News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by nodesocket on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:34AM (#27457076)
> 1.2 Bitcoin investing is a negative-sum game

Bitcoin on the day this was published was trading around $7,500. It's now trading at $37,000. I'd say these guys got it wrong. *at least so far*.

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:24AM (#27457886)
This is addressed specifically.

> "Since there is no source of revenue that would repay investments in bitcoin, there is no way to make a rational estimate for its value (above zero). There is no explanation for why the price is now 7300 USD/BTC rather than 0.73 or 73,000,000" (section 1.3)

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by Yizahi on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:31AM (#27458358)
Actually this is very interesting question about which I'm thinking for some time lately. Why does overwhelming majority of crypto tokens cost approximately in the range between single dollars and thousands of dollars per token, regardless of total number tokens printed or reserved? My first thought would be - because those are "humane" prices, i.e. prices most humans interact daily and have reference points for. Parkinson also wrote about similar effect - when the most discussed price by a group would be the one closest to the daily amount of money, e.g. committee would discuss budget for a nuclear reactor for a few minutes, then argue for an hour about price of coffee supplier for the office coffee maker. But while this hypothesis looks interesting I can't imagine how it may happen in real life, how do the prices converge to the 1-1000$ range and why?

PS: good example was recent HDD token Chia. Before the token become listed on exchanges people hypothesized that it's price would be hundreds or thousands of dollars, and they were right eventually. But why really? Why not 0.0001$ per token or 1 million per token? How did this price fixation happened?

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by jjjdjjddddsfsd on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:02AM (#27458165)
Why is a liter of milk worth 1$?
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:19AM (#27458288)
It doesn't matter why a liter of milk costs $1 - what matters is that it costs $1 now, it'll cost roughly $1 a year from now and in the interim, it'll still also cost $1. Predictability and consistency is a critical aspect of currency.

The actual numerical value is irrelevant.

You can't assign a fundamental value to the purchasing power of a bitcoin when treating it as a currency because there's nowhere in the world that bitcoin is used to denominate the sticker price of goods. If there was you could regress its value based on how much one bitcoin would buy you in terms of goods priced in it.

However, without that, you can only treat it as a purely speculative asset as jstolfi did. If that ever changes, our model will have to change. It has not, and IMO will not, even with El Salvador because its wildly fluctuating notional value determined predominantly by global speculators precludes it from being used to actually price things in a meaningful and consistent way.

[edit] Either way, the title of the write-up was 'Bitcoin as an investment' - currencies aren't an investment, so the analysis models it as an asset.

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by jjjdjjddddsfsd on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:27AM (#27458702)
"what matters is that it costs $1 now, it'll cost roughly $1 a year from now and in the interim, it'll still also cost $1. Predictability and consistency is a critical aspect of currency."

And that is not the case, in general.

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by hervature on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:26AM (#27458332)
Your entire comment is an argument why Bitcoin is more an investment than currency. The opposite of what the paper is trying to accomplish.
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by Yizahi on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:38AM (#27457564)
All bitcoin gains came from some poor guys who bought into this hysteria later than other and are now hoping to find another poor guy who will buy at current prices. I'm not saying that they will definitely stop, it is possible that this loop will continue for a long time, but people need to remember that these "valuations" is simply a product of a hype to resell at a higher price.
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by ddrdrck_ on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:41AM (#27458419)
So far I wouldn't talk about "poor" guys
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by Elzear on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:10AM (#27457361)
"At any point in time — past, present, or future — the people who have ever bought bitcoins, considered as a whole, have put into the game more money than they have got back."

Are you claiming that this sentence is false?

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by pcthrowaway on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:19AM (#27457857)
Let's consider this in the context of another currency, say, the Euro.

"At any point in time - past, present, or future - the people who have ever bought Euros [with real currency, aka every other fiat], considered as a whole, have put into the game more money than they have got back."

Now the Euro is heavily traded in forex markets, and surely the price fluctuates. Is this statement true? I'd suspect yes, though there are many other factors at play. Has the value of Euro increased relative to the other currencies it trades against? If so, this is probably due to large amounts of money pouring into it as a more lucrative asset than the quote currency.

I think this question really only makes sense using another currency as a reference. So let's consider the Zimbabwe dollar during its period of hyperinflation (2007-2009). In this case, citizens of Zimbabwe who bought Euros very likely got back more of whatever currency they eventually converted it to than they would have if they had kept their money in Zimbabwe dollars.

But what does this even mean. There is no 'stable' currency to use as a true reference, the value of each in the global market is constantly fluctuating. 'Getting less or more money back' becomes hard to evaluate.

So let's talk about purchasing power instead. I suspect the people who have ever bought into bitcoins as a whole, have increased their purchasing power (the number of coca-cola's they can theoretically buy on any given day).

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:26AM (#27457897)
> Now the Euro is heavily traded in forex markets, and surely the price fluctuates. Is this statement true?

It is not true, because currencies aren't assets. Currencies are a medium of exchange. Their job is to hold value for only as long as it takes you use them to buy necessities or invest them in assets. That's it. Any longer is a non-goal. Goals include low transaction costs, high transaction speed, fungibility, stability and predictability.

As for the FOREX market, that's a highly leveraged speculative trade on the relative purchasing power of a pair of currencies. That's not an investment and it's certainly not an asset.

With that in mind FOREX is widely regarded as a zero-sum market in the same way options and futures are. Money from the winners goes to pay off the losers.

> In this case, citizens of Zimbabwe who bought Euros very likely got back more of whatever currency they eventually converted it to than they would have if they had kept their money in Zimbabwe dollars.

This would have been a zero sum trade, not negative sum. Zero sum doesn't mean reversible or that there aren't winners and losers, just that considered as a whole, between all participants, no money left the system and no money entered - what was there was simply redistributed.

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by pcthrowaway on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:45AM (#27458037)
I think you're missing the point I'm making, which is that bitcoin is also (legally now, at least in El Salvador) a medium of exchange
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:51AM (#27458083)
Ok, it has the title, but its an awful medium of exchange by any objective measures. Giving it the title doesn't suddenly make it fit for purpose. To borrow a turn of phrase, if my Grandmother had wheels she would have been a bike. [1]

Bitcoin being negative sum has nothing to do with its title and everything to do with its intrinsic characteristics. I believe a study showed its PoW model extracts as much welfare from the system as a ~55% rate of inflation.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-RfHC91Ewc

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by pcthrowaway on Thursday June 10, 2021 @06:50AM (#27459201)
I agree about all of the above; it's not a great currency, and it's certainly more volatile than most global currencies, but it is a currency. The idea of nations recognizing bitcoin or something like it as national currency (instead of their own or another country's currency) is monumental.

Personally I'm hoping the shift comes soon for proof of stake currencies with low transaction fees.

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by ta1234567890 on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:18AM (#27457416)
That’s true. And it’s also true for any stock that doesn’t pay dividends as well. Should people not invest in those stocks? Or should we ban non-dividend stocks for being Ponzi schemes?
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by JediLuke on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:22AM (#27458665)
At least stocks/companies have a balance sheet with real assets. Even if the whole company shut down (and wasn’t bankrupt) investors would still get at least some of their money back after liquidation.
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:28AM (#27457909)
That's not accurate.

Dividends are just one of the many ways that companies accrue value. Companies use revenues to invest in the business, to repurchase shares and also to issue dividends. This net welfare accretion must be considered in its totality.

Just because a company doesn't issue dividends doesn't make it a Ponzi scheme, and it doesn't make it a zero sum investment (like precious metals) or an negative sum investment (like PoW coins and to a lesser extent, most (all?) other coins).

“In the short run, the market is a voting machine, but in the long run, it is a weighing machine”

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by randomsearch on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:28AM (#27457493)
I believe that the missing point there is the expectation that those stocks will _eventually_ pay dividends.
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by mastermojo on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:01AM (#27457732)
I don't think (in my lifetime) I've heard anyone discuss buying or selling a stock in the context of a Dividend Discount Model.

This observation isn't really in support of Bitcoin, it's more of a depressing thought that our stock markets are closer to a Keynesian beauty contest. (GME, AMC, etc).

I don't personally own stocks or real estate for cash flow purposes. I own them with the expectation that I can sell them for more money down the line.

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by randomsearch on Friday June 11, 2021 @07:20AM (#27471776)
> I've heard anyone discuss buying or selling a stock in the context of a Dividend Discount Model.

Pension funds.

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by BenoitP on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:10AM (#27457793)
This is compatible with Bitcoin being a store of value. If velocity stays low, the price will continue to go up.
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by keymone on Thursday June 10, 2021 @02:14AM (#27457394)
is it not? only tiny fraction of bitcoin's lifetime -- two months out of 12 years -- has it been at higher levels than today.
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by ryan-allen on Thursday June 10, 2021 @01:41AM (#27457135)
If only we could predict the future!