We've had similar discussions with customers in the past - we've found the vast majority (90%) are happy to pay monthly, and the remainder are very vocally against.
We are looking to accomodate both sides, and the current plan is to offer a subscription 'pause', where all of your existing data is stored for free, and you can unpause to edit/create new projects.
It's still being worked out, but hopefully this will be a happy medium ground in the future.
If you want to justify monthly payments, figure out how to provide ongoing value. In your case, it could be that you will update sitemaps in the background and notify users about changes. That way, itβs much easier to see the reason behind recurring payments.
I am thinking ecomerce and classified ads sites
It looks very nice, by the way.
I'd prefer to pay per project rather than per month. I think this makes more sense at the lower end / for the "freelance" tier.
Say I do 5 web projects a year. Each one is reasonable budget, and mapping is a core part. From a psychology pov I'd much rather pay (say) $200 one off for each project (maybe based on a cost per page) fee than a rolling per month cost on a thing I'm only using intermittently.
Money wise, my response is silly, I know, but I think the psychology at play here is important. As a small company I don't like to spend money monthly on a thing I don't use whereas when client has just paid me a big deposit for a new gig, I'm happy to pay.
For larger tiers, cool. But a per page "once off" would make sense to me.