Re:John Carmack on JPEG
by Sebb767 on Friday June 04, 2021 @06:41PM
(#27399891)
What's the advantage of JPEG2000 lossless over, say, PNG?
Archives will probably be compress later on anyway and using a widely-supported and known format seems far more suited for archival purposes.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:John Carmack on JPEG
by aaron-santos on Friday June 04, 2021 @07:00PM
(#27400052)
JPEG2000 can be more of a data container than an image format. While the downsides are many, there are a few upsides to JPEG2000. Greater bit depth is useful when storing DNs. More than three channels is useful when storing multi-spectral images. Internal tiling is useful when range reading specific parts of an image (obvs more useful when working with very large images). These specifically make JPEG2000 more useful than PNG when working in certain domains. Satellite imagery is one such domain.
Why not just TIFF for container?
DNs?
Digital Negatives
Re:John Carmack on JPEG
by aaron-santos on Friday June 04, 2021 @07:32PM
(#27400332)
Digital number, the output of an analog to digital converter.
I thought Digital Negative.
Re:John Carmack on JPEG
by aaron-santos on Friday June 04, 2021 @10:04PM
(#27401282)
I can see how it would be useful for digital negatives too, but I don't know much about those.
It's a fancy word for raw files.
Thanks!
> Archives will probably be compress later on anyway
What do you mean by this? Zip, 7zip, gzip, zstd, etc. get little to no compression on PNG. JPEG, or JPEG2000. Presumably you mean something other than zipping up directories of images.
Zip compressing a single PNG is kinda redundant, since it already uses the same algorithms as part of its own lossless compression.