News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:38AM (#27503889)
Ooh, a crypto bank could be cool. Maybe the bank could create its own class of coin, and make it so that each bank_coin can be redeemed for a btc they have in deposits. Since not everyone needs their btc often since they're hodling all the time, the bank could probably lend out more bank_coins than they have bitcoin to help others get access to more assets and get a return on the loans. As long as everyone didn't withdraw at the same time it'd probably be fine.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by giaour on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:49AM (#27504042)
There could be some kind of Crypto Deposit Insurance Corporation (CDIC) to insure deposit accounts in case everyone does try to withdraw at the same time. You might want an entity with deep pockets and serious longevity (like maybe a sovereign state?) to offer that so you could trust that it would exist for the foreseeable future
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by lisper on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:00PM (#27504211)
What a great idea! The sovereign state could even offer loan guarantees to help stabilize the system during financial crises. Wow, crypto is really turning into a game-changing innovation!
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by MR4D on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:10PM (#27504356)
Well, then you need to set up a Federal Cryptocurrency Reserve System (FCRS) in the US, and a European Cryptocurrency Central Bank (ECCB).

And if that happens, you probably need a World Cryptocurrency Bank, and an International Cryptocurrency Fund as well.

Wow, things are going to get fun!

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by doggosphere on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:07PM (#27504323)
Your state would eventually fail, but the core decentralized blockchain lives on.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by jakeva on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:10PM (#27504355)
Assuming there is still a power grid
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by throwaway6734 on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:40AM (#27503911)
They could also provide protections for end users so that if there are fraudulent transactions they could work with other banks to undo transactions.

Wow this is such an advancement in banking and finance!

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:41AM (#27503933)
Probably need some sort of central org to agree on a fair rate bank_coin / btc to avoid a race to the bottom though
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by base698 on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:49AM (#27504043)
From 2010:

While this view of Bitcoin might sound like it is a betrayal of Bitcoin's original vision of fully peer‐to‐peer cash, it is not a new vision. Hal Finney, the recipient of the first Bitcoin transaction from Nakamoto, wrote this on the Bitcoin forum in 2010: Actually there is a very good reason for Bitcoin‐backed banks to exist, issuing their own digital cash currency, redeemable for bitcoins. Bitcoin itself cannot scale to have every single financial transaction in the world be broadcast to everyone and included in the block chain. There needs to be a secondary level of payment systems which is lighter weight and more efficient. Likewise, the time needed for Bitcoin transactions to finalize will be impractical for medium to large value purchases. Bitcoin backed banks will solve these problems. They can work like banks did before nationalization of currency. Different banks can have different policies, some more aggressive, some more conservative. Some would be fractional reserve while others may be 100% Bitcoin backed. Interest rates may vary. Cash from some banks may trade at a discount to that from others. George Selgin has worked out the theory of competitive free banking in detail, and he argues that such a system would be stable, inflation resistant and self‐regulating.

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:01PM (#27504230)
That's one hell of year to say "You know, I think banks should be able to choose whatever fractional reserve rate they want"
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by analyst74 on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:52AM (#27504098)
They can also spin off an insurance arm called Crypto Deposit Insurance Corp, and provide CDIC insurance to depositors in case their bank becomes insolvent.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:55AM (#27504153)
Greatly amused that were a little later than the other comment but arrived at the same acronym
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by arthurcolle on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:48PM (#27504872)
I mean, what else would you call it? It's not really that clever IMO. But yes, I see the recreation of all these traditional institutions but with a crypto flavoring to be a little unnecessary and instead of reinvisioning specific financial instruments and other types of financial products, people are just reskinning the same underlying products + mechanisms.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by tudelo on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:54AM (#27504126)
I mean, the idea of trading one coin for a "new" coin is pretty wide spread now. And the coin can be printed by the contract owner, if they specify it that way. So if people want to buy in to that system they totally can, and it can exist now. Its surprisingly easy to create your own coin, and the nice part about creating smart apps on blockchains is that you don't have to worry about hosting.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by intev on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:51PM (#27504931)
I know you're being sarcastic but you know what has happened? All these exchanges issued their own tokens that is backed by NOTHING and have their own tokenomics. One of the reasons people assigned value to those tokens was the more you owned the larger discount you got in trading fees. In same cases better savings rate.

What's funny is it started the same way your clever little remark did but it didn't end the same way.

I think the really sad part here is you think that revisiting an old problem will lead us to the exact same old solution despite decades of advancement.

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @02:44PM (#27506544)
> I think the really sad part here is you think that revisiting an old problem will lead us to the exact same old solution despite decades of advancement.

I mean yeah. Traditional banking is very lucrative, especially at lower reserve requirements and capital investment regulations.

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by iSnow on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:55AM (#27504147)
I think some kind of IOUs would work really well here! While we are at it, we also could do this for USD on the blockchain. We could say "tether" them while embezzling the real USD.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by Seattle3503 on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:03PM (#27504264)
> Since not everyone needs their btc often since they're hodling all the time, the bank could probably lend out more bank_coins than they have bitcoin to help others get access to more assets and get a return on the loans.

I know you're trying to be cute, but the SPDI charter that Kraken Bank has prohibits fractional reserves. Kraken must hold your deposit.

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:13PM (#27504383)
I tried looking that up and found this: https://bpi.com/beware-the-kraken/#_ftn1

> If Kraken Financial had been in full operation in March 2020, it may not only have ended up insolvent by mid-March but would likely have been subject to a bank run. In practice, it has more in common with a prime money market fund than a bank.

Sounds about right

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by Seattle3503 on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:51PM (#27504929)
BPI isn't an impartial source of information. They are essentially a think tank / lobby group for incumbent banks. See their about page: https://bpi.com/about-us
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @02:41PM (#27506506)
Maybe? Their thesis seems pretty straightforward though. Kraken deposits are uninsured. Kraken intends to invest your deposits in fixed income assets, which are vulnerable to capital losses if interest rates rise, among other things (e.g. corporate bonds). If these investments go negative, Kraken will have less than 100% reserves and there's no insurance to help customers, so the rational thing to do is withdraw all assets before others do.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by Seattle3503 on Monday June 14, 2021 @07:10PM (#27509532)
> Kraken intends to invest your deposits in fixed income assets

They don't source this claim at all, they just assert it and expect you to follow along.

It's always easy to craft a just-so-story that sounds reasonable. We could find theories all over the internet about why existing banks today should collapse any minute. What matters is the expertise and credibility of the source.

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @09:37PM (#27510419)
Fixed income assets are just about the only thing they're allowed to invest in. If they leave it in cash they won't be profitable.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by joemazerino on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:08PM (#27504329)
For now ;D
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by retube on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:41AM (#27503923)
amazing how everything gets rediscovered :)
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by wyager on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:11PM (#27504370)
This patronizing line of commentary is so tiresome. I guarantee the median Bitcoin industry participant has an excellent knowledge of banking history. Half the people in Bitcoin are there because they’re aware of the trends in fiat money since Executive Order 6102, August 15th 1971, etc.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:21PM (#27504506)
When I google btc price, all of the headline news articles are about elon musk making memes.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by wyager on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:05PM (#27504283)
You joke, but a lot of BTC advocates would probably be satisfied if we still had a gold-backed dollar. A paper note backed by BTC is at least marginally better than a paper note backed by nothing.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by hcknwscommenter on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:11PM (#27504369)
> A paper note backed by BTC is at least marginally better than a paper note backed by nothing.

Assuming you are believe the US dollar is a paper note "backed by nothing." Many people strongly disagree with this statement.

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by UncleOxidant on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:24PM (#27504553)
The US dollar is backed by a large military and nuclear weapons. I don't get these people who are always saying "it's backed by nothing".
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by wyager on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:47PM (#27504869)
> The US dollar is backed by a large military and nuclear weapons.

This is a meaningless statement. Please explain explicitly how you think nuclear weapons ensure that the dollar has some trade value.

The US government doesn’t offer nuking privileges at a fixed price, to my knowledge.

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by hcknwscommenter on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:23PM (#27663889)
The U.S. government collects taxes throughout the world and those taxes MUST be paid in US dollars. Most international trade eventually (if not exclusively) passes through the dollar system. Since no jurisdiction is entirely self-reliant, basically all aspects of the economic system touch on the dollar directly or indirectly. That tax collection is enforced by an apparatus with many levers of power including, but not limited to, the military and its nuclear weapons. So yes, the dollar is backed by the threat of nuclear annihilation in some sense.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:17PM (#27504455)
That's fine. A lot of BTC advocates don't understand how money works.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by wyager on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:51PM (#27504924)
Your commentary so far has not exactly demonstrated a clear understanding of monetization.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by spywaregorilla on Monday June 14, 2021 @02:47PM (#27506587)
Well obviously. I'm a bitcoin advocate.
Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by captn3m0 on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:22PM (#27504514)
Maybe we should tell them about Liberty Dollars[0]

[0]: http://www.libertydollar.org/index.php

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by adventured on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:28PM (#27504612)
Paper notes - fiat - are anything but unbacked. It's commonly backed by the voting taxpayer being willing to go along with the taxation system that underwrites the funding of the government, including the currency the government controls.

The government systems of the US extract 35%-40% of the economy in taxation & spending obligations (inflation). Unbacked? That's ~$7+ trillion of annual tax revenue ($8+ trillion of annual spending) from the world's largest economy.

It's one of the more ridiculous myths endlessly circulated by the delusional goldbug types for pretty much the entire past century. When confronted with the facts of reality about how taxation actually works and the fact that fiat isn't actually unbacked, they always instantly run away from their premise (and I say this as a fan of gold as an inflation hedge).

Fiat is backed by a lot of guns pointed at the taxpayer's collective head, ensuring the ability to collect tax revenue from the nation's productive output; whether a given taxpayer likes it or not, whether they agree or not, whether they resist or not, it simply does not matter, the guns (along with the reach of the regulatory body) ensures compliance. In 99%+ of cases they don't even need the guns, they merely need you to understand they're always there as an option. The only thing a goldbug can do when confronted with this fact of reality, is argue that it's immoral to hold a gun to the taxpayer's head to extract taxation, which is a moot argument ultimately: your neighbors all support that virtual gun being held to your head to collect the taxes.

Those guns have very broad public support generally, meaning most of the population - in most every country on the planet - supports tax collection, by force if necessary. They may disagree on nuance, or about what the ideal rate of taxation is, however the public very strongly supports collecting taxes. There's a reason every functional nation & government uses a fairly typical tax collection system: the public broadly supports the concept and will tolerate it. And if you refuse to pay taxes, the public is generally ok with sending in the guns to make you pay your taxes as needed. The public ultimately knows they benefit in various important ways from tax collection, even if everyone simultaneously grits their teeth about paying taxes.

It's probably more reasonable to argue that the US Dollar is supported even more strongly than if it merely had gold behind it and not the guns of tax extraction. The US Government has the ability to take enormous arbitrary sums from the population (see: Covid spending), via the Fed and its capacity to 'print' as they deem it necessary. The USD has more economy behind it accordingly than it would with just gold behind it; it has probably 50%-60% of all possible economic activity behind it as needed, which is a high-end figure for what the governments of the US can perhaps take out of the economy before prompting an extremely negative social reaction. Gold could never come remotely close to matching up to that kind of financial backing.

Having backing (support) is not the same thing as saying that the dollar would retain more or less value over time if it had a gold requirement behind it however, those are two entirely different matters. The USD simultaneously has massive backing behind it, and it's going to endlessly be devalued by the fiscal mismanagement in DC.

Re:US’ First Crypto Bank Reveals Date of Commencement by wyager on Monday June 14, 2021 @12:56PM (#27504992)
To your credit, this is a relatively coherent statement of this line of argument (“USD is valuable due to artificial demand from tax collection”). Unfortunately it doesn’t really hold up to careful scrutiny. If the only demand for the dollar were to fulfill tax obligations, there would be a massive surfeit of dollars. Price is not linear in demand. Most of the dollar’s value is due to monetization, not a just-so story about wha it’s useful for. This is true for any and every kind of money.

There is actually a coherent way in which the dollar is backed by guns, but it’s the enforcement of the petrodollar system - nothing to do with taxes.