest on these reserves, at two rates: one rate for required reserves, and another for excess reserves. These serve to put a floor under the FFR, since there is no reason to lend reserves at a rate below what you can get by just sitting on them.

Of note is the fact that only Fed member banks have access to this, so other financial institutions must go through the banks when they have excess cash to park somewhere. In essence, the bank can accept overnight cash from non-banks and split the IOER with them. This transaction is consummated through a repurchase agreement (repo) in which the bank sells a "safe" asset to the counterparty with an agreement to buy it back soon thereafter (often overnight, but potentially up to a year later) for a slightly elevated price. The price difference is effectively the counterparty's cut of the IOER accrued during the time that the bank was sitting on the cash. Repo transactions are used for all sorts of short-term funding needs among non-banks, so the overnight rate on high-quality repo is roughly equivalent to the FFR.

It is for this reason that the Fed started its reverse repo operation, whereby it offers basically the same deal that I described above to certain qualified non-bank counterparties, in order to set a floor on overnight repo rates. (You can ignore the "reverse" in the name; it just means that the Fed is the one lending securities in the transaction.) The Fed is extremely wary of negative interest rates and the effect they might have on market behavior, so reverse repo appears to be the preferred method for preventing this.

So what does it mean when usage of this facility skyrockets? Well, it means that banks are not willing to engage in overnight repo at the rate that the Fed is offering, which in turn means that there is suddenly a large imbalance between repo supply (high-quality lendable securities held by banks) and demand (idle cash held by non-banks). As to what that fact means for the near future, opinions may differ sharply.

Banks essentially make money by arbitraging time preferences--they borrow short term (e.g. demand deposits which can be withdrawn at any time) at very low interest rates, and lend long term for much higher rates to risky ventures. They realize a profit by earning a sufficient spread between these rates to offset losses due to counterparty risk (i.e. default) on their lending. One consequence of this model is that a bank may abruptly become insolvent due to short term market conditions, if it cannot roll over its sources of funding. Since financial assets can typically be liquidated quickly (as opposed to, say, a bunch of idle factories owned by a defunct manufacturer) this can lead to systemic instability when an insolvent bank is forced to sell everything and drags down the prices for assets held on other banks' balance sheets.

After the GFC, regulators decided to come up with a more nuanced set of rules about how "healthy" a large bank's balance sheet must be, in order to spot trouble before it exacerbates a liquidity crisis and produces a solvency crisis. A business's leverage ratio is basically capital (equity) divided by assets (or its inverse, depending on your framing). For banks, however, just looking at leverage is not that helpful since the assets being held have very different levels of risk. The new metric is the Supplemental Leverage Ratio (SLR), which includes off-balance sheet exposure. Notably, the bank's reserves at the Fed as well as holdings of US Treasuries are normally included in the denominator (risk assets), but at the start of the pandemic an exemption was put in place so these could be excluded, thereby boosting the leverage ratio and allowing banks to engage in more lending than would otherwise be allowed by the normal SLR calculation.

However, the SLR exemption has now been allowed to expire, and thus banks must tighten up their balance sheets to avoid the severe restrictions of a low SLR. We are now squeezed between the Scylla and Charybdis of financial regulation and monetary stimulus, as the Fed engages in QE to encourage lending towards riskier economic activity while simultaneously imposing leverage constraints to prevent large banks from posing systemic risks. The Fed's reverse repo has become the pressure release valve, as banks are completely hamstrung by their inability to offer negative rates so everyone is now going straight to the Fed for their overnight deposits.

Ironically, this is essentially a (short-term) negation of the Fed's QE activity, as the Fed is simultaneously purchasing assets as well as lending them out on an ongoing basis. In other words, the market is sending a pretty clear signal that QE is really unnecessary at this point in time.

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by mlac on Friday June 18, 2021 @03:05PM (#27553744)
Can you check my understanding here? So all this money builds up, they have no one to lend it to (except the Fed), which they have to because of the SLR.

The Fed raises rates in two years, and banks can lend out, but people a) can't afford the monthly payments for current prices at higher interest rates or b) have extra money from QE and don't need debt. Prices fall for things that require debt (cars, houses, college), but go up for things that people can pay for in cash? Less total is lended out due to the falling prices of things and increased interest rates? The whole volume of money moving around the economy decreases.

The Fed can inject more money, but there will already be too much (at large banks and corporations) on the market that is already not allocated effectively.

I guess... I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on what happens next?

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by neilwilson on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:18AM (#27547841)
Finally a proper answer. Not the top voted one I note.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by rbx on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:46PM (#27543032)
the banks have too much cash and not enough collateral (typically bonds). The FED lends them the bonds for one day (reverse repo) so that their books look ok at the end of the day.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by dmw_ng on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:00PM (#27543210)
https://fed.tips/sico4-1/

This relates to scarcity of short-duration treasuries, it's mostly a scary sounding non-event

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by ganoushoreilly on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:40PM (#27542963)
First, it's been at 500 or so for a few weeks this is a substantial jump. The previous high record was $589 on the 14th. This has never been this high.

But more than likely you need to understand what Reverse Repo is and why it impacts all of us. Here's a great ELI5 On Reddit.

https://www.reddit.com/r/investing/comments/1ixbwf/eli5_repo...

TLDR: More inflation and shakey times ahead.

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by eightysixfour on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:52PM (#27543103)
The jump is substantial because the Fed raised the interest rate on overnight reverse repos from 0% to .05%, so the demand skyrocketed.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by izend on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:53PM (#27543118)
Note you are off by a magnitude:

"as it raised the rate on its overnight Reverse Repo facility from 0% to 0.05%"

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:57PM (#27543163)
That is an annualized rate, right?!
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by eightysixfour on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:34PM (#27543632)
Thanks, I've edited it.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by carapace on Thursday June 17, 2021 @03:33PM (#27543616)
Riiight? I read that and my reaction was Red Dwarf Cat "What is it?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BLc5mvOGgxc
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by hall0ween on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:35PM (#27542893)
Don’t quote me on this, pretty sure I’m wrong. The Fed bought assets (with the agreement to give it back for even higher rates of return). I heard one interpretation of this being that the moneys worth less than the assets and the fed is looking for ways to incentivize financial institutions to take money.
Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by wtn on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:42PM (#27542991)
> the fed is looking for ways to incentivize financial institutions to take money

Right, the current situation is a money market "plumbing" issue; there are more deposits than banks can handle due to GSIB balance sheet regulations.

Here's some background info: https://fsforum.com/news/fixing-whats-broken-the-gsib-surcha...

Re:U.S. Fed accepts $756B in daily reverse repo operation by ganoushoreilly on Thursday June 17, 2021 @02:42PM (#27542979)
Yes, govt bonds are looked at as not reliable and the fed is incentivizing the purchase of the bonds nightly with additional interest. Problem is this is to stave off excess inflation, but it ironically will create it.