Re:Raspberry Silicon update: RP2040 on sale now at $1
by martyvis on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @06:50AM
(#27352723)
Totally agree. Their release seems to make it seem that dual core with multiple hundred K of RAM is unique. The elephant in the room is while it has nice GPIO interfaces for sensors, you want onboard wireless for backhaul. Espressif have had this space for a couple of years now.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Raspberry Silicon update: RP2040 on sale now at $1
by kortex on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @07:31AM
(#27352986)
I can think of many application with no need for wireless backhaul, or where wireless becomes a liability. It boils down to cost, power, noise, security, frequency used, and complexity. LoRa or similar is probably better than Wifi for many applications. I like that it isn't opinionated about the wireless stack.
I'm guessing that lots of Picos will see use as enhanced GPIOs for Pi "motherships," which provide backhaul to multiple wired-in Picos.
In fact I have a project which could use a decidedly non-wireless USB GPIO, for use on an airplane imaging system.
Re:Raspberry Silicon update: RP2040 on sale now at $1
by antattack on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @10:21AM
(#27354905)
What you say is true, however, $1 is a killer feature.
It can replace many IC and will make a very good addition to ESP32 which lacks pins for many projects. And, sometimes you want external chip so output is not affected by ESP32 reboots or freezes.
Re:Raspberry Silicon update: RP2040 on sale now at $1
by 6f8986c3 on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @06:59AM
(#27352779)
For secure applications, on-board wireless makes your life hell. I'm actually pretty happy they didn't.
Re:Raspberry Silicon update: RP2040 on sale now at $1
by nousermane on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @07:28AM
(#27352956)
Depending on application and how you define "secure", you might find that having an easily sniffable SPI/SDIO/UART connection between main MCU and wifi chip can be a weakness.
Re:Raspberry Silicon update: RP2040 on sale now at $1
by 6f8986c3 on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @08:37AM
(#27353527)
I believe the point is "no wifi whatsoever".
If you need wifi, by all means, go integrated. But not everybody does.
Re:Raspberry Silicon update: RP2040 on sale now at $1
by mschuster91 on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @08:22AM
(#27353403)
The problem with onboard wireless is that this adds a boatload of complexity regarding certification in various regulatory domains, trademark compliance, ...
Re:Raspberry Silicon update: RP2040 on sale now at $1
by nousermane on Tuesday June 01, 2021 @09:28AM
(#27354073)
...not to mention massive code size increase, for wifi/bt driver. And that driver is likely to come as an inscrutable binary blob.