I only ask because there is a 3-page (in my opinion, aggressively worded) email response in between "I feel this is unethical" and "legal action". I could see how the content and tone of that particular email could be interpreted in a way that could escalate the situation.
Again, I do not agree with the response here, but it's not as if there wasn't a long email with a fair amount of context in the middle.
Taken directly from the email; "but this feels weird/unethical since you worked for us and now are copying internal design decisions (even bad ones)".
Could Radon's email be worded better to defuse the situation? Probably; but they are a fresh graduate just out of university and I think it's reasonable to hold Amjad to a higher standard.
But if you are going to make statements like "I can't believe he responded in that way!!", it's important to read the thing that is actually being responded to.
The response was written by a CEO. C level positions carry a certain duty and require tremendous skill. In this case, Amjad responded to a poorly written email in such a way that every investor and employee has to fear or they’re not paying attention.
Humans have thousands of years of experience processing trust. It takes a life to build a good reputation and one email chain to destroy it. C level leaders genuinely have to be a lot better than this, especially when faced with difficult emails.
So much egotism from the CEO in this exchange. I'm glad this was published and posted to HN because it's a valuable lesson to learn by example from.
everyone is armchair quarterbacking here on what was the rational thing to do. but we are mostly not rational creatures esp when our "babies" are involved.
Even now Amjad refuses to provide any detail or receipts to Radon for his public accusations of tortious behavior.
> everyone is armchair quarterbacking here on what was the rational thing to do.
Do you seriously prefer your web psychoanalysis?
The difference here is that CEOs are expected to handle things professionally, especially CEOs of a VC-backed startup.
As noted in the previous thread, the "rough day" excuse doesn't fly when you double down and offer legal threats.
"Hey, really cool project. Though honestly, not sure how I feel about a former intern of mine publishing a project that is so similar to what they worked on as an intern. But on that note, we'd be happy to have you back on the team if you want to continue the project with us :) What do you say?"
or something along those lines. I still wouldn't agree with him, but at least I'd sympathize.
instead he went full-on attack mode, lawyers and all. sheesh. talk about tone deaf.