We're undeniably impacted by climate change right this very second. You can take a drive along the Eastern coast of the United States and see water flooding the yards of homes that are all for sale. Likewise everyone I've heard of buying costal or near sea-level property has had a hell of a time getting a mortgage because it's hard to find flood insurance.
You can watch the Arctic melt almost before your eyes [0]. If that doesn't shock someone right now, then I doubt the first blue ocean event will make a difference either.
Coral reefs are being critically threatened right now from ocean acidification, you can watch them die.
Arctic winds leaking out of the North as the polar vortex fails wreaked havoc across Texas.
The Sierra snow pack, essential for the maintenance of the fresh water supply for both California and Nevada continues to worsen and worsen with what are becoming rare years of it returning.
Record drought in the West causes continually devastating wildfires which are also sources of massive CO2 emissions.
All these are just a few off the top of my head that I've noticed.
Just like pandemic, which still has its fair share of deniers, there will be non-trivial subsets of the population that adamantly deny that climate change is happening even if the entire Midwest were to turn into a dust bowl again. Demagogue after demagogue will emerge to point the finger at some group of people.
But I full agree with your sentiment. Compared to climate change, solving pandemic should have been a cakewalk. If we had solved pandemic quickly I would still be skeptical about climate change because it is so much harder to stop. But since we utterly failed to address pandemic, it is already far too late to image we have any change to alter the path climate change is taking.
Maybe denial is ultimately the best approach for those that can't move towards horrific acceptance.
If global reaction to climate change is any guide we'll ignore warnings about climate change as we have since the 70s and earlier.
> There were so many fires up and down the West Coast last year
As someone living in Western Oregon I'm really afraid what our air is going to be like come September given that the drought is worse this year than last. I have air filters at the ready.
And I think we might, once we start trying.
And I’ve been quick pessimistic on this issue. In 2010 I determined our society was default dead.
It still is….but it’s looking more and more likely we move the cost curves on carbon capture and can actually just pay to remove the excess and solve the problem.
It takes more energy to remove carbon than it did to put it in the air, so getting all of that carbon out will take, basically, some multiple of all of the energy output of every power plant, every mile driven, every building built, in the past 200 years. We basically have to "undo" the past 200 years of civilization a few times over.
In no way does carbon removal make sense if we don't stop pushing that stuff in the air first. I'm glad Stripe is investing in it, and it makes perfect sense for them to do so and it's amazing of them, because we WILL need it, but only if the world doesn't end first.
The world is like a guy with advanced cancer. He has let his cancer grow rampant for two decades and he's now infested. Doctors say he has a few years to live. He needs chemo and surgery NOW. Maybe, just maybe, with extreme luck and the most skilled doctors, he'll make it. Like cancer, emissions reproduce and grow and every minute counts (growing cancer → arctic methane emissions).
Carbon removal is... his gym membership. Yeah, it will be great for him to get in shape in order to have a healthy and happy future...but the miserable bastard has to survive first.
Ten years ago I thought that:
* We wouldn’t be able to get renewae costs down fast enough
* Even if we did, we’d have emitted so much that the earth’s own systems would keep things going unless we got to zero
I didn’t see a realistic way out. Default dead, and almost certainly just dead.
But since then the cost curve on renewables has come down much faster than predicted. And further we are starting to bring the cost curve down on carbon extraction.
You’re right we need to get to zero. And I don’t mean to take that as a given. But I focussed on extraction because without that we’re still doomed even if we get to zero.
But the progress so far has come despite an ineffectual political response and a general lack of urgency from civil society. But both are turning around a bit, with carbon taxes, the stripe initiative, etc. So I think we may be able to move even faster on the cost curves.
Hence why I think we have moved from “basically no chance” to “some chance”. And that’s very optimistic to me, because humanity is pretty good at doing stuff if it focusses and success is actually possible rather than impossible.
I think the more apt cancer analogy is surgery:chemo = emissions halting:carbon removal
You need the first part, as you say. But without the second part you still die in the end.
It doesn't take just reducing calories input to daily needs (zero net carbon emmisions), they will stay obese and still at the risk of heart attack. They need to go below recommended calories to go into negative cal balance in order to loose weight.
Zero net emmisions is a good start but its not enough as all it means is that we are maintaining status-quo ie warming up.
The exponentiality of the changes are hard to grasp, but people grasp cancer and that both luck, very skilled doctors, and future tech is needed to treat advanced stages.
Yea, industrialized societies supposedly need copious amounts of young people for the economic system to function, but how about just less young people until we find an answer?
(I won't be back to debate. I'm not an expert on anything. It just seems like more people in the world add to the global warming problem, especially in industrialized countries.)
So this can be solved with political means, but not with prohibitions.
So those exact countries which had a declining fertility rate for ages now and, additionally, contain a rather small percentage of the world population?
> I won't be back to debate
I dislike this a lot, too be honest. Simply dropping a very divisive stance like this and then basically adding "but don't bother arguing" feels very disingenuous to me.
We invented new vaccine technologies to beat the pandemic. Yes, many people died but civilization did not collapse.
Climate change will not solve itself like this. It will keep reducing food supply and habitable land, causing mass migrations that sooner or later will end in wars. Trying to wait it out is suicide.
The global food supply is increasing:
* See production numbers for key crops - all are still increasing.
* See famine and hunger numbers all are still decreasing.
* See the problem of soil depletion.
* Consider that crops are temperature-sensitive, and continued warming of the planet will be turning currently food-rich areas into zones where crops cannot be grown.
This is probably the opposite of what is likely to happen, warmth is likely to enrich the food productivity of more northerly countries which tend to be politically more stable and have less distribution and corruption problems, resulting in more net food production, not less.
> See the problem of soil depletion.
Not related to the carbon dioxide issue.
If you poison the carbon dioxide issue with unrelated or poorly-thought out assertations, you risk discrediting it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desertification
Have you seen the size of Africa?
You are literally a character from futurama proposing to drop a giant ice cube into sea to cool it down.
Well, it will but in 10,000 years, so noone will be around for that except neo-cavemen or something
It's not perfect. A better test would be a bona fide alien invasion.
But the similarities were in:
- High stakes - millions of lives are as high as you can get outside an actual existential risk
- Global coordination needed for effective response
- Cooperation of every individual needed for effective response
In a way, COVID was a more pressing situation, and to the degree we've failed at both global coordination and individual cooperation, it suggests we'll do even worse with climate change.
Some of the things the pandemic revealed are:
- People don't trust the experts and authorities, way beyond the extent of reasonable doubt.
- There's an infinite supply of pundits willing to sow doubt about the seriousness of the problem.
- We can be staring death in the face, seeing our kin fall left and right, and many of us still reject effective means of mitigating the problem, seeing them as an "attack on their freedoms".
The technology was there, and ready enough that Moderna even reportedly designed their vaccine in "2 days" in January 2020 after SARS-CoV-2 was fully sequenced.[1] There's a bit more to making a Covid vaccine than cutting off the ~3,000 nucleotides (~10%) that encode the S protein and printing them + packaging them into nanolipid particles, but the rest is mostly a set of known tricks to do things like keeping the mRNA from folding onto itself and increasing its GC-content for easier transcription.[2]
The ~11 months between January and December were spent testing and getting approvals, not developing new technologies.
[1] https://globalnews.ca/news/7492076/moderna-coronavirus-vacci...
[2] https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/reverse-engineering-source...
mRNA vaccines have been great. But multiple conventional vaccines were developed about as fast and we’d probably do fine just with those.
> But the sky turned orange for a week last year, as wildfires
California doesn't and can't manage its forests properly, so orange skies are expected annually. Very little to do with climate change.
The useful part in the article:
What's interesting in the article is that CO2 levels increased during a pandemic shutdown. That should be investigated to see why.
Climate scientists dream of the chance to collect measurement samples during cessation of human activities like this pandemic (same with the grounding of US aircraft during 9/11.)
I was speaking about this to a friend and he recommended to read book called Drawdown to lift me out of despair. The book is published in the library and all of it is available at https://drawdown.org/. It was great to see that the work to fix or at least slow things down is already underway. But of course by no means guaranteed to succeed. Especially since that collection of essays did kind of dance around the biggest challenge of industrial rapacious capitalism really being incompatible with caretaking of the entire planet in a fair and balanced way.
On that note, somehow right after reading The Drawdown I stumbled on (I think via HN maybe?) Kim Stanley Robinson's The Ministry for the Future (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ministry_for_the_Future) which I swear takes a lot of the stuff from The Drawdown and lays out a path to turning things around that includes a lot of people saying no to the current way of doing things and finally caring for the environment. It was interesting to see the pleas of Mary to the bankers who the book makes a great case are actually the rulers of the world with the quotes of USA's central bankers from just a couple of days where they explicitly state that climate is not within their purview.
I don't know. I got children and I get really depressed about shit they will have to deal with. My parents were similarly depressed when they were my age now, and I was my children age now, and nothing got done.
Wishing us all lots and lots of luck.
I'd love to be wrong on this one. But the sky turned orange for a week last year, as wildfires tragically demolished entire communities just 35 minutes by car from where I sit. EPA didn't know how to classify the air quality. There were so many fires up and down the West Coast last year they started simply numbering them, or labeling them as whole collections. Here in the PNW we've had a shockingly hot and dry spring, with ominous implications for this summer.
I'll leave you with this: check out 'The Carbon Farming Solution'. It's an incredibly well-researched book. It's in my wheelhouse, but I think it would appeal to a lot of you here (and yes, I've mentioned it a bunch of times before.) It goes both wide and deep on many aspects of land-use change, and is sober and realistic in what we can hope to achieve through better land-stewardship, and rethinking our food system.
1: http://carbonfarmingsolution.com
2: Please don't waste time arguing with me about how 'there have always been wildfires'. What we're facing now is incomparable to the annual burns that used to happen here hundreds of years ago – though prescribed burns to reduce fuel load are certainly something we should be trying to do.