News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:24AM (#27457886)
This is addressed specifically.

> "Since there is no source of revenue that would repay investments in bitcoin, there is no way to make a rational estimate for its value (above zero). There is no explanation for why the price is now 7300 USD/BTC rather than 0.73 or 73,000,000" (section 1.3)

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by Yizahi on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:31AM (#27458358)
Actually this is very interesting question about which I'm thinking for some time lately. Why does overwhelming majority of crypto tokens cost approximately in the range between single dollars and thousands of dollars per token, regardless of total number tokens printed or reserved? My first thought would be - because those are "humane" prices, i.e. prices most humans interact daily and have reference points for. Parkinson also wrote about similar effect - when the most discussed price by a group would be the one closest to the daily amount of money, e.g. committee would discuss budget for a nuclear reactor for a few minutes, then argue for an hour about price of coffee supplier for the office coffee maker. But while this hypothesis looks interesting I can't imagine how it may happen in real life, how do the prices converge to the 1-1000$ range and why?

PS: good example was recent HDD token Chia. Before the token become listed on exchanges people hypothesized that it's price would be hundreds or thousands of dollars, and they were right eventually. But why really? Why not 0.0001$ per token or 1 million per token? How did this price fixation happened?

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by jjjdjjddddsfsd on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:02AM (#27458165)
Why is a liter of milk worth 1$?
Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by arcticbull on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:19AM (#27458288)
It doesn't matter why a liter of milk costs $1 - what matters is that it costs $1 now, it'll cost roughly $1 a year from now and in the interim, it'll still also cost $1. Predictability and consistency is a critical aspect of currency.

The actual numerical value is irrelevant.

You can't assign a fundamental value to the purchasing power of a bitcoin when treating it as a currency because there's nowhere in the world that bitcoin is used to denominate the sticker price of goods. If there was you could regress its value based on how much one bitcoin would buy you in terms of goods priced in it.

However, without that, you can only treat it as a purely speculative asset as jstolfi did. If that ever changes, our model will have to change. It has not, and IMO will not, even with El Salvador because its wildly fluctuating notional value determined predominantly by global speculators precludes it from being used to actually price things in a meaningful and consistent way.

[edit] Either way, the title of the write-up was 'Bitcoin as an investment' - currencies aren't an investment, so the analysis models it as an asset.

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by jjjdjjddddsfsd on Thursday June 10, 2021 @05:27AM (#27458702)
"what matters is that it costs $1 now, it'll cost roughly $1 a year from now and in the interim, it'll still also cost $1. Predictability and consistency is a critical aspect of currency."

And that is not the case, in general.

Re:Bitcoin as an Investment (2018) [pdf] by hervature on Thursday June 10, 2021 @04:26AM (#27458332)
Your entire comment is an argument why Bitcoin is more an investment than currency. The opposite of what the paper is trying to accomplish.