In many smaller scenes, a successful tour is one that breaks even. They sleep on promoters floors, eat shitty food, and play in bars. I hear a lot of "fans" that download all of their music and think that they support the artist by going to their show. This is not the case.
The one way to really make money as I understand it - which is noted in the book you mention (though it is kind of dated now) - is royalties. If you are fortunate enough to have your song featured in ads and get into heavy rotation on the radio, you get paid outside of your recoupment costs (which they pull from record sales).
Well, it's not like their ticket purchases are for naught - it still offsets the cost of touring for the artist. The artists would be worse off doing the same tour with less fans attending.
What better choice do the fans have anyway? Buying the records supports the record label, not the artist.
Why people don't go the route of Jonathan Coulton or Pomplamoose, and just scratch it out on their own talents, is beyond me. Hell, I think even those "hide your kids, hide your wife" news parody musicians apparently make more money than major label star. The math just doesn't seem to be adding up anywhere being on a label, is what I'm trying to say.
I guess you have to be a blindingly white-hot ultra-mega-super-duperstar to make a penny from labels and touring, and everyone else should just pack it in or go indie?
Seems like it sucks worse to be a musician than to be a struggling actor or indie mobile app developer.
Being signed, though, indentures you to a label. If I'm going to be playing music for love, and not for money, than I'm certainly not gonna put on shackles and let somebody else make money off of my music.
Although recoupment provisions make it technically a loan, just like a VC, the label won't come after you forever if you don't recoup. At a certain point, they'll write it off and let it go; they won't be after you forever like a collection agency.
As to how bands can earn a living, the answer is of course touring, merch (t-shirts, etc.) and for those with music with mass appeal, licensing to films, tv, and commercials. If you can self-produce, you can also do a licensing deal (P&D - pressing and distribution) for the record as well.
The way to stay in control, of course, is to bootstrap it and form your own record company.
Anyone curious about how these deals work in more detail should check out "Confessions of a Record Producer" by Moses Avalon (a pseudonym).